4 ms·
Bootstrap or VC? [video]
- gumby 3y agoSeems to be no transcript.
- nivertech 3y agoMissing link to video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D81y-kh11oI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D81y-kh11oI
- dang 3y agoChanged to that from https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/bootstrap-or-vc/ https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/bootstrap-or-vc/ above. Thanks!
- mattjaynes 3y agoOn this question, David Heinemeier Hansson's talk at YC's Startup School 2008 still holds up great today. Was the first time I heard of the concept of the Fortune 5,000,000 Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0CDXJ6bMkMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0CDXJ6bMkMY Transcript: https://indiefounder.substack.com/p/full-transcript-of-dhhs-classic-startup https://indiefounder.substack.com/p/full-transcript-of-dhhs-...
- robocat 3y agoOn bootstrapping, I think Jason Cohen's talk is gold: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=otbnC2zE2rw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=otbnC2zE2rw This is fairly honest about the risks of VC: https://siliconhillslawyer.com/2017/08/01/not-building-unicorn/ https://siliconhillslawyer.com/2017/08/01/not-building-unico... and the rest of his articles are amazingly insightful too - read em all if you want to be a founder.
- mempko 3y agoYeah, but DHH really went off the deep end. https://world.hey.com/dhh/where-next-for-dei-0dc866b4 https://world.hey.com/dhh/where-next-for-dei-0dc866b4 I used to use their HEY email service until HEY decided to ban all societal and political discussions for employees. Which sparked a huge exit of talented people from their service. And now DHH went "anti-woke" and it's sad.
- candiddevmike 3y agoThis is interesting to see put out after YC was looking for more startups to apply in the last batch after the deadline...
- danjl 3y agoTheir view is so biased by being VCs. They really believe they are there to help founders. And they do! At least for first-time founders. But they are completely unaware of the damage caused by VCs and have no understanding of WHY many experienced founders prefer bootstrapping. Once you take investment, your goal shifts ever so slightly from "making a great product" to "getting the next round of investment". Your target customer shifts from your product's customers to your investors. The real question is not whether a lawn maintenance company or restaurant wants VC investment. The change that is happening now is that SaaS, mobile app and other "traditionally VC-funded" companies are finally realizing that VC funding is not a good model for building a long-term viable business.
- dang 3y ago> your goal shifts ever so slightly from "making a great product" to "getting the next round of investment" FWIW, at the last YC event I intended, the partners were talking about how it's their job to get founders to stop thinking that way, and to think instead about making a great product, as you say.
- hobofan 3y agoI think YC can say/do that, as with the YC stamp of approval you are already on the A-tier track of VCs. So for their portfolio companies having a shoddy product will be the main reason of not getting follow up funding. Meanwhile, if you started out with a "lesser tier" accelerator/incubator, you'll have to prove that you have a good product _plus_ you have to fight an uphill battle and convince A tier VCs to even take a look at you.
- jedberg 3y agoYou'd be surprised at how hard it is for YC companies to get follow up investment, even with the YC stamp. I think YC tells that to their startups because they believe it. YC has always been about elevating founders and making "start my own business" a viable alternative to "get a high paying job". And from day one their motto was "make something people want". And when you exit they give you a shirt that says, "I made something people want". They've always been product over everything else.
- synergy20 3y agoSo, assuming I apply and got accepted, am I getting the 500K, or just the 125K, or nothing until something further happened? I thought about applying but honestly 125K was not exciting enough for me :), now I just went to re-read the terms, it seems to be 500k(split for 7% etc) instead, which will be enough to make me applying, question is, how will I get them if I am accepted? first day, a few weeks later, or what.
- tfehring 3y agoYou get the full $500k upfront. In exchange, YC gets 7% equity upfront (for the first $125k), plus a proportional share of equity in your next funding round (for the next $375k).
- Joel_Mckay 3y agoThat is around 5 months operating capital in a small company. Most would laugh you out their office asking for 7% of equity. I often wonder if people understand why 1:23 companies survive the startup cycle. Best regards =)
- scrollaway 3y agoIt … depends on the company. Some “small” companies have a burn rate of 20k, some 200k, some 2M. YC isn’t about the money. The equity you give away is also for the seal of excellence it carries, and the network it brings. I would gladly give 7% of my small company today for YC’s network and seal alone, and 10% of the money they give.
- Joel_Mckay 3y agoTo me... business is about the market sector size, product/service viability, and profit model. The fact is liabilities come in many forms, and small mistakes may cast a long shadow if you are a startup. Best of luck =)
- jagged-chisel 3y agoI’m at a point in life where gambling doesn’t appeal to me. I could take VC, earn a (temporary) steady salary, and then, having given up controlling interest in my company, be at the back of the line for an exit while the VCs, who put no sweat equity into the company, get a huge payday. Or, I can bootstrap, have less stability, all the control to hire just who I need and when … and less stress. I’ve worked at two companies that took VC. In both cases, investors didn’t care about anything except whatever metric showed “growth” so they could exit larger than they entered - the tech didn’t matter, the team didn’t matter. Based on this sample size and so many stories from SV about how founders and employees are treated, I have a hard time seeing VCs as anything but leeches.
- notso411 3y ago[dead]
- wslh 3y agoObviously there is not an unique answer. My experience is the reverse of you, a bootstrapped startup was more stressful than one with investors because there is no magic money created but the one you receive from reality.
- VBprogrammer 3y agoI think taking VC money is great if you are in a capture the flag type market. Social networks, taxi market places etc. If it's something which has value with a modest number of customers, not a significant fraction of the addressable market, then maybe less so.
- andrewmutz 3y agoI think these guys did a pretty fair description of the trade-offs of bootstrap vs VC. I am currently bootstrapping a company and am really happy with the approach. There are certain types of companies that are great opportunities for bootstrapping and really don't need VC funding. One thing I think is missed from the Dalton and Michael's discussion is that while VCs know that bootstrapping is a very valid path and aren't lobbying against it, many young founders don't know much about bootstrapping. The biggest tech companies get the most attention and big companies generally need VC funding. So I agree that it is a "fake" controversy, but I also think it is important for more potential founders to hear about how bootstrapping may be a very valid and good path for them.
- frankdenbow 3y agoPretty reasonable take on the pro/cons of bootstrapping vs vc. One thing to add (and the reason why I started a conference for bootstrapped founders) is that the stories that get pushed often times are ones of investment, the articles you see are on this fundraising process so many see that as the standard way. The more you delve into these stories of companies that survived off of growing on revenue, the more you see whats possible.
- itbeho 3y agoIn this environment, if you can bootstrap a cash flowing business, you'll hold all the cards going forward.
- vipshek 3y agoThis discussion and the points being made are totally valid and reasonable. But I think there's one thing they completely miss, which is the cultural impact of VC. Given the massive success of software companies over the past decade or two, hordes of driven, talented, and smart young people have joined VC-backed companies or aspire to do so. It's become culturally accepted that if you're an ambitious person, you should be working at - or better yet, founding - a venture-backed company. The societal opportunity costs of this phenomenon are significant. I know dozens of young, talented people who are founding companies for no particular reason, simply because it's become the default path for what they're supposed to aspire to. Is this the "fault" of venture capital? Not really - VCs are just trying to attract talented founders and make their portfolio companies successful. But by doing so, they've created a negative externality, which is that VC has become the gatekeeper of perceived "success." That means fewer talented, high-energy people working in government institutions or critical industries - precisely where those talented people could have the greatest impact on society at large.
- vhiremath4 3y agoI understand what you're getting at, but are high-energy people not working in government or other critical industries because of VC lore, or is there a significant contribution from these industries being slow and bureaucratic? If I'm a high energy person who wants my work to have impact, I probably want to work in an industry where people move fast and innovate and don't get caught up in a bunch of red tape (regardless of whether this red tape is actually reasonable). From talking to friends and younger people entering the workforce, this is almost always the bigger consideration. Most feel like starting a company is still a total shot in the dark from a success standpoint, and I feel like there is more skepticism than ever of the startup lottery. What I totally agree with is that VCs need to be doing a much better job telling people that starting a VC-backed company is an extraordinarily bad way to make a lot of money. The odds are just insanely stacked against you. That said, most people gravitate to inspirational stories even if you're told it's at odds with what you can expect for your own journey, so, the more of these success stories there are (even if the ratio of them relative to total "tries" stays consistent), the more people will take the startup path.
- mattgreenrocks 3y agoI'm biased, but it is really interesting to hear VCs addressing this topic in the first place. Feels like something changed from the nascent Web 2.0 days where it's presumed every startup needs lots of capital to scale.
- adventured 3y agoThe last thing I put a lot of time into building, I took on a prominent VC as a business partner. That was a ~7 year partnership. Overall it was a good experience and yet I still find myself not wanting to do it any longer (give up equity to VCs). When your partner is a billionaire you find it's a lot more challenging to do things exactly the way you want to, to live by whatever your vision for the thing is, and to tell said billionaire no if there's a disagreement. It's not that you can't per se, it's that there is definitely additional relationship and operational risk to the context, additional calculation. It's very common for big investors to have big egos and big opinions. Pleasing investors becomes a thinking mistake problem that you have to manage. That's a mental cost to keep at bay and it gets old/tiring. The same is true whether the VC is prominent or just your average SV VC, and it persists whether it's a small number of investors or a lot of investors you're dealing with. Besides the obvious that venture capital isn't always right for every business or every business stage, sometimes it's never right for certain organizations. I'm working on a social network that will operate either as a public benefit corporation or non-profit org. There's no place for outside investors in there. Even if you eventually return to dealing with investors, do yourself a favor and build without them from time to time, at least for extended periods of time; it's refreshing to the soul if building things is what you really like doing.
- neom 3y agobtw, if you're looking for a good VC podcast, I recently discovered 20VC with Harry Stebbings. He brings on good guests, asks good questions, and has a posh English accent. A+ If anyone has some they like, I'd certainly appreciate links. https://www.youtube.com/@20VC https://www.youtube.com/@20VC
- keelhaule 3y agoSimple Answer: Bootstrap, because you keep control, VC is employment 2.0.
- notso411 3y ago[dead]
- latenightcoding 3y agoI've been around a lot of "deep tech" founders and the obvious answer in their case is VC all the way. Most are doing fun R&D on VC's dime and their company will most likely never be profitable just acquihired at some point.
- 4d4m 3y agoTruth: It's tough to do good, high-coverage marketing and PR with a bootstrapped budget.
- thewizardofaus 3y agoThis has been my observation too. VC backed competitors can spend 10-50x marketing spend of early bootstrapped companies quite easily.
- 4d4m 3y agoAgreed. This plus operating at a loss to gain marketshare make bootstrapping seem like a tough road ahead.
- metacritic12 3y agoKudos to Michael and Dalton for admitting a lot of truths that aren't VC / incubator friendly, like that most businesses should not be raising VC funding, or that lots of founders have amazing lives and get rich without VC funding. However, they're still burying the lede and the key conclusion. From those admissions above, they go into sales mode and say that if you want to be a trillion dollar company, you generally need to raise VC funding. This part is also true in favor of VCs, but hides an important assumption. All the above says is that VCs are good for certain company types, and not good for other company types. But people don't start companies to be a specific type, or to raise VC funding or not -- these are secondary characteristics. The primary reason a founder starts a company should determine the company type and whether they take VC funding: 1) If you want to have a small (1%) chance of having a massive impact on the world (think billions of dollars of founder valuation), you should aim big and take VC funding. 2) If you want to have a larger minority (25%+) chance of being quite personally rich (think tens of millions), you should probably avoid moonshots and aim for base runs that don't accept VC money. For 1), it is quite easy to see, only 1% of YC company founders, who are considered amongst the best in the valley, have a billion dollars of personal valuation at the end. If you want to be a Zuckerberg or a Gates, you have to aim for this, but know that it's very rare in the base population. If you focus on the max valuation, then yes that clearly favors VCs. If you focus on expected utility for standard utility curves, that favors bootstrapping. --- Finally, as my personal opinion, it seems obvious a priori that VC startups would be a lot more over-promoted, after all, without VC-investable startups, VC funds would do poorly. Literally trillions of dollars depend on enough founders doing these startups -- and they have a massive marketing budget. [1] On the other hand, bootstrapped companies have no clear "partners that require them" who would overpromote them. [1] https://paulgraham.com/submarine.html https://paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- dmezzetti 3y agoBootstrapping only works if you have the runway to do it and you don't feel the need to grow fast. With NeuML (https://neuml.com https://neuml.com), I've went the bootstrapping route. I've been able to build a fairly successful open source project (txtai 6K stars https://github.com/neuml/txtai https://github.com/neuml/txtai) and a revenue positive company. It's a "live within your means" strategy. VC funding can have a snowball effect where you need more and more. Then you're in the loop of needing funding rounds to survive. The hope is someday you're acquired or start turning a profit. I would say both have their pros and cons. Not all ideas have the luxury of time.
- lijok 3y ago> I don't think that anyone thinks it's more moral or good or right to start a VC backed company or a non-VC backed company. I don't think this is an actual debate. Show of hands HN, who here thinks it's more moral or good or right to start a non-VC backed company?
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoI wrote about morality here and business in another thread, but the gist is: The stories that you hear with hard work, finding a niche, product market fit, build a great product are all lies. The true secret is what I think of as "dirty business". Think: spam, sex, gambling, money making, scraping data, connections (which are not dirty per se but often not mentioned in stories). Examples: LinkedIn: spam Snapchat: sex Google: money making Facebook: sex, spam Slack: connections Uber: connections, money making Airbnb: spam I can go on and on and almost any large scale success (over $10 million ARR) have had these things. The only time these can be broken is when a new paradigm starts: Examples: PC Internet Mobile LLM These usually happen every decade or so and you have ~2 years to make it (Dirty business also helps here to go really fast). The other key insight is the way the capitalism system works, if you achieve the initial growth, you almost always will succeed. To go from $10 million ARR to $100 million ARR is easy as pie. So, the bottom line is if you are a normal, moral person, who is righteous and thinking I will make something to help others and disrupt the world, you will fail. The alternative is small tech businesses which at the most you can sell for a few million dollars. That is still achievable and easy. You must hyper focus on a location and a niche and just sell to them. But I don't think of them as a startup. They are more like your local salons and restaurants. A mom and pop shop which is instead dealing in software. For B2B software you need to have at least 3 - 5 customers willing to sign $10,000 and above contracts before you write a single line of code. This is still possible but you need the connections and the deep insight of the industry to make something meaningful. I do not know why so much of the literature and teaching stuff discounts that initial spark which causes startups to grow. They are all lies. Focus on connections with local politicians (donate $10,000 to the up and coming politician?), movers and shakers, buying large amount of scraped data etc. Think dirty business and then maybe you will have a chance of succeeding. Would love any counter arguments and comments. This is from a very long, over a decade research into why some businesses succeed and others fail.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]