5 ms·
> time has already run out, and it's too late to prevent the terrible consequences. Climate change is not a binary. We can choose how many terrible consequ
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
> time has already run out, and it's too late to prevent the terrible consequences.
Climate change is not a binary. We can choose how many terrible consequences it will have. It'll never be too late to prevent some terrible consequences.
- tovej 3y agoBy definition, there's a deadline for preventing something from happening. We're already in an extinction cycle, extinctions are happening at a rate of 100 to 1000 times the natural rate. And as for absolutes, total extinction of large mammals comes to mind as a consequence after which humanity can't really do anything.
- feoren 3y agoI think the possible outcomes of climate change (especially if we continue on our current trend) are unthinkably catastrophic, at worst including the potential deaths of a significant percentage of humanity. But there's still an enormous gap between that and "total extinction of large mammals". I don't think that's anywhere near a realistic consequence of climate change.
- nradov 3y agoThere is no conceivable future in which white-tailed deer become extinct in the next few centuries. We will probably lose some of the less resilient species, though.
- moffkalast 3y agoWith that kind of tomorrowist mindset it'll be too late. We need to make changes and we need to make them yesterday.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoI wrote "we can choose how many terrible consequences we'll have". Do you think that I would choose "as many as possible"?
- moffkalast 3y agoLately it really seems like that's indeed the answer of those that we've entrusted to make our decisions for us. If it's never too late, then we never have to stop making profit from ecosystem destruction.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoLately it really seems that everybody is saying "It's too late, we're screwed, so let's not do anything and party like it's 1999".
- lapcat 3y agoThis is a misdiagnosis. Lamenting that it's too late is the complete opposite of partying like it's 1999. We're not having fun. It's the climate change denialists who are partying like it's 1999, pretending that nothing has changed, that there's not a problem, and that we don't need to do anything. They're the ones who are complacent. By the way, the lyrics of the song 1999 were very much tongue-in-cheek. Prince had a political streak, he had not given up on caring, and he wrote a number of other political songs, such as "Ronnie Talk to Russia", "Annie Christian", "Free", "America", and "Pop Life".
- bryanlarsen 3y agoI reflected your comment back to you for a reason. Any argument that starts with "It seems like you're saying" is a bad argument. The climate change denialists are hiding behind both of our arguments.
- lapcat 3y ago> I reflected your comment back to you for a reason. That wasn't my comment.
- feoren 3y agoSaying "it's not too late to do something" is more likely to effect change than saying "it's too late, climate change already happened, we're all fucked, good bye." I think you agree with GP here.
- lapcat 3y agoIt's not a continuum either. There are tipping points: think of the ice sheets all melting, the sea levels rising to the point where the coasts of continents are swamped. Moreover, continually adding energy to the system makes it more chaotic, engendering abrupt and unpredictable shifts. We can't necessarily "choose" the consequences in some kind of orderly manner, as if from a menu.
- AlwaysRock 3y agoWe also have options that are unpopular/seem bad right now but may not in the future, like solar geoengineering via releasing specific compounds into the atmospheric. Something like that could also likely be achieved, or at least put into motion, by a single desperate nation.
- lapcat 3y agoWas this supposed to make me feel better? The options "seem bad" in the same way that volcanic eruptions seem bad; i.e., they are actually bad. A single deperate nation could also put into motion a nuclear war.
- Ringz 3y agoWhen one looks at the history of human interventions in ecosystems, one cannot be optimistic. Whether it’s about defending against invasive species or restoring ecosystems to their “original state,” our limited understanding of complex ecosystems inevitably leads to interventions with negative side effects.
- AlwaysRock 3y ago> Maybe time has already run out, and it's too late to prevent the terrible consequences. My point is that there are options for the future. Even if they are not palatable ones. It's not as cut and dry as global warming has already started, it is too late to fix it or mitigate it, and we are all fucked no mater what.
- 3y ago