4 ms·
The biggest thing for me, from the Verge review, was the limited field of view. Apple sold it as filling the users entire field of view and it sounds like that
by al_borland 3y ago
The biggest thing for me, from the Verge review, was the limited field of view. Apple sold it as filling the users entire field of view and it sounds like that isn’t the case. When I first saw the reality of the Microsoft HoloLens, that was my disappointment there as well… Google Glass as well. I don’t want to feel like I’m wearing an AR device, as so far, that’s what everything has looked like. Limits of the technology, sure, but until that is solved I’ll have a lot of trouble throwing money at it. I still plan to head to an Apple Store at some point to try it out for myself.
As far as viewing with other people, this doesn’t seem like an insurmountable challenge. They have the theaters, they have Personas, they have spacial audio, and other Apple devices have features for watching content together with friends. Put them all together and it seems like if several friends had Vision Pro they could feel like they were sitting in a theater room together while watching a movie. I’m not saying this will be easy, but it seems like all the building blocks are there. The Personas are probably the big weak point, especially looking at someone next to you, but with the focus on the movie, I that’s probably the least important part.
- Civitello 3y ago> field of view...Limits of the technology It really isn't though, at least not for long, as of mid 2023 there are publicly showcased compact lightweight prototypes with 240° FoV.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoWell there’s FOV and there’s pixel density which are both too low right now and antagonistic to one another feature wise. There’s also display brightness which is an issue and I’m not sure how that fits in to the FOV/density spectrum. And then more pixels means more compute… That prototypes exist doesn’t necessarily mean much in a space that is full of prototypes showing off one particular feature. The very hard thing is to combine all of the desired features in to one consumer ready headset.
- Roark66 3y ago>Well there’s FOV and there’s pixel density which are both too low right now. Exactly. You know what is the best "goggle" type display I ever saw (and I tried quite a few)? Recent FPV goggles (hdzero) that have 1930*1080 OLED displays at approximately 46 degrees fov. I'm very glad the manufacturer decided to use the his low fov instead of increasing it to 55deg and more like others. The picture is insanely crisp, and looks better than looking at a 4k display. Another huge benefit is that entire picture fits within your "focus cone" so there is no need to gaze around. It is not a VR display, it's purpose is different, but it shows us what visual quality is possible. I'd love if manufacturers, if they can't make 16k displays that fill the entire fov, create variable pixel density displays. Best quality in the center. Deteriorating towards the edges. That would be much cheaper, but then for good illusion one would need eye tracking and motorised optics which would probably be more expensive in the end... Oh, well, I'm pretty happy with my fpv goggles (for fpv) I just wish there was a way for them to display different picture for each eye. They already have head tracking, I wonder what VR would be like with this huge ppi narrow fov goggles. Would it be more or less immersive?
- fouc 3y agofor those who don't know: FPV = first person view. Used for drone racing and things like that.
- Xirgil 3y agomotorized displays also sounds HEAVY which is a big issue for a device intended to be used for long periods of time
- Civitello 3y agoI'm pretty sure one of the varjo headsets had displays like you describe.
- zmmmmm 3y agothey are paying the price for their obsession with super high resolution. I think it's a mistake, from my perception Quest 3 at 25ppd is nearly good enough, and its panels are nearly half the resolution. They should have traded 20% resolution for 10 deg FOV either side. In fact, with appropriate optics the effective resolutions sacrifice could be even less than that.
- saagarjha 3y agoHow is it to read text on the Quest 3? How would you compare it to a high-density display (such as what is on your phone)?
- sph 3y agoWell, it's no Retina screen. I'd say it's bit like reading text on a 1080p CRT at 96 dpi. It's perfectly doable, but there's still a hint of fuzziness and we're still a couple generations away from crisp LCD text. I care about my eyes, so I use a 4k screen at 2x scaling for coding, and will not use the Quest 3 for work, unless that involves playing games and watching videos.
- canadianfella 3y agoIs there any evidence of pixelated text damaging eyes?
- frompom 3y agohttps://www.reviewofoptometry.com/news/article/higher-resolution-screens-may-reduce-digital-eye-strain https://www.reviewofoptometry.com/news/article/higher-resolu...
- deanishe 3y agoThey only need hi-res where the user is looking, don't they? We can't see what's in our peripheral vision clearly, so they should be able to get away with most of the FoV being blocky af, shouldn't they?
- chaostheory 3y ago> As far as viewing with other people, this doesn’t seem like an insurmountable challenge. This can also be achieved with 3rd party apps. On Quest, this is already a reality with Big Screen.
- aenis 3y agoI wonder who would actually do that. The only reason I watch tv is to socialize with my family. I think if we were just sitting on the couch all wearing VR googles it would ruin the entire use case for watching stuff together. Surely, some geeks, once or twice.
- NineStarPoint 3y agoThe use case is watching something with people who are half a world away I think, not with people who are physically present with you.
- LeonenTheDK 3y agoI wonder if that "theatre experience" would be a significant improvement for most people. I already do this with friends remotely by jumping on discord and hitting play on whatever service we're using at the same time. There more more automatically in-sync solutions out there for sure, but I can't see doing this in VR being more than a novelty that wears out after a few sessions.
- chaostheory 3y agoYou should actually try it before coming to that conclusion. The main difference between discord, zoom or any other flat viewing experience vs VR is immersion. Words don’t do it justice, you have to experience it yourself.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mvkel 3y agoThat was the surprise to me too. Lower FOV than a Quest 3? Inexcusable.
- vunderba 3y agoAgreed. 8 years out from the original Oculus rift which had 110' FOV and we're still somehow staring through the AR/VR equivalent of a submarine periscope.
- hackernewds 3y agoa whole eight years???
- sigmoid10 3y agoI still have one of the Oculus Devkits at home from their initial campaign. It's more than 10 years old now. I've noticed the biggest improvements to VR over the last decade were in useability - not the screen. Once they figured out low latency by switching the screen to black after every frame every device upgrade felt like a tiny improvement in resolution at best. Size 12 font text on a 2m screen wasn't really readable yet, but I still don't use VR for text work today (even though I could) so it also doesn't matter. Right now it's still a question of usability rather than the screen.
- volemo 3y agoThat’s a double edge sword though. Were they to make it 180°, we would critique it for spreading the precious pixels. “With those 4K your virtual monitor is 1080p at most!”
- tsunamifury 3y agoApple used to excel at making the right trade off here. Choosing what feels right over numbers.
- 3y ago
- hackernewds 3y agoin some ways even the reviews seem to be placed by Apple (same as they provided the exact photos of the device the media printed). all of them seem to present a full view with floating widgets, when there's really no way to photograph them
- swores 3y agoSurely the device just has a screenshot function?
- fudged71 3y agoTwo interesting and unrelated facts: A screenshot would be blurry because of the foveated rendering The device doesn't even have a power button
- swores 3y agoGiven Apple have complete control with their OS of how the dynamic foveated rendering system works, if they particularly wanted a screenshot feature to be included - reasonably likely for marketing purposes, it seems to me - then surely it wouldn't be too hard to code it such that it renders a second version of the GPU's output to generate the screenshot, when asked to by user, which has even pixel density. (Or perhaps screenshots getting some sort of "bokeh" for the first time, highlighting whatever the user was looking at when taking the screenshot, will turn out to be a desirable feature.) Not having buttons obviously doesn't prevent there being a screenshot function, just as lack of screenshot button on iPhone hasn't prevented it from taking screenshots, and just as the VP's lack of buttons doesn't prevent users from interacting with it at all...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bjacobel 3y agoThe end goal here - multiple people who are isolated by the technology they're wearing experiencing a simulacrum of human interaction mediated by that technology - is not only unbelievably depressing but also honestly just really boring. We've already built this. It was called the "metaverse" and it sucked. Everyone left.
- Solvency 3y agoThe idea of wearing a VR headset so I can "enjoy photos with friends" is absolutely hilarious and so deeply disconnected from what human beings want and need as a species.
- al_borland 3y agoEvery time I see the spatial photos and spatial videos, I always view it as someone putting on their VR headset to reliving a memory of someone who died. Then they take the headset off and realize they are alone and the loss broke them. I have a lot of trouble not seeing those videos from a very depressing place.
- dwaite 3y agoPeople are totally allowed to watch videos of their children without their children being dead.
- al_borland 3y agoThis is true. I think it's the fade effect they add to the edge of it, it seems like an effect that would be used in a movie to show a memory of someone who died.
- OrangeMusic 3y agoIt's all about tradeoffs. If you get at the same time: - gigantic (virtual) screens showing your photos/videos in a spectacular way AND - a incredibly small, light, comfortable, and almost unnoticeable (e.g. glasses) headset then, yes people will absolutely use that instead of actual photos printed on paper. Obviously we're not there yet.
- starky 3y agoI've been telling people this for awhile, the biggest issue I have with the available VR headsets is the limited FoV. It causes unneccesary neck strain having to move your head as much as you do to look at things.