8 ms·
Dangerous Things You Were Taught In School
- lucian1900 15y agoThe print version is on one page http://www.forbes.com/sites/jessicahagy/2012/05/02/nine-dangerous-things-you-were-taught-in-school/print/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jessicahagy/2012/05/02/nine-dang...
- Tangaroa 15y agoFor a similar take on the school system, here's John Taylor Gatto's essay The Six-Lesson Schoolteacher: http://www.altruists.org/static/files/The%20Six-Lesson%20Schoolteacher%20(John%20Taylor%20Gatto).htm http://www.altruists.org/static/files/The%20Six-Lesson%20Sch...
- rglover 15y agoI wish I could recall the name, but I read an essay on the general concept of this topic not too long ago. Essentially the author referenced how schools are stratified into a series of groups: lower class, lower middle class, upper middle class, and elite (not sure if these are 100% accurate). The author explained (from a series of in-person observations) the differences in education at each of the various levels. Children at the lower class level were taught to always listen to their teachers, be on time, and not to question things too much. Jump to upper middle class and the children were taught how to organize into groups or promote consensus (much like a mid-level managerial position). Finally at the top, children were given less concrete homework and were asked to explore their creativity. They were also taught to question their teachers, and most class time was spent as a dialogue between the group and not a lecture from the "instructor." Really interesting topic and I wish more people paid attention to these things. Imagine where we'd be as a society if we didn't mold each other into groups or social brackets. Blows my mind.
- aik 15y agoI'm curious where this came from. I wonder if it can also be broken into something like: [1] Public school: low, low and mid classes [2] Alternative school (private or public): upper mid class [3] Best private schools: elite With [2] and [3] making use of alternative education models (e.g. Montessori, Waldorf, Democratic), and most importantly recognizing that EVEN STUDENTS can be fairly competent human beings that have the capability to both breathe and think rationally at the same time if given the opportunity a sufficient amount of times.
- jcromartie 15y agoI've seen [3] at public schools, from a very slim handful of teachers. Those teachers tended to generate strongly polarized opinions about themselves among students.
- arethuza 15y agoFrom what I can see, there is also a pretty strong correlation in the UK between the "rank" of a school and the amount of time pupils spend playing sports (particularly rugby) as part of the curriculum - presumably for the perceived leadership/team-building that these sports are believed to promote.
- PaperclipTaken 15y agoAt my high school, and at my college as well, the sports players are generally looked down upon by the 'gifted' or 'AP' students. I don't know how sports players compare to the average student, but the average GPA on our cross country and track teams always shocked me a little. Few of my friends ever got below 3.5, and the sports teams often had averages below 2. The football team (by rumor, I never actually saw the numbers) was the lowest gpa sport in our school.
- arethuza 15y agoNB I was using the UK sense of school - high or junior school. People here generally don't refer to universities or colleges as "schools" (apart from "law school").
- jiggy2011 15y agoPossibly because rugby is a good way to get rid of excess energy and constructively channel some aggression as well as the team building and discipline aspects. I remember reading that it had been suggested that all schools do 1 hour of physical education/excersize before school officially starts, this would help children concentrate.
- PaperclipTaken 15y agoI can relate to this based on my experiences from high school. I don't think that things are structured like this intentionally. (I think that few teachers and principal's would intentionally hold back the lower class students) But, if you have a kid who tends to do his homework less, think school is 'not cool,' and in general doesn't like authority (something I feel was more prevalent among the poorer students in my education), you get a much stronger attitude of 'sit down and do your homework' from the teachers. Then you have the upper level classrooms, where assignments were almost never turned in late, and students generally had less animosity towards authority in general. They still disobeyed and did creative things and whatnot, but they did it out of curiosity, and not because they were trying to irritate the teachers. Actually, I'm thinking of several cases specifically in my class where students held visible animosity towards these teachers. These students consistently had the lowest grades in the class.
- roc 15y agoThere's definitely something to this. If the students won't cooperate/behave/listen, how could the teacher ever hope to progress beyond reinforcement of "you need to cooperate/behave/listen"? It's sort of like the old adage that you need to understand the rules before you can break them. If one doesn't understand why you have to listen to the instructor, they're far less likely to be productive in a setting where interruptions are expected/encouraged.
- agumonkey 15y agoI'd add some theories cynically stating that the education, at times, designed to sustain replenishment of industry and nothing more. I guess i'm more individualist than pluralist, but it seems too much of a society-impeded existence rather than growing of the inner self. I'm also tempted to bet that this layered approach you experienced, by providing tension between layers, is endebting us more in the long run.
- jmj42 15y agoThis is the basic premise of "Waiting for Superman." It's a fairly good documentary on the failings of American public education. The majority of the film focuses on the problem of stratification and the impact it has on both lower and upper levels of the stratification.
- joedev 15y ago"On average, a four-year degree is the equivalent of an investment that returns 15.2% a year." - http://finance.fortune.cnn.com/2011/06/30/a-college-degree-returns-more-than-the-stock-market/ http://finance.fortune.cnn.com/2011/06/30/a-college-degree-r... Stay in school kids.
- anamax 15y agoNo one gets an "average" degree, so it doesn't much matter what the average is. Some degrees are good investments. It depends on both the person and the degree.
- aik 15y agoInteresting, but it doesn't necessarily take into account the opportunity cost due to the very significant time investment. But more importantly, you know there's something wrong with the system when so many feel they have to try to justify the cost. Meaning, I think many realize that the investment is in the credential, not the learning that takes place due to the institution. I long for the day when a sufficient alternative will come to satisfy the average student (I'm working on this myself...)
- tgrass 15y agoThe opportunity cost does not have to be more than one's liesure time. I worked thirty hours a week as a waiter in engineering undergrad and was a part time single dad. I averaged 17K a year. This is not unusual.
- randomdata 15y agoOpportunity is opportunity. If you weren't in school, you could have worked 30 hours per week as waiter plus the time you were studying. Realistically, if we assume you work for minimum wage, you're going to be around $200K short by the time you finish a four year program, and that does not include any costs associated with actually going to school, which could easily run you another $100K+, depending on the circumstances. Perhaps nothing you cannot overcome with the right program and a solid plan, but if you're going to college just because that's what people out of high school do, you should probably think long and hard about it.
- srconstantin 15y agoI think the prevailing mood among people who think of themselves as "business people" is nowhere near risk-averse enough.
- ap22213 15y agoWhen I was a poor kid from the rust belt, I dreamed of becoming an adult and getting a Phd. and talking deeply with the intellectual elite. I never got that Phd. but I became happily upper middle class, and thus got to hang out with a lot of Phds., often from good schools. Not surprisingly, many of them came from upper-class areas, and upper middle class or wealthy families. What surprised me of this bunch was the general lack of curiosity, passion, and depth that many of them had - it jarred my world view. These were people that I dreamed of being around, when I was a kid. And, they just seemed like normal people, nothing special. Over much time and after talking with many of them, I realized that many had pursued the Phd. (or equivalent) not because of any innate passion or ability, but just because that was what was expected of them. They did it because that's what people did in their world. It was then that I realized that many poor kids from the rust belt probably just did what they believed that people did.
- sopooneo 15y agoThat is exactly my experience in growing up in a poor rural area and getting a big scholarship to a fancy private liberal arts school. I had lived and breathed ideas and that naturally led to good grades. I assumed that the first day of college would be like those rare episodes of the Simpsons where Lisa finally meets a group she fits in with. I was, frankly, devastated. These people weren't smarter or more curious, they were just richer and better educated. My wife, on the other hand, went to a huge state school, but enrolled in the inner honors college within it, and had much more of the experience I had been looking for.
- jiggy2011 15y agoI agree, when I enrolled on CS I expected there would be plenty of people who had been doing interesting stuff with tech for years. While there were a few like this , the majority were just bright kids who would have otherwise done Law or Accountancy.
- why-el 15y agoYou might find Sir Ken Robinson's Academic Inflation concept interesting. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG9CE55wbtY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG9CE55wbtY
- ntkachov 15y agoMost of these things, I think, stem from the fact that it's much easier to take care of a class that believes in all 9 facts, than to take care of a class that doesn't. How many teachers could justify the 5 paragraph essay if all the kids started questioning them on the arbitrariness of that number? If you reward that kid that's really easy for you to take care off the others will follow, right? Standardized tests measure your value because they measure the teachers value (in paychecks). I have little respect for the school system. It's basically rigged to make the teachers lives as simple as possible and make the kids as miserable as possible.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoI've a rule to let my kids question anything once - they must provide a rationale if they wish to reverse my decision. However, it does sometimes come down to a simple exertion of authority (ie because I say so trumps the unsupported objections). I find now that J at 6 can usually answer my side and rationalise why an a priori arbitrary demand is being made. Surely any teacher could readily answer a challenge like 'why not 3 paragraphs?' and this is a valid and worthy question for a student. Unfortunately at some point the student will have to accept irrational or limited reasoning and learn to live with that, eg why does the law require me to learn that.
- kitsune_ 15y agoErrr? I don't know what schools are like in the Unites States, but I was probably taught the exact opposite of what is presented in this Forbes Article. For instance: "The people in charge have all the answers." > My history teacher would like to have word with you.
- robododo 15y agoSpeaking from anecdote, my relatively crappy, rural, public education in the USA was not like this. I'm guessing the article is written as hyperbole, not to paint a picture of the average US public school. Of course, it's been ~15 years since high school for me. Perhaps things in the USA have greatly degraded in that time. Public education standards are a major a concern for me with respect to my son's education.
- nerdfiles 15y agoMy issue with that statement is that it it'z misleading. People in charge have all the answers to that which they are in charge of. Naturally you resist their domain as you resist their.
- nerdfiles 15y ago[sorry, incomplete post that was sent on accident]
- drzaiusapelord 15y agoThis is a great observation. The list is bewildering to me as well. I think the author is trying to play up this strawman of conservative authoritarianism and perhaps reflects her upbringing but I don't think its typical of the American educational experience. "The best and brightest follow the rules" bothers me the most. From a young age I've been taught by the establishment that inventors and industrialists who purposely broke away from the norm became successful. I think the US encourages this kind of thinking. "There is a very clear, single path to success" is also unforgivable. Maybe the dangerous lesson here is beware thumbnails of cute authors and easily to digest comic strips that reflect your own biases.
- ktizo 15y agoI always suspected that the way that schools were set up was borrowed heavily from the old establishments for training the children of the lower ranks of the aristocracy in how to be military officers. The regimentation and rote of your average maths classroom was obviously never designed for teaching the subject, yet is the main memory of the experience for most people, rather than what is supposedly being taught.
- gaius 15y agoIronically, schools that were set up like that produced more literate and numerate kids, i.e. Grammar schools. In fact these were a key route to social mobility for bright but poor kids. They were killed off by politicians who relied on the lower classes for their votes...
- UK-AL 15y agoExcept many exist today, and there mostly populated by the middle class with ridiculously low levels of poor people. Like 1% on free school meals and majority were tutored for the entry test? Most poor people can't afford tutors. With stats like that, they REINFORCE class structure, not break it. And do poor people want to pay for the education of the elites? Which is what current grammars effectivly do.
- gaius 15y agoThat is only because there are so few grammar schools left. When they were all over the country, anyone who passed the 11-plus, regardless of their family's wealth, could go. These days they are intended to reinforce class structure. You don't need a left-wing, if you don't have a poor working class...
- UK-AL 15y agoEven in the past they had relatively little working class people in them. Even then they had tutors for people getting in, my dad went to grammar school(We're not working class, his parents were business owners) and he was tutored. His 63 now. Even I was tutored for the 11+(My county has them). The only reason for populist support for them at the moment(Daily Mail, Telegraph, UKIP, BNP and other populist parties all support them), is most people THINK their kids will get in although most won't(By definition). When they come realise that, populist support will disappear again, and they will go out favour once again.
- gravitronic 15y agoHaving gone through north american public schools I definitely agree with most of the article's points. However most of those graphs make absolutely no sense. Clearly the author was being a free spirit on "how to make a graph" day.
- stephengillie 15y agoThey didn't look particularly ironic to you?
- Thrymr 15y agoThe author of the Forbes article also has a blog which features this sort of tongue-in-cheek graphics: http://thisisindexed.com http://thisisindexed.com
- dsirijus 15y agoIt could be argued that all those sentiments listed are actually driving force that accounts for most of the creativity now.
- PaperclipTaken 15y agoThere's a big difference in how students are taught and what students are thought to think from school to school, which is mostly correlated with income bracket. It's not that our leadership structure or general society has this 'keep the poor down' mentality, it has to do with the general mentality of the teachers and the general mentality of the students. Think of the demographics of the teachers. In low income areas, the teachers are much more likely to be people that grew up in poor income areas themselves. Generally, that also means that they will be less familiar with higher-level concepts like 'when given lined paper, write the other way.' Even if they've heard these quotes and can tell you what they mean, they are less likely to be able to answer questions like 'Why 5 paragraphs?' and 'When in real life am I going to use the Pythagoras theorem?' In high income areas, you are much more likely to get teachers that come from high income families themselves, which means they are much more likely to have gone to a reputable school. My high school (William Fremd High School) is seated in a high income area, and actually had several teachers (2 or 3) with Oxford level degrees. Many teachers in the English department actively rejected the idea of a 5 paragraph model, and told you to write the essay 'until it was done.' Many of the teachers, having been through some level of engineering school themselves, could tell you that the Pythagoras theorem is very important to things like Architecture and mechanical engineering, and that the seemingly useless mathematics you are learning actually have very powerful real life applications.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>Many teachers in the English department actively rejected the idea of a 5 paragraph model Hmm. There are problems with that - writing to a limit / self editting is a skill in itself. Work needs to be equable in format to be readily compared. Should every piece of prose be written to a format requirement, no. Should the idea of writing to a particular format be rejected? No IMO.
- johnohara 15y agoTrue danger is serious business. Approaching an unexploded IED is dangerous. So is going in to reactor #2 to pump out radioactive water. There's a difference between incorrect and dangerous.
- mhurron 15y agoDangerous does not have to mean deadly.
- parfe 15y agoSaid from your safe little bubble. Dangerous is "I might misstep by half an inch and orphan the children." The college educated computer workers who post here haven't experienced danger since climbing trees as children. And certainly don't experience danger professionally. Roofing a house is dangerous. Delivering Pizza is dangerous. Picking between State U vs Private U? Choosing between Python and Ruby? Choosing between iOS vs Android for your initial deployment? Choosing VC A over VC B? Telling your Boss he's wrong? Calling any of that dangerous is an insult to people who face real danger daily.
- jiggy2011 15y agoThat's not what the article is talking about. It is talking about the school system generally and how in the author's opinion it teaches habits/ideas that could be considered harmful to that person's judgment of future life decisions they may have to make.
- ktizo 15y agoSpeaking as a college educated computer worker who posts here, I suspect that you might not have a clue. I spent a lot of last summer welding heavy metal, I am no stranger to hard-hats, safety boots and building sites. I have worked assembly, labour and construction, alongside code, graphics and networks. I get bored of desks quite regularly and have to go off and lift heavy things for a while. Is a bit like going to a gym where they pay you. Be very careful of stereotypes, especially among groups that are well known for idiosyncrasies, which at the last count is pretty much all the groups.
- Anirak 15y agoIs it just me, or are the drawings terribly confusing? It took me a while to even determine which "point" they went along with.
- goblin89 15y agoThis one's great IMO: “Days off are always more fun than sitting in the classroom.” Not exactly well-phrased—I believe prolonged sitting is indeed not quite fun for various physiological reasons. However, this makes it fair: “You are trained from a young age to base your life around dribbles of allocated vacation.” It appears to be about splitting life into work and vacation despite the alternative of doing things you love and loving things you do. (It's hard to convince people, though. They continue hate most of they regular 9-to-6 day and watch TV in the evening.)
- cafard 15y agoThere's a bunch of straw men in the emergency room today.
- K2h 15y agoNothing like a proper education to give you all the reasons an idea can't be done - instead of giving you the tools and confidence to tackle a problem no on else has even thought of and succeed. I'm still looking for the later.