5 ms·
Still waiting for an open discussion forum for scientific papers. Like StackOverflow, but every post is a paper. And there are experts of various gradations th
by amelius 3y ago
Still waiting for an open discussion forum for scientific papers.
Like StackOverflow, but every post is a paper. And there are experts of various gradations that help with questions.
- user_7832 3y agoI think researchgate tried to do that, but I don't know how successful they've been.
- roh26it 3y agoIndividual subreddits have usually been my go-to place to discuss and understand the nuances of academic papers. Love LocalLLama for discussions on generative AI papers.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thsksbd 3y agoThere's too many paper
- maCDzP 3y agoLike this? https://gotit.pub/ https://gotit.pub/
- shannonnn 3y agoI’m playing around with something similar here https://thetrecs.com/ https://thetrecs.com/ . But no experts yet. Even though I do science, I have a hard time understanding abstracts from adjacent fields so I’m using llms to make the abstracts easier for me and my friends to understand
- paulpauper 3y agoIt would be quickly overwhelmed, especially for complicated math papers
- wolverine876 3y agoBetter yet (IMHO), like HN. In my field, I know where to find papers, etc. I'm interested in other fields, and not every paper; just rank them by a HN-like algorithm. I said a few days ago, in my dream HN would be mostly papers. That's where the richest, most accurate, most intellectually curious information is - far beyond most things on HN.
- pests 3y agomost of the most intellectually curious things I've ever seen on the Internet were not research papers so I don't know how you can make that claim.
- wolverine876 3y agoIt's a matter of opinion, of course. But what are you reading? I'm very interested in finding more and better! I find research papers to be an order of magnitude richer, more accurate, more thoughtful than almost anything else. Everything else is too slow and doesn't answer most of the questions I have. Research papers (and books) not only answer the questions, they take me much further than what I knew existed - what I'd hope for from experts.
- pests 3y agoI think limiting yourself to research papers alone will deprieve you of ideas which are just developing, which may not have an official body of research or even any published papers about. Ideas we as a society or culture might only beginning to tackle. I find the discussion around a thing to be sometimes more interesting than the thing itself - a research paper might spark way more interesting discussions than the paper itself. Take the "Attention Is All You Need" paper. How many have actually read it vs. how much has been written about it, or about the things it led to? There is a lot packed into those 10 pages, but I've found the thousands of discussions around transformers and GPT to be way more interesting.
- wolverine876 3y ago
- geysersam 3y agoYes please. That's the peer review of my dreams. What an extraordinarily valuable resource that would be.
- godelski 3y agohttps://openreview.net/ https://openreview.net/ ? Open Review allows public comments. It's open, you can see revisions, authors can link repositories, datasets, and websites. You can even submit papers there outside of review. But it is expected that you are posting your own work. So kinda like arXiv but a bit more. Here's an example with Mamba. https://openreview.net/forum?id=AL1fq05o7H https://openreview.net/forum?id=AL1fq05o7H
- dwayne_dibley 3y agoReddit tried.
- o_____________o 3y agoI think this is what https://pubpeer.com/ https://pubpeer.com/ wants to be