4 ms·
> If you live in a city, rely on street parking, and have to charge at the elevated rates of public chargers (which nevertheless are still barely profitable), t
by JohnFen 3y ago
> If you live in a city, rely on street parking, and have to charge at the elevated rates of public chargers (which nevertheless are still barely profitable), then forget it.
Even if privacy wasn't a dealbreaker for me, this is what would kill the idea dead.
I would have no option at all to charge an EV at home, so I would be entirely dependent on driving to a commercial charger in order to do that. Aside from cost, having to hang out at a public charger for so long every time would be hard to put up with.
There's also the issue that I very much prefer to buy my cars used rather than new, but I have trouble with the idea of trusting a used EV. Replacing those batteries is very expensive.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI’ve never had much time to do very many things when using an L3 charger. 20 minutes is enough time to run into a grocery store and grab a few things, but not to do lots of shopping.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 3y agoDoesn't using fast charging reduce the lifespan of the batteries? 20 minutes is still a long time when you're sitting in the car waiting.
- throwaway5959 3y agoHave you ever done it? It’s really not. Listen to four songs or read a book on your phone and you’re done.
- JohnFen 3y agoHave I ever had to sit in my car waiting for something for 20 minutes? Of course. I assume everyone has at one time or another. Occasionally, it's fine. Daily or semi-daily? Less fine. But I'd worry more about the impact of fast-charging every time I'd need to charge, though. Perhaps EV batteries work differently, but fast-charging lithium batteries I'm familiar with has a real impact on battery life. I haven't looked into this much, so I don't know. That's why I'm asking.
- brewdad 3y agoIf you can't charge at home, there is almost no reason to buy an EV today. The infrastructure you would need to rely on just isn't there in most places. If you can charge at home, or maybe at work, there is almost no reason not to buy an EV for your next car. It charges at normal electricity rates while you sleep (or work) and you will never need to charge it anywhere else except for the occasional road trip.
- erik_seaberg 3y agoYou need to own a home, because you can’t know whether your next apartment would have off-street charging.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoNo, I think only if you go above 80% (and it gets slow after 80% given the way batteries work, I just go to 80 unless I plan on navigating the eastern Oregon desert). Also this is just an occasional thing for me, since 99% of the time I'm not on a road trip and can just charge at home (on an L1, L2 isn't even needed). If you look on the internet, even for phones there is a lot of debate about this, and it is universally understood that going to 100% is bad whether via slow or fast charging. They put fast chargers next to grocery stores and restaurants where I'm at, so that's why it always seems too fast for me. You don't have time to eat a meal or do some serious grocery shopping, and its too long to just wait there. Maybe that's the problem? If you are used to gassing up in 5-10 minutes, it seems like a longer time.
- JohnFen 3y ago> this is just an occasional thing for me, since 99% of the time I'm not on a road trip and can just charge at home (on an L1, L2 isn't even needed). Just to be clear, I was specifically addressing people like myself who don't have the ability to charge at home and would be 100% reliant on commercial charging stations. > it is universally understood that going to 100% is bad whether via slow or fast charging. Yes, this is bad regardless. But fast-charging normal lithium batteries reduces the lifespan of those batteries even if you never charge them fully. My question is really whether or not EVs use a different technology that mitigates this.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI really wouldn't recommend an EV yet if you can't charge at home. Unless you have a compelling reason to get one, or maybe a Tesla with a great charging network. One of the main advantages of having an EV is not having to stop to fuel it up at all most of the time. > Yes, this is bad regardless. But fast-charging normal lithium batteries reduces the lifespan of those batteries even if you never charge them fully. My question is really whether or not EVs use a different technology that mitigates this. The electronics used to regulate charging in an EV might be a bit more developed than say...a cheap fast phone charger. But there are plenty of articles you can google about it, since it is a commonly asked question; e.g. https://www.power-sonic.com/blog/fast-charging-battery-life/ https://www.power-sonic.com/blog/fast-charging-battery-life/ They don't find anything, although there are a lot of different kinds of EVs out there.
- matthewdgreen 3y agoL3 chargers are expensive because they draw huge amounts of power in a short period, plus they have major hardware costs. L2 chargers are just connections to 240VAC wiring. They're going to be a little more expensive than, say, street lighting.
- Ekaros 3y agoStreet light is couple thousand. And I think they have longer lifespan. You need to sell quite a lot of electricity with some margin to cover that. And then you have all the overhead of maintenance, repairs and billing...