9 ms·
There's More Proof That Return to Office Is Pointless
- Robotbeat 3y agoI work in a federal government position, and remote work is super problematic for getting stuff done. My background is I have a short commute, my home is small (with 3 kids with my wife who stays home with them), and my office space is great (I have my own personal office but also freedom to work anywhere on the campus via laptop). My work is about half physical and half computer normally, but mostly has been computer lately. The workforce has a median age past 50. They (especially senior staff) do not use the collaboration tools. When I write a document for review, some of the reviewers will literally print it off to make markup on it, then email the scanned document. They’re not responsive to the online chat, they are available only occasionally when in the office. People are usually working multiple projects at a time, critical review work is not given an explicit time budget (supposed to be “white space”) and often whether they decide to get to your issue depends on how they’re feeling at the moment. This increases the latency of the review/fix cycle to one or two days at least. Recently, I had a rush job on a paper, & my strategy to finish it quickly was to camp outside the reviewer’s office and catch them as they were coming in or out. Issues that were taking about 2 days to fix before got addressed in a short 5 minute conversation. On another couple projects involving physical work, we had some team members who insisted on not coming in to run their code on physical equipment, and they insisted that the other people on-site do it, in spite of those people having other work to do. The on-site people were therefore forced to carry a much greater workload than those who were remote as they had to be the hands and eyes of those remote. Not only that, but because of this disconnect, the level of abstraction the remote people were working on was much higher than the physical hardware required… they were building mathematical models and hadn’t ever tried seeing how the code worked on physical avionics; they had no knowledge of the avionics software compiling tool chain as they never used it & expected that work to be handled by other researchers (who had their own time constraints). So the project basically didn’t succeed because of this. At some point, the physical world has to come into play. Management is also a harder problem. I know this is cast as a power struggle, but you have to actually solve the management problem. If remote work doesn’t affect isolated worker productivity but does make management less effective, that clearly makes the organization as a whole less effective. I am a big fan of remote work and with proper collaboration tools, this can be just as effective. But lack of real-time communication makes this fail. Lack of physical context for software implementation can make this fail. Lack of camaraderie between workers who never see each other can make this fail. If the alternative is 90 minute commutes, it seems clear remote is probably better most of the time, but inability to actually talk to people in person ever is a potentially huge barrier in some instances. I’m not a manager. I have no commercial real estate interests. I have a compact home with no home office and three children, two of which spend most of the day at home. Focused work is nearly impossible during the day, so most of my remote work is done at night. I cherish the ability to go into the office for focused work and for low-latency communication with fellow workers and management as well as ability to do physical technological and experimental work where the software meets the hardware. The quality of much of the discussion of this is terrible on HN.
- gipp 3y agoI don't have a particularly strong stance on RTO, but I can't help but call it how much less rigorous HN is when talking about this issue than, say, anything that doesn't affect them. The putative ways in which poorly organized remote/hybrid work are supposed to affect a company -- culture, creativity, and the other things that come out of personal interaction and long-term proximity -- are things that operate on a multi-year timescale. No half-ass study on a few short term productivity metrics, looking at an RTO process that barely spans one year, are going to surface that. OTOH it's likely to be obvious to people actually in the environment long before it has a measurable impact on any kind of balance sheet
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aurareturn 3y ago>but I can't help but call it how much less rigorous HN is when talking about this issue than, say, anything that doesn't affect them. I think it's because it affects people here disproportionately. Let's be honest. I'm guessing a lot of people here are software developers or work in a technical role in general. People in these roles tend to be introverts. Introverts are unlikely to prefer the office. On top of that, people here are only thinking about their own role - but not all of the company. For example, it could be that software development can be done with 100% remote, but what about the company's marketing, finance, HR, operations departments? What if those departments function better in person? Will the company let all the software developers and product managers work remotely and then demand the other departments to come into the office? How does it look if the company only lets their software developers work remotely but everyone else must come in, including retail/factory workers if there are any? I think people here don't consider everything when it comes to RTO. So we keep hearing conspiracy theories here about how executives/companies own real estate so they want employees back. I've always said this. If you are a software developer in the US, you should definitely advocate against remote work. Sooner or later, the company is going to realize they can hire the same developer for 15% of the salary that the company is paying you.
- steveBK123 3y ago
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y ago[flagged]
- steveBK123 3y agoFTA: The study found that managers use RTO mandates “to reassert control over employees and blame employees as a scapegoat,” and concluded that “we do not find significant changes in firm performance in terms of profitability and stock market valuation after the RTO mandates.” Anecdotally this has been pretty clear. Even the language management coaches RTO in is more stick than carrot. More and more it's announced alongside layoffs, in terms of "you better do it, because", rather than "we want the collaborative environment fostered by RTO" kind of phrasing. Cool stuff, can't wait for the employment market to turn again and the ego trip ends. Reminds me again of Josh Wolfe posting twitter chants of "suits! suits! suits!" as the RTO wave started 12-18 months ago. Clearly if thats the mindset, its a punishment & capital re-asserting power over labor.
- scruple 3y ago> More and more it's announced alongside layoffs, in terms of "you better do it, because", rather than "we want the collaborative environment fostered by RTO" kind of phrasing. In their defense, it's hard to take the latter seriously when the entire office is still on Zoom calls for every single meeting.
- steveBK123 3y agoIt's also hard to take it seriously knowing how many high level execs make sure there are satellite offices near each of their homes so that they have the flexibility they are revoking from everyone else :-) I remember being on an all-hands call announcing 4 day RTO where the big boss was literally in a rural satellite office either in his own home or with like 5 desks for whatever personnel he stationed there for himself. The office is not even on the company intranet site. Similarly to my prior company picking an HQ2 based on where the CEO wanted to move due to his preferences & spouses job.
- ryandrake 3y agoThis kind of shitty behavior isn't new, though. I worked in a medium sized firm where the CEO moved the entire office miles away, lengthening everyone's commute (and having them commute across a busy bridge), to a place that was super close to his beach house.
- juujian 3y agoI think its just a strategy to cut head counts. For upper management, it has all the "advantages" of mass layoffs in terms of improving profitability on paper with less downsides...
- throwaway22032 3y ago[dead]
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoThe data are heterogenous. I broadly see three categories: jobs where RTO is a clear win, jobs where the RTO penalty is more and the WFH penalty less than the offshoring penalty and jobs where both are more. The first will RTO. The second will permit WFH with good compensation. The last will be offshored. We’re presently figuring out the divides, with a strong bias on the coasts towards domestic layoffs and offshoring experimentation in software development. The missing category, jobs where WFH is a clear win, continues to elude. From what I’ve seen, it’s dominated by niche groups of ultra-elite workers providing unique services within otherwise mixed work environments. (Disclaimer: I do this.)
- Overtonwindow 3y agoit’s dominated by niche groups of ultra-elite workers providing unique services within otherwise mixed work environments. Which applies to most people on HN.
- formerly_proven 3y ago*almost no one
- sombrero_john 3y agolol
- dangerwill 3y agoCompanies have been relentlessly thinking about how to automate and offshore positions, regardless of the broader economic trends and definitely regardless of your physical work location, for decades now. It isn't "RTO and avoid getting laid off", it's "RTO and get laid off anyway".
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Companies have been relentlessly thinking about how to automate and offshore positions, regardless of the broader economic trends Sure? The point is WFH provides a working template that expands where it works, and where it’s worth trying.
- Moldoteck 3y agooh there is a point - easier layoffs
- Overtonwindow 3y agoIF WFH THEN LAYOFF ELSE REWARD
- Moldoteck 3y ago*reward= you get a free pizza friday once a month
- frabjoused 3y agoI just went through a rough case this week where one of my employees was overemployed FT by three companies and pushing commits to these throughout the workday. When confronted he denied it despite overwhelming evidence, gaslighted me by painting me as untrusting and used that as an excuse to quit. This new problem is only possible with remote work.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoI can tell you dozens of stories about people that were collecting a paycheck and were supposed to be in the office doing work, but were in fact at the nearby comic shop or movie theatre. Do you lock the doors to the office once everyone has arrived?
- frabjoused 3y agoDid they spend 10 hours a week in the office, another 20 across the street working at Starbucks and another 10 hours working at the local movie theatre, all from 9 to 5, and draw full time paychecks from all three?
- fsniper 3y agoIf that employee was a contractor or freelancer, would you consider overemployment a problem? If the employee is underperforming it's totally unrelated consideration. If not, this is a discussion of why you are employing one. To do a job for you or to sit in 8 hours for you? You need to start thinking on why you are paying. If someone can fill in 10 jobs' requirements at the same time, none of the employers should be concerned. Or only be concerned why they need only 1/10th of that employee?
- frabjoused 3y agoIt only came up because the person seemed mentally unavailable, and would only do what was asked of them. Yes, I’m paying a full salary for initiative and responsibility.
- HNDen21 3y agoIBM to Managers: Move Near an Office or Leave Company https://finance.yahoo.com/news/ibm-managers-move-near-office-184216743.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/ibm-managers-move-near-office...
- zaphar 3y agoIt really doesn't matter. Companies want to hire me. As a result they have to hire me as remote. Once they do so my productivity is sufficient that they want to keep me around. I earned the right to be remote a long time ago. Before I earned the right I worked in offices when I had to. Whether other people earn that right or not doesn't really affect me. This isn't I think a bad state of affairs. If remote is more productive then companies will eventually switch over. If remote isn't more productive then they won't. If it's a wash then the people who earn the right to be remote will do so. The rest will go into the office. Life is full of earned rights like this. No sense in getting worked up about it. If you want to be remote then earn the right to be so.
- Hasu 3y ago> If remote is more productive then companies will eventually switch over. If remote isn't more productive then they won't. If it's a wash then the people who earn the right to be remote will do so. The rest will go into the office. Life is full of earned rights like this. No sense in getting worked up about it. If you want to be remote then earn the right to be so. I think your faith in companies acting rationally is about ten orders of magnitude higher than my own.
- stcroixx 3y agoI'm skeptical productivity would play a significant in the decision in the majority of the F500's and others who follow their lead. It's logical, of course, but if productivity was a focus, there are many other possibilities that could be explored/implemented, which rarely are. MBA run companies are full of waste and inefficiency. I think it does matter to you and many others in terms of your possible opportunities. If less companies have a policy that allows remote work, the companies that are even able to hire you are less and your opportunities are more limited than they otherwise would be. Fishing in a larger pond is in your best interest. I worked remote for years before covid, but I believe the way I earned that opportunity was by working in the office with those same people for a few years to earn their trust. Asking new potential employers who don't know me to trust me like that I think would result in fewer opportunities.
- addicted 3y agoWhat a bad faith article. Most of the links don’t support the claims made. > Your manager may suggest that returning to the office is imperative for the company’s success, workplace culture, and overall productivity. However, there’s a growing body of evidence suggesting that’s bullshit. The link under “growing body of evidence” is to a study of a 4 day work week and has nothing to do with WFH or RTO. > studies that have shown remote work is very productive The link under “remote work is very productive” says: “A study comparing productivity before, during and after an extended stint of remote work suggests information worker productivity isn't negatively impacted by remote working.” which is very different from what is implied in the text. > and RTO mandates could be causing a productivity slump This is referring to a drop in labor productivity figures post pandemic which shot up during the pandemic. It’s well known that the spike at the beginning of the pandemic and the subsequent reversion is a statistical artifact resulting from the fact that the labor force working in person jobs such as restaurant and retail workers which are lower paying reduced drastically pushing up the average productivity by reducing the number of people in the below average jobs. Once retail and restaurant workers started working again the average dropped again. The most likely reality is that we simply don’t know what works well and what doesn’t. It will take time to sort it out. But misleading screeds like this from someone whose clearly invested on one side do not help at all.
- bnegreve 3y agoThe title is rather ambiguous: evidence that RTO mandates do not increase firm performance is not evidence that returning to office is useless. > we do not find significant changes in firm performance in terms of profitability and stock market valuation after the RTO mandates.
- Finnucane 3y agoMy office is on a hybrid schedule and so far it's worked out pretty well. I think for a lot of people it's not a question of whether wfh or the office is 'better', but being able to have some flexibility to suit their own circumstances.
- ivolimmen 3y agoI always worked from home, one day a week, before COVID. I'm Dutch and a consultant for hire and never had any issues with companies not allowing it. After COVID most of the IT crowd I know wants to work from home. I am currently working for a client on the other side of the Netherlands. It's a 90 minute drive to the office. I took this contract because we only go to the office once per 2 weeks (on the day the Sprint ends). I know a lot of you think that 90 minutes is not a long drive BUT that is only on IDEAL times. It's straight though Amsterdam and on the busiest highways; it's more often a 2 hour drive than 90 minutes. Also: My wife was actually from Rotterdam so each office visit is combined with a trip to my in-laws. I stay for one night so my travel is purely outside of the daily commute hours. I only pick companies where I am allowed to work from home.
- orev 3y ago> I know a lot of you think that 90 minutes is not a long drive Nobody thinks that 90 minutes “is not a long drive”.
- teunispeters 3y agoSounds like travelling from Surrey to downtown Vancouver (BC,Canada). 45 minutes ideal, 2 hours or so if traffic. I really don't miss that daily commute, and living further out was worse. (all locations technically within the metropolitan Vancouver city). Yeah, scale is weird between countries and cities.
- irrational 3y agoDoesn't affect productivity? How could it not affect productivity? Between getting ready, driving in, finding parking, walking to the building, wandering around looking for an open place to sit, then reversing at the end of the day - I waste at least 2 hours that I could have been working. I'm not taking those 2 hours out of my non-work life. Those 2 hours are coming out of the time I devote to work. Since I've returned to office back in September, I've talked to other human beings in person precisely 3 times for a total of 45 minutes all together. And only one of those conversations was actually related to my job. And, that one in person meeting later caused a problem because the meeting was not recorded so we could not refer back to it when we needed to (all of our zoom meetings are auto recorded and stored in a place we can easily refer back to them). I know that there are some jobs where people do need to collaborate in person, but for those of us who do not need to do so, return to office is so stupid.
- eggy 3y agoI would wager a lot of unnecessary Zoom meetings with far too many people on the call to be actually productive filled a lot of WFH hours along with refrigerator, TV, web surfing, and family breaks equals the deficit of commuting and walking to your desk. I use my commute to prepare for the day, not just drive or take a train, and I try and avoid Zoom while driving especially if I'm on my motorcycle! Make a F2F office meeting a Zoom meeting in person and have it record it the way you like it.
- irrational 3y agoReally, you are using your commute time to prepare for work? Listen to an audiobook or do something else for yourself during that time. Don’t give that time to a company that cares nothing about you.
- xyzzy4747 3y agoImagine if the White House, Congress, the Pentagon, etc. turned their lights off and went fully remote. Would it be good or bad for the country?
- eggy 3y agoIt's a class thing too. I grew up poor, but had the good fortune of getting a computer back in 1978. I have had a mix of manual labor and office jobs over the years, and obviously you can't WFH if your job is diving and fixing underwater hydraulics and electrical systems or machining parts for a space mission. I've done both. I think getting out of the house to a place of mutual effort will always be required and has societal benefits and individual benefits to those who would typically shy away from face-to-face interactions. I guess if your work product is moving electrons and information you can work where you want. I worked in the middle of nowhere a few times for years. I guess that's why I need to have physical work along with my mental work. Being on a phone or laptop in a jungle or beach paradise takes away from my presence there. At least that's my opinion.
- randomdata 3y ago> obviously you can't WFH if your job is [...] machining parts for a space mission. Machining as a general practice is quite well suited to working from home. Living in an agricultural community, which as an industry demands a fair amount of machining services, I have several neighbours who make their living as machinists working from home.
- Robotbeat 3y agoBut not for a space mission which requires careful tracking, metrology, and controls. And is by default restricted by ITAR/EAR and possibly classified.
- randomdata 3y agoBut as a general practice...
- eggy 3y agoI was born and raised in Brooklyn, so that wasn't my situation. I was a welder for a company in NYC making animated displays in the mid-90s. I took the subway. I would read, think about work, observe people, etc. No phones and internet then, so sometimes talking to fellow passengers.
- Overtonwindow 3y agoI am now fully returned to the office, and while I miss not having to put on clothes, it’s much better for my career. A lot of my job is meeting and talking to people, and making those connections for later. I can’t do that at home. Isolated jobs could be work from home, but if your job interfaces with people, it really should be in person as much as possible .
- jklinger410 3y agoThere can never be "proof" that "return to office" is "pointless." There are, of course, a myriad of variables that come into play for whether or not working physically near someone is more efficient than not. Hyperbole is a bad thing in almost every case, in my opinion. And it is primarily used in the modern era to incite rage and misunderstanding between parties. I don't think articles like this should be on HN.
- varelse 3y ago[dead]
- yodon 3y ago>There can never be "proof" that "return to office" is "pointless." Setting aside a possible uninteresting conversation about the semantics of the word proof and discussions of the nature of falsifiable hypotheses that were last interesting when we were in junior high, zero average change in stock price or negative average change in stock price would be a strong signal that return to office is pointless. If the statistical significance of the result were strong enough, I would absolutely consider such a result "proof" that "return to office" is "pointless." This research may or may not clear that bar (it's hard to tell from the linked summary).
- jnmandal 3y agoThis should not be surprising to anyone. Anecdotally, what I've seen is RTO is often being used as a way to save money on doing layoffs. Announcing an aggressive RTO causes immediate attrition and doesn't require severance packages. If you look closely, you'll see that play being used all over the place in companies that otherwise need to cut costs.
- softwaredoug 3y agoI would like to see a study done of the relative costs of going to an office for management / execs vs everyone else. My hypothesis is that for many employees, the commute distances are long, relocation requirements onerous, not to mention costs like childcare, etc that pile up. I suspect thought that the management / exec class doesn't feel these pressures. They can afford to live downtown with minimal commute and may already be paying for many of the services that allow them greater mobility
- muttled 3y agoMy CIO was a big RTO proponent. He also lived a few miles away in a ritzy part of town, had full-time child-care, a parking spot at the building, a garage at home. All this in a dense city. Then he'd walk into an office that had a view, a door that closed, independent temperature controls, furniture, workspace, was quiet, and private. Contrast that to the guy who drove 1.5 hrs each way due to construction on the main highway expected to last years, pays $30-40 a day in parking, $5-15 in gas and tolls, drops his kid off at daycare that costs $500 a month and charges extra every time he's gotta stay over. It costs that guy over a thousand bucks to work in an office every month. To do the same job he was doing remote. At an Ikea desk shoved in a row of Ikea desks.
- sirmike_ 3y agoWell of course it is a power play or grab. But you what? It is the same thing when I look for a sidegig or new day job and tell recruiters representing companies -- Remote only. Thanks, but no thanks for hybrid.
- dventimihasura 3y agoWhat...are the negative aspects of WFH?
- Agingcoder 3y agoHarder communication with coworkers, less trust, more conflicts, some people find it hard to work at home and need to be in the office ( ie they do nothing at home ), harder onboarding for new joiners, people misunderstanding the rules ( no you can’t work from vacation site x in country y for tax/insurance reasons ), not feeling part of something and therefore losing interest, etc Edit: wfh also means an office ( if you have kids at home it’s the only viable option ) now so a bigger house /flat but I won’t get the corresponding pay rise. I’ve seen some or all of the above apply to various people. It doesn’t apply to everyone obviously, some people are perfectly happy with wfh. I personally need a bit of both !
- dventimihasura 3y ago>Harder communication with coworkers, less trust, more conflicts, some people find it hard to work at home and need to be in the office ( ie they do nothing at home ), harder onboarding for new joiners, people misunderstanding the rules ( no you can’t work from vacation site x in country y for tax/insurance reasons ), not feeling part of something and therefore losing interest, etc I grant that some people might experience those things, but I reject that we should expect all, most, or even many people to experience these things. I know it can't possibly be all, because I personally experience none of them. Moreover, it's easy to see counterarguments or mitigation strategies for every one of these. Remote comes with benefits. Naturally, it also comes with costs. The same is true for onsite and hybrid as well, of course. For me, the questions are: - What is the cost benefit comparison for these models? - Can the costs be mitigated? In my view, the cost benefit ratio is far more advantageous for remote and the costs can all be mitigated.
- lbeltrame 3y agoI never had anything against WFH and actually did it for three years straight between 2008 and 2011. I actually think that anyone has different preference wrt in the office versus WFH. I commute every day and I take 1h and 15 min one way due to bad public transportation. I could, technically, do everything I do via WFH. But I'm not doing it, and I get pretty annoyed when people tell me "why don't you do it?" Well, it's my personal experience and in no way is meant to act as a judgment towards others. Simply put, WFH reminds me of when I was locked inside my house for 70 days. I was and still am an introvert but I found the experience down right horrible. On top of that I had a very stressful work period with often daily tense situations. And there was no real way to "escape" (I did, mentally, but I was close to a breakdown). Ever since I was able to RTO I never did a single day WFH and I'm making sure that in no way work can get inside my house. If I ever had to remote work in the future I'm thinking of renting some co-working space. Well, long winding post to say that yes, some tightening of WFH rules may be not justified, but IMO it's one person's experience and attitude that makes WFH worthwhile or not.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dzink 3y agoWall street has tightened its expectations on money invested in a higher interest rate environment and the price/earnings ratio is one of the main KPIs that’s easy to game with a layoff. If you’re uncertain about how well your company’s performance will do, you do a round of layoffs and that boosts your chances. Furthermore in companies that pay well culture is often more cut-throat and management will blame remote work as first layer. People who have a family and live with a commute may struggle with that, but those with a spouse will make do and go back to the office. The spouses that earn less get impacted, especially if the variability of commute can’t support both parents commuting. The funny thing is that in consumer companies where you need to be attuned to consumer demand the jobs that keep a finger on that are perfect for remote work but less paid. So if you are a consumer tech company and you mandate return to office you are likely shrinking.
- thelastgallon 3y agoThe pro-RTO don't talk about why is outsourcing perfectly ok but not WFH? All large companies have people outside of US, WITCH (Wipro, Infy, TCS, CTS, HCL) in India and some have people in Europe, South America, etc. Second, even in large campuses (HQ of the company), many buildings, most people can't find a conference room to meet (they are almost always booked), and lot of them just webex from their desk because meetings are back to back, you won't have the 5 minutes it takes to walk to the conference room in the next building. Rarely do people work with just a few people around them. People work with others in different buildings, locations, countries, timezones. When this is ok, WFH is perfectly ok.
- asoneth 3y ago> The pro-RTO don't talk about why is outsourcing perfectly ok but not WFH? It isn't that companies want RTO at all costs -- if they can lower labor costs by at least 30% then executives seem to get over their antipathy for remote work quickly. Whereas in my experience, most of the employees who wanted to work remotely expected comparable salaries and employment benefits to what they earned when they were in the office. Ultimately most of them ended up complying with the RTO mandate without even demanding a raise.
- daniel_sim 3y agoI’ll believe RTO is about collaboration when people starting giving up private offices to make more collaborative spaces.
- jairuhme 3y agoI'll give a slightly different take on remote work and it has nothing to do with the productivity argument. I go into the office two days a week because I enjoy it. I get to connect with coworkers much better than the days I am at home. I'm able to chat about sports/shows we watch, as well as what is going on in their life outside of work. This is a benefit which has really no tangible benefit to the company, aside from me having more of a connection to my employment. But there is a benefit to this for me. I like the hybrid approach so that I get my days to be social, but then have days to recharge on my own. On the development side, I also think there are benefits to being in the office. I sit right by my bosses, bosses, boss. He's very busy, but we still have small talk. When it comes time to promotion, there is very real benefit to having that relationship, whether you like it or not. Now I am more goal oriented where I see promotions as a sign of success for myself. Not the case for everyone, and there is nothing wrong with that. Now the thing I hate about the conversations of working in the hybrid/remote world is the emphasis on making remote workers feel included. I have nothing against people who choose to work fully remote, but a benefit to being in the office is that its easier to connect with people. That's why I do it. Just like there are benefits to working from home, this is one of the benefits of working in office. I feel like this often gets overlooked and people are surprised that they feel disconnected when they aren't in the office. I have become good friends with my coworkers who also go into the office, and barely talk to the who don't.
- throwaway19473 3y agoI am a 23 year old Covid-era graduate and I started a job at a big organisation last year. It is very noticeable how I, and all my graduate peers, are much more driven to come into the office than our older colleagues. I think it’s a combination of day to day social interaction that you just don’t get with WFH, and a genuine want to learn and develop professionally. It’s honestly a bit disheartening seeing all of our older peers working from home all the time whilst simultaneously pushing an agenda of “network network network”. Of course we all see the benefits of a WFH / hybrid workplace but I’m sure everyone can admit that a conversation on Teams just isn’t as effective as in person. People pushing the WFH agenda tout its benefits on productivity, but I argue that it’s detrimental in the long run because the lack of cohesion in teams will lead to more and more sticking points and blockers. It’s all wonderful if you’re retiring in 10 years and you’ve already built your network, but for us younger people it’s definitely taking its toll.
- programmertote 3y agoYou can build your network by doing a great job at your current work even if it is remote. I worked remote for my previous two companies--the last one is Amazon. I left both with great contacts. In fact, I was referred to Amazon by one of my previous coworkers whom, I had only met in person once. He knows the quality of my work because we have sat in meetings, and worked on projects together. The point is you don't need to be physically present together to create a solid *professional* network. If your aim are more about building personal network (like making friends), then yes you need an in-office job. To me, I draw a very distinct line between professional and personal life, and in my 15+ years of professional life, I never got into sour relationship with my coworkers because of that.
- jmpz 3y agoI can understand this perspective, but I think it can work both ways. I'm 44 years old, and would also rather work from an office than from home, primarily for social interactions, and wanting to work outside of my house. My experience has been the inverse of yours, that most of my younger colleagues, who have spent the majority of their careers working from home, would rather continue to do so, and either hadn't had positive experiences working in an office environment and don't crave a return to it, or have focused their needs for social interaction elsewhere.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paulus_magnus2 3y agoThe progressives should really pick up on the benefits of WFH and become active proponents. WFH is the biggest equalizer of geographic opportunity, decreases physical disability impact, decreases carbon footprint, improves meritocracy, decreases opportinities for bullying and mobbing and other power play. Increases chances of mothers being able to work. You name it, this ticks all boxes. Why haven't they already??
- lamontcg 3y agoWhich should be no surprise to anyone following the studies on open offices for the past 10-15 years.
- agumonkey 3y agoMy pov fluctuates a bit on the WFH/RTO topic. I used to enjoy WFH 100% but after a few years, I do miss a bit of some offices I worked at. But it's probably traumatic memory at play because 9 times out of 10 I left these jobs with an existential relief and screaming "free at last". Commute plus office rhythm is rarely as efficient a WFH. In Office does enforce some rhythm, makes you change your mind a bit more, but you're now forced to endure the bad sides of toxic people. Warning, online streaming platform means that the same toxic people can now torture you via WebRTC.. stay strong :)
- elonergan 3y agoThe researchers involved in this study acknowledge that there are methodology shortcomings, notably that even a "soft nudge" to work in-person a couple of days per week is considered an "RTO Mandate". We have seen that unstructured hybrid - where no clear expectations of when and how to work in-person manifests as "remote first" whether intentional or not, so many of the low performing companies in this dataset could in fact fall into that category.