7 ms·
Crash tests show nation's guardrail system can't handle heavy electric vehicles
- orwin 3y agoWhat I found funny, is that most pieces against EV who are based on facts instead really target SUVs and other road monstrosities.
- djaychela 3y agoYes, but the issue is that people tend to have SUVs so have a blind spot to the criticism.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoFTA: “The system was not made to handle vehicles greater than 5,000 pounds.” The curb weight of the most popular vehicle in the USA, the Ford F-150, is 4,200 to 5,700lbs. How's it working now?
- baggachipz 3y agoExactly! The curb weight of my Tesla Model 3 is 4000 lbs max[1]. So how is this article anything but a hit piece on electric cars, as usual? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Model_3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Model_3
- bluGill 3y agoElectric cars tend to be much heavier than ICEs. While your model 3 is lighter than the limit it is a small car that is just barely under the limit. While much larger F150 starts out at only slightly heavier.
- acdha 3y agoEVs are heavier but by far the heaviest vehicles sold by volume are ICE SUVs and trucks. This should be a neutral measure based on the risky attribute since heavier vehicles are more dangerous to everyone regardless of the power source.
- bluGill 3y agoThere are already a few EV trucks and SUVs - and they are significantly heavier in general. Maybe a diesel truck (which mostly doesn't even have a EV option yet) would be as heavy - I can't find any specs to compare but maybe your google-fu is better. A Tesla model3 is not much lighter than a F150 (lowest weight of the F150), but is clearly much smaller.
- acdha 3y agoYes, nobody’s arguing that EVs are light. My point was simply that because EVs are still a small percentage of the market there are more heavy ICE vehicles on the road because we’re three decades into consumers moving away from small cars. That Tesla 3 buyer was more likely to have also been considering an Escalade than a Honda Civic.
- tromp 3y agoSince when is 4000 just barely under 5000?
- bryanlarsen 3y agoA Dodge Charger is heavier than a Model 3, and it's also a small car.
- RoryH 3y agoCause.. Big Oil FUD
- icameron 3y agoYeah! Also the study video is a head on collision with a wood-post steel guardrail, and that is not at all a common angle to hit those at. The F-150 or most any modern truck even a midsize with a couple passengers is over 5000. Who funded the University of Nebraska to specifically test EVs in an improbable perpendicular collision with a guardrail? Why’s it promoted as news?
- bluGill 3y agoGuardrails are typically installed such that a head on is almost impossible - they are designed for more of a glancing blow that redirects you back to the road. In that application I've seen them keep a fully loaded semi from crossing a medium into oncoming traffic. To get a head on at speed you would need to going across the road - maybe in the desert it is flat enough to get your car up to speed when going perpendicular to the road, but I'm not sure why you would try that. The other option is hit the start of the guard rail - while this can happen, the start of guardrails are generally angled so this is still a redirecting blow not head on. Where they cannot be the start is covered by rubber dumpers to slow you down before you hit it.
- beerandt 3y agoThis is true, but they are also designed with a maximum deflection for a worst case head-on crash. Typical one-rail guard rails should not deflect more than 2-4ft, while the cable style you see in interstate medians are designed for something like 5-12 ft. For those comparing this (EVs) to trucks, the difference is center of gravity. Even if a rail is only designed for a given weight, much effort went into containing trucks and other high center of gravity vehicles. The rail catches the vehicle and holds it down, redirecting excess energy into the ground. (Its why cable-styled rails have a gap below the top cable. Others have similar features.) But what they are not designed for is excess weight with a low center of gravity, where the excess energy just blows through the rail and can't easily be redirected in a more safe direction.
- helsinkiandrew 3y ago> Who funded the University of Nebraska to specifically test EVs in an improbable perpendicular collision with a guardrail? The US Army - who use the same barriers at road blocks. It looks like the research was really about heavier vehicles. The focus on EVs does ignore the general trend to larger vehicles as you say. https://engineering.unl.edu/news/240131/mwrsf_evs_safety/ https://engineering.unl.edu/news/240131/mwrsf_evs_safety/
- gruez 3y ago>The curb weight of the most popular vehicle in the USA, the Ford F-150 It's worth noting that even though the "most popular vehicle" is a pickup truck, pickup trucks aren't the most popular type of car on the road, making up for less than 20% of vehicles. https://www.statista.com/statistics/276506/change-in-us-car-demand-by-vehicle-type/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/276506/change-in-us-car-...
- afiori 3y agoIt is still a lot
- bydo 3y agoThat's a bit disingenuous when SUVs are another 40% of the market, making ~60% of vehicles sold still the size and weight of trucks, with or without beds.
- gruez 3y ago"SUVs" include crossovers, and they're by far more popular than truck based SUVs. The best selling SUVs (and crossovers) is the Toyota RAV4, Honda CR-V, and Nissan Rogue, all of which top out at around 3500 lb. https://www.kbb.com/best-cars/most-popular-suvs/ https://www.kbb.com/best-cars/most-popular-suvs/
- al_borland 3y agoEVs account for 1% of vehicles, and only 7.6% of new cars. If trucks haven’t been a major issue at 20% of the vehicle population, making a big deal out of EVs seems a bit overblown. https://www.edmunds.com/electric-car/articles/percentage-of-electric-cars-in-us.html https://www.edmunds.com/electric-car/articles/percentage-of-... Does this also mean they don’t care about semi trucks going through guardrails? Semi trucks account for 10% of highway miles traveled, which is also more than EVs. https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/freight/freight_analysis/nat_freight_stats/docs/11factsfigures/figure3_6.htm https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/freight/freight_analysis/nat_freigh...
- oliwarner 3y ago
- naasking 3y agoThey also can't handle trucks and tractor trailers. What else is new?
- lm28469 3y agoWhat's new is that virtually 100% of personal vehicles will go through guardrails instead of 5% of vehicles
- whynotmaybe 3y agoWhat's new is that there seems to be a really strong force trying to tell us that "EV are bad" from many different actors when in fact it's "our transportation models are bad". When Tesla seemed to be the only serious brand about EV, the panic was low in the ICE world but now that many brand have real EV and that many countries are setting up bans on ICE sales, they start to panic. Every business (fuel transport, around the corner mechanic, schools, parts shop and I guess a lot more others) in the industry have to shift and some want the propaganda to help them stay alive during the shift. If you're a teen wondering about his career, would you start a multi years studies about ICE now?
- alphabettsy 3y agoMaybe I’m seeing things with more nuance, but to me what I’m reading in many of these articles is that EV’s are still new, and there are challenges to solve, which is true. The weight of the average vehicle is increasing because of Trucks, SUVs and EVs. EVs are the new thing though.
- nytesky 3y agoWe are shopping for a car my daughter will eventually go to college with. My first instinct was to get a Honda Civic which was nicely in our budget and I loved driving when I was in college But then I realized how much heavier cars have gotten, and how much of a disadvantage they are in a collision so we will be getting a heavier car. Probably a CRV though maybe we can try and make electric car work in our budget but we will see. The irony is that we would have gotten a more efficient car, except for the weight disadvantage and safety concerns because we are now pitted against electric cars that weigh so much.
- hattar 3y agoRight thought, but I suspect wrong reason. You’ve been competing with “light” trucks on the roads for a couple decades that weigh the same or more than your average Tesla. Factor in that they have worse driver visibility, higher bumper height, and make up about 20% of the vehicles on the road and you have a much more concerning threat.
- kylebenzle 3y agoHave you seen the spiked lug nuts truckers are using on their wheels now? I love that Americans are going full Mad Max on their vehicles choices and it won't be long until we all have these projecting spikes, front end people crushers and heavy as possible vehicles. This winter I started driving around with a 1/4 ton of gravel in the back of my F150 just to help counter other larger trucks. Reduces handling a little but if I do get in a crash the other f150 or smaller vehicle will be toast :)
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> My first instinct was to get a Honda Civic which was nicely in our budget and I loved driving when I was in college...But then I realized how much heavier cars have gotten, I can't judge. It's mostly on me that my son's first car was a 1989 Cadillac Brougham. His daily driver now is a 1963 Dart but he's looking for another Brougham.
- nytesky 3y agoHaha, my mom got me a 1983 Cadillac brougham for my first car. The land yacht did 0-60 in TWELVE SECONDS. Obv I never tried passing.
- Kuldeep045_ 3y ago[dead]
- goda90 3y agoI hope society ends up settling on some fluid based sustainable fuel in the end. Maybe it's fuel cells, flow batteries, or even a combustible. The advantages of weight and refueling speed are hard to beat.
- dontlaugh 3y agoTrains, trams, microcars & bikes replacing most road vehicles and biofuels for the remaining ones would be much better overall.
- osigurdson 3y agoTrains are fine but cannot replace cars.
- dontlaugh 3y agoNot completely, just the vast majority. Especially for freight.
- osigurdson 3y agoIt does seem far from where we are now. However, if someone wants to build trains (without me paying for it in taxes), I will happily buy a ticket if it is convenient and cost effective for me to use.
- bluGill 3y agoFor 30% of the population they could completely replace cars. For another 50% they could let you go from being a 2-3 car family to a 1 car family (more likely a truck - either to haul tools, or to tow the boat) Of course to replace cars much a comprehensive network that would be expensive to build in the short run. (in the long run cheaper than the road network which would need many less lanes)
- scythe 3y ago>biofuels Absolutely not. The land use impacts are enormous.
- russfink 3y agoThis added weight is related to the tire eating article from a few days ago…? Also, added weight times millions of vehicles wears down roads and infrastructure more quickly, increases damage costs in simple fender benders… how much is this actually costing us?
- baggachipz 3y agoIt's barely a blip on the radar compared to the large trucking industry, whose tractor-trailers cause about 2500 times the wear and tear on road compared to a car[1]. [1] https://www.insidescience.org/news/how-much-damage-do-heavy-trucks-do-our-roads https://www.insidescience.org/news/how-much-damage-do-heavy-...
- bluGill 3y agofor main roads. However for back roads and residential streets the road is designed assuming only a few semis per year (mostly moving trucks which are already lighter than average) and so the heavy car every day is a much larger share of the wear.
- Halfwhit 3y agoWell in the UK these new EVs are road-tax exempt, so the owners aren't even contributing towards maintaining the infrastructure...
- Anonbrit 3y agoRoad tax is paid into the general funds, same as any other taxation, and stopped being related to the maintenance of roads several generations ago. EV drivers do pay less tax in general (including significant amounts of fuel duty not needing to be paid) but then they do far less harm to the people and environment around them too.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoI'm certainly adverse to the high volume of visibility killing, oversized vehicles - but the video card shows a truck smashing thru a jersey wall. I used to open closed roads by pushing jersey wall sections with my 1969 Delta 98. JWs already seemed persuadable when confronted with a weighty personal vehicle (granted, those JWs weren't joined). I'd like to know the failure rate of super-weight vehicles against corrugated rail or cable+post guardrail system.
- tehwebguy 3y agoI keep seeing YouTube shorts of guys going up to highway guardrails, checking them out and discovering that they were improperly installed like no nuts or that the bolts aren’t torqued down enough. No idea why this showed up in my feed or if it’s just some weird funnel for someone’s side hustle or what.
- blamazon 3y agoThere's someone I follow on YouTube[0] who criticizes the install quality of roadside barriers, with some positive results[1], after his daughter died in a collision with an incorrectly installed guardrail. [0]: https://youtube.com/@TheGuardrailGuy https://youtube.com/@TheGuardrailGuy [1]: https://foxchattanooga.com/amp/news/local/after-wrongful-death-lawsuits-gdot-to-begin-removing-controversial-guardrails-in-georgia-x-lite https://foxchattanooga.com/amp/news/local/after-wrongful-dea...
- M2Ys4U 3y ago(USA)
- oatmeal1 3y agoElectric vehicles have an irrational amount of range. Is renting a car for the <1% of the time you need to drive >100 miles that hard?
- kylebenzle 3y agoWho would want to spend $100k on a car then spend another $500-$1000 to rent a car for long distances? At that point an electric car is pure luxury.
- oatmeal1 3y agoBatteries are a major part of the cost of an electric car. If you spent $100k on an electric car that had a 100 mile range, it must be a Maybach. It would be much more realistic in this scenario for the electric car to be $30k, in which case you can earn interest on the $20k not spent, and have plenty of money to rent a car when you need it.
- acdha 3y agoYour prices are all off by a factor of 3-4 or more. Most Americans would be fine with a sub-$30k EV for daily life and an occasional rental the handful of times they need to pick up large cargo or travel hundreds of miles in a single day with only brief stops. Among other things, that would mean you don’t have to pay more for every other trip you make carrying extra weight for features that you don’t need most of the time. People buy SUVs thinking they’ll go skiing twice a year but they’re paying 2-3 times as much for almost all of their mileage which doesn’t need that ground clearance or 4WD in addition to the 30-50% higher sticker price.
- kcplate 3y agoNot sure where you live, but at least 50% of the time I am driving my car I am probably putting over 100 miles on it per trip. My weekly trip for groceries might be the only one where I am driving a shorter range.
- bluGill 3y agoHave you ever tried to rent a car for long trips? To rent a minivan is $100/day and my vacation is going to cover several days. My mom lives 300 miles away - close enough to make this trip over a weekend every month. The savings in rental costs more than half the payment on a new minivan, and with your plan I'd still need to pay for the EV I use most days. Rental cars also have damage clauses. When I own it I don't worry about what my kids are doing to the car - as anyone with kids knows they will do something.
- bilsbie 3y agoI’d think the low center of gravity would be a great match with guardrails putting more force near the base where it’s strongest.
- bensecure 3y ago> Guardrails are intended to keep cars from careening off the road at critical areas, such as over bridges and waterways, near the edges of cliffs and ravines and over rocky terrain, where injury and death in an off-the-road crash are much more likely. ... “Guardrails are kind of a safety feature of last resort,” Brooks said. From what I've observed this is wrong. Guardrails seem to be used semi haphazardly along roads in places where it wouldn't be the end of the world to go into the ditch. On a bridge, or a median, or elsewhere where going outside the road boundary could be particularly dangerous, they use much better reinforced walls.