4 ms·
Neanderthals, modern humans may have co-existed in Europe for at least 10k years
- 7thaccount 3y agoI saw a documentary on humans and Neanderthals about a decade ago and it melted my mind. Absolutely fascinating that there was another species that was very similar to us that we interbred with. Crazy!
- pavlov 3y agoI kind of feel the opposite: the crazy part isn’t that we had relatives, but that we’re the only remaining species of the Homo genus. It’s somehow unsettling that we are the only ones left. Most large mammals come from a genus with many cousins. We’re alone either because we killed the others, or because intelligence actually has a hard time surviving in nature. Neither is really good news for us.
- throwup238 3y agoThe taxonomy of archaic humans is debatable to say the least so "we are only the ones left" may just be an artifact of 19th century anthropology and prestige chasing. Realistically the genetic variation between the average human and Neanderthals is only about twice the variation within the modern human gene pool. Compared to our nearest primate at 10-50x the difference depending on how you measure. Given the number of genetic bottlenecks we have evidence of in our past, we may all be the same species and the modern human is just the last surviving group of inbred Homos.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y ago[flagged]
- pavlov 3y agoIsn’t “genetic bottlenecks” another way of saying that intelligence has a poor track record of surviving?
- kombookcha 3y agoNot really - genetic bottlenecks aren't a feature of intelligent animals, it's a feature of a population that's undergone some kind of very dramatic pressure event like catastrophic loss of habitat or mass illness. Bottlenecks are more likely to be an issue for species with a limited range, population and a slim range of survivable conditions. Intelligence has a way of expanding those ranges by making you more equipped to access otherwise inaccessible resources. Think of elephants navigating between watering holes during droughts, crows using tools to fish out hard to get food, or orcas using sophisticated hunting techniques to get at prey they otherwise could not. Intelligence adds flexibility, and flexibility is especially useful under pressure.
- mjfl 3y agowhich implies that there are humans alive that are genetically as far apart from each other as the average human was from the average neanderthal (i.e. statistically there probably exists humans who's separation from each other is twice the average distance).
- hyggetrold 3y ago[flagged]
- ffgjgf1 3y agoAs far as we can tell Neanderthal populations were very small and fragile (very low genetic diversity) to begin with. So it’s not unlikely that modern human just absorbed them. A bit like the hunter gatherers who pretty much disappeared in much of Europe during the Neolithic
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSeems silly, but why Genocide specifically? What does that word mean to you and what do you think that would look like?
- hyggetrold 3y agoMeans pretty much the definition: "the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group." So yeah...in my crazy conspiracy theory (which I don't take very seriously) I think Neanderthals may have been systematically hunted down and exterminated. When you study human history you soon discover that no matter the era, we have a total fondness for killing each other.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoGenocide really depends on the motivation. If we simply ate them to extinction, that wouldnt be genocide. Even expanding and taking their lands would be a stretch, as long as the destruction is incidental
- hyggetrold 3y agoUm...wow. Might makes right?
- 3y ago
- mjfl 3y agothey weren't necessarily killed off, rather blended into the human population through conquest and wife-stealing and the resulting interbreeding.
- mistrial9 3y agoindeed, wife-stealing appears to be a very successful formation over long periods of time.. woe to the peaceful
- ffgjgf1 3y agoIf anything it was the opposite: > No evidence of Neanderthal mitochondrial DNA has been found in modern humans.[30][31][32] > This suggests that successful Neanderthal admixture happened in pairings with Neanderthal males and modern human females Of course it also might mean that human males and Neanderthal females can’t produce viable offspring
- mjfl 3y agoIt doesn't follow that if human males stole Neanderthal wives sometime in the past, that you would necessarily see Neanderthal mitochondrial DNA in present populations. Consider a serial 'wife-stealing' human culture. One generation of human males leaps upon a small population of Neanderthals, killing the men and stealing the women. The next generation, a new group of half-neanderthal males leaves the colony in search of wives, finds a human group, kills the men, and steals the women. The children of this generation will be 1/4 Neanderthal with no Neanderthal mitochondrial DNA. Imagine that the first colony gets wiped out, as most ancient communities were. There you go.
- ffgjgf1 3y ago> There you go. So either it didn’t happen at all or if it did it happened in on a much smaller scale than the opposite (Neanderthal male and human female)? Also this scenario is completely unsubstantiated conjecture so hardly worth discussing.
- shagie 3y ago> or because intelligence actually has a hard time surviving in nature. Alas, I can't find it now... there was a book that I read (Bear / Brin / Benford as the author I believe... maybe Baxter... one of the great Bs I'm sure of) about the matrilineal line from a small shrew like animal in the time of the dinosaurs through neanderthals to modern times... and beyond. Part of the "and beyond" was the theme that intelligence and our brain is an extremely expensive organ to maintain (our brain consumes about 20% of the calories that we consume a day https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC124895/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC124895/ ). After some catastrophe that reduces the energy budget that animals can use... well, intelligence is one of the things to go. (Late edit: It was Baxter - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution_(Baxter_novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution_(Baxter_novel) )
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think that any forecasts are probably reading too much into a limited data set. Intelligence does have an incredibly hard time surviving in nature. Humans are hyper-optimized for it. We are far weaker than chimps, and burn 30% more calories. We are slow reproducing k-strategists, with infants that are helpless for years. That said, Humans are planet level apex predators, and universal omnivores that consume everything whales to yeast and synthetic foods made from elemental materials. Over the course of our existence, our capability for growth has vastly overshadowed any downside from intra-species hostility. We are also the most cooperative and social animal that has ever existed. This is a pretty strong position to be in, and certainly better than just about any other animal sharing the plant.
- polishdude20 3y agoYeah what blows my mind thinking about it is just how we are the only species that communicates across continents.
- golergka 3y agoOr may be because we lived together for so long that individual differences disappeared and averaged out as people intermarried and had a lot of mixed babies. I'm not saying that this necessarily happened, only that the burden of proof for your theory should be higher.
- mrangle 3y agoThis is what happened, logically speaking. Though not averaged out in a balanced manner: instead, to the degree that Neanderthal genetics comprise anyone's genome. Not to say that there weren't interspecies genocides, but we interbred with them and then outcompeted, for resources, the pure species into extinction generally speaking. Which was inevitable, parallel to how homo sapien lineages also die out from simply being outcompeted. It is likely that the Neanderthal genome was outcompeted down to a percentage at which it was and is competitive. 50-50% Neanderthal-Modern Human? No dice, Darwin. It had to be reduced to a few percentage points, at which point individuals started being competitive. Was the last pure Neanderthal pair murdered, did they die from starvation, or did they just refuse to have kids? It could have been any of those, but the general procedure was likely defined by resource competition. And Neanderthal isn't the only alien-homo genome mixed with that of modern humans.
- namlem 3y agoWere Neanderthals more genetically different from typical Homo sapiens than modern day pygmy peoples? Iirc, Khosians also diverged genetically from other regional peoples.
- hobs 3y agoDon't forget that we intermixed with the Denisovans too.
- bjackman 3y agoBased on modern DNA patterns there also seems to have been at least one other major population group around the same time that we have not found any remains of, which was related to both Sapiens and Denisovans. They probably lived mostly around southeast Asia. (Neanderthals were mostly in Europe and Denisovans are thought probably to have generally inhabited northern Asia). I can highly recommend The World Before Us by Tom Higham, it goes into the history of the archaeology and science and also goes over a pretty up-to-date understanding of the topic of recent Hominin evolution. (Also, it's very likely I've misconstrued some of it in my paragraphs above, apologies if so).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mjfl 3y agoanother interesting fact is that modern Europeans are descended from 4 distinct populations which were as genetically distant from each other as modern Europeans are from Asians: Western hunter gatherers, anatolian farmers, eastern hunter gatherers, and eurasian steppe herders. David Reich goes into it in his book 'Who we are and why we got here'.
- amelius 3y ago> another species that was very similar to us that we interbred with Ok, if it is so similar to us and we interbred with it, then why is this so special? Might as well call it the same species by stretching the definition a little.
- itronitron 3y agoYeah, the interbreeding must have been uncommon as otherwise over 10,000 years there wouldn't be any meaningful distinction (I assume).
- acchow 3y agoEither uncommon or many of the attempts were unsuccessful.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoAlternatively, it could have been so common that Neanderthals were fully assimilated far more rapidly than could be preserved in the fossil record. Especially that limited part of the record that has been so far revealed.
- meheleventyone 3y agoThat is one of the issues with species as a concept. There are quite a few differing definitions which are all useful. It’s typically discussed as the ‘species problem’.
- acchow 3y agoWe were only "separate" species because for a period of tens of thousands of years we did not interbreed and developed independently due to physical separation. But we could and did interbreed when the physical separation was crossed. Despite the separation, we remained similar enough genetically that interbreeding was possible. Were there a higher number of miscarriages than between 2 humans? We will probably never know.
- 3y ago
- carlosjobim 3y agoThey still do ;)
- begueradj 3y agoI once watched a documentary where it was mentioned that homo sapiens co-existend with around 20 archaic human forms (Homo erectus, Homo floresiensis ...etc) , of which only homo sapiens survived and thrived. But this is a subject that always scared me especially with nowadays' politics.
- itronitron 3y ago[flagged]
- qdw 3y agoDuring the period for which we have evidence, Neanderthals seem to have had smaller populations than Homo sapiens, and they reproduced more slowly (longer gestation plus longer interval between pregnancies). So it may be that they went extinct for those reasons.
- manishsharan 3y agoThat may be so .. but I recall reading about Neanderthals' cave drawing .. they depicted Homo sapiens as frightening creatures.
- huytersd 3y agoI can’t find anything about neanderthal cave art that represented Homo sapiens.
- huytersd 3y agoThey also had a lower brain to body ratio so weren't as intelligent.
- namlem 3y agoTheir ratio was about the same as homo sapiens. It's not clear that they were less intelligent, they seem to have had a similar degree of intelligence based on findings from caves in Spain.
- alex201 3y agoIMO it's not that there 'were' multiple species and only we survived; we are still multiple species, but we don't point that out for cultural correctness. Yes, the extent of our differences has narrowed as we passed through survival bottlenecks, but we never became a single species.
- ComplexSystems 3y agoIf every human can interbreed with every other and product viable, non-sterile offspring, then how could it possibly be that we aren't one species?
- InitialLastName 3y agoTo be pedantic about the fuzziness of the "species" delineation, not every human is capable of producing viable, non-sterile offspring (breeding partner notwithstanding).
- kspacewalk2 3y agoThe fact that some individuals are sterile has nothing whatsoever to do with species delineation. If there were entire pairs of population groups, say the Ainu and the Xhosa, which can no longer produce viable offspring with each other due to generic distance, then we could begin a conversation about speciation of homo sapiens. But there aren't, so we don't.
- wolverine876 3y agoDo you have anything that will persuade others that we are actually multiple species? I know of no basis for it. And given no scientific basis (unless I'm wrong), isn't that the reason nobody believes it? The "cultural correctness" argument seems a rehash of the tired, preconceived argument applied to everything.
- acchow 3y agoGiven that there is a single species of human today and most of us have some percentage of Neanderthal DNA, it seems that we are one species today and we were also one species in the past (since we could and did interbreed)
- kromem 3y agoIn the 50s, it was thought that we were smarter than them and killed them all off (the author of Lord of the Flies even wrote a book on this). This seemed to inform futurists at the time thinking about what it would one day look like if there was something smarter than humans. Hopefully we do a better job at considering this revision to our picture of the past and correcting our anchoring bias in our estimation of such a future.
- goatlover 3y agoIt's not known for sure why they went extinct and the extent of their cognitive abilities. It's also only one example. Another might be Europeans coming to the Americas (with more deadly technology and infections diseases, not smarter). Or humans being super predators. We don't know what advanced alien life would be like. Or what AI might become. There's lots of possibilities. Sagan's Contact and The Culture are on on one end, with The Dark Forest and Skynet being on the other.
- labster 3y agoI wonder how much both the early 20th century and the current postmodern views on relations with the Neanderthals was influenced by the politics of the times. Back then people wanted justifications for colonialism and promoted social Darwinism; now we’re looking to promote multiculturalism and global trade. Both ways we’re projecting onto the prehistoric past what we want to see there.
- huytersd 3y agoWell we don’t know that they were smarter than us. The EQ (brain to body ratio) of homo sapiens is 0.019 and Neanderthals was 0.017. They were probably considerably stupider.
- yywwbbn 3y ago> They were probably considerably stupider. What makes you say that?
- dools 3y agoThe origins of the 2 party political system.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39215750 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39215750
- musicale 3y ago> Neanderthals, modern humans may have co-existed in Europe for at least 10k years We're not all Neanderthals here. I think.