3 ms·
> hat's scientific rigor, that's sufficient for a scientific journal paper. I don't buy that's sufficient to put a person in prison for life. It may be suffici
by pif 3y ago
> hat's scientific rigor, that's sufficient for a scientific journal paper. I don't buy that's sufficient to put a person in prison for life.
It may be sufficient for a scientific journal paper, but if it is not sufficient to put a person in prison for life, then it's not scientific rigor!
- IshKebab 3y agoThe bar for scientific paper should be far lower than the bar for imprisoning someone for life.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoScientific rigor is built up over time by different scientists replicating and re-proving and building on the work of others. It's never a single paper. So the OC is right. Before this should be used to decide someone's life, there should be a larger foundation of evidence.