3 ms·
IIRC, Intel peaked at 98% of the Data Center CPU Market. AMD released an arguably superior CPU almost 7 years ago, but Intel still has 70%. You might be able
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
IIRC, Intel peaked at 98% of the Data Center CPU Market. AMD released an arguably superior CPU almost 7 years ago, but Intel still has 70%.
You might be able to argue that MI300 is competitive, but it is certainly hard to argue it's superior, so we're not yet at the GPU equivalent of the 2017 release of EPYC.
- incrudible 3y agoIntel never had a software moat. AMD has a terrible reputation for software that will be hard to shake.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoReputation is basically meaningless here. If they fix the software, people will figure that out in short order. They just have to actually do it.
- incrudible 3y agoThey are not fixing the software though, and they never do. You have this problem with every new generation, it launches broken and never gets fixed by the time it is obsolete. If you told me they fixed it, I would not even believe you.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt doesn't matter if you believe the first person who figures it out. Ten other people will try it and then there will be ten people saying they fixed it and a hundred people will try it. At some point you either believe everyone who has tried it or you lose business because your competitors have figured it out and you haven't.
- incrudible 3y agoTen people saying “it works now” is not going to lead to ten times that many risking their time and money on AMD. “Works for me” is a meme for a reason.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe number of people who believe you is the average probability that someone believes you times number of people you tell. In the bronze age this was really bad because you had to travel on horseback and contacting people in the same industry in other cities was quite slow and burdensome. Now we have the internet and communicating with someone on the other side of the world takes 200ms, so the speed at which new information spreads is fast. Meanwhile those people then know each other, so as soon as someone credible claims it works, several other credible believe them, try it themselves, and say the same thing. It doesn't really matter if you think it's 10 or 100 or 1.2, it's exponential spread at the speed of the internet.
- cesarb 3y ago> Reputation is basically meaningless here. If they fix the software, people will figure that out in short order. What matters is not just "the software is working", but also "the software will keep working" (for both new releases and new hardware). Reputation is meaningful for that.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThat's not usually a problem for software, especially this kind of software. New drivers and libraries for existing hardware are typically bug fixes because otherwise people wouldn't install them instead of using the existing code. The code for new hardware is generally based on the existing code, so if the existing code is good then it's likely to remain that way. Also, if the new hardware isn't any good then you just don't buy it. This is why anyone making long-term investments in hardware-related software is wise to write it in a vendor-agnostic way -- even if the software continues to be good you may have other reasons to want to switch hardware in the next generation.
- nabla9 3y agoI don't believe this is true competitive numeric software stack, like AI applications are. 1. Code must be hand optimized, refactored for each architecture while the API stays the same. 2. New APIs, algorithms must be backported and optimized for older hardware. That's insane amount of testing and performance tuning.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoSo there are two things you might want here. One is, can I just buy this thing and run the existing somebody else's code on it and it will work and be faster than the previous generation? If it isn't, you just don't buy the new hardware until that changes. The other is, you're going to buy a thousand of them or you're making software for the general public to use and you want to optimize it for each specific generation. But in that case you're redoing the work for each generation regardless and you don't have to be concerned about your current efforts carrying forward because you already know that they won't.
- latchkey 3y agoThey are working hard on it: https://www.phoronix.com/news/AMD-ROCm-6.0.2-MI300 https://www.phoronix.com/news/AMD-ROCm-6.0.2-MI300
- lumost 3y agoIntel also charged a competitive price for CPUs, recent NVidia chips are charged at a premium rate not seen in semiconductor for decades. I'd venture the margin on an H100 @65k is probably ~98%. If the market for datacenter GPUs rises to ~30 million deployed GPUs and ~10 Million new chips per year... that would be 192 billion in profit/year. I'd be skeptical that NVidia can maintain that margin, or price point. Had they owned ARM it may have been possible, as new entrants to the chip market could have been locked out.
- nabla9 3y ago> I'd venture the margin on an H100 @65k is probably ~98%. You are not far off. Nvidia spends $3,320 to manufacture H100 unit, says Raymond James Financial, Inc. analysis.
- nabla9 3y agoIndustry estimate is that Nvidia market share declines 75% in 2027-2028. If the AI hype is real, then Nvidia revenue is $300 billion in 5 years. Assuming P/E 25 would mean $7.5 trillion valuation. That sounds insane. If hype is 1/3 true, Nvidia grows 17% per year and is valued $2.5 trillion in five years. ps. Intel vs. AMD is not completely symmetric competition because AMD is fabless and Intel is not. While AMD gets better margins, Intel can produce volumes to match demand. AMD competes directly with Apple, Nvidia, ARM,.. for TSMC fab capacity (I know Intel also buys manufacturing from TSMC).
- bonton89 3y agoUntil Intel actually releases a discrete GPU on an Intel process instead of the same TSMC everyone else is using their fab advantage remains a theoretical one in this space. It is to bad they didn't have even a power sucking discrete GPU available built on one of their older processes during the previous GPU shortage since they'd at least have a strong install base right now by simple virtue of being able to put out a large supply.
- nabla9 3y agoIntel vs. AMD was abut CPU's not GPUS. Intel still has > 70% market share in server CPUs where it once had almost 99% market share.
- adam_arthur 3y agoP/E is a ratio on earnings, not sales. 25 * $300B (revenue) = $7.5T, yes. But that's using a P/S multiple, not P/E. Your math makes sense if you assume Nvidia will have 25x P/S... which historically is very high, and unlikely to be the "correct" multiple after all of that growth has already occurred. Unless you expect them to continue growing at same CAGR in perpetuity. Also, very unlikely they will maintain that kind of market share if they reach those valuations. A relatively simple software solution to improve integration with AMD/Intel/TPU offerings that is worth trillions is a bit of a no brainer. It wasn't a financial prerogative until recently, so yes, all the competitor software here sucks, today. Compute is fungible, despite what many say here. The cost differential between implementing good software support for AMD and paying Nvidia ~98% gross margin makes it kind of obvious. A bull case could still see NVDA at a few trillion 5-10 years out... very unlikely it would go much beyond that. I fail to see any remotely rationally made, objective, case for it. At least not one that warrants investing in Nvidia today, at the current valuation, versus other opportunities It can still be a multi-bagger in the short-term due to what looks like dotcom 2.0 enthusiasm.
- Agingcoder 3y agoIntel is very good at convincing you to stay with them, by essentially subsidizing your servers do you don’t get used to working with amd.