6 ms·
The Race Is on to Stop Ozempic Muscle Loss
- bookofjoe 3y agohttps://archive.ph/TcyqX https://archive.ph/TcyqX
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[dead]
- Anotheroneagain 3y agoYou can't stop the muscle loss. The drug doesn't actually do anything except that it makes you starve yourself. The people are losing muscle because they're starving.
- cyanydeez 3y agodont think you understand how technological progress work. We don't ask "should this tech even exist", we ask, "what tech can we figure out that offsets the bad things from this"
- two_handfuls 3y agoThis is very true in my experience. Including in cases where taking a step back would be the better choice.
- Anotheroneagain 3y agoNo I mean more like this doesn't seem to work as well as you expected. It only sort of masks one of the symptoms. We absolutely should ask if the advantages outweigh the drawbacks, and only use it in cases where it does. Not every new thing is good, in fact most new things are crap. New only seemed to equal better when people were more careful and only adopted the new things that were better. It isn't given in any way. You do need that bit of neophobia to get real progress instead of confused wandering around.
- adrian_b 3y agoThen someone must teach those people that for weight loss only the intake of carbohydrates and that of non-essential fats must be reduced, while the intake of proteins and essential fats must remain the same. The daily intake of proteins must never be less than 60 g to 100 g, depending on body size. Even the older recommended in USA daily intakes of proteins of less than 1 g per kg of body weight have been discredited as too low, especially for elderly people, and now better recommendations are between 1 and 1.5 g of proteins per kg of body weight and per day (towards the upper limit if the proteins are of vegetable origin, when a lower fraction is digested). Even when you are not hungry or you follow a weight loss diet, you must still take care to eat the minimum necessary to keep you healthy.
- postalrat 3y agoAre you saying as long as you eat the same amount of protein you won't lose muscle no matter how many calories you eat?
- adrian_b 3y agoIf you eat much less calories than necessary, e.g. 1000 kcal/day or even less, you will also lose muscle mass. However, if you do not eat enough proteins, you will lose muscular mass and the albumin amount in blood will diminish, regardless how many kcal are provided by your food. So for preserving muscular mass, both enough proteins and a minimum intake of kcal per day, which varies between people, but it is typically somewhere between 1500 and 2000 kcal/day, are required. Nevertheless, usually only the amount of proteins requires special care, because it is extremely easy to eat enough kcal per day when you eat enough proteins. Normally a great effort is required to diminish the amount of kcal of the food that contains enough proteins, especially if it is of vegetable origin or of dairy origin. The only natural source of proteins without extra kcal is lean meat, like turkey breast or chicken breast or cod fillet. Fat meat, most dairy and raw vegetables have a kcal content that is usually more than double of what corresponds to their protein content. For example, when the easy method of eating lean meat is excluded, enough proteins for a male of average size could be provided by eating 500 g of wheat flour and 167 g of lentils per day. That alone would provide 2235 kcal/day, which is too much for someone with a sedentary life. Preserving the amount of proteins and also allowing the eating of other food besides that, without using industrial methods of protein extraction that are expensive and require energy and chemicals, could be achieved by making dough from the flour and washing it to remove most of the starch. This example is meant to show that unless you eat only turkey breast or the like, as long as you eat enough proteins you normally have no need to worry about eating enough kcal.
- nathanyz 3y agoIt helps you eat at a caloric deficit. I wouldn't say that is starving yourself. It is basically the same mechanism for how any weight loss would work. Less calories consumed versus burned on a daily basis. There are additional mechanisms that are still being studied, but at minimum it is helping people to eat at a level that supports weight loss.
- thriftwy 3y agoOnce being skinny becomes a sign of drug ingestion rather than fitness, its desirability would vanish fast. People will choowe whatever form they are comfortable with.
- smileysteve 3y agoIsn't this already the case with nicotine and cocaine?
- stavros 3y agoNobody likes skinny people because they're fit. People like skinny people because it's rare, because food is so abundant. 200 years ago, it was beautiful to be fat, because everyone was skinny (because poverty). Being skinny because of drugs will still be desirable, because only rich people can afford these drugs right now. Once we see generics, maybe that will change.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThis is a ridiculously pessimistic take. I'd hardly say that a drug which is used by obese people which lowers their appetite to more normal levels "makes you starve yourself". I've yet to see any reports of people on Ozempic et al who lost so much weight that they died. Usually it's more like they went from obese to "just overweight". They are losing muscle because whenever someone loses overall body weight there is less mass to carry, so their muscle adjusts accordingly. Similarly, if you put on a fat suit that added 50 pounds to your frame and walked everywhere in it you'd quickly gain muscle.
- aszantu 3y agoit's true though, younger folks need like 1 gram/kg of weight in protein daily or so. When you're female and over 40 that goes up to 1.6 grams up to 2.0 grams/kg. If you think you can get that from lentils, you might wanna look into bio-availability. AND if you have any problems with absorbing nutrients in your gut, you are probably not getting enough of everything, no matter how healthy you eat. Protein needs https://health.gov/our-work/nutrition-physical-activity/dietary-guidelines/current-dietary-guidelines https://health.gov/our-work/nutrition-physical-activity/diet... bio-availability https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6723444/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6723444/
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoLiterally nothing you have written is evidence for the idea, which I was challenging, that Ozempic-like drugs "make you starve yourself". Most of the people, currently anyway, who are prescribed these drugs are morbidly obese. There are an entire host of well-known, evidence-supported extremely negative consequences from being obese. So why are you talking about, basically, "eating too many lentils??" in the scope of this conversation? We weren't exactly talking about ensuring vegans get enough nutrients.
- aszantu 3y agoI probably mixed something up in the structure of the thread, sorry I threw it at you
- jupp0r 3y agoWeight loss is not starving yourself, it's a great improvement for lots of western adults health if done responsibly.
- buescher 3y agoWhat do bodybuilders do to minimize muscle loss when cutting?
- brigadier132 3y agoLift weights and eat a minimum of 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight. Also they limit their weight loss to 1% of bodyweight a week.
- doix 3y agoAnabolic steroids.
- rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 3y agoThe correct answer.
- smileysteve 3y agoTo a small degree, creatine supplementation will increase muscle health; and ensure you get your protein.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xeromal 3y agoMake your calories count. Whatever calories you do manage to ingest are low carb, high protein, high vitamin. Think cod and brocolli with no butter.
- matwood 3y agoCuts are hard, but focus on nutrition (lots of protein) and heavy weight lower volume. The lower volume because on a cut you just don't have the energy to go crazy. The heavy weight keeps the body wanting to hang on to the muscle. But, unless steroids are involved, no one is getting stronger/bigger while on a cut.
- 3y ago
- Reubend 3y agoMy (basic) understanding is that weight loss always causes muscle loss if you don't exercise or don't ingest additional protein to compensate. Is there anything new about these drugs specifically that causes muscle loss, or is it the same as with natural weight loss?
- brigadier132 3y agoBased on our current understanding its the same as normal weight loss. So imagine all these people basically just eating less of the terrible diet they likely were originally eating. Forget muscle loss, we are gonna get ozempic malnutrition, wont be surprised when we see people with scurvy
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago> wont be surprised when we see people with scurvy While I wouldn't be shocked to see it happen very rarely, I was under the impression that it was hard to get scurvy today because vitamin C gets added to so much food because it's a preservative.
- zemvpferreira 3y agoThe only news here is that lots of people, especially older women in my experience, continue to be allergic to lifting weights despite overwhelming medical and anecdotal evidence that it's one of the most potent quality-of-life interventions available. 0.01% of people will have some pre-existing condition that prevents them from lifting. For the other 99.9%, I don't care who you are or what your excuse is. Practice some sort of resistance training and you'll be much fitter, happier and healthier as you age. This goes double for every decade above 20. I wish I could pop a pill that's just as potent as a squat but the facts are the facts are the facts.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoHow do body-weight exercises compare? Things like push-ups and sit-ups and such.
- theptip 3y agoBetter than nothing but you want to go reasonably heavy to get the improvements in bone density. Also hard to get hypertrophy in the posterior chain, which is a major area for atrophy with age. I think calisthenics/gymnastics can give a heavier load but there is a substantial skill component there, much harder to learn than, say, squats and deadlifts.
- mondocat 3y agoIf you're able to increase your strength using body-weight exercises, then they're excellent. And they can go a long way - most people probably can't do a pull up, and very few will ever be able to do a pistol squat or a handstand pushup. However, for basics like pushups and squats, body weight offers only a beginner's level of resistance, and going to the gym not only offers the ability to continue making improvements, it makes incremental progress accessible for all kinds of movements, not just those two. Specifically, most people doing pushups and body weight squats are probably doing no pulling movements, or overhead movements.
- pavel_lishin 3y ago
- optimalsolver 3y agoAs someone into heavy women I’m genuinely concerned about the future. I don’t want to live in a skinny-girl dystopia.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- exoverito 3y agoIt's a dystopia either way. I'd prefer the one with fewer diabetics on scooters.
- rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 3y agoHow heavy are we talking?
- antisthenes 3y agoPeople are going to be trying to solve this in 100 years, because no one actually wants to do the hard work of eating correctly (keeping track of macros and not overeating) and exercising. There's no long-term miracle drug that's going to allow you to be fit and strong without any effort. Everything else is just either short-term solutions or straight up juju-science that's equivalent to moving around pieces aimlessly on the same game board.