6 ms·
Where did DNA come from?
- panja 3y agoThere are some mysteries I don't think we'll be able to solve and that makes me sad
- bregma 3y agoIt makes me glad. One's reach should always exceed one's grasp. Keep searching.
- alas44 3y ago“The mystery of life isn't a problem to solve, but a reality to experience.” Frank Herbert
- exe34 3y agoFeyman once spoke of how his arty friend thought that scientists miss out on the beauty of a flower when they try to understand its components. (To paraphrase, since I can't remember the exact words), He replied that a scientist can see the outer beauty of the flower as much as the poet - it's just that the scientist can see poetry on a larger scale (the ecosystem, the bees, the co-evolution) and smaller scale (the cellular biology, the biochemistry, the chemistry, the atoms themselves, and then further down into the subatomic particles, etc). Just because you know how a car works doesn't mean that you can't enjoy a ride across the countryside.
- WhrRTheBaboons 3y agoyeah, it's like saying directors can't enjoy movies, since they know how they're made. sure, some times it's more difficult to suspend disbelief, but on the other hand there is many more details that can be appreciated only by people who know how difficult they are to pull off, and are completely missed by people not in the know.
- indigochill 3y agoIf you take the view that existence is physics and physics is math, then doesn't this follow from Gödel's incompleteness theorems?
- msla 3y agoNo, it doesn't, at least when applied to physics.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- verisimi 3y agoA: Watson and Crick
- defrost 3y agoPhotograph 51, by Rosalind Franklin (1952)
- Faaak 3y agoSadly everyone forgets Rosalind Franklin, which played a huge part and even got the Nobel price after her death (she couldn't be recognized before, as she was... a woman).
- coldtea 3y agoThat's the modern pop version. The reality is more mundane: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-01313-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-01313-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature01399 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature01399
- genman 3y agoIt (the first in the list) is a very nice and empowering write-up. Thank you for sharing it.
- dekhn 3y ago
- ggm 3y agoSynergistic effects, catalytic effects and basic things like van der waals forces. Molecules in energy rich evironments which self assemble and become both antichaotic and self reproducing. Why does water freeze in star patterns? Why are salt crystals regular shapes? It's energy efficient. They may be local minima in better packing choices but if some number of these arrive at the helical zipper, the rest is history. Did mitochondria have any idea what they were doing agreeing to be engulfed? Was it a choice in a soup of competing mitochondria, to hide in a fat-bag and acquire skin? It's a shit answer: it's a posh wordy version of "because". Feynman said (better) that much physics is "we don't know" built on shakey foundations, that explanation is often invoking primitives we treat as axioms without knowing what makes them axiomatic. All subatomic explanations of particles ultimately go to "we don't know" Biology is applied physics.
- yamrzou 3y ago> Biology is applied physics. Can Biology Be Reduced To Physics? — https://youtube.com/watch?v=A4yzK-8OGtc https://youtube.com/watch?v=A4yzK-8OGtc
- genman 3y agoHe claims that the way we study complex systems, like those in biology, simply can't be reduced to physics. Then he goes on to claim that the first Newton law doesn't apply to biology: but when we look at the biological world, matter seems to move by itself all the time. This is simply not true. If it was true then we could also claim that any chemical process (that is governed by physics) can't be reduced to physics. Which obviously we know to be not true.
- metricspaces 3y ago> [emergence of order] The Origins of Order: Self-Organization and Selection in Evolution (1991) https://www.abebooks.com/9780195058116/Origins-Order-Self-Organization-Selection-Evolution-0195058119/plp https://www.abebooks.com/9780195058116/Origins-Order-Self-Or... > Did mitochondria have any idea It remains a possibility, not subject to fascile dismissal, that ‘our world’ is a side-effect of a self reflecting mind. You will note on serious reflection that all you know and experience is ‘image’ and ‘imagination’. Now that there is a ‘correspondence’ to an ‘outside reality’ is only obtained when there are 2 or more of ‘us sentients’ and we compare notes using ‘language’ (with all its limitations and to be understood in its maximal sense & associated limitations, including ‘expression’, ‘communication’ and ‘reading’). > Biology is applied physics Not all applications of physical laws result in living forms. Physics can be applied to understand (some aspects) of biological entities given that they are (conceptuallyminimally in part) made of physical stuff subject to governing regime of matter we study as physics.
- tetris11 3y agoDNA: file.c polymerase: gcc (transcribes DNA→RNA) RNA: file.o file.m file (the last one is mRNA) ribosome: ./file (translates mRNA→Protein) protein: (program in RAM) epigenome: (program in RAM changes file.c) RNA world: (different file.o's messing with each other by some unknown program, eventually giving rise to stable file.c files)
- willis936 3y agoHas anyone written a simulator in this style? You'd want to sandbox it so it doesn't get flagged as a virus, but it might be fun.
- tetris11 3y agoIn a sense, the historic development of GCC[1] is similar to this, relying on the previous version of GCC to compile the newer, whilst making modifications to the parser to allow the new symbols to parse. 1: "Trusting Trust" by Ken Thompson https://users.ece.cmu.edu/~ganger/712.fall02/papers/p761-thompson.pdf https://users.ece.cmu.edu/~ganger/712.fall02/papers/p761-tho...
- willis936 3y agoYes but always human in the loop. I mean a self replicating, source modifying program.
- fxj 3y agoisnt it more like: RNA: asm text file Protein: compiled binary also: t-RNA is a hybrid of RNA and amino acids, which is like a hash table
- Faaak 3y agoAFAIK, it's even "worse" as ribosomes are made of RNA (rRNA). and amino acids are linked to small RNA (tRNA) in when translating the (coding) RNA. RNA is the start of everything (see: RNA world)
- _yb2s 3y agoI like that this article mentions the metabolism first hypothesis. It seems less popular, but much more plausible to me then “RNA world.” There are many natural situations where there is available chemical energy, and reactions very much like central carbon metabolism spontaneously occur. A gradual stepwise process from that to present day metabolism seems fairly straightforward if you also add in isolated units that can be selected for. Importantly, and still relevant to modern day life is the fact that metabolic states contain information and themselves can be heritable.
- pfdietz 3y agoFor selection, you need something with "memory", like genes. I've wondered if something like this could work: store information in templates formed in otherwise random organic solids. The idea would be that a molecule adsorbed onto a surface would be most stable if its shape and charge density matched the shape and charges of a hollow in the surface. These charged holes would be a kind of analog memory. They promote formation of the matching chemicals, since they'd make formation of them from precursors more energetically favorable. At the same time, the presence of the small molecules would encourage the formation of matching holes. This mechanism should be testable in small scale systems, forming tars from a mixture of various monomers. RNA/DNA would come later and take over from this primordial mechanism.
- ambyra 3y agoI like the "lipid world" hypothesis over the "RNA world". It reminds me of the chicken or the egg argument. I don't see how life could form outside of a controlled environment, like an egg or a seed. Something forms in a lipid that couldn't form in a harsh nature, the lipid pops, the something gets to hang out with the other somethings that formed in lipids nearby, and they get reabsorbed by lipids. Make sense to me. There are so many specific control mechanisms for getting inside of eggs, seeds, cells, etc. Seems like a fundamental part of life. I remember something from the "your inner fish" book, talking about how all of evolution in a body happens between layers.
- _yb2s 3y agoYes, as I understand it the metabolism first and lipid first ideas are related, in that you have some sort of micelle or vesicle that contains metabolism, and is partitioned off in a way that selection can act on them.
- ivanojakov33 3y ago[dead]
- M95D 3y ago> But the paired RNA or DNA strands then bind together so tightly that they can’t separate without help from sophisticated enzymes, preventing them from making any new RNA or DNA. No. They can be separated by temperature alone. See DNA denaturation phase during Polimerase Chain Reaction.
- treyd 3y agoThis kind of thing is why I think cyclical changes of environmental conditions (temperature, light, etc) on short and long timescales was important for making the chemistry of early life work. There plausibly needs to be some way for enzymes and other processes to be switched on and off for various reasons, and if that just happened naturally through the day that would avoid the need for more sophisticated signalling/control machinery to have evolved spontaneously. It's easy to see how this could then evolve into the circadian rhythms that nearly all complex life on earth has as other processes were built into/around that basic behavior.
- a_gnostic 3y agoMidichlorians are the power house of thw cell.
- utopcell 3y agoLet me save folks some time and summarize the article: something happened 4bn years ago, it possibly created RNA, it might have created DNA after or concurrently (we don't know) and we definitely have no clue about how genetic code was formed, but it must have been done a long long time ago because it is the same on all life. The end.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- singularity2001 3y agoit might've come from outer space which only shifts the question and we still have no idea
- photochemsyn 3y agoThe free-living ribosome hypothesis of the origin of life seems the most likely, was introduced over a decade ago, and isn't even mentioned in this article. The basic idea is there wasn't an RNA world or a protein world, but that abiotic genesis of nucleic acid and amino acids took place concurrently, and those entities (which may have formed short polymers) organized into various structures based on the well-known amino acid / nucleic acid association mechanisms (based on hydrogen bonding). Somehow, this proto-ribosomal-association developed the ability to self-replicate. Ribosomes today are engaged in the process of linking one amino acid to another using an mRNA template as the blueprint (and a complex association of amino-acid binding tRNAs which 'read' the mRNA template, and a suite of enzymes that correctly link tRNAs and amino acids, the critically important amino-acyl tRNA transferases.). In the origin-of-life model, the protoribosomal RNA becomes the very first functional RNA to self-replicate, but it's already associated with abiotically formed amino acids (a much smaller set than what life uses today). It's something like a virus that can self-replicate without any help from a cell. Practically, this means the earliest ribosomes must have also been RNA polymerases, an activity which later was separated into a separate entity by evolutionary processes. Even if you can make something like this in a lab [1], it doesn't really 'prove' that this is how life started, there might be multiple different routes to a living self-replicating cellular entity, but time and evolution have erased much of the evidence. As far as the origin of DNA, the main benefit is having two copies of the information which allows for error-correction, and the disadvantage is having to translate the DNA to mRNA to feed to the ribosome to make the proteins, so perhaps it took place after cellularization [1] "The Ribosome as a Missing Link in Prebiotic Evolution" Root-Bernstein & R-B https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6337102/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6337102/
- jononomo 3y ago[flagged]
- dougmwne 3y agoI am a theist. I also find what you are saying pretty unconvincing. Panspermia theory means there’s basically no bounds on how long ago life may have formed or how many trillions of planets may have hosted primordial soup waiting for the right interactions. Good statical analysis and biochem showing that it couldn’t have formed on earth would be better evidence for panspermia than divine genetics. The universe and our existence is plenty awe inspiring to me. I don’t need to invent miracles or fit the evidence to the conclusion. I think it’s better to use our intellect and see where the evidence leads us rather than pre-supposing the nature of God.
- jononomo 3y agoPanspermia gets you nowhere and merely allows you to try to save face before what you suppose are your more sophisticated colleagues. Also, "no bounds on how long ago life may have formed" just displays ignorance of the fact that we do in fact have bounds on the age of the universe. It is obvious to me that you have ruled miracles out by definition, allowing you to conclude that miracles must not have occurred. Forgive me for rolling my eyes. There are single proteins that are so complex that the search space for them is so large that it would be equivalent to picking a single specified elementary particle out of all the elementary particles in the Universe. Also, the shape of a protein is like a combination lock -- you have to get it right or it just doesn't work and also gives you no feedback that you can use to make a better guess. Also, why are you a theist? Do you hear God talking to you or something like that?
- miohtama 3y agoMost people are atheists, because the concept of god was created to explain the world when humans did not have enough knowledge and information for scientific analysis, but this is not the case anymore today. Over centuries, this went away due to inventions of printing press, literature, a lot of basic scientific research and so on. Also if you read the article it gives you multiple theories how initial proteins formed. No god needed there.
- manesioz 3y ago[flagged]
- rolph 3y ago'primordial' chemistry, such as deepsea geothermal vent locations. the abiotic synthesis of ribose related compounds start it all up. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assembly_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assembly_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentose_phosphate_pathway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentose_phosphate_pathway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archean https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4023395/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4023395/
- miohtama 3y agoFor panspermia theory (the life originated from the space) you need to remember that universe itself has evolved. There was early time in the universe when it was so warm that liquid water was possible “everywhere”. Though this does not solve anything, just shifts the starting point and conditions somewhere else.
- baruz 3y agoA G Cairns-Smith postulated that self-organizing, growing silicate crystals could have formed a substrate against which organic molecules would pattern themselves until they eventually began self-replicating on their own.
- jacknews 3y ago"and finally, self-copying RNA formed." LOL, do we have an example of such a thing, RNA that can copy itself independently, without helper chemicals/energy? It's quite clear to me that life most likely started with a 'co-operating set' of chemicals that could catalyse each other's reactions, necessarily in the presence of some kind of energy gradient, and that RNA, DNA, etc came after, and even then still rely on the 'soup' of chemicals that they are in, for reproduction.
- pfdietz 3y ago> There’s also no oxygen or ozone layer, leaving the planet’s surface exposed to the sun’s intense UV rays and making it blisteringly hot. The Sun has increased in brightness by 30% since it settled onto the Main Sequence, so press X to doubt the "hot" part.
- coolhand2120 3y ago> So, it seems reasonable to expect that the building blocks of life formed spontaneously Why on earth is that reasonable to expect?! That has to be the most anti scientific thing possible. “We tried really, really hard in a lab under carefully controlled conditions and couldn’t make it happen therefore it must just happen spontaneously!” And that’s what passes for mainstream science? I think this article is secretly trying to convert people to alien origin or creationism the way they argue this point.