5 ms·
I Am the Magpie River: How a Quebec river became a person under local law
- office_drone 3y agoThis is misleading. The river has personhood according to a municipality with a population of ~7000. The Canadian legal system has made no such recognition.
- labster 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoOk, we've replaced "the law" with "local law" in the title above.
- bawolff 3y agoTechnically its probably still incorrect (ianal). Municipalities cannot make any local law they want. All law making authority has to be delegated to them by the provincial government. Band councils are a bit more juridsictionally complex, but i imagine this is beyond their authority too. Municipal government making a law outside of their authority has the same effect as if you or i declared a law.
- Sirizarry 3y agoWhy?
- maximus-decimus 3y agoBecause Quebec uses the French civil law system and that doesn't allow cities to make their own laws?
- randomdata 3y agoYou can always make your own laws. Whether or not anyone else is willing to go along with it is another matter. Making a law does not automatically compel others to accept it as their law. Indeed, those who believe in the French civil law system, which describes the majority of Quebec residents, are not likely to accept laws that are made outside of that framework. But they might. The only thing that would try to stop it is other people, but if those other people are also on board then anything is possible.
- bawolff 3y agoWhile you are technically correct that if you overthrow the government you can make any laws you want, it seems unlikely that applies to this situation.
- randomdata 3y agoThe government isn't something that exists off to the side. It is literally just the people. The laws in force are simply what the people choose to recognize. Indeed, Quebec tradition ensures that most people will choose to recognize the laws crafted under the given framework and not beyond. But they can also choose to look beyond it if they so wish. Of course, they don't have to either.
- maximus-decimus 3y agoLet's someone in that city punches the river and get put in jail by the local cops for battery, what do you think would happen? I encourage you to watch Fargo Season 5 which just finished. The bad guy is basically just that, the sheriff of a small town that doesn't recognize the authority of the U.S. federal government.
- randomdata 3y agoLet's say someone posted explicit nude photos of Magpie on the Internet without her consent. Because CBC just did exactly that (see the link, if you're into revenge porn). What do think will happen? The answer is nothing, because ain't nobody taking this law declaring Magpie a person seriously. You can create all the laws you want, but they don't mean anything if nobody else is willing to recognize them. Government isn't something off to the side. It's just the people.
- bawolff 3y agoBecause the constitution says so. (Or more specificly, the constitution doesn't mention municipal governments so they dont have instrinsic rights, and all their powers come from the laws creating them. They definitely do not have the power to issue letters patent or anything of the sort)
- bawolff 3y ago> In 2021, the Innu Council of Ekuanitshit and the regional municipal council of Minganie passed sister resolutions, granting the Magpie River the landmark right of legal personhood Maybe i'm missing something, but surely this would require an act of either the provincial or federal legislature. Surely this is way outside of the powers of a municipal council.
- lainga 3y agoAlas! Once it has the benediction of the CBC, it has the weight of the federal government behind it. (only half-joking...)
- amarant 3y agoHow is that municipality name supposed to be pronounced? My first attempt sounded too much like "u-can-eat-shit" to be correct...I hope...
- bawolff 3y agoThat's technically a band council not a municipality. They probably have more or at least different rights than a municipality, but i still doubt they have the authority to incorporate a river.
- hinkley 3y agoJournalistic piece I found about the Maggie pronounced it something like e-QUAN-uh-she Silent T’s apparently.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- unsupp0rted 3y agoThis never made sense to me. Personhood should be reserved for persons. Instead of contorting language and law into pretzels, make new law to conserve nature. A river is not a person. A corporation is not a person.
- anamax 3y agoA corporation is, however, a collection of people. Which raises the question, should a collection of people have different rights than the members of said collection?
- floydnoel 3y agoOf course a group of people should have no more rights than any one person! It's only natural.
- xhevahir 3y agoNo one said more rights; that they should have all the rights of a single citizen is contentious enough. What if, for example, we grant freedom of speech to this entity, and we take freedom of speech to include the funding of political parties, causes, or candidates? (That's how things are at present in the United States.)
- zilti 3y agoNo, that is not how things are. Companies do not have freedom of speech etc. in the USA.
- AdhemarVandamme 3y agoDon’t they? In Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., 573 U.S. 682 (2014) the Supreme Court did not address and answer whether for-profit corporations are protected by the free exercise of religion clause of the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, but the Court did recognize a for-profit corporation’s claim of religious belief (equal to the belief of its owners), sufficient for such a corporation to be exempt from a regulation that it (or its owners) religiously object to, if there is a less restrictive means of furthering the law’s interest, according to the provisions of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993.
- jl6 3y agoJust as long as it pays its taxes, we’re cool.
- shrubble 3y agoThey missed an opportunity for a tie-in to Spirited Away...
- randomdata 3y agoThe CBC might want to ease up on the 'revenge porn'. Magpie River has not consented to the sharing of that revealing imagery.
- sandworm101 3y agoThe creation of new personhood, the attachment of legal rights to what was previously a non-person, is a very dangerous game. It sounds in both abortion and animal rights. If a non-sentient river can be a person, why not a whale? Why not the wild animals that use this river? As living beings one would assume they were due more rights than the river.
- brudgers 3y agoYes. Why not? Because corporations are persons with constitutional rights under US law, if there is a slippery slope this is not where it starts. Animal rights are one of two important philosophical movements from the second half of the 20th century. Copy-left is the other (and the easier one).
- csande17 3y agoThat actually makes me wonder: how, if at all, is this different from creating a government agency or non-profit corporation or whatever, giving it ownership of the river, and chartering it to protect the river? Such an entity would have the same "legal personhood" rights, and its leadership / officers would do pretty much the same thing as the "guardians" discussed in the article. And it avoids all the goofy questions of whether the river itself can be guilty of strict-liability offenses or liable for flooding damage or whatever.
- brudgers 3y agoI am not a lawyer. If an informed opinion regarding the your proposed alternative matters, hire a lawyer with expertise in such matters. On the other hand, if it doesn’t matter, it doesn’t matter. Instead I have some training in philosophy. It gives me some experience with slippery slope arguments, the philosophical rationales for animal rights, and some other equally useful (or useless) ideas. But insofar as I understand the common law, persons are strictly liable for matters of strict liability and “being guilty” would require a criminal act (e.g. criminal negligence). But again, hire a lawyer if it matters etc.
- belval 3y ago> Although the title of legal personhood is a unique way of approaching conservation, it can draw questions about how the Magpie will manage the intricacies of the legal system — especially since it can now theoretically sue and be sued. > In the case of damage, due to flooding for instance, Cárdenas explains that the Magpie would likely not be found liable. "The river doesn't commit intentional damage, therefore it cannot be sued," she said, pointing out that those who build in known flood zones are also aware of the risks. Intent is not a condition for successfully suing someone but realistically this entire thing is mostly a joke anyway so might as well make up the entire thing as they go.
- jswrenn 3y agoIf you enjoy thinking about the legal implications of this, you'll almost certainly enjoy the first entry in "Legal Systems Very Different From Ours, Because I Just Made Them Up": https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/30/legal-systems-very-different-from-ours-because-i-just-made-them-up/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/30/legal-systems-very-dif... An excerpt: > The Clamzorians are animists. They believe every rock and tree and river has its own spirit. And those spirits are legal people. This on its own is not unusual – even New Zealand gives rivers legal personhood. But in Clamzoria, if a flood destroys your home, you sue the river.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- a_gnostic 3y agoCan't be a person without a cute Magpie River-Chan avatar.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoAre Japanese river gods usually represented as cute young girls?
- whythre 3y agoIf anime is to be believed, just about anything from vampires to dragons to inanimate objects can be represented by cute girls.
- verisimi 3y agoWe should make trees persons too, and animals, and ai, then as they pay taxes it'll decrease the tax burden on people, right?
- krapp 3y agoIf you're going to post dismissive snark at least make it relevant to the content of the article.
- iwontberude 3y agoFloura and fauna pay their tax in-kind, we use their products to power the economy in lieu of currency. I disagree with the child comment saying that your comment is snarky, I think it's completely valid to look at it this way and helps to complete the systemic analysis.
- AdhemarVandamme 3y agoIt’s been done before (sort of): the river Vilnelė is declared to have the constitutional right to flow by everyone, in the very first article of the constitution of Užupis. [0] [0] https://uzhupisembassy.eu/uzhupis-constitution/ https://uzhupisembassy.eu/uzhupis-constitution/
- petiepooo 3y agoThis makes me wonder, how does a certificate of death work? Could a doctor declare that it does not have a heartbeat, and is therefore dead? Would that remove its person-hood, as there is no person to represent it and show life in court?
- pyuser583 3y agoIt would just be disincorporsted, like a defunct company.