9 ms·
TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out
- farmdve 3y agoLet it, it was a scourge on the world. Like every other simiar app it preyed on people's attention span, disintegrating it in the process, getting them addicted to just scrolling for that dopamine rush.
- hacker_newz 3y agoWhy the past tense?
- huimang 3y agotwitter, facebook, and reddit already did and do that and are far better at it due to being mostly images or text content. if anything tiktok pushes back on that due to the length of the videos.
- huimang 3y agoAt some point, you all need to think about herd mentality. tiktok is much chagrined here, but it's not any more egregious than facebook, twitter, youtube, or reddit. The extreme aversion here to tiktok in particular is not well-informed.
- jfdbcv 3y agoYou realize that it will only be replaced with something MORE addicting? People won't exactly start reading newspapers when Tik Tok dies..
- astrodust 3y agoHow can we help?
- RhodesianHunter 3y agoThis take always feels very "get off my lawn" to me. Have you tried it? My feed is woodworkers showing their techniques, physicists talking about strange discoveries, and developers talking about what you can do with ai. As with all social media, it's going to try to show you what it thinks you want to see.
- farmdve 3y agoI did and it was too addicting. I was scrolling for hours on end. At one point it was 12AM in the next it was 3:30AM and I was still scrolling. After deleting it, I felt better and my battery life improved too.
- xnx 3y agoThis has been said this about books, movies, television, video games, recorded music, etc. etc.
- brrrrrm 3y agoRecycled commentary on product changes made by an app trying to grow its ad revenue. Honestly this article could be AI generated
- dylan604 3y agoIt will be recycled again at some point for whatever the next trend in apps will be. ____is dead, long live ____ has been a thing for oh so long.
- ertian 3y agoI love the irony of reading: "The app is even testing a new feature that uses AI to identify products in the background of regular content and turn every single video into an ad", followed immediately by a dozen pages of ads targeted at me based on my browsing history (missed the 'Read More' button).
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoI sincerely love that bad content has become synonymous with AI content.
- jjice 3y ago> Outrage is brewing among a growing contingent of users who post videos arguing TikTok is ruined now, and analysts say the company is jeopardizing its success. People say this about all platforms. As much as I dislike Facebook, Twitter, Pintrest, etc, they all are doing fine. The vocal minority/article bias is at play. I don't like TikTok as a platform either, but it's insanely massive and that's not going to change for a while.
- datpiff 3y ago> As much as I dislike Facebook, Twitter, Pintrest, etc, they all are doing fine. Hah, Twitter isn't exactly doing fine
- noworld 3y agoBy what measure?
- tokai 3y agoIncome, engagement, image?
- next_xibalba 3y agoWhat was their 2023 income?
- jujube3 3y agovibes on HackerNews
- thierrydamiba 3y agoI was under the impression Twitter was doing well. What makes you say this?
- iwontberude 3y agoThey were a startup, but now they are a medium sized business with website that burns cash.
- smoothjazz 3y ago[flagged]
- silveira 3y agoIn my personal feed and algorithm, it was showing content from Gaza initially. I started following some of the victims and journalists. Then it stopped, not a single content from Gaza anymore.
- tokai 3y agoAre you sure that the people you followed are still alive?
- dogman144 3y agoTo note - the platform’s content is steered for information operations shaped at the demographic of the scroller re: foreign policy goals from CN. So what you’re seeing is a good content, but worth considering when you get shown policy-charged content - when and why is this in my feed. Edit - or, to put it more simply, you should try to answer the second part of your comment - why is a state-sponsored social media company the only one showing me this right now?
- basil-rash 3y agoTo increase distrust of the US Government, especially when it comes to warmongering. Great alpha for the country sitting at the top of many DOD lists.
- rightbyte 3y agoThat sounds like a cherible cause? I think TikToks initial succes was mainly due to a "fair" feed with no algorithmic nudging. Facebook used to be like that but somewhere around 2012 to 13 posts or articles could not go viral anymore, in the organic avalanche way it would earlier. Facebook wanted you to pay up for the reach I guess. If TikTok nudge people they will lose their edge.
- dvngnt_ 3y agoumg pulling their music will do more damage as half of popular videos are muted and comments have being suggesting moving to reels. if zuck goes after the music companies of which there's only like 3, he might win.
- brycewray 3y ago“. . . and nothing of value was lost.”
- StopTheTechies 3y ago[dead]
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- simonswords82 3y agoI recently hired a person who was on the moderation team at TikTok. I won’t go in to detail but they suffered at the hands of a barbaric company which does not care about its staff or its users. People on the moderation team are SLA’d to death and most have some form of PTSD from the videos they’re subjected to. I’d love to see Tiktok and all the other attention grabbing shitty apps die a death. But here’s the kicker… despite leaving TikTok due to the stress and anxiety working there caused her she still uses the app!
- 99catmaster 3y agoThat’s crazy.
- wredue 3y agoAddiction is crazy. You see people doom scroll several feeds, in a loop. They’ll see the same status again and again and again, just hoping something changed.
- tsunamifury 3y agoTikTok is, first and foremost, a deplatform American tech play. Thats it, and it is hyper aggressive about getting there. Anyone who works there and thinks otherwise doesn't know whats up.
- nebula8804 3y agoAt least we get to enjoy the American elite losing their marbles over the fact that there is a mass-platform where they have no control over the narrative. Imagine if we had TikTok during the ramp up to the Iraq war. May have turned out differently.
- rightbyte 3y agoI actually believe any social media platform back in those days would have made things worse. War mongerers seem to scare people to silence in the initial hysteria phase. Looking at e.g. Reddit today it seems the narrative is controlled by bots. Maybe that would have been hard in 2003.
- SethMLarson 3y agoEnshittification is a possible outcome for all platforms.
- AlexandrB 3y agoNot just possible, inevitable. It's why we should demand more interoperability - so platforms have to compete with each other instead of milking a captive audience.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoLet's just call it "composting." Something flowers and blooms into a beautiful experience, draws a critical mass of users, which draws the attention of parasites, the flower withers, dies, and turns to crap... compost. The composting of the internet.
- popularrecluse 3y agoBut composting implies something good is coming to replace it.
- jprete 3y agoI think it's become inherent to Internet platforms. The playbook is too well-known for founders to ignore.
- JoshGlazebrook 3y agoI like TikTok, but the number of TikTok Shop related videos is way too annoying at this point. I would say over half of a set of 10 videos is related to some TikTok Shop item, "eligible for commission" aka random people shilling this product of the week as the "greatest invention ever" and its some cheap dropship product that will break after a few months of use. I think this all started with the hype around the Ninja Creami, and TikTok saw that if you got enough people on there talking about one product to the point that it drove them to sell out for months they saw their new revenue stream. But there is a difference between real organic word of mouth, and this fake TikTok Shop "eligible for commission" nonsense.
- joeyrobert 3y agoI didn't follow the whole session (only saw the memes about it on TikTok), but in the recent congressional hearing, was the TikTok CEO grilled on misinformation on his platform? I see tonnes of astroturfed content on TikTok, significantly more than other platforms. Russia bots, flat earthers, moon-landing deniers, 9/11 truthers -- obvious misinformation. I've reported these before under misinformation but the report is usually rejected. Does TikTok turn a blind eye to these things, or is it the nature of the algorithm that I'm exposed to more content outside my "bubble"?
- dogman144 3y agoThere’s ample research to indicate CN govt encourages TikTok’s content to be steered in support of foreign policy goals related to the demographic of the user. So, when you see a mess of divisive content on there, and you’re in the UK (maybe?, re: “tonnes”), the content is there for a reason perhaps. …Stoke the fires of Western users’ current inability to handle this content without some % of the viewers losing their minds and <last 6 yrs of instability>. This has been reported on amply by Washington Post the Guardian as early as 2019.
- Apocryphon 3y agoAre articles intentionally avoiding Betteridge's Law now by not phrasing their titles in the form of a question?
- karaterobot 3y ago[a pedant appears] Betteridge's Law! [exit pedant, swinging on a vine]
- add-sub-mul-div 3y ago(2023)
- skywhopper 3y agoTikTok in early to mid 2020 was truly an amazing place. But as video length has gotten longer, and with the addition of photo slideshows, there's been a rapid falloff in the unique quirkiness that made it more interesting than, say, YouTube. Now it's more like a YouTube where the creators are much lazier about presentation and you have very little control over what you watch.
- xnx 3y agoLive and TikTok shop videos are annoying but easy to skip. Long videos are occasionally useful and aren't that annoying now that you can watch at 2x or skip ahead. Slideshows are pretty great. I enjoy meme slideshows and some of the recurring gags that are just 2 slides (e.g. "I feel like that wasn't my best friend last night ... that was the devil.")
- legitster 3y agoI'm kind of like, 65% confident that TikTok was developed for the US to to be a highly addictive way of seeding and farming apathy, cynicism, and misinformation. So there would be a great irony that it is so effective it destroys its own userbase first.
- resters 3y agoThe only way to cultivate a lot of good TikTok shops is to allow a lot to be created and then filter them down. TikTok used this strategy with creators in the beginning when it was easy for anyone to go live. Strategically, TikTok is intentionally sailing into a rough patch in order to launch the e-commerce play without giving an unfair advantage to big/established brands, which would crowd out the "crowd" and defeat the purpose. I thought this was pretty obvious.
- kibwen 3y ago> The app is even testing a new feature that uses AI to identify products in the background of regular content and turn every single video into an ad. I'm about ready to divest from any technology more advanced than a 1980s terminal. Any takers for my Neo-Amish movement? On Fridays we have pancakes and on Sundays we stone ad executives.
- popularrecluse 3y agoI'm in. Old Order Netizens unite.
- SleepilyLimping 3y agoLearning how to self-host things on Docker and a NAS has been a lifesaver for me. Almost every SAAS I've wanted to use at a consumer level has an open-source equivalent on Docker that I can reverse-proxy to access from anywhere.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoDo something with large fires at night and I'm a convert.
- deanCommie 3y agoI'm a 40 year old geriatric millennial who is the only one amongst my friend group that loves TikTok. None of them get it. They say "isn't it just a bunch of teenagers dancing?" Meanwhile, I'm on here following dudes wintering at the south pole, a captain of a container ship in the middle of the indian ocean, an orthodox rabbi in brooklyn, a physicist, a philosopher, a civic designer, and 10,000 hilarious meme makers and comedians who are remixing and lipsyncing and making incredible content that I can't even conceive of doing through a mobile interface. Most of THAT group are not famous anywhere else - their bios don't link to instagram or a management group. Some of these videos get longer - but nothing more than 5 mins. Concentrated deep dives into a single topic. Heavy on personality but otherwise mostly Signal, not Noise. Which is why it's also so hilarious folks in this thread rolling their eyes saying that people say that every platform gets ruined, but it never is. No, the NUMBERS go up. But the platforms have been ruined over and over and over again. None of my generation is on Facebook anymore. They are still on Instagram but exclusively to follow celebrities. There is no place in the world to just hang out and catch up with friends anymore - not a ubiquitous one anyway that we had through the 2000's. Even Reddit has lost all culture and is a ghosttown compared to what it use dto be. I'm not saying Tiktok is that. But what Tiktok has been for the last 3 years is UNIQUE. Special. Distinctive. It's own style, it's own brand of interesting and engaging. And this: > Then there’s the videos themselves. In a bid to compete with YouTube, TikTok is reportedly preparing to allow users to post 30-minute videos and prompting creators to upload horizontal content instead of the app’s standard vertical format. TikTok is even encouraging people to upload photo slideshows instead of videos altogether. On top of that, TikTok just fumbled a relationship with Universal Music Group, which pulled its music catalog off the platform and silenced any video featuring Taylor Swift, the Weeknd, and every other Universal artist. Will absolutely ruin it, if they don't quickly pivot and turn away. I don't mean "ruin" by pure user/engagement numbers. But ruin what currently makes it special in terms of connecting humanity to one another. That will go away and not come back somewhere else.
- grep_name 3y agoIt's good to see the other side of this. I don't use most social media apps, but I had a friend who told me they used tiktok mostly to see videos about 'foraging and luthiery', which gave me pause. Sometimes I wonder if I could benefit from the platform if I had the right subs. Maybe even learn something interesting. Ironic to see that tiktok is being made worse by trying to compete with youtube. I absolutely hate youtube shorts and am annoyed to no end that I can't remove them from my youtube experience. Doubly ironic that I'm more likely to give tiktok a chance than to ever succumb to youtube's wheedling insistence that I click on their 5-second content clips.
- zoogeny 3y agoI know this is one man's anecdote - but TikTok somehow lost that early magic. I remember it in 2018 and it was much wilder than it is now. It would regularly give me some pretty far-out content and the algorithm would mix it together into a surreal yet cohesive package. In many ways it was a much worse objective experience back then, the duetting which was pervasive at the time often became pretty intense bullying. But it was often genuinely surprising in an almost Monty Python-esque kind of way. Now I feel they have sanitized it pretty well, and the volume of creators means that each niche is overfull with middle-brow content. I think that has left little room for the truly bizarre stuff that lurks to come out into the light. It still manages to keep me stuck to the screen for hours at a time (the reason I very rarely dare to open the app at all) but I don't have the same belly laugh experience I did when I first used the app. I walk away less often thinking to myself: "what the hell just happened". Mostly it serves me pretty tame content. I mean, this really just feels like textbook case of Enshittification [1] 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification
- rchaud 3y agoSounds like the trajectory of the Internet in general.
- pqwEfkvjs 3y agoTiktok is a platform for kids and teenagers (right?), but teens don't have money. So how's their business model even supposed to work?
- carteazy 3y agoThere are sponsored posts dispersed through your feed. Writing this, I've realized that TikTok hasn't made the terms for it's posts/feed obvious. Twitter has Tweets/Timeline, Facebook has Feed, I don't know what I would say to describe a post from TikTok outside of calling the video itself a 'TikTok'
- wruza 3y agoMy 1940’s grandma spends more time on tt than yt, like whole evenings. And her brother’s ex too. They don’t spend money on it either and tbh I don’t know what their interaction with it looks like. But “for teens” is a common misconception. I’ve had a few 25..40-ish coworkers who were scrolling it as well.
- olyjohn 3y agoShhh... don't tell the advertisers.
- cupcakecommons 3y agoTikTok is a Chinese propaganda tool right? Honest question. Truly not attempting to make an unfair statement implying other parts of the world including the US don't have plenty of propaganda tools of their our own. But isn't it?
- jrochkind1 3y agoI don't think so. But I guess it depends on what it means to say something "is a Chinese propaganda tool." Is facebook "is a USA propaganda tool"? I'm not sure what people mean when they say this.
- cupcakecommons 3y agoI tried to make the original statement very fair. I think facebook is definitely a propaganda tool. It's a propaganda tool of its high-level employees and moderators, founders and, more recently, US government agencies. The twitter files [1] document pressure from employee culture and various government agencies on twitter, I assume the US government puts the same kind of pressure on facebook. There is absolutely bias. That isn't to say that the bias is bad necessarily, just that it obviously exists and this is isomorphic with it being propaganda. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Files https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Files (I know linking wik as a source is lame but lots of additional links here)
- RhodesianHunter 3y agoThe only thing the twitter files showed is that the US government sends requests to Twitter to take down illegal content and misinformation, and sends them "scoops" or other information as they would a news outlet or journalist. You can certainly argue that in this day and age what is "misinformation" has become politicized, but at the end of the day they were only requests. That that has become a conspiracy theory is a testament to the modern right's understanding of events and facts, as seen through the lens of the media they consume.
- jrochkind1 3y ago
- ertian 3y agoBased on my wife's experience with Douyin (the original product in China), I get the impression that they're trying to roll out products or features that have been wildly successful in China. The store, for example, seems to be very popular there. TikTok needs to adjust to a very different cultural landscape.
- rchaud 3y agoAll social media apps have users, but users are not customers. Advertisers are. Longer videos pave the way for non-skippable, mid-video ads, which they can charge more for. TikTok Shop is for taking a cut of every transaction on your "territory", like Apple is doing with the App Store. QVC for Gen Z. The sooner people stop believing this BS about social media apps caring about "connecting people" , the sooner the reality of the business model can be made apparent to everyone.
- lucideer 3y agoI think what this article describes is normal & probably "smart" from Bytedance's perspective. > Social media success is a delicate balance No it isn't. It's three things: 1. Luck / Startup x-factor: what makes these novel formats flourish to begin with, but it's short-lived: it won't sustain a platform long-term. 2. Money: what Meta have done with Instagram - pushed through by cannibalising instead of innovating by sheer power of investment 3. Inertia: why Twitter has defied all doomsayers' reports of its demise. TikTok's current trajectory looks more like trying to ape Meta's strategy & ultimately avoid what happened to Snapchat, by abandoning the innovation that got them to where they are & instead take advantage of the power, money & inertia they currently have to sustain themselves in other ways & broaden their audience (beyond the more fickle TikTok-early-adopter-influencers). > its ad revenue growth is slowing down Translation: its ad revenue is growing. This is an industry that was being reported as being generally in decline across the board only a year ago - some competitors like Meta have only recently started to show growth again after losses.
- yao420 3y agoSo what’s up with that Oracle buyout/integration? According to https://usds.tiktok.com/ https://usds.tiktok.com/ all US user data is on Oracle servers. Is that still happening?
- mvdtnz 3y ago> It’s ironic that TikTok doesn’t seem to have learned the lessons that its own success taught Instagram. Isn't the lesson from Instagram "user backlash is temporary, keep doing what you're doing and the users will return"?
- tmaly 3y agoI was a regular TikTok poster in 2020-2021. I had a few mini viral videos. It was incredible that I could reach so many people with my phone. That feeling is totally gone now. I see many accounts that I follow that use to get hundreds of thousands to millions of views per video now are lucky to break a thousand views per video. The feeling that it is a platform for creators is gone. Tiktok had the lead in short form video, Instagram Reels and YouTube shorts were just copying their lead. You can feel that the content on your for you page is not as original, quirky, and authentic as it was. TikTok positioned itself as a mobile app you could create video on. They even own the video editing app CapCut. Their move to focus on long form video will be a failure in my opinion. People are not going to create and edit 30 minute videos on a phone. Only those with dedicated computers for video editing are going to be able to produce 30 minute videos. And the audience? I for one would not watch a 30 minute video on my phone. If I want to watch a 30 minute video, I go on my PC and watch it on YouTube. I think someone with the right funding could figure out a way to create a 2021 version of TikTok where people on a phone could go viral without anyone's thumb on the algorithm.
- nunez 3y agoFrom a linked article in the post: > TikTok Shop launched in September and has quickly been littered with cheap, fake products. However, the online marketplace is profitable, raking in $4 million every day in the United States. I want to destroy myself like that!