6 ms·
London Underground is testing real-time AI surveillance tools to spot crime
- Arrath 3y agoPerhaps it's time to reread Gnomon.
- Aaronstotle 3y agoThat book was intriguing, it made less and less sense to me the more it continued. I should give it another read
- proaralyst 3y agoSuch a good book, though ultimately not that much about surveillance?
- Arrath 3y agoYou're right that its not, but the Inspector sure has an impressive surveillance apparatus at their disposal. To me it felt like the aspirational endgame that the powers that be would like to see for the UK, basically.
- henriquez 3y agoThese things always disproportionately target non-Caucasian individuals, so queue future outrage article. See how well it worked out for Rite Aid, here in the U.S.
- janice1999 3y agoIt's London. It's going to exclusively target the poor and vulnerable, e.g. the homeless.
- pqdbr 3y agoAnd you say this based on what exactly?
- BriggyDwiggs42 3y agoIn his comment he said London, implying this was taking place in Britain.
- rhodo 3y ago> They also say the system generated alerts for “rough sleepers and beggars” at the station’s entrances and claim this allowed staff to “remotely monitor the situation and provide the necessary care and assistance.” ah yes I love using technology to better deny the most vulnerable people a place to sleep.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoIt seems fairly obvious to anyone in London that recorded announcements are frequently triggered by events on the platform. Someone walks too close to the platform edge; "Please stand behind the yellow line at all times!" Someone lights-up or vapes; "All stations are non-smoking areas!" --- and so on. These are probably done by humans watching the cameras and just lazily pressing the corresponding announcement button. But one gave me real cause for concern, and it seemed obvious that "AI" was involved; A woman was pushing someone in a wheelchair, and left their disabled friend for a moment to look at a map on the wall. "Please do not leave luggage unattended at any time!" "Please do not leave luggage unattended at any time!" The message kept repeating until the woman walked back over to the wheelchair. I hoped the person in the wheelchair was also deaf, because what could be more dehumanising than being wrongly labelled as "luggage" by a machine.
- bonton89 3y agoDon't worry, in the future they'll just auto mail a fine for abandoning luggage to your last known address based on facial recognition instead of calling you out.
- exe34 3y ago"care and assistance", in Tory Britain means they can send some bored police officers to destroy your tents and other stuff, no?
- huytersd 3y agoThe place to sleep isn’t the station. There are shelters, rehab centers and mental health facilities. Minimum wage jobs are easy to get. There are plenty of social workers that will help you get set up with these things.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- noodlesUK 3y agoI don’t see how AI cameras are a solution to any crime issues in places like tube stations. The staff at these stations know when people are jumping the turnstiles and evading fares. They know if there is a fight. It’s already recorded on classic CCTV (though with shockingly bad cameras if we are to believe recent news reports). The issue is not in my mind the detection of crime (especially petty crime). This may or may not improve the detection of crime, with a cost to civil liberties and loads of false positives. I don’t know if increasing detection of more minor crime is useful if there is not a clear way of being able to respond to the volumes of crime we already know about. You can’t jail every fare jumper or shoplifter in London. It simply isn’t practical. Even if you did jail them, you’d eventually have to let them go, whereafter they very well might reoffend, as they would be more desperate than before their incarceration.
- scotchmi_st 3y agoMy wife had her phone stolen recently, in Highbury and Islington tube station. Nothing to be done, by the time she noticed it gone, it was too late. However since then, she's been getting messages from the perps that appears like a message from Apple, with a link that takes you to a surprisingly convincing site, that then asks you to enter your pin. It's clear that not everyone falls for this sort of ploy, but enough do to make it worth the thief's time to steal it, and sell it for parts otherwise. There are a lot of moving parts to this sort of crime- Apple don't make it easy for you to profit from a locked iPhone, and Android probably don't either. Someone able to write and maintain a convincing-looking website and forward recorded data, someone to take the phone, someone to manage the operation etc etc. Finding out who is stealing the phones would be very helpful in stopping this sort of thing from happening, by cracking the organisations involved. I get the privacy arguments, but if this does actually help stop thieves, on balance I'm in favour.
- fakedang 3y ago>I get the privacy arguments, but if this does actually help stop thieves, on balance I'm in favour. News check, it doesn't. London Met has faced severe cuts over the past decade, it's focusing the core team on major crimes, while hiring a volunteer force for the petty stuff like these. The volunteer force can't be arsed to fight a fly, much less catch a gang of pickpockets.
- verisimi 3y ago"China's facial recognition won't be rolled out in Western countries..."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- d1ss0nanz 3y agoNow we only need a safe definition of crime.
- bonton89 3y agoIt will probably work well at its real purpose, breaking up protests and identifying any protestors to have their bank accounts frozen. No coincidence they're planning to make mask wearing at protests illegal at the same time.
- floren 3y agoI was informed in 2020 that COVID can't spread at protests, so it only makes sense to make masking illegal there.
- BriggyDwiggs42 3y ago[flagged]
- floren 3y agoSarcasm, you fool
- BriggyDwiggs42 3y agoYou really brought up the covid stuff out of nowhere man. Makes me think you care way more about that than about the right to protest.
- LAC-Tech 3y ago[flagged]
- FerretFred 3y agoThey're looking at the wrong end of the problem - you can implement all the tech you like, but ultimately you'll run into the Slough of Despond of the so-called British Justice System. [Alleged] perps will wait months to get to trial only to be either acquitted on a technicality, or be handed a derisory "slapped wrist" fine/sentence. If the former they'll be able to pay in instalments. If the latter, it'll most likely it'll be suspended or reduced to Community Service.
- mocko 3y agoSad but true. Anyone wanting to learn more about how dysfunctional the UK's justice system is after years of underfunding should read Secret Barrister[1]. For comfortable technology folks who seldom brush with the law it's eye-opening stuff. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_Barrister https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_Barrister
- hknmtt 3y ago[dead]
- ideashower 3y agoAs long as poverty remains a primary cause of various crimes, employing extensive technology will not eliminate criminal activities and behaviors that endanger lives.
- Tycho 3y agoI was in London this week and encountered these 'Amazon Fresh' grocery stores for the first time. You walk in, somehow they track your movement through the shop and know what items you have picked up (or put back), and then when you leave you scan your membership card and they charge all the purchases to your account. So effectively they've solved the shoplifting problem. If you are not a member then you have no business being in the store.
- htrp 3y agotons of issues with the amazon go concept to fix from the tech side > The Just Walk Out system requires a considerable number of staff to oversee manual reviews and enable the system to work. For example, while the process—from the consumer’s perspective is cashierless—Amazon still needs staff on the backend to review video footage of the transactions to “facilitate pricing and payment.” In fact, Amazon initially set out to use roughly 20 to 50 employees per 1,000 sales by mid-2022. But quickly realized that figure was too low and ended up using up to 700 employees during that timeframe. https://www.paymentsjournal.com/amazons-just-walk-out-tech-fails-to-hit-the-ground-running/ https://www.paymentsjournal.com/amazons-just-walk-out-tech-f...
- saiya-jin 3y agoSo social graph and hobbies/passions is not enough to monetize, they want all your shopping history, habits, quirks etc., on camera to be analyzed to death? Nobody sees this as privacy and security problem in 2024? I get that Bezos is an obsessive penny-pincher and thats part of his success (and fucked up persona that leaves a lot to be desired), but please allow me to politely say Hell fuck no, I'll give premium to competition that just doesn't have this. I can't imagine this being OK in EU, but then again we don't talk about EU standards here anymore. I wonder what makes British population OK with this, its not like we talk about former East Germany.
- Tycho 3y agoBut retailers in some places are having to shut down stores because theft is so high and the law is not enforced and for some reason private security is not an option.
- nimbius 3y agocurious to see how long it takes a dance troupe to fool AI into sending riot teams after a street performance.