3 ms·
Actual article: [1] "We estimate that loud alien civilizations now control 40%–50% of universe volume, each will later control ∼ 10^5 to 3 × 10^7 galaxies, and
by Animats 3y ago
Actual article: [1]
"We estimate that loud alien civilizations now control 40%–50% of universe volume, each will later control ∼ 10^5 to 3 × 10^7 galaxies, and we could meet them in ∼200 Myr–2 Gyr." Those numbers seem inconsistent.
"Ours is a model of grabby aliens, who by definition (a)
expand the volumes they control at a common speed, (b)
clearly change the look of their volumes (relative to
uncontrolled volumes), (c) are born according to a power law
in time except not within other GC volumes, and (d) do not die
unless displaced by other GCs."
That's an interesting set of assumptions. Kind of a 1960s science fiction model.
If we now have a reasonable understanding of physics, you get a different model.
No FTL, radio works at light speed,
Technological civilizations may not last all that long. Human civilization is about 6,000 years old.
Heavy industrial civilization is about 200 years old. Most mineral resources already are past the point where the easy stuff has been mined. The USGS tracks total worldwide mineral resources.[2]
On a scale of years, things look good. On a scale of centuries, not good. On a scale of millennia...
[1] https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/ac2369/pdf https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/ac2369/...
[2] https://www.usgs.gov/publications/mineral-commodity-summaries-2024 https://www.usgs.gov/publications/mineral-commodity-summarie...
- cryptonector 3y agoThe speed of light is a tremendous limitation. W/o FTL there's no such thing as "loud alien civilizations" that can "control 40%-50% of [the] universe['s] volume".
- XorNot 3y agoRather depends on other factors though: you can perfectly well run an interstellar empire with very long communication times and people going into suspended animation for transit. Control strategy simply has to adapt accordingly: i.e. a message probably comes with a fleet sufficient to ensure its obeyed. This was one of the ideas in the Doom novelizations: that the aliens had spent so long travelling that there was little chance of victory because of you attacked a place you took along everything needed for overwhelming victory.
- Mistletoe 3y agoSuspended animation may be as impossible as faster than light travel.
- Animats 3y ago> Rather depends on other factors though: you can perfectly well run an interstellar empire with very long communication times and people going into suspended animation for transit. Probably not. Historically, a few months of lag is roughly the upper limit for running an empire. The Roman empire got round trip lag down to two months to the distant provinces. The Spanish empire was at 4-5 months of lag for the New World. Holding an empire together with a lag of decades probably won' work.
- cryptonector 3y ago> you can perfectly well run an interstellar empire with very long communication times and people going into suspended animation for transit. If travel times are orders of magnitude longer than lifetimes, then you will tend to lose civilizational cohesion. > Control strategy simply has to adapt accordingly: i.e. a message probably comes with a fleet sufficient to ensure its obeyed. What even is the point? The message takes N years to be received by a receiver N light-years away, but travel times will be orders of magnitude longer, so no "fleet" can be sent.
- exe34 3y agoThe fleet carries the message. Of course, there's a fair chance that by the time the fleet gets there, the colony is long dead, or has advanced in weaponry in a different but overwhelming direction, so they just barely notice the little flash way out past their oort cloud.
- cwillu 3y agoAs stated in the paper: “The second of our three model parameters is the (assumed universal) speed at which grabby civilizations expand. Our model predicts that on average at grabby origin dates, a third to a half of the universe is within grabby-controlled volumes. So if the grabby expansion speed were low, many such volumes should appear quite large and noticeable in our sky. However, as noted by (Olson ’15; Olsen ’17) and discussed in Section 13, if their expansion speed were within ∼25% of lightspeed, a selection effect implies that we are less likely to see than to not see such volumes. Thus if we could have seen them, they would likely be here now instead of us. As we do not now see such volumes, we conclude that grabby aliens, if they exist, expand very fast.”
- cryptonector 3y agoThey couldn't be cohesive civilizations though, not unless their individual lifetimes were very long.
- ben_w 3y agoWhile true, a poor choice of name doesn't invalidate the logic. I'd call them "lineages" for this reason, but I don't really expect the name to catch on.
- cryptonector 3y agoIt's just not a single cohesive civilization. Though it would be fascinating. Imagine if our world were seeded with life and terraformed (which now would be quite the misnomer) to be able to host the human-like spawn of a human-like "civilization" that very slowly and discontinuously spread through our corner of the galaxy. That would be quite something, though how would we know unless the parent civilization left us clues to this? And they would have to, if they wanted us to eventually further spread the species/whatever. Or maybe we are sui generis and about to embark on such a program. Or maybe we are about to run headlong into another's such program, possibly causing conflict. Or maybe it's all much too unlikely. I wouldn't know.
- scotty79 3y agoWe are living an mining just the skin of our planet. If we achieve technologies to extract interesting resources out of magma w could have boundless resources.