10 ms·
Elon Musk's $55B Tesla Pay Package Voided by Judge
- pavlov 3y agoDoes this mean he could face margin calls on loans banks have made against his Tesla stock? A substantial part of the collateral may not belong to him after all…?
- TheAlchemist 3y agoYes and no. He still owns ~400M shares and had options on 304M more. The 304M just got cancelled. He has around 260M shares pledged as collateral against his loans - at least according to the latest known numbers (from 2022 I believe). So let's say he's not yet under water, but the margin just got dangerously close to the limit.
- fooey 3y agoAccording to the Tesla bylaws, you can only leverage 25% of your stock, so that's going to be a problem for him too https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000156459021022604/tsla-10ka_20201231.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000156459021... > In order to mitigate the risk of forced sales of pledged shares, the Board has a policy that limits pledging of Tesla stock by our directors and executive officers. Pursuant to this policy, directors and executive officers may pledge their stock (exclusive of options, warrants, restricted stock units or other rights to purchase stock) as collateral for loans and investments, provided that the maximum aggregate loan or investment amount collateralized by such pledged stock does not exceed twenty-five percent (25%) of the total value of the pledged stock.
- ksherlock 3y agoNot a problem when you can ask your friends to rewrite the rules. My favorite story: FedEx doesn't allow BoD/executives to pledge stock for margin loans. But they will make exceptions on a case-by-case basis. They only made on exception, (then) CEO Fred Smith. How it started: "In accordance with our policy, Mr. Smith has established his financial capacity to repay the loan without resorting to the pledged shares. In the unlikely event such a sale were necessary, based on the 30-day average trading volume for FedEx shares as of August 4, 2014, it would take two days for the pledged shares to be sold in the open market. Furthermore, Mr. Smith’s unpledged share ownership is very substantial and would likely be able to prevent any margin call." How it went: "As a result of the stock price decline during fiscal 2020, Mr. Smith was granted approval to pledge additional shares in March 2020."
- kortilla 3y agoRight in your own quote, options were excluded so this doesn’t alter that.
- fred_is_fred 3y agoThank you. I've been looking for this in every news story posted since the verdict. Does anyone know where the cancelled shares go? Back to Tesla? I assume he can get a massive tax refund now?
- microtherion 3y agoThese are options, not shares, so I think they simply cease to exist.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThe options cease to exist. Tesla has 50 billion is shares earmarked for elon, which it no longer has to pay out, this means the shareholders made 50B
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kklisura 3y agoCourt's opinion/judgement [1], and a PDF version [2] [1] https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9470356/richard-j-tornetta-v-elon-musk/ https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/9470356/richard-j-torn... [2] https://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=359340 https://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=359340
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- epups 3y agoThe arguments used here are weird. The decision says that Musk was close friends with many members of the board so he effectively controlled it. That's the case for many, if not most public companies. The other argument was that the board didn't meaningfully push back on the proposed remuneration scheme. Yet, it amounted to a huge gamble - multiplying the value of a 50B company by over 10x -, which in case of success the board agreed to reward with 6% of shares. It sounds silly to me to suggest the board failed their duty when shareholders - including them - had record profits even discounting Musk's reward.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y ago> The decision says that Musk was close friends with many members of the board so he effectively controlled it. That's the case for many, if not most public companies. In Eastern Europe we were calling this tunneling of a company - create a tunnel with help from inside to get riches out and leave the shell to its own demise.
- clipsy 3y ago> In Eastern Europe we were calling this tunneling of a company - create a tunnel with help from inside to get riches out and leave the shell to its own demise. Elon prefers to call it “boring.”
- Taek 3y agoIncreasing the share price by 10x and turning the Model 3 into the worlds best selling vehicle is hardly "leaving the shell to its own demise" *edit: Model Y
- justinclift 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20240130220549/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-01-30/elon-musk-s-55-billion-tesla-pay-package-voided-by-judge https://web.archive.org/web/20240130220549/https://www.bloom...
- soulbadguy 3y agoThe court opinion is surprisingly readable. I don't know why, but I was expecting a lot more opaque lawyerly jargon. TLDR : The process used to decided the comp package was flawed (mainly because of the conflict of interest from the people negotiating on behalf of tesla) and the comp package itself can't be justified by objective metrics
- bdjsiqoocwk 3y ago> The court opinion is surprisingly readable. I don't know why, but I was expecting a lot more opaque lawyerly jargon. As a European person, this is the kind of pleasant surprises I expect to hear from America
- arcastroe 3y agoThank you for this. I instinctively avoided the link due to same expectations of illegible jargon. After I read your comment, I read the court opinion and found it almost too informal!
- DannyBee 3y agoShe's a good writer, and always has been. Most of her opinions are written in clear, plain, understandable way because as the chief judge she sees it as her job to try to set the standard for how the court should behave
- nocoiner 3y agoYeah, she’s an excellent communicator. Many of her opinions are also pretty funny too (relatively speaking, of course).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Rapzid 3y agoI find they usually are including SCOTUS decisions. I would encourage everyone to read at least some of them. It's a shame starting law programs requires an undergrad degree in most of the country. Otherwise more people may be encouraged to get involved particularly later in life.
- TheAlchemist 3y agoFun fact - it's the same judge that forced Musk to buy Twitter !
- ivanmontillam 3y ago[flagged]
- TheAlchemist 3y agoIt could, and it certainly will be by Elon. But it also could be, that Elon is completely disregarding the law, and has for years. This will become very apparent soon(ish) as there will be more trails, against him and against Tesla.
- rsynnott 3y ago… Revenge for _what_? I think it’s probably just that there aren’t _that_ many Delaware chancery judges, and he’s kind of a frequent flier.
- mikeyouse 3y agoYou can argue literally anything - but it's highly doubtful that this rises to anything resembling judicial misconduct. The appeal would have to go to the US Supreme Court. Ruling is here [https://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=359340 https://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=359340] but this part seems instructive: > The plan offers Musk the opportunity to secure 12 total tranches of options, each representing 1% of Tesla’s total outstanding shares as of January 21, 2018. For a tranche to vest, Tesla’s market capitalization must increase by $50 billion and Tesla must achieve either an adjusted EBITDA target or a revenue target in four consecutive fiscal quarters. With a $55.8 billion maximum value and $2.6 billion grant date fair value, the plan is the largest potential compensation opportunity ever observed in public markets by multiple orders of magnitude—250 times larger than the contemporaneous median peer compensation plan and over 33 times larger than the plan’s closest comparison, which was Musk’s prior compensation plan. This posttrial decision enters judgment for the plaintiff, finding that the compensation plan is subject to review under the entire fairness standard, the defendants bore the burden of proving that the compensation plan was fair, and they failed to meet their burden. The lack of indepdence of the Tesla Comp. Committee was one big issue the judge found; > The process leading to the approval of Musk’s compensation plan was deeply flawed. Musk had extensive ties with the persons tasked with negotiating on Tesla’s behalf. He had a 15-year relationship with the compensation committee chair, Ira Ehrenpreis. The other compensation committee member placed on the working group, Antonio Gracias, had business relationships with Musk dating back over 20 years, as well as the sort of personal relationship that had him vacationing with Musk’s family on a regular basis. The working group included management members who were beholden to Musk, such as General Counsel Todd Maron who was Musk’s former divorce attorney and whose admiration for Musk moved him to tears during his deposition. In fact, Maron was a primary gobetween Musk and the committee, and it is unclear on whose side Maron viewed himself. Yet many of the documents cited by the defendants as proof of a fair process were drafted by Maron.
- feliciegerald 3y ago[dead]
- tschellenbach 3y agoFine for non-majority shareholders to be able to sue. Also fine that they win. But 6 years after the package was awarded?
- delecti 3y agoHe sued the same year as the pay package, it just took 6 years for the case to complete. From the judgement: > Plaintiff Richard Tornetta (“Plaintiff”), a Tesla stockholder, filed his complaint on June 5, 2018.
- enslavedrobot 3y agoAs someone who made a million dollars on Tesla stock, I'm ready to backdate a new package with better language any time.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoI am glad he's staying on, even without the compensation package, just like many said he would (proving the package was excessive), and is still going to perform as CEO, just like many said he would (again proving that the package was excessive). I am skeptical he would be able to extract the same amount of value from out of the pockets of shareholders and into his, without resorting to the fraud he used to gain shareholder approval the first time. We'll see!
- enslavedrobot 3y agoThe apparent "fraud" was that the board was not independent not that the package was unfair to shareholders. I would absolutely vote for any compensation package that payed a CEO 1% per doubling of my investment. Shareholders will pass a package that contains appropriate legalese so that the options will be reinstated. We can afford it.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoThere's no need to put fraud in quotes, or inappropriately add "apparent". In fact, let's capitalize it to drive the point home: elmu Definitely Committed Fraud to try to trick shareholders into forking over tens of billions of their own wealth, directly into his pockets. It was an open and shut case, and he was judged guilty of having done so. I doubt shareholders will pass it again*, since the way he got it to pass the first time was by defrauding them. Remember: elmu committed fraud (multiple times, this is just the latest!) There's no escaping that. He's a fraudster in the eyes of the law (though perhaps not in the eyes of his fans). As for your investment, just imagine how much it's worth now that 50 billion dollars of company wealth is staying with the company and investing in even higher returns (!) rather than into elmu's pocket, so he can waste it on another twitter on which to shitpost. elmu having that money wouldn't have increased the stock price over him not having it, but the company having it, probably will. So congrats on your increased future wealth! Remember, too, the judge found, according to the evidence, including elmu and tesla's own statements, that he was motivated to perform even without the additional 50 billion in compensation on top of his existing compensation. So there was never any risk of him performing differently with or without, as judged by the judge of the matter. * Honestly, I doubt it'll even get to a vote, and that he'll even be offered the same package when he has to negotiate against new people representing the interests of shareholders, rather than "negotiating" (*wink*) against his friends.
- leetgirl83 3y agoI encourage everyone to read the official filing of the compensation package in 2018 and decide if it is misleading to the investors. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000119312518035345/d524719ddef14a.htm#toc524719_10 https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000119312518... In particular, this part: The Compensation Committee has overall responsibility for recommending to our Board the compensation of our Chief Executive Officer and determining the compensation of our other executive officers. Members of the Compensation Committee are appointed by our Board. Currently, the Compensation Committee consists of four members of our Board: Brad Buss, Robyn Denholm, Ira Ehrenpreis and Antonio Gracias, none of whom is an executive officer of Tesla, and each of whom qualifies as (i) an “independent director” under the NASDAQ Stock Market Rules and (ii) an “outside director” under Code Section 162(m).
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoIndeed her decision rests on that finding. But according to the opinion, the issue was not what was included in the proxy statement, but what was left out. For example, details about those directors and their relationship with the CEO. Was that intentional? Call me crazy, but having the CEO's divorce lawyer as the General Counsel is impossible to ignore as a potential red flag. Why. There are only so many reasons he would be given the job and most of them are problematic. Was he in charge of preparing this proxy statement.
- alecco 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathaleen_McCormick https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathaleen_McCormick Interesting context. (Note: I'm not from USA)
- gamblor956 3y agoBuss was the CFO of SolarCity, which Tesla acquired, and Ehrenpreis was friends with Musk at Stanford. As an employee, Buss is by definition not an independent director, see NASDAQ SMR 5605(2)(B).
- YeBanKo 3y ago
- leetgirl83 3y agoIn 2018, 80% of the TSLA shareholders voted favor of a compensation plan that would pay Elon $56 billion if the company met certain goals. As of 2023, these goals have been met, and yet, the judge will rule in favor of a shareholder who holds 9 TSLA shares that the plan is excessive and should be voided. Interesting, isn't it.
- jimkleiber 3y ago> Of course, Tesla shareholders voted for the plan, but the judge found that “the defendants were unable to prove that the stockholder vote was fully informed because the proxy statement inaccurately described key directors as independent and misleadingly omitted details about the process." [0] I think the argument was that the vote wasn't valid because the the voters weren't properly informed and that Tesla didn't actually try to negotiate too hard to get a better deal for shareholders. That being said, I have no idea about the law surrounding this stuff, just trying to add more context. [0]: https://electrek.co/2024/01/30/elon-musk-billion-tesla-ceo-compensation-voided-by-judge/ https://electrek.co/2024/01/30/elon-musk-billion-tesla-ceo-c...
- tmn 3y agoCan anyone make an objective case that this was a bad deal for share holders?
- nocoiner 3y agoI’m not sure what your point is. There’s a well established standard in Delaware for upholding conflicted transactions and the process for cleansing them ex ante. That this particular transaction lifted the tide for all boats doesn’t mean that all, most or even many similarly conflicted transactions result in a positive amount of value creation for non-controlling shareholders. What I think is more interesting is how the duties imposed on controllers, directors and officers of Delaware corporations are, in my opinion, one of the key factors that have directly contributed to such a massive creation of wealth over most of the past century that $56 billion is a merely a drop in the very large bucket. Delaware as a venue for capital formation and value accretive corporate norms works so well that I’d think anyone raising third party capital would welcome the enforcement by all shareholders, whether they hold a million shares or just a single one.
- soulbadguy 3y agoIs there a precedent of the sort? I am curious of the long term effect of this ruling in CEO effect. Especially since the burden of proof/justification actually falls on the board. It might make it harder for captured boards to reward CEOs
- nocoiner 3y agoIf a board following the (well defined) process, the board is, under Delaware law, entitled to famously broad deference to their decisions. If they can’t run an aboveboard process and procure the necessary shareholder approvals, then that’s probably in a lot of cases a pretty good sign that they’re not really doing their job as a board very effectively.
- leetgirl83 3y agoThe guy that sued and just made Elon Musk lose 55 Billion dollars only had: NINE SHARES OF TESLA STOCK.
- bdcrazy 3y agoHE ALSO SUED ON June 5, 2018.
- pHollda 3y agoMusk is getting robbed. At the time, everyone believed the challenges were too big to surmount and he would never actually achieve them. He does and suddenly "oh the reward is far too much"?
- dangrossman 3y agoTesla was planning and projecting that it would meet the milestones in Elon's pay package before it was offered. They were not seen as insurmountable or unachievable goals, that was part of what made this case. Quoting the court's opinion: > "During the December 12 meeting, the Board also reviewed Tesla’s then-current operating plan and projections. Ahuja developed, and Musk approved, the projections in December prior to the meeting (the “December 2017 Projections”). The one-year projections underlying the operating plan forecasted $27.4B in total revenue and $4.3B in adjusted EBITDA by late 2018, and thus predicted achievement of three milestones in 2018 alone. The three-year long-run projections (“LRP”) underlying that plan reflected that, by 2019 and 2020, Tesla would achieve seven and eleven operational milestones, respectively."
- pHollda 3y agoI remember very clearly what everyone thought as it all happened in 2018. No one thought they could actually achieve all of the milestones. Everyone knows how much Musk overpromises. That they have is incredible and makes Musk totally deserving of the compensation.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoI dunno, the poster you replied to brought receipts: they cited the evidence proving them correct. A court took those citations, and judged what the poster said to be correct, settling the matter. So the poster you're responding to is officially, legally correct. What do you think about the evidence and decision made based on the evidence above? It seems many people remember very clearly what everyone thought, and it was that the goals were achievable. Do you believe the above evidence cited, was falsified?
- efitz 3y agoI’m not arguing the judgment was unfair and I’m not asserting that musk and the board acted wisely, prudently or even ethically. But the guy just got robbed of his compensation after increasing the value of the company’s stock by 10x. In return for accomplishing this he was supposed to get 6% equity. That does not sound to me like the plaintiffs suffered actual losses.
- bhouston 3y agoThe judge said his compensation was that he owned 21% of Tesla so that he already received $10B for every $50B he increased Tesla’s value. Awarding more stock to Musk was just depriving the other stock holders of their value.
- Taek 3y agoThat doesn't seem like the judge was acting in the fiduciary interest of Tesal. It seems like the judge was acting in the interest of stopping corporate greed. The judge had multiple quotes to that effect, including "Is the richest man on Earth overpaid?" - that's not a question you ask for matters of fiduciary responsibility, because it completely ignores the question of how valuable Musk is to Tesla.
- bhouston 3y agoThe judge makes clear that he thinks that Musk was likely to stay CEO of Tesla whether or not this pay package occurred. It was already in Musk’s interest to stay given his shareholdings. Remember that this growth of Tesla brought Musk $120B of wealth given his existing shareholdings. That is already a lot of compensation for a job well done.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoWhich is an interesting argument. If the board should reject any deals, even mutually beneficial ones, because they already have someone in golden handcuffs, then Mutual assured destruction is the only leverage remaining.
- syntaxing 3y agoWhat happens next financially? Does 6% worth of volume disappear from Tesla tomorrow and the stock price increase 6%?
- cookingrobot 3y agoNot if he threatens to quit Tesla to start a competing car company out of spite.
- raesene9 3y agoI kind of doubt he'd do that. AFAIK most of Elon's wealth is in Tesla shares, and a lot of them are pledged against loans. If his Tesla shares go done seriously in value that could leave him open to margin calls. Over time, he may be able to unload those Tesla shares, making him less tied to the company, but I'd guess it'd take a while to sell that stock without risking a serious share price drop.
- what3ver 3y agoLet's say you invested in Tesla for your pension and you see that the board give Must 3.5 years of company profits as bonus, nullifying any company profit for that time: "Tesla ended Q4 2023 with a net income of $7.9 billion and the full year with $15 billion in profits" , that money is more 3 years of profit, meaning that the company , after that compensation, must wait almost 4 years, if the trend remains that one, to generate profit ! Are you happy in that case ? EV market is now more competitive, it's no more the time when Tesla was founded, Mercedes has a better autonomous guidance system, there are plenty of alternative EV brands, moving that kind of money int the pocket of one of the owners a good move or you are crippling the company because you are taking away money could be user for R&D, for example, killing the company in years ? Or you think they are slowly burning your savings. Maybe you are not a billionaire, that are all your saving. Let's go further, most lucrative automaker is Toyota, Tesla is 5 position under in that top 10. If I take the CEO of Toyota, giving him double salary, to manage Tesla, without 55 billion bonus, will the company be mismanaged ? I don't think so, Musk isn't the only "genius" able to run a carmaker company and, in fact, there are at least 6 guys are doing a better job. Obviously there is the marketing benefit of the Musk brand associated to Tesla, but, men, 55B$, is it worth ??? IMHO, he did need money for Twitter and used Tesla as his own wallet, ignoring correct management practices and acting not in best interest of the company , de facto crippling its grown. Plus, CEO also owning company big shares percentage, often reduce their salary and benefits because , you know, it's your best interest work to increase company value because that enrich yourself. So I really don't understand because someone think judge's sentence is unfair : again , I have shares in a company where the same happen, I also call my lawyer. Also, I expect that the judge deliberate to guarantee the rights of all shareholders, independently by the quote they own and in the best interest of the company existence and grown. Think the judge did, IMHO.
- kortilla 3y ago> Let's say you invested in Tesla for your pension and you see that the board give Must 3.5 years of company profits as bonus, nullifying any company profit for that time: That’s irrelevant and wrong. First, they don’t give profits, they were options grants for equity which dilutes shareholders. Second, profits aren’t divided amongst shareholders because they don’t pay dividends. Your pension got a 10x gain from this agreement if it was invested and voted for it. Now the agreement is being withdrawn but your pension will keep the 10x. If you can’t see how that can be seen as unfair, I don’t know what to tell you. Musk led the company through a moonshot goal and the argument is “eh, we said we would give you a huge bonus for doing this but you’re already invested”. It’s not meaningfully different from taking away a software engineer’s options because they have a bunch of vested stock because “they already have skin in the game”. The conflict of interest is the only thing with merit. The fairness arguments are complete bullshit and will set a terrible precedent on their own.
- nojvek 3y agoI have a feeling Elon musk being the richest billionaire will bully Richard Tornetta to teach him a lesson. Billionaires are powerful people, and people can be very petty when someone goes against their ego.