3 ms·
> For example, on LinkedIn, someone may say they were CMO of a company for just three months, and if you take that data at face value, you may think something v
by Aurornis 3y ago
> For example, on LinkedIn, someone may say they were CMO of a company for just three months, and if you take that data at face value, you may think something very bad must have happened for a company to hire and lose such an important role in so short a time.
> But when you look closer, you see that this person was a sophomore in college at the time, that the company was just a month old, and that actually, it wasn’t so much an executive hire as it was kids trying to get something off the ground.
Although not the main point of the article, this is much better advice for finding high-potential employees who are under the radar than the article that was on the front page a few days ago: ("How to hire low experience, high potential people" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39288669 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39288669 )
When the last article hit the front page I couldn't believe HN was upvoting an article that advocated for deep-diving into people's personal early life history as a hiring technique. That's like reading the tea leaves for interviewing candidates.
Instead, this article reveals the real secret: You have to be prepared to do some legwork and research, as well as look beyond the obvious. You could go hire a lot of smiling ex-FAANG people with perfectly curated LinkedIn profiles and professional headshots by throwing large salaries at them, but you're not going to get the best results that way. It's also one of the least efficient uses of your headcount budget and those people are almost guaranteed to ghost you in 18 months when someone else offers them a fancier title.
There is a lot of gold waiting to be discovered among people who aren't curating perfect LinkedIn profiles or collecting famous company names for their resume. It takes some work to find it, but it's out there.
- edmundsauto 3y agoThis is funny because Facebook was famous for adopting this attitude early on. Hire people with potential instead of credentials. If you have a good perf review system and don’t mind false positives it can work. Maybe it worked better before boot camps.
- febeling 3y agoWhat changed with boot camps?
- ildjarn 3y agoIt’s the shift of perception from technology being “geek stuff” to a lucrative field on par with finance, medicine and law. Before, someone who knew a bit of programming was likely to be passionate and with high potential. Now they may still be, but also they may just a way to get rich quick.
- vik0 3y agoBut the vast majority of people who go to programming bootcamps don't get rich quickly, or rich at all. Same with most people in the world who practice medicine or law Or did you mean to convey that people who go to boot camps think it's a way to get rich quick? Your wording is a bit confusing toward the end there
- john-radio 3y ago> But the vast majority of people who go to programming bootcamps don't get rich quickly, or rich at all. Of course not, but that's the sales pitch, isn't it?
- shakow 3y agoI think he means that ‶guy who knows to code″ used to be a statistically strong marker of ‶tinkering guys with a potential″, which is less true now that IT is now socially internationally perceived as a high-reward career, hence a one where people may go either because they like it, or just because they want to make stacks.
- kasey_junk 3y agoThe problem with this theory is people have been saying it for 25 years. At least as long as I’ve been in the profession. And it’s not historically accurate in the past either. Programming was a clerical job for much of it’s history.
- ozim 3y ago
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoWhat's the impetus for headhunters to do all this legwork though? Just like noone got fired for buying IBM, the headhunters at large FAANG almost always go for the shiny, smiling LinkedIn profiles.
- ozim 3y agoFor headhunters none, for you if you are running your small company - huge. Great hire can pull you out off troubles, bad hire can run company to the ground.
- jmathai 3y agoI am trying to build a hardware prototype which expands beyond my experience in software. There’s no way I would try and hire someone with lots of experience and credentials. There’s too much risk. Instead, I found a recent college grad who I believe is capable of doing what’s needed at this stage. I face lots of risks and the last thing I want is to add an expensive hire to it.
- intelVISA 3y agoA highly curated LinkedIn is a red flag - nobody producing value has time to tend that walled garden.
- gessha 3y agoA sizable chunk of engineers from the most competitive companies got fired - people used to optimizing for everything - resume readability, LeetCode hards, system interviews, etc. You think they won’t optimize their profiles for their next job?
- Hayatabad 3y agoHe has a point. It depends on how optimized it is.
- samatman 3y agoThere's a line somewhere between "optimized" and "highly curated" where I consider LinkedIn a negative signal. Those are both utterly subjective phrases, but nonetheless. My LinkedIn is utterly moribund, which has come up in interviews a few times. Either they say "you don't really use LinkedIn, huh" or I explain the same. As far as I know this has cost me nothing.
- ronald_raygun 3y agoReally? Is it a walled garden when like 90%+ of recruiters are on there? Would you say “a good resume is a red flag, nobody producing value has time to tend that”. The big irony is making things look nice, be readable, be sellable is creating value. In the case of making a LinkedIn or a resume, the value your creating is in terms of your very own capability to get a job and have a high take home pay!
- intelVISA 3y agoThat is true, I suppose...
- jacurtis 3y agoI have a highly optimized LinkedIn, yet I don't really spend a ton of time on there. I log in once or twice a month, answer messages, and do a few things. Maybe make a post once every 2 months or so. Nothing crazy, yet my profile is very well optimized. And this is why: Everyone looks at it. Far more people then you would expect. I can't tell you how many meetings I have gone into where I walk in and see that everyone at the conference table has my LinkedIn profile up on their laptops. They knew they were meeting with me, had no idea who I was, so they looked me up on LinkedIn right before. Its my introduction and sets the tone for a meeting or presentation. This experience is not only in the professional world either. I recently (in my mid-30s) decided to go back to academia to get a PhD and now I am encountering people in academics who use my LinkedIn to learn about me when I reach out for academic or research assistance. When applying for stuff, presenting at conferences, all of it uses LinkedIn as the central way to communicate your identity. Having a nice profile helps me set a positive first impression that helps me gain more responses. Also, I can't fail to mention that recruiters use LinkedIn as a search tool. Not every recruiter is worth your time, but the right ones certainly are worth it and LinkedIn helps connect you with more of them. THey also use your LinkedIn when communicating with their clients. Almost every job interview you do, you can assume the hiring manager and interviewers have looked at your LinkedIn profile before meeting you. Most have probably looked more closely at your LinkedIn profile than your resume. Curating a LinkedIn profile is not that much work. Maybe 30-60 mins per month is all it takes if you have a lot happening and maybe 1 hour per quarter for everyone else. Its not a huge commitment, and yet the gains in my opinion are far greater than the small amount of time spent on it. I don't care if people want to hate on LinkedIn and say its stupid. If anything that benefits me, because it helps optimized profiles stand out. Maybe theres a few people (like the parent comment) who have an aversion to LinkedIn for some reason and will look down on someone with an optimized profile. But I truly believe it offers far more value than it detracts. The people that look down on it are usually people that are not in any position of power anyway or they are a micro-minority.
- dataflow 3y agoWhat about that example do people find to be high-potential? I'm a bit confused because to me 3-month "CMO" of 1-month-old company as a college sophomore sounds at best like a slightly positive signal, and at worst a strongly negative signal, since it could mean anything from "they had enough ambition to work and study at the same time for 3 months and learn stuff on the job" to "they couldn't focus on classes and/or wanted to do something that quickly would put a big-sounding title on their resume".
- pc86 3y agoHonestly any "big-sounding title" within 3-5 years after undergrad is a big red flag and takes a lot to overcome that resume going in the trash. I think best case scenario it means they have connections and got a legitimate job somewhere using those connections, in which case it's extremely unlikely I'm reviewing their resume since I barely graduated with a social science degree from a college nobody's ever heard of. The more likely case is that they aren't actually doing the job of a "Chief Technology Officer" but are instead just a programmer. Which, at 22 years old, is good and what they should be doing. At 22 it's very unlikely you have the technical chops to lead large teams doing big projects, and even less likely you have the emotional maturity to do so. It shows immaturity to try to shoehorn a C-level job into your resume where it doesn't make sense and where 99% of people will rightfully raise an eyebrow at it. I say this as someone who had "Assistant Director" on my resume as my second job out of college, and I was assisting in the direction of a department of two people. Myself, and my boss. In my actual day-to-day I wrote bad PHP and read HN. It was a joke, and looking back I'm sure there are some jobs I applied to that tossed my resume after seeing that, and rightfully so.
- jstarfish 3y agoC-level positions from anything less than a Fortune 500 are a joke and an immediate disqualifier. Anyone exaggerating that much upfront makes me not trust anything that will follow. So much of life these days feels like Freddy Got Fingered. Fondling someone else's horse on their farm does not make you a Farmer.