3 ms·
> We also need to get to a place, culturally, where we can have calm rational conversations about how many people we can reasonably ask this planet to support.
by Terr_ 3y ago
> We also need to get to a place, culturally, where we can have calm rational conversations about how many people we can reasonably ask this planet to support.
I disagree, that's a dangerous trap. Oh, sure, it seems reasonable and sagacious at first glance, but that's what makes the eventual misdirection/procrastination so insidious! Long-term planning is not automatically wise planning.
________
To illustrate, imagine that:
1. There's a local park with houses around it.
2. Some people periodically dump their trash in it.
3. The trash-piles are getting kind of big and stinky now.
4. A well-meaning neighbor says: "What we really need is to get a place, as a community, where we can have calm rational conversations bout how many people can live near this park."
5. (Bonus) Many of the biggest trash dumpers agree: "Exactly, literally everybody here is to blame, and especially people moving in and/or having too many kids! The only way forward is a very thorough and lengthy symposium with multiple committees to develop recommendations to stop that kind of thing."
________
In that analogy, it's easier to see that your neighbor's proposal is--er--less than practical, because (A) the immediate problem isn't actually total visitor count,(B) we'll never reach full consensus, and (C) any consensus number would still meaninglessly unenforceable.
So it can't really help, but it can harm by creating unnecessary discord and will prevent/delay practical changes like "Anything you bring must be taken back out", or "Littering: $X fine."
- marcosdumay 3y agoIt's punishing the innocent on behalf of the guilty. For some reason people really like to do that, in lots and lots of contexts.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoWho is innocent? I can't think of anybody.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoI don't think it's a very good analogy because, at least when it comes to the parks in my neck of the woods, 95 percent of the litter problem is 5 percent of the people. Clearly you can solve it by addressing their behavior. When it comes to our impact on the carrying capacity of this planet, we don't have a small handful of bad actors. We have a small handful of good actors. The vast majority of us (here in the US) are not willing to make the compromises necessary to be carbon neutral. We just don't know how to live that way, and it may take several generations of trying to figure it out. In the meantime, were going to have to find a balance between quality and quantity of life. To leave quantity unconstrained is to expect the have-nots to quietly tolerate the excesses of the haves to a much greater degree than they already do. It seems like a recipe for needless conflict (which will further set back, if not completely prevent, our sustainability goals).