5 ms·
> Websearch is sputtering sure but that's normal after a challenge like chatgpt. How would the existence of LLMs make "classic" web search worse? SEO spam and
by lxgr 3y ago
> Websearch is sputtering sure but that's normal after a challenge like chatgpt.
How would the existence of LLMs make "classic" web search worse? SEO spam and content farms cluttering the first results page has been going on for longer too.
> Services like Gmail/gsuite are awesome for productivity and while they lag in shiny features, the teams are adding features quickly enough.
Google Docs has some of the most cursed UI that I've used in the past 20 years (and I work with Jira). I'm forced to use it at work so I stick with it.
FWIW, 90% of my gripes would go away if it just supported a "markdown mode" instead of WYSIWYG, and I don't understand what's so hard about that for somebody of Google's caliber.
> It's cute to think you have any real privacy while carrying a cellphone.
The alternative is... giving up on the idea? Just storing anything centrally because end-to-end/client-side encryption/local processing is a lost cause?
> Drive and storage just work.
That's what Google does really well indeed: Things close to infrastructure with as little product/UI aspects as possible. Getting rid of hard links in Drive was a great move too. No complaints there. Voice is another thing in that category: It's a hard infrastructure problem, and Google nailed it. The same goes for the versioning/conflict resolution backend of GSuite: A marvel of engineering.
The hardest part is not accidentally cancelling things that work and that solve problems for actual users in favor of yet another instant messenger.
> Google contributes more to open source than anybody and especially Apple and Microsoft. Chromium and Android alone blow everyone else out of the water.
Quantitatively, sure, maybe. Qualitatively, having unleashed Protobuf onto the world alone undoes a significant amount of goodwill in my view.
- ghaff 3y ago>Google Docs has some of the most cursed UI that I've used in the past 20 years (and I work with Jira). I'm forced to use it at work so I stick with it. >FWIW, 90% of my gripes would go away if it just supported a "markdown mode" instead of WYSIWYG, and I don't understand what's so hard about that for somebody of Google's caliber. I guess that's a philosophical point. I have pretty much zero interest in markdown. And, as someone who has used word processors since the 1980s, I really like Google Docs (and Google Slides) they pretty much do all of the things I want and rarely lack a feature I need. (Might feel different as a lawyer for revision tracking and my use of Sheets is far lighterweight than my use of Lotus and then Excel was back in the day.) And I think I'd just give up were I to go make to emailing copies of documents around. It's not perfect for everything and everyone but the Google Suite works really well for me.
- lxgr 3y agoThere's an easy solution here: Offer both! Google can afford to offer two kinds of document editors, and it would make the entire GSuite infinitely more valuable and enjoyable to me. I already have a bunch of Markdown text files synced to my GDrive – why can I literally not edit them in the GDrive web interface? There's not even a basic text editor!
- ghaff 3y agoWhich can be the formula for adding another layer of features that 1% (or whatever) of users care about.
- refulgentis 3y agoWant me to really bake your noodle? Ready? It has Markdown mode as an option. Peak HN, perfectly executed: - "it's obvious my pet peeve feature X should be added to Y, the company in the article". - "I don't like X". - "Can we have both?" I'm guffawing
- lxgr 3y agoPeak HN is also claiming Y already supports X without showing any evidence. And no, converting a `#` into a H1 is not "markdown support". I want a non-WYSIWYG mode that can let me work on plain text and export it without changing a single comma or tab, optionally with a WYSIWYG presentation layer on top of that like Dropbox Paper does, but one that does not let me add non-markdown features (which would inevitably get lost when exporting and re-importing the same file, or parts of it via copy and paste). Update: You made me look: Sadly still no Markdown support. I would have been very happy to be wrong here.
- shoelessone 3y agoI’m with you. I would love this so much. Maybe irrelevant, but I will say that my spouse who spends a lot more time in Google docs can’t be bothered to learn even the markdown shortcuts for H tags in docs even though it would save her a ton of time. I imagine that’s a large majority of people.
- WWLink 3y agoIf you think jira is bad you should try deltek costpoint. Holy shit.
- notpachet 3y agoDon't say its name!
- a_gnostic 3y agoits name
- mattgreenrocks 3y agoCostpoint is the UI hell you didn’t even know existed until you see it for yourself. It’s timesheet software that appears to be a legacy Windows app using an unholy number of compatibility shims to run in the browser. Almost nothing is a native control! It sometimes refuses to load randomly, and can be really slow at certain hours. Its job is to record a few numbers for each user once a day.
- WWLink 3y agoIt can be used for a lot more than just timesheets, and the UI gets weirder and weirder in those other features.
- cratermoon 3y agoMicrosoft's "Azure DevOps" is worse than Jira.
- WWLink 3y agoTBH I'm surprised we aren't forced to use it since it's a Microsoft product and whenever there's a Microsoft version of something we seem to get forced to use it. Weird.
- esafak 3y agoThe only thing worse than B2B for UX is B2G.
- klyrs 3y ago>> Websearch is sputtering sure but that's normal after a challenge like chatgpt. > How would the existence of LLMs make "classic" web search worse? SEO spam and content farms cluttering the first results page has been going on for longer too. To add my latest peeve, google search is suddenly terrible at units. When I look for "24 inches in cm" it gives me an answer in meters. And duh, I know that conversion, but until quite recently my browser search bar was a handy little calculator and now that's gone. Surely we aren't blaming GPT for this.
- johannes1234321 3y ago> FWIW, 90% of my gripes would go away if it just supported a "markdown mode" instead of WYSIWYG, and I don't understand what's so hard about that for somebody of Google's caliber. This exactly hard on Google's caliber. Not only do they have a bunch of requests for special modes where they can't simply add all without creating a mess, but at that size they also have to consider the support cost of users hitting the "wrong" mode and being tied to it and being frustrated. WYSWIG is core to the product definition.
- lxgr 3y agoI do see that it’s not a simple problem. But this brings us back on topic nicely: This is Google we’re talking about! There was a time when the name was synonymous for the best software engineering and some of the brightest minds in the world! And here we are arguing whether two different editing paradigms in one word processor might be too hard for them.
- sanderjd 3y ago> FWIW, 90% of my gripes would go away if it just supported a "markdown mode" instead of WYSIWYG Approximately nobody wants this though. Sure, you want it, and I want it, and some other people like us, but we're a rounding error of the user base of Google Docs. This would be a great plugin, but very difficult to justify building as a first class feature. And there's nothing wrong with protobuf :)
- readams 3y agoMarkdown in Google docs: https://support.google.com/docs/answer/12014036?hl=en https://support.google.com/docs/answer/12014036?hl=en Of course, if you want non wysiwyg, then don't use Google docs just use markdown in a text editor or install mediawiki or something.
- lxgr 3y agoYeah, I want non-WYSIWYG, or at least something that cleanly copy-pastes into and out of markdown. I don’t get to choose, and I bet a considerable fraction of Google Docs users don’t either and it’s just what their workplace prescribes.
- senseiV 3y agoI just saw a markdown mode show up today, but only partially, like bold and italics in markdown