9 ms·
Cable companies, automakers try to derail FTC, FCC quest to kill misleading fees
- mc32 3y agoYes, please. Price and I’ll relent, taxes, just because it’s nice to know how much the gov is taking in. Apply this everywhere, including restaurants, delivery services, etc. Make it so that anything beside price and taxes can be ignored at the discretion of the customer. If it not in the price and it’s not a sales tax, I’m free to ignore it.
- gotoeleven 3y agoThis article doesn't mention it, but at least some of these fees are actually taxes or regulatory fees that the government is just requiring that the cable company or car dealer collect on the government's behalf. How about we be fully transparent to the consumer and break all prices down into payments to the seller and payments to the government? I suspect the government would not like this.
- manicennui 3y agoNor would most consumers. I don't want to know about every cost a business has to pay in most cases.
- r3d0c 3y agodon't read it then, let the people who want to be informed and not be mislead about corporations increasing prices and lying about the reasons
- pessimizer 3y agoDo you feel like having fees spelled out in the billing could hurt customers' eyes or painfully confuse them, or do you think that a customer would be able to handle all of this extra information by ignoring it?
- manicennui 3y agoThe problem is when "the price" is presented and then the fees are presented later. Tell me the total price, and break it down separately. Most companies separate the fees so they can show a lower price and then surprise the customer later.
- plagiarist 3y agoLet's break it down further into payments to the government, payments to the laborers, payments for parts, and payments to the executives.
- skywhopper 3y agoI don't think consumers or the government would care too much if the fees were spelled out on the bill. The government fees have a purpose and it's actually a good thing to know that, for example, we pay a fee to subsidize rural phone and internet access. The important part here is that the advertised price for the service should match the total price that's actually billed.
- ceejayoz 3y agoMy cell phone bill is broken up that way, and has been for years. They add their own misleadingly named fees to give the illusion that they're direct taxes paid to the government. For example, Vonage: https://support.vonage.com/articles/answer/Regulatory-Compliance-and-Intellectual-Property-Fee-979 https://support.vonage.com/articles/answer/Regulatory-Compli... > The Regulatory, Compliance and Intellectual Property (RCIP) Fee covers regulatory, legal, intellectual property and compliance-related expenses, including those related to customer privacy protection, anti-fraud protection, number portability and innovation, all of which enable our services to enhance your communication experience. The RCIP fee is not a government mandated fee.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39005223 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39005223 ("Verizon to keep charging controversial fee despite $100M settlement") https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2024/01/verizon-wont-stop-charging-3-30-telco-recovery-fee-may-raise-it-again/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2024/01/verizon-wont-sto... > Verizon Wireless customers may get up to $100 each as part of a $100 million settlement in a class-action lawsuit over Verizon's monthly "Administrative and Telco Recovery Charge." > But as is typical in class-action settlements, Verizon isn't admitting any wrongdoing. It also plans to keep charging the monthly fee and says it may raise it in the future.
- a_c_s 3y agoWhy are judges approving such settlements? Either their fee is wrong and they should both have to stop charging it and pay a settlement or the fee is totally fine and Verizon should pay nothing.
- mc32 3y agoI think that's okay: net price + local, state and fed sales taxes in their respective buckets. But none of this service charge for that and healthcare fee for that and exclusive fee for this other.
- FireBeyond 3y agoA lot of the time, you're quite backwards. On the contrary, cell and cable companies have been fined or smacked for describing their fees as "taxes" and similar on bills. The FCC mandated that they were not allowed to call anything a tax unless it went 100% to a government agency.
- rootusrootus 3y agoI think you've just explained exactly why we are unlikely to see any resolution to this problem. A lot of people think we need to see the taxes that go to the government so we can get mad about it. See also Grover Norquist. The consequent pain and suffering is a feature.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoI feel we are having two different discussions. This is less about "show full breakdown of price in final bill",which is what I see debating here and what level should that be taken to,and more "don't advertise $X and then show $x+$y+$z unexpectedly" on final bill which I assume is less controversial .
- taeric 3y agoThis is an odd one, too. There is a lot of defense these companies will get for how complicated it is to price in all of the costs of business that are local taxes. Never mind that they already do this with the likes of labor and infrastructure cost variation. I'm somewhat sympathetic to billboard advertising, as that is something that can't really do this. But the vast majority of advertising can, in fact, show this level of detail quite easily.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoIf you know how much to charge me, you know how much to advertise. It's literally that simple.
- uxp100 3y agoNo. It does depend on where you live. Buying vehicles across state lines is very common and can result in significant differences in price. Doesn’t mean you couldn’t advertise the price as “for residents” or something.
- gwbas1c 3y ago> Buying vehicles across state lines is very common and can result in significant differences in price At least in MA, you have to pay the sales tax in order to register the vehicle. It doesn't matter what state you bought the car in. The regulators aren't letting that loophole slip in. Everyone here goes to NH to skip out on sales taxes, including the regulators that pass the sales taxes.
- 3y ago
- seventytwo 3y agoThe larger question about Chevron doctrine is really the issue. SCOTUS gutting Chevron will cripple the ability of the market to be regulated. You think companies charging fees is bad now? Just wait… you think you’ve seen OSHA violations now? Just wait. You think companies don’t give a shit about pollution now? Just wait.
- ihsw 3y ago[dead]
- jimbob45 3y agoAgency heads appointed via cronyism is undemocratic. Better we move to a system where Congress has to pass laws rather than installing yes-men into these agencies to push through their own personal agenda with little to no pushback.
- jandrese 3y agoSaid as a person who clearly does not pay attention to Congress. Congressmen are in no way equipped to deal with minutia from agencies. They can barely pass a budget.
- triceratops 3y agoThink about how little your Congressperson knows about technology - a field you're presumably well-versed in. Then imagine if they brought that depth of knowledge to every single field they pass laws in. "Leave it to Congress" is tantamount to deregulating literally everything.
- jimbob45 3y agoThis is a false dilemma fallacy. The options are not "let Congress vote on everything forever only" and "unelected agency heads rule your life". There are shades of gray between those two extremes.
- 3y ago
- frankus 3y agoThe article regularly refers to Automakers (e.g. in the headline), but the actual suit is from NADA and its Texas equivalent, who represent auto dealers.
- jacobyoder 3y agoWhen my wife first moved here to the US (from overseas), we'd pass by some used car places and they had cars with big "$1999" and "$2799" in the windows. "Wow... they've got great prices!" she said. I burst her bubble with "that's just 'downpayment'". Eventually we went up close to one to show her "yep, the car is actually $11k, but they put $1999 in giant numbers to get you to pull in. She's not dumb by any means, but I don't think this was legal in the UK where she came from. That was a bit of an eye-opener for me.
- jimt1234 3y agoI once read a comment here on HN from someone in Australia, saying that, according to local laws, advertised prices must match the final price, including taxes, fees, etc. So, if the price says "$100", you're gonna pay $100. That blew my mind. I've lived in the US my whole life; I never really thought a straight-forward pricing system was possible. Seriously. Then I remember getting kinda depressed, because the pricing system here (in the US) isn't going to change anytime soon. I recalled an article about Ticketmaster, which basically said that their system of showing the final price only at checkout, after a bunch of screens/clicks, is hugely profitable for them, almost everyone still purchases the tickets, regardless of the fees, because the process is so painful and there's really no alternative. Back to reality. Advertised ticket price = $100. Final price = $165. Ugh.
- mgkimsal 3y agoWith so many local taxing jurisdiction, it's essentially impossible. I bought something from my office, and if it's shipped to my office, I pay one tax. Shipped to my home (in a neighboring county), it's a different (lower) tax. I did some POS work for a company years back and tried to integrate 'taxes'. I was replacing an earlier system, and I used modern tax SaaS (avalara, IIRC). The client was telling me all my taxes were wrong, but... digging in... Avalara was correct, and the client had been calculating and collecting taxes wrong for... about 15 years. I had no way to try to figure out how they were doing it 'wrong' to match how they'd been doing it. This had to do with 'service/labor' income vs 'product' vs 'chemicals' they used. Different counties in the same state had different rates (which changed over different months/years historically). Tribal lands had different rules still. The biggest lesson I took from that was... if you do something (tax calculations), do it consistently and uniformly. Should they have been audited, it may have looked a bit better that they were at least consistent in their tax issues, instead of looking like they were explicitly trying to somehow intentionally scam customers or the govt.
- post_break 3y agoMy favorite thing is the documentation fee. Yeah, we're going to charge you a fee because we're selling you a car and we have to put in some information. Tax? Title? License? Don't forget the bullshit documentation fee. How about the fee just because we can fee. Nitrogen in the tires? Window tint that we install on every car that touches our lot no matter what that we up charge 100% on? And then how about an extended warranty? Want to finance through us so we can double dip? Buying a car in America is one big show and dance as to who can screw the customer the most. And then god forbid you need to get service on the vehicle, they will do everything they possibly can to make sure it's not covered under warranty.
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoThis is why buying a used car from a private individual is a much nicer experience and probably how I will buy any future car.
- RankingMember 3y agoYeah, with some rare exceptions, I think I agree: even if you happen across an untrustworthy person in person-to-person sales, at least they don't have the additional benefit of a whole infrastructure around them set up specifically to aid in screwing you.
- antiframe 3y agoRight. People tell me "but how can you trust a perfect stranger?" To which I reply most people selling cars are honest. Most car salesmen are dishonest. I trust private sellers more than I trust car salesmen.
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoGet the car checked out by a trusted mechanic or shop before buying it (a mechanic or shop that you've used before). They charge less than $200. Yes, they can miss problems, but they're not going to miss obvious problems. i've done this and the buyers never had a problem with it. If the buyer pressures you, "I've got 3 other people lined up to buy", then walk. You don't need THAT car THAT badly.
- pompino 3y agoMost online stores that do that, when you're about to checkout, they ask you if you want to add a previously viewed item, or some other kind of add-on, etc. Its a sales tactic and I can see how it works. If the FTC is to regulate this, to make it fair I'd say broaden the scope to make it more general for other stores and domains.
- dylan604 3y agoI just finished ordering groceries just a few minutes ago. I make heavy use of the site's carousel listing my previously purchased items. It is a huge time saver for me since I re-order things all the time. They offer one on the main page after logging in, but offer it again at check-out. More than once, I've found something I was about to forget. Since it's something I use and find useful, I don't think of it as a sales tactic in a negative manner. Not to say that there are not different versions that are more on the dark arts side though
- pompino 3y agoSure but the tradeoff is that either you accidentally order more things than you need (based on retailer recommendation), or you have to do a new order because you forgot (when there are no retailer recommendations). Some retailers allow you to modify an existing order, which can partially solve the problem as well. Overall, I think its not a good idea for a retailer to be so pushy at checkout especially when I want to checkout quickly and get back to doing whatever I was doing.
- legitster 3y ago> As it stands, Congress passes a (often vague and badly written) law, and it’s up to regulators with very tailored knowledge (on subjects ranging from wireless spectrum management to emission controls) to implement useful rules within the confines of the law. To what degree is this actually true? My experience with regulators is that they often do not have "very tailored knowledge" - they are just cogs in their own machine. They are often generalists whose skills are more transferrable to other regulatory branches than they are to the industries in question.
- fifteen1506 3y agoThis is simple without getting the state to meddle in the business of private individuals. Just set FairBusiness, LLC. Businesses who want clients have to be certified by FairBusiness in how they don't screw up customers. Customers who want to find the nearest non-screwing business have to pay a listing annual fee to FairBusiness, LLC. And thus the market polices itself. No need for noisy governmental agency.
- hobs 3y agoAnd then this business just sells out in less than 5 years, hell even the big four screw up constantly for their primary focus.
- jawns 3y agoYou've just described the Better Business Bureau. But guess what? There are plenty of underhanded businesses that could care less about a bad rating from the BBB, because the type of customer they're fleecing is not particularly savvy. Think elderly folks who are a little too trusting, or immigrants with a bit of a language barrier who aren't familiar with the BBB.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoAlso, BBB is basically just pre-Internet Yelp. Their business model is to extort businesses for better ratings, not to actually provide useful ratings to end-users.
- fifteen1506 3y agoThen people shouldn't buy there without having proper knowledge.
- belthesar 3y agoThis type of "buyer beware" position describes the exact problem US auto dealerships already take advantage of, and advocating for more uses of this methodology doesn't address any of the actual problems, and makes the problems the industry are currently facing actively worse.
- more_corn 3y agoThis is an example of corporations working directly counter to the interests of consumers. I reluctantly concede that we need government intervention in this case.
- seventytwo 3y agoIt’s only coincidental that companies work in the interest of consumers. Profit is the only real incentive. Often times, the profit and consumer benefit are aligned, but it’s because of feedback systems like public reputation, product usefulness, pricing, and government regulation that those two things are coupled at all. There’s no inherent reason why any business must work in the interests of consumers. Without social or government regulation, the dynamic reduces to an oscillatory predator/prey system, where maximal profit is extracted at any cost until the consumer base is damaged. The damaged consumer base reduces profits and causes the company to extract less, allowing the consumer base to recover… repeat.
- JohnFen 3y agoIt's truly amazing how hard they're fighting against the idea of actually telling people what things cost in an honest and transparent fashion. It doesn't speak well of their intentions.
- neuralRiot 3y agoIt’s not just cars and cable, most services are loaded with “fees”, what is the point of a price sticker if you gonna charge whatever you want, it should be like retail, you have to charge what is posted.