5 ms·
US Added 1.2M EVs to the Grid Last Year and Electricity Use Went Down
- EricE 3y agoI notice this "report" doesn't consider the impact of banning natural gas appliances. Funny that.
- dragonwriter 3y agoIt considers the impacts of all the things that are real, since it is using real total numbers. It doesn't consider things that didn't happen, because its not fiction.
- hulitu 3y ago> US Added 1.2M EVs to the Grid Last Year and Electricity Use Went Down And there is no link between the two. I wonder what is the reason for EV push ? Nobody who has any idea about electricity would buy an EV.
- rgmerk 3y agoEfficiency is great! However, most models suggest that electricity consumption will significantly increase over the next couple of decades. Efficiency isn’t going to go close to covering the extra demand from EVs and electrifying heating.
- more_corn 3y agoThe big problem is balancing generation and demand. Demand is variable and it is very hard to spin generation up and down. Gas peaked plants have been a popular way to solve it. Electric cars are actually a brilliant way of flattening out the demand curve so that utilities have to do less ramping up and down. There’s a significant amount of good they can do simply by consuming power at night.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://electrek.co/2023/11/20/world-may-be-on-track-for-tripling-renewables/ https://electrek.co/2023/11/20/world-may-be-on-track-for-tri...
- Skinetio 3y agoThere is no 'extra demand' as electricy is energy. The overall 'energy' needed will be less because EVs do not waste 70% of energy to heat and a heat pump creates out of 1 energy unit 2-5 energy units. It is also much easier to efficiently do gas to power/oil to power in big plants and use the excess process energy for other things. Even if our whole society will consume more energy in the next x years, thanks to EVs and electrifying heating (with heatpump) this line/graph/curve will be less than if we would not have EV and e heating through heatpumps.
- ericpauley 3y agoGP said electricity consumption, not energy. While it's true that EVs use less energy (in a raw material/CO2 sense), they clearly use more grid-supplied electricity, and grid capacity needs to be built to meet that demand.
- hughesjj 3y agoThis is my prior belief as well, but devils advocate: how much electricity does the oil refinement process cost? I'd wager something like 8% or less relative to the total calorie content of said gasoline, but I have no idea
- rgmerk 3y agoI haven’t bothered to dig through the details of this report, but the total energy use in petroleum refining is about 4% of US total energy consumption. https://www.osti.gov/biblio/7261027 https://www.osti.gov/biblio/7261027 Even making conservative assumptions about how much of that is electricity, net demand for electricity is going to go up. This is also what the people who model this stuff for a living are predicting - somewhere around doubling to tripling of electricity demand by 2050 IIRC.
- mlyle 3y agoVery little of the energy used in petroleum refining is electricity. About half of it comes from the refinery's own byproducts; and a big remainder is from natural gas or coal used to produce heat. Indeed, I just peeked at your report and it says the same thing: "Nearly one-half the energy consumed by refineries is obtained from by-product refinery gas and coke, and about one-third is supplied by natural gas. "
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y ago> significantly increase over the next couple of decades Great, that gives us time to build out wind and solar
- p1mrx 3y agoAnd long-distance transmission, storage, nuclear, geothermal... because we still want temperate buildings and movable vehicles when the weather is uncooperative.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoEach EV has a battery that also acts as storage, so we have something at the start already.
- p1mrx 3y agoDo you really think people will voluntarily give away their miles during a shortage? Even after seeing the 2020 toilet paper scenario?
- rgmerk 3y agoNot unless they're properly compensated. However, it's already possible in some jurisdictions to play in the wholesale market with a home battery, and the same should apply for V2G. If they were offering, say, $2/kwh for the electricity in my car battery, unless I needed to take a long trip immediately afterwards I'd very happily take it. Wholesale peaks can go even higher than that on occasion!
- p1mrx 3y agoHow many vehicle owners are flexible enough to give up driving for several days, in exchange for a $120 payout? I think EVs can smooth out the daily bumps, but we need something to stabilize the grid over longer periods without burning fossil fuels. At least for the US, lots of long-distance transmission should help, because weather events generally don't affect the entire country.
- robomartin 3y agoThe US will need to at least double power generation and transport capacity to support 300 million EVs. Today our capacity is approximately 1200 gigawatts. We need to double that, or more. And then we have to upgrade the entire power transmission infrastructure to support the change. No, solar alone cannot do it. At best, solar can deliver about 40% reliability. Wind alone isn’t much better. The combination of solar and wind (equal parts) can deliver 70% to 80% reliability. A more optimal mix, in most of the world, is 25% solar with 75% wind, overbuild by a factor of 2 and with 3 to 12 hours of storage. This gets you to over 90% reliability in most of the world. Places like Canada and Rusia need more wind and less solar to achieve this performance. The problem is equipment service life. The replacement cycle, given today’s technology, is approximately three decades. Recycling options are far from practical or mature. This means that mass conversion to th technologies we have today will result on a massive replacement/reconstruction event every 30 years. Nobody can even begin to imagine the ecological consequences of such a scenario. In short: We need better technology.
- thebruce87m 3y ago> The US will need to at least double power generation and transport capacity to support 300 million EVs https://www.nationalgrid.com/stories/journey-to-net-zero/electric-vehicles-myths-misconceptions https://www.nationalgrid.com/stories/journey-to-net-zero/ele... > In the US, the grid is equally capable of handling more EVs on the roads – by the time 80% of the US owns an EV, this will only translate into a 10-15% increase in electricity consumption.
- robomartin 3y agoYeah, well, take the time to write a realistic simulation of 300 million EVs, from motorcycles to big rigs, driven and charged differently, across 1000 cities armed with population and other demographic data…and you quickly conclude some of these articles are delusional. It is also true that some nations will do a better job than others. And some have better circumstances and starting points. In the US? We have become so dysfunctional we would probably crumble if we added a few million EVs in most states. I was just in Zürich at a conference and had interesting conversations with experts and leaders in the energy sector; from hydro to geothermal and more. It is clear that some are taking the transition seriously, while others are not. The key differentiator is pushing ideology rather than reality. Only one of those stances gets us to the clean renewable energy future we all want.