5 ms·
I don't think it means much at all. Software jobs boomed in the 80s and 90s despite high interest rates. Tech tends to do well in almost every econ environment
by paulpauper 3y ago
I don't think it means much at all. Software jobs boomed in the 80s and 90s despite high interest rates. Tech tends to do well in almost every econ environment. And already, interest rate forecasts falling.
- cableshaft 3y agoIn the long term I think you're pretty much right, but in the short term, all these businesses that were structured around the assumption of easy massive funding rounds from low interest rates have to figure out how to operate in high interest rates again, and will likely shed a lot of employees in the process.
- hello_moto 3y agoAll businesses are used to certain range of interest-rate for the last 20 years.
- thfuran 3y agoSure, but most businesses at least try to be profitable, whereas many in tech were fundamentally untenable without a constant injection of external capital to prop up a venture aiming only to grow rather than to actually be sustainable.
- cableshaft 3y agoStill blows my mind that Uber's first reported quarterly earnings that showed a profit in its entire history was Q2 2023[1]. And the company was founded in 2009. They've been losing money for well over a decade and yet still getting wave after wave of cash from investors. [1]: https://techcrunch.com/2023/08/01/uber-reports-first-quarterly-operating-profit/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/08/01/uber-reports-first-quarter...
- lotsofpulp 3y agohttps://www.crunchbase.com/organization/uber/company_financials https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/uber/company_financi... >Their latest funding was raised on Sep 14, 2020 from a Post-IPO Debt round. I would not even count that since "getting wave after wave of cash from investors" usually means receiving cash in exchange for equity, not borrowing money. It seems the most recent cash they received from investors was at IPO in May 2019, and before that, Softbank in Jan 2018: https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/111015/story-uber.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/11101...
- cableshaft 3y agoYour own link shows that they've had 32 funding rounds. I'm sure they've had an increasingly smaller burn rate in recent years, as they've gotten closer and closer to profitability, and thus required less cash less often (also if the funding round is large enough, they'd need to do it less often), but I'd consider 32 funding rounds wave after wave of cash from investors to me. That's even more rounds than I assumed, that's more than 2 each year on average.
- kipchak 3y agoGrowth businesses like tech and startups also tend to be more sensitive to rate increases due to changes in the time value of money. At 0% rates a business that generates a return in 10 years is fairly close to the same as a business that generates a return in 1 year, but at 5% rates the math is very different.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoHow many of these businesses even existed 20 years ago? Or even 15 or 10?
- paulpauper 3y agoVC boomed in the late 90s when interest rates were very high. The federal funds rate in 2000 was as high 7%. If VCs expect to double their money on the latest AI fad, do they care if the interest rate is 0% or 5%? likely this does not factor much into their decisions.
- disgruntledphd2 3y agoThe VCs don't care but their limited partners who supply the money certainly do.
- hackernoteng 3y agoCorrect. If risk free return is 5% there is less need to take more risk on risky VC or private equity bets. Those allocations would necessarily be smaller overall. In addition the same effect on term sheets - the VCs will expect MORE return on their money for taking the investment risk which will be reflected in the terms.
- itsoktocry 3y ago>Tech tends to do well in almost every econ environment. Yeah, I think "no more ZIRP" is a stand-in for "the economy is changing". And, that much is true. We just went through record-low rates for a record length of time, straight into the fastest hikes in history. That has repercussions, and I don't think anyone knows what they will be yet (oh and there are some interesting geopolitics as well). But I can't help but think most of these layoffs are also a return to "normalcy". The pandemic job market was, literally, insane. But even before that, it was hard to get development work; prices were astronomical if you could even find people at all. For the tech ecosystem as a whole, there are advantages to salaries and wages coming down. That shifts around cui bono, but it allows for more ideas to see the light of day...maybe. All this is to say I don't think it's doom and gloom. We'll have a period of transition and realignment, but tech skills will always be in demand.
- govg 3y agoThis was a historic period for low rates, but rates have been higher and have been changed faster before, for example during the late 70s / 80s. It went from 4-5% to nearly 20% over the span of a couple of years.
- acdha 3y agoThat still hurt plenty over the short term, and it’s important to remember that metrics aren’t people. If you were a mainframe developer in Cleveland who just got laid off from a bank, it didn’t help your next mortgage payment to know that a company in San Francisco hired three people to build web apps even though the BLM’s national report would show a net gain of 2 jobs. This time we also have two big differences: most businesses are much further along on adopting IT (we’re unlikely to see the equivalent of the web boom in scale) and the internet’s ubiquity means that the alternatives often include replacing existing processes with SaaS services, which often requires fewer people than 80s/90s automation projects did or means they’re looking for someone to customize SAP, etc. and won’t consider you if your résumé doesn’t have the specific service they bought. I am not saying that doom is the correct outlook here but I do think it’s a good idea to really think about what a prolonged down market would mean personally. That’s especially true if you were, say, flying high at Google until a layoff and now are looking at things like a public sector job which is quite stable but has no prospect of paying better than half of what you used to make.
- netbioserror 3y agoYes, but when interest rates were high decades ago, malinvestment bubbles started smaller, deflated, and ended up much smaller. I think by most measures, the current economy-wide credit bubble (and tech wage inflation bubble driven by stocks) have only been minorly dented by tightening (despite the layoff waves), and we're very likely to reverse course into easing. Keeping these fundamentals in mind, it's likely Silicon Valley will see an outflow of workers over the next couple of years, and salaries will be depressed in other cities due to the moving labor supply. Then once easing begins, we'll see that trend reverse yet again.
- steveBK123 3y agoTech does well enough in most economic periods in the US. But ZIRP was like the juicing era of baseball homerun record setting. The valuations, and therefore level of employment and particularly the compensation all got very distorted and is slowly coming down. Why? Interest rates are the cost of money. If money doesn't cost anything/much, you don't have anywhere else to park money, and you can take longer bets! VC funded startups going a decade with no revenue or no profit is something you can tolerate in that environment. What else are you going to do, put the money in a bond paying 0.5%? After a decade your $100 is now.. $105 in nominal terms, and a loss in real inflation adjusted terms assuming essentially any inflation. So you gamble that 5% of the 100 companies you invest in will be worth 25-50x what you invested, in 10 years. You end up with $125-150 in nominal terms after a decade for every $100 you started with. A lot better than $105! It is 5-10x the safe return. Now, when you run the math again with available no/low risk investments yielding 4%, you suddenly need a much higher hit rate and/or much higher return. Simply putting the money in a 4% yield for 10 years gets you $148, the top end of the prior ZIRP era VC return example.. uh oh! So what do you do, as an investor who still wants to get paid for taking VC risk? To get 5x the safe bond return, you need 25% of your book to return 25-50x, or 10% to return 62.5-125x, or 5% to return 125-250x. Everything is much harder and you need more of your investments to work, and for the ones that work to return far more. So tolerance for profitless unicorns for a decade is dramatically reduced.
- commandlinefan 3y ago> ZIRP was like the juicing era If you say so, but the 90's were _way_ better than the 00's.
- sneed_chucker 3y agoSoftware engineers in the 80s and 90s weren't making 3-5 times as much as people in other professions.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agocough dotcom boom cough
- acdha 3y agoThe dotcom boom definitely included decent wages but it wasn’t anywhere near as pronounced - lawyers and doctors weren’t trying to become software developers. A few people made a lot of money on stock options but that was usually the owners rather than the developers, and a bunch of people really weren’t even making more than boring corporate jobs when adjusted for the number of hours they were working at burnout.com.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoMore money is more money overall, even if hourly rate falls when you work more hours than an alternative.
- acdha 3y agoOh, sure, but in the 90s if you wanted to work crazy hours you’d have made a LOT more money by going to law school and making those extra hours billable. A lot of dotcom people were making like $60-80k - not bad but not amazing - and hoping for a big options payout to make the extra hours more worthwhile.
- importantbrian 3y ago$80k in 1990 dollars is equivalent to $192k in 2023 dollars. I'm not sure salaries are all that inflated compared to the .com days.
- ak217 3y agoInterest rates followed a downward trend overall throughout the 80s and 90s, with a few brief spikes and a 5% plateau between 1995-2000. We started the 80s with sky high rates from the Volcker inflation era. Ultimately, interest rates halved, from around 10% to around 5%, during this period. By contrast, interest rates went from 0.1% to 5.5% in the past 18 months. Even if you add the prime rate, the cost of capital tripled, from around 3% to around 9%. That's an unprecedented financial shock for pre-revenue companies.