7 ms·
Google significantly reduces recaptcha free tier, introduces new pricing models
- benconf 3y ago[dead]
- gs17 3y agoI'm surprised they didn't just kill it outright if the data is no longer worth providing a reasonable price (hCaptcha seems to offer 1 million free still, Cloudflare claims unlimited use).
- gruez 3y agoGoogle uses it internally, so they probably can't kill it outright. Might as well make some money from clueless enterprises while they're sunsetting it.
- vesrah 3y agoIs there an official source for this yet?
- gs17 3y agoI got an email with exactly the content they described, didn't have a link to any page about this.
- singlepaynews 3y agoThe text of the email I received (I assume you got something similar): Dear -snip-, Starting April 1, 2024, we will be expanding existing features and providing additional pricing options for Google reCAPTCHA product tiers. What do you need to know? Starting April 1, 2024, the following price changes will be available with Google reCAPTCHA: Inclusion of transaction protection in reCAPTCHA Enterprise and a price reduction from $40 to $1 per 1,000 assessments. reCAPTCHA Enterprise will also include 10,000 no-cost assessments per month instead of 1 million. Addition of reCAPTCHA Standard for bot protection at $8/month for up to 100,000 assessments per month. Renaming of the reCAPTCHA no-cost product to reCAPTCHA Lite, providing protection for up to 10,000 instead of 1 million assessments per month. We will continue to provide 1 million no-cost reCAPTCHA Enterprise assessments per month to eligible Nonprofits, Charities, and Libraries. What do you need to do? Please complete the following actions based on your Google reCAPTCHA product tier: Existing reCAPTCHA Enterprise customers on a subscription contract: Nothing changes until your next renewal date. If your renewal date is after April 1, 2024, you will have the option to renew into the new reCAPTCHA Enterprise product. Existing reCAPTCHA Enterprise customers on a pay-as-you-go model: You will be automatically upgraded to the new reCAPTCHA Enterprise product after April 1, 2024. Please monitor your usage and make sure your new monthly bill is as expected at the end of April 2024. reCAPTCHA Classic (Non-Enterprise) customers: No action is required from you. You can upgrade to reCAPTCHA Standard or reCAPTCHA Enterprise to use the additional features. Eligible Nonprofits: Sign up for a Google for Nonprofits account to activate your non-profit subscription. Your affected projects are below: -snip- Thank you for choosing Google reCAPTCHA. —The Google reCAPTCHA Team
- gs17 3y agoYes, that's the same email.
- nathanaldensr 3y agoSo now that Google has extracted all that free labor to train their algorithms, they begin to close the spigot. I don't care, really. reCAPTCHA and the like can't die fast enough.
- SllX 3y agoFor the number I fill out in a week, Google should be paying me for the labor. Please, spike that price as high as you like. In fact go ahead and reduce the free allocation to zero while you’re at it.
- NotSammyHagar 3y agoI'm tired of picking motorcycles, busses, stairs and bicycles. Someone please clarify if you are supposed to pick the squares next to the object if they only have a tiny bit of the object there. And the actual process often fails to load some part of the picture, so then you have to refresh and start over. You can never just refresh the current 'test image'. I had captchas, because I figure the spammers have worked around them, and they constantly waste my time.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Someone please clarify if you are supposed to pick the squares next to the object if they only have a tiny bit of the object there. I dunno, I intentionally pick the wrong items in the second Captcha challenge to poison their ML dataset, as Google's not paying me to be their forced-labor mechanical Turk, and I hope everyone does the same. Suck it Google, you trillion dollar cheapskate, pay for your damn labor.
- paradox460 3y agoBack when they were using the two word ones, a common meme on the internet was to put a swear or epithet as the second word.
- greatgib 3y agoAwesome! I'm doing that also but I was thinking that I was kind of an exception. I'm happy to know that others are doing the same!
- mikecoles 3y agoI do as well. If anything looks remotely similar to what I'm providing the free labor for classifying, I make sure to click that in the tiniest of hopes it does mess up their training.
- addandsubtract 3y agoGood, let it die. ReCAPTCHA is probably the worst captcha service available, anyway. God forbid if you're on a VPN.
- righthand 3y agoI just type the wrong thing in the audio captcha option. Works like a charm. “politicians say that the industry” == “stalled morticians pay for the mystery”
- 0xy 3y agoCloudflare Turnstile is a free alternative, and there's also hCaptcha as a freemium alternative. ReCAPTCHA is not effective if your users are any way motivated.
- acdha 3y agoAlso reCAPTCHA’s error rate is through the roof now. My nephew was unable to open a Steam account because it was erroneously rejecting correct responses and, of course, there’s no way to report this which won’t be ignored unless you can raise a fuss on social media or know someone who works at Google.
- askvictor 3y agoSince switching from Chrom{e|ium} to Firefox, I'm noticing I'm having to fill in a _lot_ more captchas - is this just me, a coincidence, or is Google treating Firefox as less trustworthy?
- nawgz 3y agoGoogle? Using its market position and suite of products to undermine competitors? How dare you imply they would partake in such unbecoming behavior.
- AlienRobot 3y agoiirc many bots use Firefox UA string as their own.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoWhy would they do that? Chrome is far more popular and therefore a better spoofing target
- screamingninja 3y agoThat's the punishment for ad-blocking and/or tracking mitigations.
- askvictor 3y agoI was running ublock origin on Chrome previously (as I am now on FF), but getting many more captchas on FF.
- TechRemarker 3y agoGet the requests all the time in Safari, but when using Chrome almost never. But most likely since in Safari, have all the anti tracking enabled as well.
- sjwhevvvvvsj 3y agoChrome is spyware to begin with; they know if you’re a bot out of the gate. Captcha is redundant to the deeper spying Google does at this point. Likewise captcha is useless against multimodal LLM available to anybody, many of which can be run locally. I see this as a tacit admission captcha is a dead technology more than anything.
- js4ever 3y agoAfter doing the same for Google maps few years they just did it again. It's beyond me that anyone would use Google/GCP for anything serious. Services killed all the time (check Google graveyard), sdk and APIs constantly deprecated, prices increases, ... It seems google is doing everything wrong since at least a decade now.
- sct202 3y agoI think it is a good reminder that with these services you can design your own usage around making it easy to switch providers. With maps it was a rude awakening, but there were so many other providers by the time they did the rug pull that at least there were places you could go. The ride might not last forever but you can take the API savings now while building and testing backup sources.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoGoogle continuing to forge ahead with the drug-dealer business model... Seriously Google, are you trying to convince even yourselves that you are just IBM with slightly better food? I mean, this change just reeks of "we're out of ideas but the bean counters told us we need to find change in the couch somewhere".
- hot_gril 3y agoTheir motto was "don't be evil," which translated to "don't take profits too early." Now they're in the profit-taking stage.
- m00x 3y agoSundar is doing to Google what Steve Ballmer did to MSFT.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoJoke's on him. Steve Blamer has an estimated net worth of 120 billion while Sundar is estimate "only" at 1.6 billion. He could afford to hire Sundar as his pool boy. He probably also has car who's doors open like this, not like this.
- reactordev 3y agoHe’ll be a quatro comas member before too long. Not tres, quatro…
- ipsum2 3y agoThat comparison doesn't make much sense, since Ballmer made his money by holding on to Microsoft stock after he left.
- frfl 3y agoAs a visual aid for readers, car who's doors open like \|/, not like [|] https://youtu.be/0oV4IVy8tvE?t=66 https://youtu.be/0oV4IVy8tvE?t=66
- G0lDR0ger 3y agoDoesn't look like the reCAPTCHA pricing page (https://cloud.google.com/recaptcha-enterprise/pricing https://cloud.google.com/recaptcha-enterprise/pricing) has been updated to reflect this.
- malermeister 3y agoWait, Google wants to be paid for having other people train their AI?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoQuestion: reCAPTCHA prevents automated browsing but does it allow Google through?
- gs17 3y agoAccording to the Google video linked on this page: https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-cant-see-content-behind-captchas/421202/ https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-cant-see-content-... , "Googlebot doesn’t fill out any captchas. Even if they are Google-based captchas we don’t fill them out." That's from 2021, no idea if they changed it since then, and it probably works okay with reCAPTCHA v3.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThat seems specially worded. Would it need to fill them out to be allowed through? reCAPTCHA is served from Google servers and the Googlebot is on Google servers so couldn't they just report the Googlebot as human?
- nerdjon 3y agoAnd yet people still try to convince me that google's reputation is unwarranted and that relying on Google Cloud is perfectly fine since somehow it's "Different". It never ceases to amaze me how often google shoots themselves in the foot and just ruins their reputation. I cannot imagine relying on anything from google as a business. It just isn't worth the risk.
- SushiHippie 3y agoDoes google reCAPTCHA have anything that other captcha solutions dont? Or what will stop people from using cheaper/free alternatives?
- someotherperson 3y agoIf you use anything other than their offering, and the Google bot gets hit with a captcha, Google won't crawl the page. They give themselves an exception with their own offering.
- kevincox 3y agoIn pretty sure that most major CAPTCHA services exclude the Google bot.
- tonymet 3y agoIt’s funny to me how often the “first one’s free (or cheap) “ playbook gets used on Amazon, AirBNB, Uber, Netflix, Google, Facebook (with FB API), Datadog , Splunk – and still continues to work. Create a service and run it at a loss subsidized by investor funding. Customers & Partners naturally adopt it because it’s cheap in the short term and they lack long term thinking. Kill all competition. Once the customers/partners are hooked, and the competition is gone, jack up the prices . Even massive businesses & consultants with actuaries fall prey to this, including hotels, movie studios, fortune 500s. Just remember there’s no free lunch. If something is free or cheap then they are getting you hooked.
- skybrian 3y agoSeems like the lesson is to take advantage of free stuff (or low prices) while you can? Nothing lasts forever, but they got some good years out of it. (Looks like reCaptcha started in 2007.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hot_gril 3y agoNot always best, but in this case, yeah getting several years of free captchas would be worth. And it's not too hard to switch elsewhere if needed.
- mey 3y agoBeen exceptionally wary of Atlassian's free beta products recently because of this.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI think there is a very different dynamic from what Google is doing and what some of those other companies are doing. For example, I'm not aware that AirBNB significantly changed their commission rates at all. I know originally lots of hosts weren't requiring taxes, for example, but that's really a very different thing. Similarly, I don't have as much of a problem if a company charges X per instance of something and then over time raises rates to, say, 1.25 * X. What Google does, though, is charge 0 for X instances of something, and then say "we're providing additional pricing options" by now charging 0 for only 0.01 * X, but then everything else has a much higher per-instance cost. They also do this with products where the switching costs are relatively high. That's much different than just saying "Oh well, I'll cancel my Netflix subscription because they raised the rates by 25%".
- calmworm 3y agoGoogle is more and more useless by the day. I use a VPN and I get a captcha challenge with every search, but that’s not all, I still get blocked with a message saying something to the effect of “we’ve noticed unusual traffic so we’re blocking you anyway” and I just can’t use Google at all.
- seydor 3y agoAt what point do they start charging for all Gmail?
- 20after4 3y agoThat's exactly what I was thinking. If they started charging $5 per gigabyte of gmail storage with 10MB of free storage they would instantly rake in a lot of money while simultaneously pissing off 20% of the world (total guess at gmail's market share).
- danpalmer 3y agoLooks like reCAPTCHA Enterprise is increasing in price for orgs up to 1.02475m impressions per month, but decreasing for everyone above that. Reducing the sticker price from $40 to $1 per thousand could be transformational for some businesses. For big users, this seems great. For medium sized users – 10k to 1m impressions – this sucks, but for many will only suck to the tune of $8/m. Users between 100k and 1m who haven't been paying the $40/k this is tricky, but I wonder how many are in that category.
- jsnell 3y agoThe email seems confusing on this point. As far as I can tell, most Recaptcha features already cost $1 per thousand uses. The $40/k -> $1/k reduction applies only to the "transaction protection" feature.
- danpalmer 3y agoAh! Thank you, that does make sense. In that case this sounds like it won't be cheaper for anyone, but that in absolute terms there's a cap of $990/m for users right at the top end of the previously free allowance, and the $8/m plan for 100k impressions will probably account for many users.
- 20after4 3y agoGoing from free to $990 is a huge price hike.
- danpalmer 3y agoSure, but going from $5000 to $5990 isn't that interesting a price hike. Without knowing the distribution of customers it's really hard to say how impactful this really is. I'd guess that the majority of users fall into the <10k bucket, that there's a group of SMEs in the 10k-1m bucket that the $8/m pricing is intended to support, and that for enterprises the price reduction of the premium product will often entirely offset the loss of the 1m free impressions.
- rtcode_io 3y agoHappily using Cloudflare Turnstile! Works like a charm.
- Ferret7446 3y agoI see 70 comments but I don't see anyone saying the obvious yet. Google provided captcha as a service. Previously, the service was paid for by the user providing training for AI. This is equivalent to Google charging the website a few cents per X captcha, and the site providing a Google Opinions or similar where the user gets a simple task/question that is solved for a few cents credit. The user solves the task/question and pays a few cents to the site so the site can pay for the captcha service. The arrangement was strictly a win-win because the user would have to solve the captcha anyway. recaptcha hasn't provided value in terms of training data for a long time now, years/decades before the most recent LLM boom AFAIU, so Google was providing the captcha service at a loss. Now they're asking to actually be paid. Likely, Google is buckling down on its financials, like many other tech companies (and the layoffs are a similar symptom)
- aitchnyu 3y agoTangential, has anybody switched to the proof of work open source captchas and happy with it?
- ryandvm 3y agoAs AI models continue to progress, I have a hard time seeing how captchas will stick around. GPT-4 can surely already answer which squares have traffic lights in them faster and more accurately than I can. What is the future of captchas? Reverse captchas - where only a human could do such a crappy job?