4 ms·
Banning Private Jets and Going to a 4-Day Work Week Are Radical – and Popular
- fasthands9 3y agoFour day work weeks are popular in the same way it is both popular that taxes should be lower and public spending are both popular. Degrowth/anti-capitalism are popular to many but even among this subset of people they are very upset (as we have seen) when prices of things go up slightly. I understand the arguments for the four day work week as it relates to reforms (such as the hours threshold for receiving healthcare could be lower) but that does not seem to be what this author is talking about here.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoData shows productivity is maintained in the pilots so far. Reverse Parkinson’s Law. https://www.4dayweek.com/casestudies https://www.4dayweek.com/casestudies https://hn.algolia.com/?q=4+day+week+success https://hn.algolia.com/?q=4+day+week+success https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_law https://www.economist.com/news/1955/11/19/parkinsons-law https://www.economist.com/news/1955/11/19/parkinsons-law (Prices will rise and neutral inflation rate higher than historically regardless due to structural demographics globally; importantly, labor has power to enact change as the working population cohort shrinks)
- danbruc 3y agoWhat about someone driving a bus, working on a production line, ... everything would become almost 20 % more expensive.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIn certain industries, consumers will pay a bit more and shareholders will see lower returns. People work to live, not live to work. There are already shortages of bus drivers because the pay is insufficient for the work. This is good, because when there is surplus labor, stakeholders will say “thems the breaks.” Better to be perpetually starved of labor and force systems to adapt. https://www.epi.org/blog/the-school-bus-driver-shortage-remains-severe-without-job-quality-improvements-workers-children-and-parents-will-suffer/ https://www.epi.org/blog/the-school-bus-driver-shortage-rema...
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoBus drivers and line workers are also among the lower fruit for automation. Increasing their price could be what’s needed to push us into a higher-productivity state.
- danbruc 3y agoLet's look at this the other way, everyone gets a 20 % wage cut and we maintain current prices. On the one hand we would have additional demand for labor to do the 20 % of work, on the other hand we would have a 20 % drop in demand, so there might not even be a demand for additional labor pulling wages up. I would expect a relativ shift towards essential goods but I do not see how this could incentivize more automation.
- kelnos 3y agoOr no, we don't do that. Everyone gets the same pay, and prices stay the same. Shareholders see lower returns, but them's the breaks. This idea that we should prioritize dividends and capital appreciation over the happiness and mental health of the masses... it's disgusting.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- danbruc 3y agoSame prices and same wage does not work, because your wage now only produces 80 % of the products compared to before. If someone is syphoning off 20 % of your labor for nothing, then I am all with you and this should be brought to an end, but I fail to see how working a day less each week could be an effective tool to achieve this.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Everyone gets the same pay, and prices stay the same. Shareholders see lower returns, but them's the breaks This gets attempted once a generation somewhere in the world. The problem is when you devalue capital, it isn’t maintained. The only way your equation balances is with a massive jolt to TFP. There isn’t a free lunch in reducing labour; we must be realistic about the tradeoffs involved.
- jrockway 3y agoWe watched everything become 20% more expensive in 2021 and we didn't get an extra day off. I'm happy to try it again if I can get a day off every week. This time I'm prepared, I have a nice mortgage that can be made 20% less expensive in terms of real dollars.
- WWLink 3y agoOr would it? Perhaps running easier shifts and staffing better to handle things like employees on sick leave, would lead to less attrition, fewer sick employees, and better job satisfaction. If you can convince the employees that you're on the same team, they might also be more open to communicating inefficiencies like "this process is crap, if you change these steps you'll have fewer defects and the line will run faster". Saving EVEN MORE money and time.
- danbruc 3y agoThat is certainly a possibility but I have doubts. If you could gain 20+ % percent of productivity be making your employees work 20 % less, it would be stupid for any company to not do this. What seems more likely to me is that you can gain a few percent which would make the overall impact less than the full 20 %. Making processes better and so on seems mostly unrelated to me, that you could also do with a full work week.
- Ekaros 3y agoI think nursing is one sector I could see directly translating shorter work weeks to higher costs. Something like bus drivers you could remove part of services. With factories labour should not be significant part of cost compared to raw materials. In many areas you could just provide less hours of services, thus lower costs. But in some this is just not possible and those will cost more.
- danbruc 3y agoWhat is the cost of raw materials? It is the labor that went into digging them out of the ground and refining them.
- kelnos 3y agoSome things may get more expensive, and maybe that's fine. Inflation is a thing, and things become more expensive all the time; hell, over the past couple years, things became a lot more expensive, and we didn't get anything good in return for it, like a shortening the work week. Production lines don't need to run 24/7. Advances in automation, and productivity in general, could also close the gap. I'm so tired of this idea that the point of life is to produce more and more and more. That degenerates into the point of life being to work and work and work. It's dumb. Human lives could be so much more.
- fasthands9 3y agoAs far as I can tell all those links you posted were case studies involving public administration jobs and bureaucracy. Parkinson's Law is explicitly about this. It is not at all clear if (or how) productivity would go up in most other jobs, including construction, factory work, barbers, nurses, garbage men, chefs, etc. While technology may make it possible that people are productive per hour, there is no study or even pathway for how a chef (for instance) could produce more meals in 32 hours than 40.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.npr.org/2023/11/11/1207991399/4-four-day-work-week-manufacturing-work-life-balance https://www.npr.org/2023/11/11/1207991399/4-four-day-work-we... https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/lamborghini-introduces-four-day-week-production-workers-2023-12-05/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/lambor... https://www.equipmentworld.com/business/article/15280393/hawaii-contractor-says-fourday-work-weeks-make-crews-happier https://www.equipmentworld.com/business/article/15280393/haw... (4/10 admittedly)
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.4dayweek.com/casestudies/case-study-golden https://www.4dayweek.com/casestudies/case-study-golden (City of Golden, Colorado police department)
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20240214223733/https://ehq-production-us-california.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/cfbe4617ccc633a3398b57da3c6290e271e2ce96/original/1707496976/32b4a17b6f7324f5514392756db3db3b_Compressed_Workweek_6-Month_update.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20240214223733/https://ehq-produ... ("City of Golden 6-month Update on Police Department Compressed Workweek Pilot") Highlighted results: * Faster call response times across the 6 month trial * Faster responses on Priority 1 calls (e.g., crimes in progress, life threatening emergencies) for 4 of 6 months * 3x increase in code enforcement (e.g., parking tickets) * 79% decrease in overtime spending * -304 hours/month of overtime * 50% drop in resignations and retirements (!!)
- ToucanLoucan 3y ago> Degrowth/anti-capitalism are popular to many but even among this subset of people they are very upset (as we have seen) when prices of things go up slightly. Citation: trust me dude I don't really recall getting upset at prices of things going up unless I perceive that the price change has no correlation to the value delivered. I get angry when my cable internet bill would go up $20 every quarter because they were selling me the same (terrible) service still, for a higher price. Just helping themselves to a larger portion of my monthly income while delivering the exact same product. Or you have the even worse version of that, streaming services that raise their prices, as they're removing content from their libraries. Conversely, I've personally known tons of people who buy higher priced products for the perceived value they gain. That's an utterly normal thing.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoI'm sorry for throwing more anecdotes into the barrel, but our local Facebook groups absolutely lose their shit when things go up in price (or are perceived to go up in price.) Things like fast food places upping the price of a burger, or grocery stores charging a dollar more for eggs than last year, are certainly noticed. (And honestly, for people on a fixed/limited income, food prices going up are probably a fairly reasonable thing to be upset about!)
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoI mean companies gouging on the prices of every day goods under bullshit "inflation" excuses is a hot topic right now, and deservedly so I feel. It's hard to take their cries of "we can't help it!" as seemingly every major corporation is reporting record profits constantly. Irrespective of the larger economic forces at play there, if you're simultaneously whining about how you need to raise your prices because everything is expensive, or worse still, doing it because your laborers are demanding better wages, while not paying said wages and charging more and then posting record profits? I think people have every right to call your price rises bullshit.
- timeon 3y ago> Degrowth/anti-capitalism I think you are merging too much of it here. I was born in communist regime and as far as I can remember degrowth was never popular.
- belter 3y agoPlease don't ban my private jet. You can all work from home and move to a three day work week...
- kkfx 3y agoshorter workweeks, while perfectly possible according to a classic https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/ https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/ are generally used to force people in cities with hybrid works model instead of full remote. So I claim arrogantly that such proposals and experiments are ultimately AGAINST the declaimed "green goals" IF such goals are green in the sense of spring grass, not in the sense of the dollars dominant color. Private jets since they are a little minority does not count except for PR/emotions (no, I do not have one). BTW I observe always in "spring grass" green sense that living in dense cities is the most polluting way to live we have. Oh, yes, formally a new high rise building need less energy to heat/cool than an equivalent number of single family homes and being "near" demand less energy for personal daily trips BUT that's not the big picture. Single family homes can be rebuilt "frequently", for instance at a generational change (inheritance, and so on, let's say after 50 years) and the ability to to far shorter personal trips means the need of a much big infra to supply dense zones in food and water. The "TCO" is far higher for high density than for moderate-low density. A classic (well, not ideal but...) study http://www.newgeography.com/content/006840-high-density-and-sustainability http://www.newgeography.com/content/006840-high-density-and-... as a sample. Oh, and of course a single family home can have p.v. (it it's meaningful where it exists), charge a BEV at home and so on, I do have them now, I couldn't have them in a dense city.
- tux1968 3y ago> Private jets since they are a little minority does not count except for PR/emotions (no, I do not have one). They do count. It's incredibly important that elites/leaders have skin in the game, and live by the same rules as those they govern.
- Ekaros 3y agoI personally expect anyone asking for sacrifices, to make even bigger sacrifices themselves. And those that actually impact their quality of live. Like if you want to ban meat, you should be ready to get rid of things like coffee or large selections of fruits and vegetables.
- vdaea 3y agoBanning stuff that you can't do is popular for obvious reasons. It's like when the EU overregulates the software industry.
- vdaea 3y agoAlso I wonder what some will do with so much free time. I know many men for whom work is a way to escape home with the nagging wife and the kids who don't respect them. I guess they'll spend one more day a week drinking at the pub. Before someone flags this for being against progressivism, it's just a thought that crosses my mind whenever this comes up. I'm not arguing against it.
- graemep 3y agoThey will probably have better relationships with their wives, and certainly with their kids, if they spent more time with them.
- timeon 3y ago> I know many men for whom work is a way to escape home with the nagging wife and the kids who don't respect them. Imagine sharing chores, the horror.
- kelnos 3y agoAssuming the trope you mention is common these days (I don't think it is, but sure, let's run with it), perhaps part of the reason for it is the wedge that the working day pushes between the breadwinner and the rest of the family. And perhaps that breadwinner would have a better relationship with spouse and kids if there was a little less work and a little more family time. Either way, if you don't work and get bored, that's on you. There are so many exciting things to do in our world (many of them low-cost or free, even), that there's no excuse for being bored, except, perhaps, for laziness or a lack of imagination.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI love my family (no nagging wife or disrespectful kid) but long weekends leave me exhausted. We have to figure out how to keep the kid engaged for a day without school or after school care for an assist. And this is at the same time trying to keep screen time down by providing interesting alternatives. Coding is much easier than childcare, at least from my perspective. However, I know I’ll look back on my kid’s needy phase with fond memories.
- jmyeet 3y agoI don't think we need to ban private jets. It should just be more expensive to use them. Take Taylor Swift as an example. Is she meant to fly commercial? How would that work exactly? She'd get mobbed at the airport, at security, at the gate, on the plane. Just look at what happened when Taylor Swift went to a friend's rehearsal diner in New Jersey recently [1]. It would be a legitimate security issue too. The last one is why many executives of large companies (eg Tim Cook) are banned by their boards from flying commercial. So, stop making private jets any form of legitimate tax deduction. Give them absolutely no tax advantageous treatment whatsoever. Increase the fuel excises, landing fees, parking fees, you name it. When the amortized flying cost of that jet jumps from $10k/hour to $30k/hour, we'll see who still needs to fly private. Oh and as for working 4 days a week. Yes. Most jobs are bullshit. Most work is bullshit. Work less, get paid more. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUjXdKEVoBg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUjXdKEVoBg
- gruez 3y ago>So, stop making private jets any form of legitimate tax deduction. Give them absolutely no tax advantageous treatment whatsoever. AFAIK there's no such "advantageous treatment" for private jets. They're are tax-deductible in the same way that plane tickets (or any other business expense, really) are tax deductible.
- kelnos 3y agoThat could change, though. The tax code could have a carve-out that says use of a private plane can't be counted as an ordinary business expense (or cap it at some amount, or some percentage of the cost).
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- gruez 3y ago> The tax code could have a carve-out that says use of a private plane can't be counted as an ordinary business expense Seems like a weird way of doing it, considering that such a change wouldn't affect paying for such flights individually. After all, it's not like a company funded jet emits more co2 than a personally funded jet. If your concern is co2 emissions, you should just tax co2 directly, not through weird carveouts.
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago[flagged]
- sapphicsnail 3y ago[flagged]
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago[flagged]
- thiagoharry 3y agoNot the OP, but I read most of Das Capital... 1. He is not. The companies that employs those workers are the ones that are exploiting. 2. I'm not sure that it is the case here, but a person can be paid more than her labor by several reasons, including luck in the market. Of course, in a large volume of exchanges, good luck and bad luck cancel each other out, therefore to explain a stable surplus value accumulation, you need another explanation. Marx explains this as a non-paid value taken from the workers. If he do not employ anyone, he is not exploiting anyone according with Marx. Anyway, even though he was exploiting, any Marxist would condemn your moralistic view of the situation. Marx's critique is not a moral one. Friedrich Engels, who helped Marx to develop his theories was a capitalist who owned factories. You have all right to do not like Marx or his theories. However, I think that any criticism should be valid (99% of what you find in the Internet is propaganda, not serious criticism), otherwise it is the critic who would be the pseudocientific/religious ideologue.
- chanakya 3y agoWhether or not degrowth can be made to work, what this guy is talking about is fantasy. For example: ...That creates some pressure on planetary boundaries. So that means that the Global North needs to consciously degrow because it is over-developing, and has excessive production and consumption. This will not help. Emissions from the US and Europe now account of about 20% of global emissions and are going down. Emissions from the rest of the world are rising steeply.
- sapphicsnail 3y ago> I think it’s [degrowth] in some sense utopian. But believing that capitalism will prosper in the decades to come is utopian too, because we will have more natural disasters, inflation, wars — and these will all accelerate with the climate crisis. So it’s naive to think that our way of life will somehow continue. He admits several times that this isn't a concrete solution and that the global south will continue to grow but the point remains that we can't really continue what we're doing. *Edited to mark the quote
- chanakya 3y agoThere were more wars and disasters before capitalism, not fewer. In recent times, both wars and fatal disasters have dropped drastically.
- thiagoharry 3y agoNot sure about this, as the 2 World Wars in 20th century and colonialism were a great source of deaths and disasters. But anyway, even if this is true, the point is that climate crisis probably will change this score, provoking lot more disasters and wars in the future.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoHe is a Marxist shilling his books. There is nothing intellectual or deep worth critiquing here more than what you have in your comment.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated: Germany explores 4-day workweek amid labor shortage https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39219344 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39219344
- sirdarius 3y agoMaybe a dumb question, but what does "banning private jets" actually mean? Do we ban the actual planes themselves, as in, crack down on plane manufacturers to somehow restrict them from building small passenger capacity jet planes? And if so, what minimal capacity should be the threshold? Or do we ban private companies and individuals from flying jet planes under said hypothetical capacity? Another possibility might be to ban non-scheduled flights using jet planes. In any case, who would have the authority to enforce this internationally, ICAO I guess? It does not appear like something they would even consider, their efforts being targeted towards implementing CORSIA (Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation) instead. Now to go even further, let's hypothesize that private jets are banned. What about non jet planes, as in props or turbo-props engines? Perfomance in terms of speed can be close to jet planes. Take for example the Piaggio Avanti EVO, which can reach around 740 km/h. While its fuel consumption is notably lower than similar jet planes, it's still higher per passenger than commercial flights. We can imagine a strong market demand for them will appear, to replace the banned model range. So should non jet private planes be banned as well? Even models like Cessna 172 and such?
- wmf 3y agoIt's not a serious policy suggestion so the details don't matter. Coincidentally I went down a Piaggio Avanti rabbit hole recently; it sounds quite cool.