3 ms·
Reaction: Who's this magical "we", who's supposed to teach parenting? Is it related to the magical "them" who run the world, from a child's PoV?
by bell-cot 3y ago
Reaction: Who's this magical "we", who's supposed to teach parenting? Is it related to the magical "them" who run the world, from a child's PoV?
- lapcat 3y ago> Who's this magical "we", who's supposed to teach parenting? Schools? The same "magical" we who teach math, for example. I haven't been in school for a long time, but back in the day we had home ec and shop classes. I even took a typing class in high school, which turned out to be quite useful. We can teach kids practical life skills.
- readthenotes1 3y ago"teach math so effectively".
- r0ckarong 3y agoSchools are already notoriously failing children and their individual needs. Parenting decided by committee that needs to be comparable to retain budgets. Oh my word, sounds like hell.
- lapcat 3y ago> Schools are already notoriously failing children and their individual needs. That's an overgeneralization. Schools vary widely in quality. Some schools have excellent results.
- u32480932048 3y agoSource?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ejb999 3y agoI doubt it - many schools can't even get 50% of the students proficient in math and english - I sure as heck don't want those schools teaching parenting skills as well.
- lapcat 3y agoDo you suggest that we abolish the teaching of math and english entirely, because some schools have issues (which are largely correlated with economically disadvantaged neighborhoods)? Should we shut down all the schools? I don't really understand how the nihilism in these replies makes any sense.
- simonsarris 3y ago> because some schools have issues (which are largely correlated with economically disadvantaged neighborhoods)? I don't you understand just how bad things are. Nationally 29% of 8th graders score "proficient or higher" in reading, 26% in math. The median American student is doing far worse than you think.
- lapcat 3y agoBogus, fearmongering stats, based on unrealistic ideals: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/a-test-everyone-will-fail_b_47607 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/a-test-everyone-will-fail_b_4... Tell me how the US students compare to all of the other industrialized nations. And again, I ask, what would you suggest? You seem to be suggesting we shouldn't be teaching parents skills in schools, because schools are allegedly no good, but isn't that also an (absurd) argument that we shouldn't be teaching anything in schools?
- ejb999 3y agoDo you suggest when you have a employee that is failing at the projects you have already given them, to load 2 or 3 more projects on top of that and somehow hope that will make things better?
- 3y ago
- graemep 3y agoProbably the professionals who look after children. However, it is the outsourcing of looking after children to professionals that causes the problem in the first place. Otherwise people would learn from their "village" as the author puts it from when they were kids themselves. You also learn to parent if you spend lots of time with your children. I worked from home from when my oldest was about an year old and it made a huge difference. I admit I cannot reconcile this with the increased amount of time the article says parents spend on caring for children, but I wonder exactly what those numbers are recording as they are hard to reconcile with the article it ultimately links to which comments on the shift from male breadwinner plus housewife households of the past.. The "steeper expectations" are the other big problem. You do a better job if you relax and enjoy it.
- monknomo 3y agoI figure the difference in time in caring for children has something to do with transporting children around. Now, take the source with a grain of salt, but in the Ramona series one of the characters has swimming lessons at the YMCA, and they get on the bus by themselves and go to the Y, swim and come home. Zero time spent on the parent's part. These days that'd probably be 60 minutes of childcare
- candiodari 3y agoYou mean Youth Services? https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2002/12/the-at-risk-youth-industry/302645/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2002/12/the-at-... Here's the problem with that. A few years ago the FBI announced that they had liberated 42 children from sex trafficking. What they neglected to mention: "the professionals who look after children" had lost ALL 42 children in 4 days. Which of course means that in about 4 days every last of those children decided anything was better than "the professionals who look after children", and had run away. The idiots among those children who ran away to their home were ... well, idiots (for a child, that's a crime, ironically called "depriving a child of parental rights", yes, running away FROM youth services TO parents is called that). In other words they got arrested, and put in juvenile detention. (this is a crime also somewhat famous because the police, on a regular basis, refuses orders from a judge to arrest) The real change is elsewhere: in 1970, having child allowance for 3 children was essentially a living wage. In 1980s, it was over 5. Today ... 15? We effectively had professionals who look after children (almost exclusively mothers), paid but not employed by the state. Today we seem to have lots of professionals who don't seem to do half of what those mothers do, but spend more on them. We exchanged child allowance for a huge expansion of government. It didn't work, to put it mildly. Of course, these days such a policy would tilt greatly towards immigrants, and it's probably a non-starter especially with Trump's numbers where they sadly are. And the joke is: look at the population pyramid. Even if we decided to reinstitute that policy and it actually got fertility back up to 3 ... it's too late. I don't know how we're going to keep population, even in the US, at the level it currently is. In Europe ... "will the last person please turn out the lights?". Ironically China is actually the country arguably worst off. Hell, in 20 years we'll need a version of youth services that actually breeds children or something. Of course, nobody is arguing that this needs to start happening, well, 20 years ago. "Too many people" you hear everywhere. But look at the numbers: there's WAY too few people.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoYou make a very good point, and I see the depth of it. Do we want some institution teaching us how to raise our kids, making sure that our kids learn that we have parents too, parents with credentials and authority, ensuring that we pass on to our kids the sense that when they're adults they will not be their own people, making sure that the idea of autonomy never crosses their mind? I guess some people do. Sounds like an interesting world, a different world, a world that sounds very brave and new.
- randomdata 3y ago> Do we want some institution teaching us how to raise our kids Whether or not we want it, institutions do teach parenting. I, for one, took the parenting course when I was in high school. I also took another parenting course offered by the local health authority just before I was about to have my first child. Perhaps what is really going on is that parents/would-be parents don't want to be taught?
- friend_and_foe 3y agoNo, I don't think so.
- randomdata 3y agoIs it, then, that because it isn't Stanford and Harvard teaching it that we discount the teaching? That is certainly a theme seen outside of the topic of parenting. High school graduates in particular, who have spent 12+ years of their life in the education system, are oft considered 'uneducated'. Not because they actually are uneducated, just that they haven't received an education from a particular school. I don't know where this general idea that we don't teach parenting comes from. Even ignoring said classes, once I had children the teachers will still lining up around the block to help me through the process. There is no subject I know of that has more teaching resources directed to it.
- friend_and_foe 3y ago