6 ms·
On the one hand, I don't expect anything to exist "forever". Companies don't stay in business forever. A forever contract doesn't even make sense. But on the o
by crazygringo 3y ago
On the one hand, I don't expect anything to exist "forever". Companies don't stay in business forever. A forever contract doesn't even make sense.
But on the other hand, there need to be protections here. Just because a company merges or gets bought, doesn't mean they should be able to end their guarantees.
What about if, to be legally allowed to license streaming content, companies were required by law to:
1) Specify a minimum duration available as part of the buy button and all other text using the term "buy" or "license"? E.g. "Buy for 5 years" or "License now (min. 10 years guaranteed)"
2) Require some kind of insurance/escrow/backup in advance, that guarantees that if they go out of business, all accounts and purchases will transfer to another service that will continue to honor them for the time period specified (or full purchase price is refunded)
In terms of a minimum time duration, there are even physical analogies here -- books can yellow and their bindings crack and glue fail, vinyl wears out, floppy disks become unreadable after a decade or two -- I've even had CDs experience some kind of green growth in humid climates rendering them unreadable. So we already have a kind of pre-existing expectation of media purchases only lasting so long, on average.
- consumer451 3y agoI believe that the rules you are asking for exist in the EU. https://commission.europa.eu/business-economy-euro/doing-business-eu/contract-rules/digital-contracts/digital-contract-rules_en https://commission.europa.eu/business-economy-euro/doing-bus...
- NegativeK 3y agoI agree with pretty much everything you've said. But the difference with physical media and streaming access is that it's actually legal to make a backup of physical media. It might be annoying or enthusiast-behavior to do so, but on the flip side, if a company finds out I'm making rips of streams, they'll at the least shut off my account (which includes access to the rest of the media) and quite possible throw a lawyer at me. Companies have done everything they can to nuke the idea of perpetuity.
- RajT88 3y ago> if a company finds out I'm making rips of streams Vanishingly few people are themselves ripping streams thanks to Widevine. They are just torrenting stuff. BTW only the first "level" of widevine has been cracked as far as I can find, which is limited to lower quality streams.
- Retr0id 3y agoThe torrents don't just pop out of thin air, someone has to download from the streaming service and strip the DRM at least once.
- RajT88 3y agoRight, but my point is most people are not ripping streams. HDRips are likely either some 0day exploit in Widevine or a device which pretends to respect HDCP. Just about everyone archiving or "archiving" is torrenting.
- Retr0id 3y agoI'd argue that the archival happens the moment the DRM is stripped, the seeders are just helping out with the data replication part - but I get what you're saying. As an aside, HDCP is broken in practice but frowned upon for archival, since it requires a re-encode, introducing generation loss.
- charcircuit 3y agoHDCP itself isn't broken, but it shifts the problem to the next weakest link which would be between the controller board and the panel.
- Retr0id 3y agoNo, HDCP itself is broken. According to the DMCA, and corresponding legal precedent[1], you're allowed to convert one version of HDCP to another. You can buy legitimate adapters off the shelf (provisioned with valid keys) to convert HDCP 2.2 to HDCP 1.4. No jumping through hoops, no legal grey areas (for now), it just works. HDCP 1.4 uses export-grade (broken) cryptography, the master keys are available on the public web. But you don't need to bother understanding the specifics, since just about any HDMI 1.4 sink you buy from China (whether it's a capture card or splitter) will strip HDCP 1.4 as a matter of course. [1] https://torrentfreak.com/4k-content-protection-stripper-beats-warner-bros-in-court-1605xx/ https://torrentfreak.com/4k-content-protection-stripper-beat...
- Retr0id 3y agoIt would be a lot simpler to just ban DRM, and allow digital copying for personal use. I don't expect it to happen any time soon, but I can dream.
- CamperBob2 3y agoWe don't need to ban DRM, we just need to force content providers to choose between technical and legal means of copyright protection. They should not be permitted to use both, because DRM amounts in practice to theft from the (eventual) public domain.
- Retr0id 3y agoYeah, I agree with that, and was going to add an edit to that effect but I guess I forgot. The way things are currently, the legal protections are stronger than the technical protections. I think it's much more realistic for legislation to be updated to allow copying for personal use, than it is for DRM to be banned outright.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> We don't need to ban DRM, we just need to force content providers to choose between technical and legal means of copyright protection. This is not even interesting because in practice all of the DRM is broken. The actual problem is that we have tools that prohibit circumventing DRM even when the copy is not an infringement of copyright (e.g. fair use) and that prohibit distribution of circumvention tools even if they're not used for copyright infringement, e.g. because the same DRM system is being maliciously applied to works already in the public domain. Or -- and this is the real reason this garbage is on the books -- the DRM is being used for anti-competitive purposes rather than to prevent copying. Because it doesn't prevent copying (evidence: all the content being on all the piracy sites), but it does prevent a legitimate competitor who actually cares about complying with the law from doing interoperability things that are not an infringement of copyright but are a violation of the DMCA.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jtbayly 3y agoNo. If you buy a book and determine its quality will leave it falling apart sooner than you want, you can return it or copy it or work to preserve it. If it starts falling apart, you can repair it. If a cd gets a scratch you can repair it. You can store it in a climate controlled environment. All of these things are in your hands. Some people will burn their books or toss them. Some will preserve them for centuries. The problem is that with purely digital, there is just nothing you can do. None of it is up to you. You can’t copy it, preserve it, etc. Sony says you’re done and that’s it.
- Retr0id 3y agoStreamed digital media can be copied trivially, you're just not allowed to. I'm not even allowed to tell you how to do it.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoWell, only for the one protected by DRM.
- 22c 3y agoNit: It's not protected by DRM, it's protected by copyrights. It's still against the law in most places to violate copyrights, even if there's no DRM involved.
- bfdm 3y agoBut it's equally important that where the copying would otherwise be allowed under copyright rules, anti tampering DRM laws (like DMCA 1201) make it criminal to perform or aid that copying. That's why DRM protection for its own sake needs to get tossed. It's a massive overreach.
- Aerroon 3y agoWould it still be considered bypassing DRM if you just record the screen? All the layers of DRM are active in that case.
- evulhotdog 3y agoThere was a related post a few weeks ago, and someone mentioned that it shouldn’t be called buying, but _renting_ the content. Since it can be removed from you any point and time for any reason.
- BlueTemplar 3y ago> A forever contract doesn't even make sense. Why not ? People aren't forever either. Unless a non-human entity can agree to one / it can be sold / it can be transferred to heirs ? (I guess it would be better to call it "until your death", but I would guess marketing finds that phrasing too negative ?)
- justinclift 3y agoHmmm, how about "if a company advertises something being available 'forever', they are required to make it available for a length of time not less than the average human lifespan"? That sounds reasonable to me. :)
- cuckatoo 3y agoLet's tie it to the length of copyright law. If it's still protected and under copyright then the obligation to keep it available exists. So if they want to keep extending copyright, well, it will go both ways.
- lamontcg 3y agoAnd if they want to stop maintaining it, let them have the option of releasing it into the public domain and sending a digital copy to the library of congress or something.
- android42 3y agoAt the very least I would also accept a DRM free copy being provided to everyone who had purchased it (e.g. at least one year or so to download it), and in failure to do that it becomes public domain. Anything less and we basically just end up with the classic xkcd situation https://xkcd.com/488/ https://xkcd.com/488/
- cncovyvysi 3y agoWhy bend the knee? They want insane copyright protections. We do to.
- PurpleRamen 3y agoYou can't make a work public domain, just because one distributor is shutting down their digital library. In the first place, they don't even have the rights for this, they just resell other people's work. Demanding for ensuring another way for accessing the work in the same or similar way is fair enough. You lose nothing, they gain nothing, fairly balanced.
- flenserboy 3y agoTrue. Yet I think the idea is sound — if a publisher / rights holder refuses to put a work into print or make it available, they should not be able to keep it away from the public. Copyright is a benefit given to authors & publishers, but is too-often used to suppress works due to content or retire works that can be replaced in the catalog by more profitable offerings.
- Kamq 3y ago> I don't expect anything to exist "forever". On one hand, that's kinda fair. Forever is pretty rough. On the other hand, companies probably shouldn't use the word forever when promising things then. I don't like your solution, because there's legitimately movies I really only want to watch once (actually that's the majority of them), and I'm pretty sure companies are gonna use the need to provide it for X time as a reason to jack up the price. I think there's a legitimate place for limited time things, but the deal should be up front and you shouldn't be using the word "forever". Also, kinda limits the notion of "buying" far beyond the standard english definition. "Buying" a ticket to a movie in a theater is perfectly legitimate, but doesn't really correspond to anything you're talking about. We all know we have to leave the movie theater afterwards and can't watch the movie again. This is fine, generally, because we know the deal going into it. It seems like the solution here is to have companies be up front with the deal. I feel like the easiest way to do that is to hold a couple companies accountable for the language they use when promising something, and the rest of them will be very up front, very quickly. And I don't mean bury it in a EULA, but the actual deal that gets filtered down to the human beings, just make it so that only provisions of the EULA that most customers know about are actually enforceable or something.
- faeriechangling 3y agoI don’t see how Sony isn’t simply defrauding their (funimation’s) customers. How does a merger change this? I could maybe understand a digital library being disappeared after a bankruptcy but it appears funimation was doing okay and they just screwed their customers to make extra margin. I don’t see why they shouldn’t be sued. It’s not as though funimation advertised these leases as leases, they called them forever purchases lol. It’s outrageous these companies don’t advertise a period of time your purchase is good for and purchase insurance to ensure availability. They trick their customers with the fraudulent lie that they’re buying something and then screw them because they paid a lump sum up front and made themselves easy marks. I’ve paid for Crunchyroll before but fuck doing that ever again when anime piracy sites like aniwave provide in many ways a better experience.
- imp0cat 3y agoWhat's wrong with Crunchyroll? I just recently noticed that new Sony TVs come with a dedicated Crunchyroll button and wondered whether this streaming service is worth it? It seems like you don't think it is, correct?
- rob74 3y agoThere's probably nothing wrong with Crunchyroll if you're into the content it provides. The article is about Sony removing the digital copies that buyers of Funimation DVDs/Blurays purchased together with their physical media - and the article argues that some may have discarded the physical media because they have (had) convenient access to the digital copies (hint: don't do that!). But yeah, this is another instance where people who forked out their hard-earned money for legal copies of media are screwed and might be tempted to think "why didn't I simply download a pirated copy?".
- kazinator 3y ago> A forever contract doesn't even make sense. There are hundreds-of-years-old annuities that are still paying interest. "A living artifact from the Dutch Golden Age: Yale’s 367-year-old water bond still pays interest" https://news.yale.edu/2015/09/22/living-artifact-dutch-golden-age-yale-s-367-year-old-water-bond-still-pays-interest https://news.yale.edu/2015/09/22/living-artifact-dutch-golde...
- earthwalker99 3y ago>What about if, to be legally allowed to license streaming content, companies were required by law to: They won't be and that's your problem.
- m463 3y agoMaybe don't say BUY or OWN clearly and be upfront and pedantic about it.
- rkagerer 3y agoI like your idea. Though in a sense this problem is already solved. If a company promises "forever" but doesn't back it up with a surety bond or endowment guarantee of some sort, then you should treat it with great skepticism. In the meantime, consumers are free to litigate under breach of contract, false advertising or other appropriate doctrine. In this case, it was never really "forever" at all, as the Terms stated: Funimation can “without advance notice… immediately suspend or terminate the availability of the Service and/or content (and any elements and features of them), in whole or in part, for any reason."
- consp 3y agoIsn't that still false advertising? At least in some parts of the world?
- eru 3y ago> 1) Specify a minimum duration available as part of the buy button and all other text using the term "buy" or "license"? E.g. "Buy for 5 years" or "License now (min. 10 years guaranteed)" They might already have that kind of fineprint in there somewhere? > 2) Require some kind of insurance/escrow/backup in advance, that guarantees that if they go out of business, all accounts and purchases will transfer to another service that will continue to honor them for the time period specified (or full purchase price is refunded) That's a nice idea, but I think customers should also be allowed to opt out of that requirement. Why should I be forced to pay for that insurance, when I don't need it? (And, of course, that's the situation we have today: companies can legally license you content with our without that kind of insurance.)
- exe34 3y agoOr that they have to provide a DRM-free version before removing access.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Require some kind of insurance/escrow/backup in advance This is kind of ridiculous in this context. The content is not really at risk of being lost. Did the service go away even though you were supposed to have permanent access? Okay, now it should be legal for you to download it from The Pirate Bay.
- scotty79 3y ago> Specify a minimum duration available as part of the buy button and all other text using the term "buy" or "license"? E.g. "Buy for 5 years" or "License now (min. 10 years guaranteed)" Why not till the end of life of the customer plus 95 years? Seems reasonable.
- Cub3 3y agoThey shouldn't be able to call it "buy"ing it should be referred to as "rent"ing if they can pull your purchased copy at any moment
- ksec 3y agoWe need physical copies. We need to bring it back. A Storage medium, that is cheap, small, durable. I was looking at SD Card or Switch's Storage card the other day and thinking if Movies or Titles could be stored just like it while being significantly cheaper to manufacture.
- account42 3y ago> (or full purchase price is refunded With inflation that is not enough - the minimum acceptable refund should be the price to buy the same product at the time of the refund. > In terms of a minimum time duration, there are even physical analogies here -- books can yellow and their bindings crack and glue fail, vinyl wears out, floppy disks become unreadable after a decade or two -- I've even had CDs experience some kind of green growth in humid climates rendering them unreadable. So we already have a kind of pre-existing expectation of media purchases only lasting so long, on average. That's why copyright law in many countries allows you to make backups for personal use. This isn't possible with streaming services so the service must provide the equivalent.