8 ms·
How not to bomb your offer negotiation (2016)
- diebeforei485 3y ago> Rest assured, this person is actually a terrible negotiator. They’re good at being difficult and causing a scene, which can sometimes convince a waitress or shift manager to appease them. But this style of negotiating will get you nowhere when negotiating with a business partner (that is, an employer). You need to pick your negotiation strategy based on the situation. Sometimes you do need to be bullheaded when insisting on a refund. That doesn't make you a bad negotiator when negotiating pay - you just use a different strategy when negotiating a pay raise.
- mewpmewp2 3y agoBut also in many cases asking for a refund itself is a waste of time, money and nerves. Another thing to consider is, what is worth negotiating for. +20% on your salary? Absolutely. 10% off a cupcake. Maybe not.
- diebeforei485 3y agoA cupcake no; but a new TV that arrives scratched up, yes. Again, it really depends.
- dang 3y agoRelated: How Not to Bomb a Job Offer - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21382224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21382224 - Oct 2019 (1 comment) How Not to Bomb Your Offer Negotiation - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12476814 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12476814 - Sept 2016 (125 comments)
- foobarbecue 3y agoSeems crazy to tell them in an email "I sometimes get nervous in important phone calls." Why would you do that??? Just leave it at "I prefer to discuss this type of thing via email" ... no need to announce your incompetence.
- iancmceachern 3y agoOr even "I prefer to discuss this", not even "type of thing".
- codegladiator 3y ago[flagged]
- HaseebQ 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ta_or_even 3y ago[flagged]
- mewpmewp2 3y agoWhat about > blushes I-i-i sometimes get nervous cough if maybe it could possibly be ok with you could we maybe do it with a phone call, whoops, I mean e-mail!! nervous laughter Some recruiters may find it cute
- seritools 3y agoneeds some more uwuspeak for full effect
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kaliqt 3y agoThere's a mistake in the post regarding the cost to the company of selecting you (~$24k). They have runner-ups, and they most certainly didn't take down their postings yet, so they will not lose the $24k and start over again, they'll lose a bit more money negotiating with the runner-ups if they're still available, only if the negotiations dragged on forever would the cost keep going up for the company.
- scaryclam 3y agoAnd to add, it's a large cost if the candidate takes the offer and doesn't work out. If a candidate is unhappy with the offer but accepts it, they are more likely to leave sooner than a candidate who is happy with the offer. Companies I've worked at would rather a bit of negotiation or a flat out "I won't work for what you can offer", than a candidate who leaves after a few months. I've never seen a recruitment pipeline that stopped when they got an acceptable CV in, nevermind risk a lot of money on an offer stage. It keeps going until a contract is signed, and sometimes beyond, exactly to mitigate risk.
- doix 3y agoI wonder if nowadays you can just ask ChatGPT to negotiate for you. Personally, I hate negotiating salary and the games that come along with it. I usually go in with a number in my head and if they can't meet it, I just thank them for their time and say I'm not considering offers below my number. The risk/downside is that my number could be too low, but that's something I'm willing to live with if it means I can avoid having to negotiate. If they immediately agree to your number, it probably means you asked for too little. Or the person you're dealing with also hates negotiating.
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoEvery person is different, but I wonder what is it that you hate so much about negotiation, so much that you’d accept a lower salary even though if you had bills to pay. Even I don’t like to push hard and use tactics like the ones you see in sales calls, but the last time I had to negotiate salaries, I just said that I was excited for the position and the company, and reminded them it would be difficult to accept what they were offering because it didn’t meet my expectations. Virtually everyone was convinced by said statements and came back with salary increases after that. As for ChatGPT, there are tell tale markers when someone uses that, and because of its content-free nature of writing, it is very likely to backfire.
- doix 3y ago> Every person is different, but I wonder what is it that you hate so much about negotiation, so much that you’d accept a lower salary even though if you had bills to pay. Why are you assuming that I'm constantly accepting lower salaries? I pick my number so that I can my bills and live a comfortable life. Sometimes they have to close a job req and open a new one with a higher pay grade to give me my number. I've read a few times that employees don't care about the absolute number, as long as they feel like they are getting paid fairly compared to their peers. I was like that when I was younger but now I don't care. If Jeff does nothing and gets paid more than me, whatever. As long as I make a number I'm happy with then I'm happy. > As for ChatGPT, there are tell tale markers when someone uses that, and because of its content-free nature of writing, it is very likely to backfire. I just tried it, and it came up with: > Thank you for the offer. I appreciate the opportunity to join your company. However, based on my skills, experience, and the market standards for this role in the industry, I was hoping for a salary closer to (your salary). I believe this reflects the value I can bring to the team and the responsibilities of the position. Seems _good enough_. I'm sure if I spent more time with the prompt and actually told it what industry I'm in, it could write something less generic.
- jongjong 3y agoNegotiation tactics only work when the other person is dumb and has a big ego. Thankfully most rich people have both. In a way, you need to also pretend to be dumb and with a big ego. If you're irrational, they'll think they might lose the deal and will offer more.
- rightbyte 3y agoYe. It feels so stupid playing these games, but if your counterpart does think like that, you more or less have to. It resembles dating. The same tiptoeing and guessing what the other person is thinking.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoThis isn't true at all. Even between two perfectly rational actors, there's a lot of hidden information in the hiring process, contradictory goals, and orthogonal goals. This demands negotiation. At it's most basic, the company wants to pay me the least I will accept. I want to be paid as much as possible. These are contradictory, so some middle ground needs to be found. There's also a lot of hidden information, on both sides: What's the most the company is willing to pay? What's the least I'm willing to take? We can also have orthogonal goals: personally, I put a pretty high value on PTO, so there's room for trading salary expectations for additional time off. By not negotiating, all you're doing is leaving money on the table. The company is going to represent it's interests, you have to represent yours.
- debacle 3y agoIf you already have an offer in hand, you shouldn't be negotiating through the recruiter. This is a hiring decision not buying a home. CC the recruiter, take their advice, but work with the hiring manager directly. One of the worst things you can do in negotiation is talk to the wrong person. Instead of going you -> recruiter -> HR rep -> team lead -> hiring manager, you need to go you -> hiring manager. Talk to your recruiter, strategize, whatever, but everything else is playing telephone and it's very easy to get a yes from someone who's not allowed to say yes.
- msy 3y agoThere's usually layers of approval for offers inside organisations, it's improbable anyone you're talking to is going to be able to make a decision independent of people outside your communication loop and they're all going to be talking to each other.
- michaelt 3y agoIt's fine for them to talk to each other. The distinction is - if there's one person with the authority to say yes to your salary requirements, and three people who only have the authority to say no, does it benefit you to go via those three people? In some organisations it might benefit you! If your salary needs to be approved by a hierarch of the fourth level but you'll be reporting to a hierarch of the second level who'll be benefiting from your genius, they might be a highly motivated advocate in your favour. In other organisations though, the more opportunities there are to say no, the higher chance of the answer being no.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoThose are all good points. I also look at it from the perspective of having an "inside person" championing a package you both agree on, versus you convincing the recruiter to champion it enough for HR to champion it too.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoThe tricky part that it's not always clear who will be the best internal advocate. Sometimes, it's the manager because they benefit the most from hiring you and the organization probably values their opinion, but some managers are pushovers with zero people skills and will be useless. Sometimes, it's the recruiter because they are the most experienced with the hiring process and know what wheels to grease; sometimes they're useless because recruiters are often viewed as interchangeable cogs.
- mlsu 3y agoThere are some good things in here, like not closing the door on yourself early, not giving lowball numbers, the overall mindset that you're in a negotiation with a corporation that negotiates salaries all day every day. But what he describes is definitely not an outcome you can expect in this market if you are 3 months post-bootcamp. There is the flipside also, which is that if you misrepresent your own value and cinch an offer higher than you're worth, you'll be first to go when downsizing comes -- moreso the higher the number. As an aside, I looked at the post he talks about here ("how I got the job at airbnb") and this guy seems... kinda shiesty? First, top comment on the last story: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12477191 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12477191 And this, also in the same thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12477866 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12477866 He didn't stay at AirBnB for very long, has since moved onto... yup, crypto.
- dilyevsky 3y ago> But what he describes is definitely not an outcome you can expect in this market if you are 3 months post-bootcamp. Hate to say it but in this market you ain’t going to get a callback with 3mo bootcamp so i wouldn’t waste the time reading it
- mlsu 3y agoThe guy in the post describes doing just that: https://haseebq.com/farewell-app-academy-hello-airbnb-part-i/ https://haseebq.com/farewell-app-academy-hello-airbnb-part-i... 2016 was pretty wild.
- resolutebat 3y agoPart 2 is even wilder: https://haseebq.com/farewell-app-academy-hello-airbnb-part-ii/ https://haseebq.com/farewell-app-academy-hello-airbnb-part-i...
- beacon294 3y ago>There is the flipside also, which is that if you misrepresent your own value and cinch an offer higher than you're worth, you'll be first to go when downsizing comes -- moreso the higher the number. This is really an edge case. I would err towards earning more, having more saveable income, and growing into your pay.
- jeffrallen 3y agoSalary needs to be enough to make you not think about money anymore and get on with making value for your company. If no amount of money will ever make you stop thinking about money, you don't need negotiating advice, you need a psychologist.
- geraldwhen 3y agoI only go to work to get paid. As such, I’m always thinking about money. How much more can I invest each month? How might different risk investment allocations affect my retirement date? The second I have enough money to quit and live the rest of my life as I want to, I will. If pessimistic retirement projections show a large success rate of funds through retirement, I’m gone! I don’t care how long I’ve worked for a place; I’m only there for the money and no other reason.
- bityard 3y agoWhat do you plan to do when you retire?
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoA lot of the same shit I do now between work but without work interrupting it and in the vicinity of a mansion and having built a family trust fund for their future.
- mewpmewp2 3y agoWhat if no amount of psychologist will make you stop thinking about money? Just I don't really like this approach of ending with a suggestion to "see a psychologist". It's like this conversation: Alice: Alcohol is bad for you! Bob: But I can't relax and have as great conversations in social settings or connect with people properly. Alice: That's just an excuse! If you can't enjoy yourself without alcohol there must be something wrong with you! Bob: Okay, maybe there's something wrong with me. What should I do. Alice: Go see a therapist. Bob: Sees therapist Bob: Still can't enjoy or relax Bob: How long should I try this and for how long should I skip being able to enjoy social situations or relax? Alice: Keep trying! Bob ends up trying, but never gets anywhere, then dies.
- resolutebat 3y ago> I know that the average software engineer in Silicon Valley makes roughly 120K a year salary. Even allowing for inflation since 2016, this seems like a terrible way to start negotiating a salary: you just proclaimed yourself "average" and anchored yourself to a low number.
- WJW 3y agoProclaiming yourself average may not be such a bad thing if your experience consists of a 3 month bootcamp. If anything, proclaiming yourself "average" with that kind of background is vastly overselling yourself. I would say it is actually pretty good negotiating strategy by subtly getting the hiring person to agree that 120k is the absolute floor and probably insultingly low, since who (especially at companies like Google and AirBnB) would willingly admit to hiring below-average or even average employees? "Everyone knows" that they want Only The Best (tm). Just the fact that they're talking about salary therefore implies that the applicant must be above average and confident behavior/being hard to get can easily reinforce that impression.
- fxtentacle 3y ago"Most people think negotiating well is just looking the other person in the eye, appearing confident, and asking for tons of money." Yup. That's the way to go as a freelancer. You announce your rate and either they book you or not.
- GreedClarifies 3y agoLevels.fyi exists.
- gear54rus 3y agobut mostly in the us
- drdrek 3y agoWho wants to hire the most adversarial person alive? yeah a company is not your friend and you should get as much as possible there is a point that you make yourself unhireble by showing that you are so mercenary that you'll be out the door the instant an x+1$ offer arrives.
- rightbyte 3y agoYes. You need to pretend to be fiercly "loyal" and drink the kool aid, until you are not. Preferably you should go out the door still drinking it. If you get a better deal just switch. The MBA caricature type will just despise you for taking the worse deal anyways. There deal gotta be better though and 1USD is certainly not worth the risk alone.
- jwmoz 3y agoThe trick is to do it politely and respectfully.
- k__ 3y agoI had a negotiation once, where our payment expectations we're off by 2x. Never ever had I seen a CEO that much in shock.
- steveBK123 3y agoPeople don't understand how wide the range of compensation in this space is. I'll get pings from recruiters for jobs with compensation ranges from 1-3x. They are looking at the same LinkedIn page with my years of experience, career history and skills. Often the companies that want to pay 1x are looking for quite a lot of experience & seniority, despite wanting to pay 1/3 the top of range I can achieve. I've had job negotiations that they wanted me to manage 20 people, in-office, for less compensation than I was collecting as a remote IC.. and with more of it locked up in deferred stock with the slowest vesting schedule I had ever seen.
- k__ 3y agoYes, it's crazy. One company pays you 50€/h and think you're expensive, another pays you 150€/h and thinks it's a bargain.
- tome 3y agoDo you mean you've been offered 3x your current salary and haven't taken it?
- steveBK123 3y agoNo. Mostly I've been offered as low as 1/3 my current salary. And I know of places I can go for a 50% bump if I want to give up my personal life (I don't) for a couple years . But I have helped peers in managing their careers / salary negotiations and found situations where people at my level were making 1/3 or 1/2 what I was. I have also done the same and found people junior to me by quite a bit who were making more or less the same. Compensation is path dependent and somewhat random.
- FireBeyond 3y agoI started talking to an org in NYC (in higher ed) that was hiring for a Director of Product Management. Then I heard that their salary band was 90-110K (and was fixed, but variable depending on your COL band). "That might get you an Associate PM..."
- okeuro49 3y ago> I sometimes get nervous during important phone calls, so discussing the offer over e-mail helps me to keep a clear head and communicate more clearly. I hope this is okay with you. :) I personally wouldn't send something like this. "I would prefer to discuss the offer over email". Is enough.
- hiAndrewQuinn 3y agoPersonally I've always found the most important thing to offer negotiation is BATNA. If your BATNA is going back to your current job, which is already decently paying and something you've made pretty easy by understanding it in depth, you're in a really good negotiating position from the start. If your BATNA is unemployment, and you're not already wealthy, not so much. Some people find it tough to bluff that kind of thing, in which case, getting any job at all is going to do more for your future negotiating power than quibbling over the number. (I would still recommend quibbling, but only because most people won't retract the offer just because you counter these days!)
- sevagh 3y agoPersonally, I find that SANBAK is a better model than BATNA, especially considering the BATMAN aspects of the MEASL.
- nfriedly 3y agoBATNA stands for Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement. In other words, it's your plan-b if you don't accept the current offer. It's a fairly common acronym when discussing negotiations, and is also spelled out in the article.
- yellowstuff 3y agoI believe that I read in Cracking the Coding Interview that big tech doesn't consider your current job as a comp, only pending offers. They won't increase an offer because you make more at your current job. I agree that candidates who are currently employed are generally seen in a much better light that candidates who are not currently employed.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoThen you don't accept their offer. What's the problem?
- notso411 3y ago[dead]
- soneca 3y ago> ” Now say you end up turning down their offer. They’ve spent over $24,000 just extending this single offer to you (to say nothing of opportunity costs), and now they’ll essentially have to start over from scratch.” They definitely won’t start over from scratch. Most companies where I worked held on to reject one or two finalists until the selected one accepted the offer. Precisely to be able to go back and offer them the job without any significant cost if the first one in the ranking rejects the offer. Since this final decisions are for minimal, very subjective reasons, I often saw a manager having second thoughts and kind of hoping the selected person to reject their offer so they can go with the other that, e.g. doesn’t have that experience in a stack, but seems nicer to work with. In that scenario (not uncommon in my experience), the hiring manager has incentives to not raise the salary a bit. But… otherwise is a very good, helpful article. Lots of good tips there.
- indymike 3y ago> They definitely won’t start over from scratch. Most companies where I worked held on to reject one or two finalists until the selected one accepted the offer. I've hired so many 2nd or 3rd choices when the first choice overnegotiated. In almost every case the person I passed over re-applied with us 3-6 months later. I'm not sure why, but I suspect that love of money does not always equate to a great software engineer.
- DonsDiscountGas 3y agoKnowing the market value of a person (including oneself) is a business skill, and distinct from the skill of software engineering. Being bad at this means either overestimating or underestimating the value. Most people are going to underestimate their own worth if they need a job, but it shouldn't be too shocking when people err in the other direction sometimes.
- snapcaster 3y agoHow do you know they aren't great software engineers if you were unable to hire them? I don't really understand what you're saying here
- codingdave 3y agoI really loved the first half or so of this post. But they went off the rails a bit when they said that the hiring company will start over if you turn them down... that simply is not true. They move on to their next choice, and often have the 2nd choice offer ready to go in 5 minutes once you turn them down. Heck, you may be their 2nd choice for all you know. Or 3rd. Or 4th. And the rest of the article then falls into role-playing contrived conversations, all of which can be skipped by being even more honest than they recommend. Simply say that you want an offer that is good enough to never make you second-guess your choice in joining them. That pretty much covers every conversation and scenario you can imagine, and you don't need to make up strategy for 3 potential layers of back and forth on who says what.
- renegade-otter 3y agoSeeing that this is from 2016, it does not really apply to the current market, which is BRUTAL. I have 20 years of experience, I just built my own SaaS service, and I have a pretty eclectic experience with languages and frameworks. Forget interviews - I don't even get phone screens. Recruiters will ghost you, which is new. Usually you would not be able to get rid of them. I think when an interview does come along, I will approach my salary demands gingerly.
- zerr 3y agoSuggestion to counter the ageism: remove the first ~8 years of experience from your CV.
- renegade-otter 3y agoThank you - I just did that!
- electroly 3y agoSurely they'll still get it from your college graduation year? Do you remove that as well?
- ParetoOptimal 3y agoI didn't graduate and frequently don't even list education on my resume. I don't get asked about it very often either.
- zerr 3y agoNo need to specify years.
- malfist 3y agoRecruiters ghosting is far from new
- renegade-otter 3y ago
- iwangulenko 3y agoTech recruiter here with 8 years of experience running a recruitment agency and I have seen 1000s of people negotiating salary (in Switzerland). I wouldn't never recommend doing what the author suggests, namely: "I’d prefer to discuss the details of the offer over e-mail." The phone is always better. Busy business people such as recruiters prefer it. Especially, because nowadays everyone hides behind text. Only the phone or an in person meeting gives you the chance to really hear what is possible compensation-wise and then really get what you want. Btw I wrote this guide years ago: https://iwangulenko.gumroad.com/l/5-salary-negtiation-hacks?layout=profile https://iwangulenko.gumroad.com/l/5-salary-negtiation-hacks?...
- crooked-v 3y ago> everyone hides behind text My experience with recruiters on the phone has mostly been those recruiters pulling in one or two extra random people from their company on the call to hide behind as they try to lowball me with fifteen minutes of rambling about market conditions.
- me_me_me 3y agoDont talk about salary with recruiter. Demand to discuss your salary with person that is hiring you. They are looking to hire people, they have the say who gets hired and they decide on the number. Talk to them not man in the middle that has no power. And person that will try everything to lowball you.
- djmips 3y agoIt's complicated by the fact that recruiters can make a percentage of your salary.
- kqr 3y agoThis is really good stuff. My negotiation skills really benefited from Voss's Never Split the Difference and this is exactly the kind of thing he'd suggest, I think. Except: > salary is almost always the hardest thing to give This is not really true. There are many things that are much harder to change, like composition of social groups, databases, upper management, sales-dominated development, etc. Changing money is just poking an accountant to edit a number in a spreadsheet somewhere. (That said, there may be even easier things to change, but money is far from the hardest.)
- cranberryturkey 3y agoi just give a 100k range. like 150-250k...but again it depends on how desparate i am.