5 ms·
'Employers hold the cards now' as power shifts in US jobs market
- braza 3y agohttps://archive.is/dzWM6 https://archive.is/dzWM6
- 5350-uiop-1130 3y ago> "companies becoming more demanding of their staff as they find it easier to replace them." for (web)dev it began with learn2code. that was the death knell. > "At this point, I suspect we will see further moderation of wage growth" with this being the goal. i haven't had a pay rise in 4 years. and was told indirectly, since job market is bad they feel no need to be competitive.
- kaashif 3y agoThe past 4 years includes a time when the market was red hot and great for software engineers - 2021-2. Not getting a raise during that time is due to something other than "job market is bad" because it wasn't.
- 5350-uiop-1130 3y ago> 2020 - sorry covid, hiring and pay restricted > 2021 - see above > 2023 layoffs > 2024 dead job market > "great for software engineers" you must be referring to yourself eh?
- ellieee 3y ago> you must be referring to yourself eh? or anyone else who was paying attention and had a bit of drive to seize opportunity. early 2020 to late 2022 was a gold rush
- BadCookie 3y agoOn the other hand, if someone made a jump to a new company in 2022, they were more likely to be on the layoff chopping block in 2023 than employees with a little more tenure. At least, I have seen in my own organization that the recently hired are at much higher risk of being laid off even if they’ve shown promise.
- bdcravens 3y agoThe reason why you've seen so many 2023 layoffs is that companies went crazy hiring during the pandemic. "From the end of 2019 to 2023, tech companies scrambled to keep up with an explosion of consumer demand, as people stuck at home splurged on new computers and spent much more time online. Apple, Amazon, Meta, Microsoft and Alphabet, Google’s parent company, added a total of more than 900,000 jobs." https://www.seattletimes.com/business/why-is-big-tech-still-cutting-jobs https://www.seattletimes.com/business/why-is-big-tech-still-...
- fatnoah 3y agoPersonally, I've had a wild ride: 2019 - 50% raise 2021 - 30% raise 2022 - layoff and eventual 67% pay cut 2023/2024 - applications everywhere, and "success" is getting a company to communicate a rejection.
- fxtentacle 3y agoI agree that there are a lot of coding bootcamp web devs flooding the market. But I see almost no influence on the full stack consulting market that I'm working in. Those bootcamp devs can replace your outsourced devs in India. But typically they have very little skill in thinking like an engineer, meaning they will utterly fail to implement any business logic and/or those software components that actually create value for the customer. If you feel like learn2code graduates are competing with you, maybe that means it's time for you to level up yourself.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoFresh out of the schools, in the first year or two sure. But afaik most of them don't really stay full time engineers for that long, most bounce out or switch to other specializations with the experience they've earned. Code school devs 4+ years into their careers are as reliable as anyone else at the same experience level. I slightly prefer them with hiring, since succeeding with that approach shows a certain degree of flexibility and calculated risk taking. The first code school cohorts are a decade or more into their careers now. Most of them didn't stick around but the ones who did are very solid. They are just the forerunners, the big swell of 2015-2018 graduates who stayed in the industry is just hitting that mid-senior level.
- rcbdev 3y agoFor the record - This is absolutely not the case in Europe as far as I can tell.
- dagw 3y agoI guess it really must depend a lot on where you are then, because in my experience of my corner of Europe, lots of companies have had significant layoffs, jobs hunting is getting harder and raises have not at all kept of with inflation.
- StreetChief 3y agoThere are major strikes in Germany about Quality of Life issues right now. I think France might be having strikes too now, but I haven't investigated the one clip I saw.
- fxtentacle 3y agoFully agree. The article says "The days of the battle for talent are over." but as a consultant I keep getting project requests by companies who couldn't find enough employees and are now willing to pay a premium for outside help that may enable then to still keep their deadlines.
- braza 3y agoI do not buy that cause in Central Europe there’s a lot of tech companies offices closing or exiting, and the whole scene of startups and scale ups are not so dynamic as USA and if you go to pitchbook/Crunchbase you will see tons of “startups from 2011” with overhead/org bloat with last round in 2020/21. If I was employed in some company in Central Europe, I would not bet my livelihood in any kind of job stability that is sold in the region by work council or regulations that can be easily hoped.
- firstplacelast 3y agoHopefully next time the tech market is in an upswing, we can unionize?
- avidiax 3y agoNow would be the time to unionize. Nobody wants to join a union during a hot market. It's easier to negotiate for yourself at a new job.
- earthwalker99 3y ago>Now would be the time to unionize. As someone who actually knows something about unions and their history, it literally never works that way. OP is correct. You can't make moves when you don't have power. >Nobody wants to join a union during a hot market. That's what has to change. I'm not saying it will change, but it's the only way. If your union is dependent on temporary conditions, it's weak. Weak unions are usually worse than no union at all. There are no shortcuts.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoWhile it's true that this would be a difficult time to unionize, I think part of that is that companies are looking to replace software devs with AI over the next decade. Not entirely, but a future where companies can get the same amount done with half the number employees seems reasonable with tooling improvements. Which is to say, it may not be the historically best time to unionize, but it also might be the best time that we'll see in the future, and the most critical time to do so.
- qwertyuiop_ 3y agoWhat do you think is stopping tech employees from unionizing?
- garciasn 3y agoMoney. Perceived or actual self-control of your own destiny. —- I worked as a unionized employee for the first part of my career and all it did was severely limit my pay and growth trajectory. I’m not going back to that.
- TeckPerspecc 3y agoSounds like it’s time to cancel the H1B visa.
- bdcravens 3y agoHow is that related to the article? In theory, no matter what the job market, companies will have the need for talent unavailable locally (of course the H1B is abused, but that's the stated purpose) If you're implying that eliminating H1Bs would shoot wages upward, I don't believe that would happen.
- Dig1t 3y agoIt would, immigration in all forms directly affects labor supply, which affects wages. There’s a reason that basically every single CEO is pro-immigration.
- lumost 3y agoIn Tech, H1B is commonly used for relatively generic SWE positions. It could be argued that there is a shortage - or it could be argued that employers prefer Visa holders due to additional control they get from employing a Visa holder. If the local workforce doesn't feel like they can get ahead... they will grow disgruntled. Targeting Visa and other immigration programs is something that they perceive they can control more so than changing employer attitudes. The same pattern can be observed in Canada. If I have to spend ~3500 per month to own a home within an hour of downtown. Then I need a take-home pay of 168k/year which is roughly 268k/year pre-tax. The number of positions which actually pay 268k/year is already small.
- jannyfer 3y ago$3500/month rent is $42k/yr. You need $124k/yr of after-tax money for food, transportation, and everything else?!
- lumost 3y agoThis was for owning, rental rates are more difficult to assess due to the likelihood of collective living. General rule is that mortgage shouldn't exceed 30% post-tax, hence multiplying by 4 to allow a 5% buffer and a stable financial situation. In a city where a condo costs 3500/month.. It's quite likely that you'll need 124k for everything else. A basic "fast" lunch in downtown Boston runs ~20 dollars these days (5000/yr), parking alone can burn ~10k/yr. If you opt to avoid cars for public transit then you need to add 2-4k to the mortgage payment. As everyone else is facing the same housing math, prices rise. There is some lag to pricing as individuals avoid paying market rate for housing by buying 10+ years ago or locking in lower interest rates.
- tamimio 3y agoIt never was otherwise, WFH was the only thing that shifted little of these cards to the employees, you might didn’t get a high salary but you saved on commute/rent/etc., and yet, they fought tooth and nail to end it, job market in the US is a modern slavery, which should be obvious with a country that has no minimum days mandates for an annual vacation or getting fired to form a union.
- webninja 3y agoIt will always be that case so long as an employee can hold only one full time job and yet an employer can diversify amongst many employees.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI wasn't a union supporter until I realized it was the only way to tilt the power balance, once you have built a mental model of current state. I don't need a union, as I do not require an income, but my fellow human does, so onward. You only need majorities to arrive at outcomes.
- lurking15 3y ago> job market in the US is a modern slavery seems despicable to invoke slavery for people nowadays who get paid as free people
- rcbdev 3y agoIn my country 98% of all workers are under union contracts - this has always just been a fact of my working life and I never knew how different it could be in other places until rather recently. The lack of unionization and mandatory PTO in the US is the most foreign concept imaginable.
- gamblor956 3y agoNeeding to go into the office is not slavery. It's disgusting to liken the literal ownership of a human being as property to be used and abused 24/7 to having to commute to a nice, air-conditioned office a few days a week.
- downrightmike 3y agoCorporate profits are just unpaid wages.
- webninja 3y agoInteresting perspective. They’re instead paid to my retirement investment account and Uncle Sam.
- downrightmike 3y agoNot really, especially if they are left in offshore tax evasion accounts
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2024/02/08/case-against-401k-ira-retirement-tax-breaks/72506433007/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2024/02/08/case-against... > The federal government should stop subsidizing pre-tax contributions to retirement savings accounts, two economists from opposing ideological camps argued in a research brief in January. > Allowing people to shelter their retirement money from taxes is a policy that largely favors the well-heeled, they said. Congress could use that money, nearly $200 billion a year in lost tax dollars, to shore up the underfunded Social Security program. People supporting these accounts will put forth "personal responsibility," but the evidence shows that most Americans can't afford to get exposure to the capital markets due to wage stagnation and whatnot, so it's theater vs a real solution. It works for the lucky ones, but most people aren't lucky. Good policy isn't built on luck.
- downrightmike 3y agoremoving pre-tax retirement contributions really won't do shit to fix American's not saving because the wages are stagnate. You really jumped through some hoops to get there.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoUnions and organizing are needed to push wages up [1], admittedly, but tax sheltered retirements aren't helping anyone but a privileged minority (as the paper in the USA Today piece mentions). No hoops required. We tried 401ks and IRAs because it was an easy way to shed pensions and keep those contributes for shareholders, leaving most folks to end up on paltry Social Security benefits. The experiment failed. If you don't see it, you're ignoring the data [2] [3], which I suppose is a choice. [1] https://www.epi.org/publication/eroded-collective-bargaining/ https://www.epi.org/publication/eroded-collective-bargaining... [2] https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-23-105342 https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-23-105342 [3] https://www.gao.gov/financial-security-older-americans https://www.gao.gov/financial-security-older-americans