4 ms·
Part of the issue here on why people are adding rules to this game is because there is a real life abstraction in what seemingly most people would consider nons
by pixl97 3y ago
Part of the issue here on why people are adding rules to this game is because there is a real life abstraction in what seemingly most people would consider nonsensical rules.
If you said "are borbs allowed in the bezzilizx" it would be more interesting on what the gradient of answers would be as we are not making as many presuppositions.
For example, if my grandma is dying of a heart attack in the park, one of the most common behavior of those involved will be "fuck your rules, get the ambulance down here". This is that humans are not yes/no rule following computers and we will gladly toss rules to the side over a number of factors encompassing everything from immediacy of need to the depths of our greed.
- moolcool 3y agoThe presuppositions are what make the question interesting. It's an explicit test of pedantry.
- j2kun 3y agoI think this is the real point: it's not a test of whether people agree on what is allowed, but on how pedantic people are in an abstract setting. I think agreement would be much higher if people were told to evaluate the "spirit" of the rule, and not the "letter" of the rule.
- Dylan16807 3y agoBetter yet, have them submit two answers for spirit and letter. Because it seems that people will ignore instructions that say to focus on just one.
- krisoft 3y ago> I think agreement would be much higher if people were told to evaluate the "spirit" of the rule, and not the "letter" of the rule. I think you are right. I think agreement would be even higher if you would be asking people what should happen as a result of the situation as described. There could be options with increasing level of seriousness. Things like “do nothing”, “send a park officer to ask them to leave, they get a fine if they persist”, “send a cop who asks them to leave and arrest them if they perist”, “send a cop to arrest them without warning”, “order a snipper to headshot them without any warning”. I think asking if something is a violation is too abstract, and people are bad at abstract things. On the other hand when we make it concrete people will be better at expressing what they think should happen and you are more likely to see agreement.
- Nevermark 3y agoWhich sheds light on why moderation is hard, given moderation hinges on serious, but in practice necessarily subjectively interpreted, abstractions. I.e. “freedom of speech”, “on topic”, “low quality speech”, “no hate speech”, “no harassment” etc.
- int_19h 3y agoAgreement would be much higher if people were asked whether it is okay or not, rather than asking whether it violates the rule or not. Deciding whether it violates the rule can be done in a fairly objective way. Deciding whether circumstances justify violating the rule is where the subjectivity is, but the test says nothing about that.
- jodrellblank 3y agoThat’s what made it not interesting, and a better question would be “for each case do you think the police should spend taxpayer money enforcing the rule?”. Not “does this pedantically violate the rule” but “would it be good for society if this case was punished?”, “would it be good for the park?”, “would the effort of punishing it be worth the cost?”. I can’t imagine anyone seriously saying it would be worth the cost of the police trying to move an orbiting space station “out” of the park - the cost would be huge and the return negligible, but peoples views On whether a WWII tank is appropriate for a pedestrianised park are interesting, whereas people saying “yes the tank is a vehicle” are not so interesting.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoThis line of thinking presumes that you are the legislator, judge, or police officer. But one can easily approach the questions as to likelihood of being hassled as a park-goer.
- jodrellblank 3y agoI'm not following what you mean by likelihood of being hassled?
- yukkuri 3y agoOther park goers harassing you because they think you violated the rules and they think trying to deride you for it is a good idea. See most "x while black" incidents.
- jodrellblank 3y agoHow does that relate to "one can approach the questions as likelihood of being hassled", I don't understand it in this context. "Is a WWII tank/pram/scooter a vehicle in the park?" - those original questions? Or my suggested alternative which was "should the police should intervene*"? Is the commenter they saying that people might answer based on whether they think they would expect to be hassled for doing those things? Or answer whether people doing those things should be hassled by passers-by? Or what?
- bagels 3y agoThe ambulance violates the rule, but few would care that it does.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- barrkel 3y agoCourts tend to care, when something goes wrong; e.g. the ambulance causing injury all by itself.
- c22 3y agoCourts only care about cases that are brought before them. They're not out looking for cases, that's what law enforcement does and LE is going to look at the context. If the ambulance is being driven by a carjacker they will cite it for being in the park even if it caused no damage. If the ambulance is driven by a medic and responding to a call they will likely overlook it. And of course they'll drive their own cars in the park whenever they want.
- rcbdev 3y agoI have an anecdote contrary to this - When I was in the US, a friend explained to me how drug dealers tended to live in private trailer parks in part because it was harder for law enforcement to get into the general area without a warrant. Basically, the rule of that park was "no (police) cars in the park" and the police could in fact not drive their own cars in the park whenever they want - only whenever a judge wants them to.
- barrkel 3y agoI think there's a degree of US specificity to your comment. The situation in the UK would be different.
- danielscrubs 3y agoIf that is how US police works then I can assure you it kind of make sense why you have people hating them. Thats some Animal Farm. Can someone that knows US law confirm this? What I mean is that the exceptions should be written in the law and there should absolutely not be a case where you cherrypick.
- IIAOPSW 3y agoI think this is explicitly addressed at the start. The question is not one of if certain cases should be prosecuted or if there should be certain rules that supersede the "vehicle in park" rule. The question is of the fact that the statement "no vehicles in the park" is violated or not. An ambulance is allowed to violate the rule, but it is still strictly speaking violating the rule.
- mtrower 3y agoThe letter or the intent though? Because if it’s the letter, we’d better throw in wheel chairs, surfboards etc. as well. The law does not specify motor vehicles, even though I would believe that to be the intent.
- IIAOPSW 3y agoI went with the letter, and did in fact throw in wheel chairs and surfboards.