3 ms·
Apple's European revenue for the App Store is only 7% of its global App Store receipts. At some point apple will just leave the market. The EU is a bit bonkers
by adastra22 3y ago
Apple's European revenue for the App Store is only 7% of its global App Store receipts. At some point apple will just leave the market.
The EU is a bit bonkers to think that it can get global tech companies to comply with increasingly tech-hostile regulations without any push back or red lines. At some point it just stops being worth the hassle.
- 5350-uiop-1130 3y ago> At some point apple will just leave the market. maybe a good thing. yanis varoufakis said EU had become irrelevant in tech. more investment can go to local tech instead of US monopolies.
- adastra22 3y agoI would love for there to be a vibrant European tech scene. But these same sort of business-hostile behavior is exactly why there isn't a European version of Silicon Valley.
- dedene 3y agoThat is not true at all
- adastra22 3y agoYou're free to think otherwise, but this is what I've been repeatedly told by entrepreneurs in Europe (who mostly copy US ideas), and europeans living in Silicon Valley (who came here to innovate in ways they can't back home).
- qngcdvy 3y agoYeah or it's just the capital that has been there in abundance. Spawned from the defense industry, thriving through the money made in the 2000s and after by creating profits all over the world (ads!) and then evading taxation as much as possible while funneling the money back to the valley and hiring the world's best talent to keep that first place. The small business owner pays taxes because what else can they do? Big corps go through tax-havens and relocations and don't do so, while profiting off of the infrastructure paid for by taxes (=> enabling customers over seas to even buy iphones). Traditional companies ship physical products and/or employ more people in the respective countries, while they also try to evade taxation I think those circumstances make them a much better subject to it though. Really, the more I keep on talking to my friends in the Valley the more it boils down to the money factor. Salaries, VCs and all the likes. I don't say Europe shouldn't be less business hostile, but one should see the Valley the way it is and realize that just buy changing the laws and trying to copy it Europe can't succeed. They should find their own path.
- rglullis 3y agoThey can't make money like they do in the US, but I'd argue that good innovation - that increases the welfare of the people and is meant to bring universal progress - still is more abundant in Europe than in SV.
- fxtentacle 3y agoThat's a strong selection bias because you'll never meet people who stay in Europe because they like running a business there.
- adastra22 3y agoMy work routinely takes me to Europe to interact with these people. I’m not in traditional tech.
- herbst 3y agoWe don't need a silicon valley. No need for a ultra concentrated tech valley. We have many small tech valleys all over Europe. With many many good, honest, privacy respecting companies. We just don't have that unicorn culture. But do we need highly overvalued tech businesses?
- Bancakes 3y agoWho wants that? A market made up of clustered, small-time players that don’t have to live up to standards, and don’t have their hide in the game? A market made up of clones and forks, all worse than the prop competition.
- herbst 3y agoNot sure if you are sarcastic. But that is exactly the reason why we have such a abundance of high quality products and depend way less on mid quality products of big brands. Alone food quality is on a whole different level in Europe, exactly because we have, allow and welcome small time players reinventing the market.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoVilnius is sometimes touted as new valley yet hosts all the shady VPN companies that engage in hacking your home cameras, routers and tv's so they can offer IP addresses at residential space! They are just as privacy invasive as US albeit with less financing which means they are even more ruthless and hostile.
- herbst 3y agoSee, good that there are many places, so that the VPN bullshit can't make the other cool places a bad name.
- flgstnd 3y ago> business-hostile behavior trying to regulate monopolies is business-hostile? maybe sometimes its needed to hurt a monopolist business in order to .. enable competition..
- maeln 3y ago> I would love for there to be a vibrant European tech scene. But there is ? Go to Paris, Berlin, Lisboa, Barcelona, ... There is a lot of start-ups, incubator, investor, meet-ups, conference, etc. The EU has a very vibrant tech scene. It is probably more distributed than the U.S, by nature, and not on the same scale. But acting as if the E.U is some sort of ludite, back water, hostile to business, is just plain wrong and huge exaggeration.
- alpaca128 3y agoThe issue to me is less about the existence of a tech scene and more about reliance. A European app running on locked down hardware with permission of a megacorporation (US or not) doesn't make you much less dependent.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoIt's not EU that's hostile, but employment laws in most countries which make it extremely hard to fire people or hire contractors.
- surgical_fire 3y agoDo we really want the venture capital grift machine on these shores? I mean, I indirectly benefit from the grift, but I am not one to put some lipstick on this particular pig.
- esarbe 3y agoI'm looking forward to Apple leaving Europe. Good riddance.
- 4gotunameagain 3y agoGlobal tech companies are a bit bonkers to think that they can get the voted political establishment to comply with increasingly human-hostile behaviours as well ;)
- phatfish 3y agoI'm counting down the days like it's Christmas.
- adastra22 3y agoYou want iPhones and iPads and MacBooks to be discontinued from the European market?
- danogentili 3y agoYes, I certainly do: if Apple can't behave, there's no reason their unrepairable, overpriced garbage should stay on the EU market.
- matwood 3y ago> overpriced garbage You have highlighted my issue with this whole DMA situation. Every Android phone I have used has felt like privacy invading garbage (except maybe the nexus 4), yet I don't think they should be off market. I simply use an iPhone instead. Instead of the DMA being pro-consumer, I read it as anti-business (probably US business). It feels created out of EU jealously of the US tech industry, and secondarily a way to help EU companies. Consumers will likely end up worse off, which I reminded of every time I visit the EU have to dismiss cookie banners on every damn site.
- rglullis 3y agoThere are a good number of "Android devices" which I can unlock the bootloader (or comes already unlocked from factory) and install another ROM. Done, no more "privacy invading garbage". That is virtually impossible to be done with any Apple product.
- piva00 3y ago> It feels created out of EU jealously of the US tech industry If it feels like that for you I recommend checking your emotional state, the EU has a different approach to regulating businesses than the USA, it's not jealousy but different principles aiming for different outcomes than what the USA aims for. > Instead of the DMA being pro-consumer, I read it as anti-business (probably US business). You've criticised the DMA twice about being: a bad implementation, and now as anti-business. Yes, it is anti a specific case of business which in the EU's view is not aligned to the outcomes it wants in the economy, calling the EU anti-business is, at best, naïve, since it's an organisation focused first and foremost to deal with commerce and business in general. It is against business using leverages against citizens, something that the USA does not seem to care about, and that's fine for the USA just don't try to apply the same principles you live under to a different culture regarding businesses.
- omeid2 3y agoYou see it as "7%" but for Apple it is "a large enough market for a competitor to grow into a potential risk for taking away market elsewhere too".
- tussa 3y ago7% is $26.8 billion for last year.
- adastra22 3y agoSo? It's still 7%. What happens when compliance or fees costs them $30 billions? Those go up with scale too.
- btasker 3y agoApple reported 30bn net sales in Europe in the last quarter: the second biggest region after the US. Although some of that'll be driven by non iOS stuff, we know that's the main earnings driver. In a future where Apple have withdrawn the app store, who in the EU is going to buy an iOS device? Sorry, but the idea that they'd be able to justify pulling out to shareholders over this is pure fantasy. edit: source - https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/fy2024-q1/FY24_Q1_Consolidated_Financial_Statements.pdf https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/fy2024-q1/FY24_Q1_Consol...
- alpaca128 3y agoApple has shown with China that they're perfectly okay with localized rules in their systems. If you think they wouldn't make a few EU-only changes to preserve a whopping 7% of the revenue I don't know what to tell you. 7% is much more than you make it seem, and actually as someone else pointed out the real number is higher because without App Store the iPhones are worthless.
- herbst 3y agoUltimately getting rid of shitty and privacy invading products is exactly what this all is for.
- itzprime 3y agoEurope is 25% of Apples Revenues. If they exit with the App Store, nobody is going to buy an iPhone anymore.
- FeepingCreature 3y agoAt some point, the tech companies are gonna run out of globe. But hey, maybe they can disband the government and elect another.
- aeurielesn 3y agoThe US companies thinking the EU needs to bow down to them is what's bonkers.
- pjc50 3y agoApple are somewhat dependent on being able to use Ireland as a tax haven. It's also quite hard for a publicly traded company to abandon a multibillion dollar market out of spite alone without getting sued by shareholders.
- austurist 3y ago"Apple's most valuable intangible asset isn't its patents or copyrights – it's an army of people who believe that using products from a $2.89 trillion multinational makes them members of an oppressed religious minority whose identity is coterminal with the interests of Apple's shareholders." -- https://pluralistic.net/2024/01/12/youre-holding-it-wrong/#if-dishwashers-were-iphones https://pluralistic.net/2024/01/12/youre-holding-it-wrong/#i...
- fxtentacle 3y agoThere's no way Apple can justify leaving 100 million in revenue on the table to their board. They will do whatever it takes to remain in the EU market.
- surgical_fire 3y ago> At some point apple will just leave the market. I live in Europe. And I truly hope so. > The EU is a bit bonkers to think that it can get global tech companies to comply with increasingly tech-hostile regulations without any push back or red lines. So... We in Europe would not be able to access anymore US huge advertisement networks and manufacturers of luxury tech toys? Please, wake me up when those awful corporations do push back on red lines.