5 ms·
Sending in a swat team without any kind of in person validation is pretty insane anyway IMO. I've never heard of this happening in Europe in the counties I've
by wkat4242 3y ago
Sending in a swat team without any kind of in person validation is pretty insane anyway IMO.
I've never heard of this happening in Europe in the counties I've lived. They have such teams but they're only sent in after a serious hostage situation is confirmed by cops on the scene. They don't just go around busting down doors because some anonymous caller says so.
I wonder how many of these situations in the US are legit and actually needed such a response.
- asddubs 3y agoit's a natural conclusion of the militarization of the police. The police gets a bunch of toys it doesn't need and then itches to use them on something.
- djbusby 3y agoLike developer with new shiny JavaScript framework/toolkit. Gotta use it at the next opportunity. Human condition to want to use the gear you're excited about. I'm glad my work is crappy rather than dangerous.
- Log_out_ 3y agoAnd it's utterly useless.. What good does a tank against a drone with an rpg7 head. Real resistence by a gang would obliberate a Swatteam. A cold War style armament spiral between gangs and police can not end in success.
- Y-bar 3y agoBut it can end in a kind of success for the arms manufacturers, their shareholders, the “hard on crime” politicians, the upper management of the police force, and the pro-police state people who gets validation for their calls ever-increasing need for violence.
- timeon 3y agoMilitarization of the police is just symptom. Root cause is that police needs to expect that almost anyone in the US could be armed. This is not the case elsewhere.
- actionfromafar 3y agoIf we are going for root causes, aren't there assault rifles in most Swiss homes, for instance? And yet...
- johannes1234321 3y agoIn Switzerland the guns are typically locked away and out of reach. While guns may exist in a house, for police it's unlikely to be confronted with it.
- Clubber 3y agoIt's unlikely police get confronted with guns in the US too; we just have 350 million people, extremely authoritarian police culture, and a corporate news that jumps on the chance to report every instance. I would wager way more citizens are killed by police (rightfully or not) than police are killed by citizens.
- nucleardog 3y agoEstimates are that there’s a firearm in 23-33% of Canadian households, while estimates for the US are around 44%. I don’t disagree that the firearms are a problem, or even a factor, but it certainly doesn’t seem likely that it’s the root cause unless there’s some tipping point between 1-1.5/5 houses and 2/5 houses that makes things substantially more dangerous.
- int_19h 3y agoThis was true long before police was militarized. Militarization of police was indeed a symptom, but rather a symptom of the War on Drugs - the first SWAT team (in LA) was organized largely for that purpose.
- jimbob45 3y agoSending in a swat team without any kind of in person validation is pretty insane anyway IMO. If I’m a police captain, I’m going in guns blazing every time because I know the trend of SWATting won’t end until the penalties are ratcheted way up. The only way that’s going to happen is for terrible stories like this to become public.
- neilkk 3y agoYou're claiming that police chiefs deliberately overreact to these calls in order to put pressure on lawmakers via the FBI and the media?
- DANmode 3y agoProbably accurate, and underlines the complete disconnect between lawmakers/law enforcement, and modern technology.
- mindslight 3y agoYou're right about the incentives, and in my opinion this won't change until police departments and the local governments that enable them are required to compensate their victims, including for things like emotional distress (being assaulted by a violent gang is going to take some time to process). The deep root of the problem here is that police are allowed to cause harm and then just walk away from any responsibility.
- shermantanktop 3y agoI’m in the US, with European family (parent, cousins, etc.) and I can’t count the number of comments that I’ve heard or read that begin with “I am from Europe” and go on to make a very sensible, reasonable assertion about how things ought to be in the US. Well, they aren’t that way. However your town works, Detroit is different. NYC is different. Tampa is different. At some point the person who is repeatedly surprised at what doesn’t make sense to them has an obligation to either accept that their expectations aren’t universal, or to dig deeper. Maintaining perpetual shock and confusion is not a sign of moral righteousness or principle, it’s provincial.
- inamorty 3y agoSo it should not be assumed to be a functioning first world country?
- superb_dev 3y agoYou don't think this is the place to share a sensible solution to the problem we're discussing?
- matkoniecz 3y agoWell, info that some problem does not exist elsewhere at all and there is an obvious solution to that is useful. Even if that means that situation in USA is sad/broken.
- Log_out_ 3y ago? A region has such a weak rule of law, that police can terrorize a man without consequences - and a person from a vast region of various states were that is rather unheard of (and people travel way more) is provincial for calling that out? I'm honestly confused. We had some "valley rulers" in europe, but the law tends to get rid of them, bloodfeuds and other idiocies included. And any low point ought to remain shocking. Getting numb to pain is not normal.
- sebasv_ 3y agoI understand your frustration about the "I'm from Europe" comments, but you have to appreciate that those comments come from a similar frustration. The universally shared image of the US is that they loudmouth how great they are compared to the rest of the world. So when news comes out on how the US fails so dramatically on very basic public/social services, it leaves people from outside the US stumped.
- jojobas 3y agoHow do you in-person-validate a distress call alleging multiple guns fired in a particular home? You might try to call the residents with a false pretext, but surely the SWAT team would be on the way as early as it can.