4 ms·

That being said - there's something to be said for enterprise support. Are there plans to support importing/converting/running third party OVAs? Many vendors

by tw04 3y ago

That being said - there's something to be said for enterprise support. Are there plans to support importing/converting/running third party OVAs? Many vendors will support something running in KVM, I can't recall the last time I saw b-hyve as a supported hypervisor. I'd imagine as broadcom slowly destroys vmware's market share vendors will look to alternatives, but I doubt b-hyve is even a blip on their radar at this point.

steveklabnik 3y ago
I don't know the status of supporting OVA as a file format, but we absolutely support creating and uploading your own images. Here are the current docs on how to do so: https://docs.oxide.computer/guides/creating-and-sharing-images#_overview https://docs.oxide.computer/guides/creating-and-sharing-imag...
antranigv 3y ago
OVAs are basically ZIP files with some XML. If you want, you can convert an OVA to RAW image or VMDK or whatever the latest fancy format is, and bhyve can boot that for you. Better to use Raw. bhyve, unlike other "famous" hypervisors is pretty stable, has good enough virtualized drivers (altho I'm sure Oxide has made it better) and can boot a VM with 1.5 TB of RAM and 240 vCPU[1]. Something I was not able to do with anything other than bhyve. I know this is HackerNews, so I have to say it, marketing != engineering. Just because the FreeBSD project's marketing suck, doesn't mean engineering is bad. usually it better than the mainstream ones. 1: https://antranigv.am/posts/2023/10/bhyve-cpu-allocation-256/ https://antranigv.am/posts/2023/10/bhyve-cpu-allocation-256/
- tw04 3y ago
  There's two parts to the question. There's the file itself and the underlying hardware. The wiki is pretty light on details, does it actually support emulating the same hardware as vmware? I'd assume no to the vmxnet devices but Intel E1000? Adaptec SCSI adapters? Similar USB and VGA? A lot of the vendor-provided OVAs cut out a bunch of hardware support with the assumption that they only need to support vmware emulated hardware.

by tw04 3y ago

steveklabnik 3y ago

I don't know the status of supporting OVA as a file format, but we absolutely support creating and uploading your own images. Here are the current docs on how to do so: https://docs.oxide.computer/guides/creating-and-sharing-images#_overview https://docs.oxide.computer/guides/creating-and-sharing-imag...

antranigv 3y ago

OVAs are basically ZIP files with some XML. If you want, you can convert an OVA to RAW image or VMDK or whatever the latest fancy format is, and bhyve can boot that for you. Better to use Raw. bhyve, unlike other "famous" hypervisors is pretty stable, has good enough virtualized drivers (altho I'm sure Oxide has made it better) and can boot a VM with 1.5 TB of RAM and 240 vCPU[1]. Something I was not able to do with anything other than bhyve. I know this is HackerNews, so I have to say it, marketing != engineering. Just because the FreeBSD project's marketing suck, doesn't mean engineering is bad. usually it better than the mainstream ones. 1: https://antranigv.am/posts/2023/10/bhyve-cpu-allocation-256/ https://antranigv.am/posts/2023/10/bhyve-cpu-allocation-256/

tw04 3y ago
There's two parts to the question. There's the file itself and the underlying hardware. The wiki is pretty light on details, does it actually support emulating the same hardware as vmware? I'd assume no to the vmxnet devices but Intel E1000? Adaptec SCSI adapters? Similar USB and VGA? A lot of the vendor-provided OVAs cut out a bunch of hardware support with the assumption that they only need to support vmware emulated hardware.