9 ms·
An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's plane may have found it
- zelos 3y agoSurely to search a plane have to have already found it?
- Arainach 3y agoNonsense. For instance, I do a search every morning for "tomorrow's winning lottery numbers" on several search engines and haven't found them yet.
- lainga 3y agofor
- echelon 3y agoTangent - wouldn't it be absolutely fantastical (and perhaps scary) if we could break the deterministic universe? Time travel movies about sending people and things never made sense to me. To receive information from the future alone would be all you needed. Not only could you get stock prices or a lead on innovation, but you could also perhaps perform instantaneous, constant time computation of any function. And you'd have perfect foresight of anyone trying to disrupt you and take away your advantage. But then maybe the future sends instructions for a machine that destroys you. Or it could be even simpler - it knows where to send you to die. So maybe you can't trust what it tells you at all. It has all the time to plan around your choices, and if you're still listening in any capacity it can coerce you to do its bidding. Wild science fiction ideas searching for novelization, I suppose.
- 1024core 3y agoBruce Willis starred in one such movie, "Looper".
- lb1lf 3y agoArguably in two - 12 Monkeys, too...
- asystole 3y agoThe 2004 indie film Primer is a very good take on this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mikestew 3y agoReminds me of DirecTv’s Black Sunday[0]: the future machine gives you all the pieces you need to build the machine that, as the final puzzle piece is put into place, explodes and kills you. [0] https://blog.codinghorror.com/revisiting-the-black-sunday-hack/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/revisiting-the-black-sunday-ha...
- dllthomas 3y agoNot quite the same thing, but https://qntm.org/causal https://qntm.org/causal is related.
- Sunspark 3y agoThe reason time travel movies don't make sense, while absolutely lots of fun to watch, is because the Sun is travelling through space. If you were to hypothetically build a time machine and set it for any given year, you would materialize in a hard vacuum. So, you need more than a time machine, you also need a spacecraft to be able to fly to where the Earth's previous position is. Chemical propulsion won't do it, you need something with significant velocity and energy. Unless of course, you are able to enter specific astronomical coordinates to appear in and match velocities. Would suck if you got the coordinates right, but were off on the velocity by 1000 km/hr.
- p1mrx 3y ago> you could also perhaps perform instantaneous, constant time computation of any function See the first section of HPMOR chapter 17: https://hpmor.com/chapter/17 https://hpmor.com/chapter/17
- paulddraper 3y agoThe article title currently says "for"
- kylebenzle 3y agoThere would be hundreds of WWII planes in that area that would be indifferentiable from what Mr. Tony Romeo says he's looking for. More likey he's just looking to fund his retirement hobby.
- OJFord 3y agoThat's what I thought, not even WW2 specifically, but (and I'm no expert) the image supposedly showing 'the distinctive shape of the fuselage, tail, and wings' is not that compelling? To paraphrase Jaws: it certainly looks like an aircraft, but not the aircraft. It could be! Wings broken off/up a bit. But is it that likely? It could also be some other aircraft. Seems a bit sensationalist until they go back for a better look.
- wharvle 3y agoMaybe. Looks to be a bit (... by Pacific standards, so, hundreds of miles) off the Easternmost part of the Pacific that would have seen lots of air traffic in the war, which should leave it relatively clear, but I may be wrong. [EDIT] I still doubt it's the plane, but this area may be far less-cluttered with 1930s-40s aircraft wreckage than others, is all I mean.
- ianburrell 3y agoHowland island was pretty far from the fighting in WW2. The Phoenix Islands were not used by the military. All the fighting was to the west or the north (Hawaii).
- HumblyTossed 3y agoAir Force pays goooood[0]. But seriously: >> but then we're thinking: 'How do we lift the plane? How do we salvage it?'" Don't. Just leave it. Be happy it was found, but just be respectful and leave it. [0] Yes, I RTFA.
- deadbabe 3y agoIt can be raised respectfully.
- yardstick 3y agoProbably can. Should it though? Like the Titanic, maybe we just let it rest in peace? Send a sub down to confirm what it is. Then maybe update a few of the monuments to her to indicate her final resting place has been found… My only concern would be looters. If it is quite feasible to access “easily” then yeah maybe we should recover it just to protect against looters and pillagers.
- not-my-account 3y agoThe titanic is massssive, making raising it a much more difficult challenge compared to raising a single aircraft.
- notbeuller 3y agoThere was a rather silly 1976 thriller “Raise the Titanic!” predating it’s actual discovery by about 10 years. They made a movie from it too in 1980. Based on a premise that there was something valuable the government wanted on board)
- RegBarclay 3y agoThen Arthur Clarke wrote "The Ghost from the Grand Banks" in 1990 (after Ballard discovered it was in pieces) with a slightly more plausible approach to raising the bow. The wreck has deteriorated now to the point where raising it would probably destroy more than what would be recovered.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoIn a surprise twist, when they explore it in detail, it turns out to be MH 370.
- georgeecollins 3y agoThat's what I was thinking. Someday I or my kids will read about finding MH370. Will they put that in a museum?
- rand1239 3y agoNo because it's not mysterious anymore. Also not many museums in the world that can fit one.
- bell-cot 3y agoI - Howland Island (near which they seemingly found this wreckage) is in the Central Pacific Ocean. Vs. MH370 seems sure to have gone down in the Central-ish Indian Ocean. II - If they have even the vaguest sense of scale from their image - MH370 was a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_777-200ER https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_777-200ER. Vs. Earhart was flying a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_10E https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_10E. There is a ~10X difference in wing area, and ~50X difference in weight.
- CommieBobDole 3y agoThe interesting thing about this is that it doesn't appear to involve TIGHAR at all. TIGHAR, for those unfamiliar, are the people who pop up every few years with tantalizing new evidence that certainly will prove once and for all some novel theory about Earhart's disappearance and raises a couple of million dollars to mount an expedition which of course reveals nothing but some tantalizing new evidence that requires a new expensive expedition to investigate. So, there might be something to this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RajT88 3y agoI seem to recall these guys. Last time I read an article about them, it read like they were in cahoots with the government of Kiribati to promote tourism. Fun read though!
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoFor others curious about the acronym: The International Group for Historic Aircraft Recovery, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TIGHAR https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TIGHAR
- Kon-Peki 3y agoI have no idea how to interpret that sonar image. Am I supposed to see what looks like an airplane when viewed from above? Because the Lockheed Electra didn't have swept-back wings. I don't think any airplane had swept-back wings until the 1950s.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoCould it be either sonar distortion or that the wings were damaged in the crash? Speaking of which, it looks pretty intact, which means (armchair air crash specialist here) it wouldn't have crashed but done an emergency landing on the water.
- jlbooker 3y agoThat would match with the leading mis-navigation theory. She and her navigator were fine and healthy, as was the plane. They were looking for the island to land on, but had messed up the navigation and were sufficiently off-course. There were US Navy boats in the area of the island that heard their radio calls. There was no emergency -- they just reported to be searching for the land that they should've found. Presumably they flew until they ran out of fuel and likely set it down in the water as gently as possible.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jncfhnb 3y agoThere’s literally a side by side diagram showing you how to look at. Not that your wings comment is wrong.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoHa, I clearly didn't scroll far enough. Thanks :)
- entangledqubit 3y agoStill, seeing as how I don't look at these kinds of images all day it's really hard for me to gauge if the sea floor is littered with false positive images that may seem to be a good match. I could also imagine a true match to also have some other confounding blob attached to it. It'd be nice to have some kind of score to summarize that aspect.
- whycome 3y agoTitle reaction: How much does an 'Air Force Officer' make?! Answer: > But Romeo, a former real-estate investor who sold commercial properties to raise the $11 million needed to begin funding the search, returned in December from a roughly 100-day voyage at sea with a sonar image that he believes shows the lost plane in the ocean's depths. (Also, article title uses 'former air force officer')
- wharvle 3y ago20 years in + take retirement + also work for a government contractor at 3x+ your former pay rate (while collecting retirement!), can equal a lot of money in a hurry at a relatively young age (say, money to fund a real estate investment venture without risking being penniless in old age).
- FireBeyond 3y ago> government contractor at 3x+ your former pay rate And then some. Friend of mine rode backseat in F-15s. After retirement, he spent two-three years as a contractor for Boeing training allied military in the Middle East and paid off his mortgage, and much much more (I want to say at least 1, maybe 2 investment properties owned effectively outright).
- wharvle 3y agoYeah, the "+" is doing some heavy lifting there :-) 3x is what you can basically just fall into after military retirement without trying very hard, with a bad network, and with poor luck. Another factor is that your expenses can be quite low while you're in, even with a family. Put an officer's salary on top of that—which isn't amazing, but isn't terrible either—and you can save a fair bit of cash even before you even start the contractor + retirement double-dipping. Though there are real costs—the schools are generally very good, but you may have to move every couple years. The bureaucracy is hellish (though, for all their dysfunction, they've got a lot of shit figured out way better than your average bigco). You'll probably serve under and with some real assholes at some point. And there's ever the temptation to get out early and start taking those sweet contractor dollars before you secure the government retirement check. Plus, you know, you may have to go kill people or get killed or what have you. [EDIT] Oh, another downside: it can be really hard for your spouse to have a career, due to all the moving and often living in places without much economic opportunity.
- karaterobot 3y agoRelevant search: this presumed plane is at 16,500 feet of depth, and the record for deep sea salvage is, according to a quick search, about 19,000 feet. I had wondered whether it was feasible on the face of it to try salvaging this plane, and it may be. No comment on the advisability.
- fred_is_fred 3y agoHow would/could you distinguish this from any of the hundreds or maybe thousands of planes that went down during WW2 in the Pacific? Assuming it's even a plane.
- jandrese 3y agoI think the author is excited because he found the plane in roughly the area he expected to find it if she was thrown off course by an instrumentation fault that occurs when crossing the international date line. Also, it was about the right shape. Also, it wasn't near the fighting in WWII, and the shape doesn't match that of WWII carrier aircraft. I'll be more excited when they get out there with a deep sea probe and take some photographs.
- rconti 3y agoFrom the source linked in another comment: (edit, ugh, I hate HN formatting, can never get it right even after all these years) ---- One piece of good news for Romeo’s search is that there are probably very few other planes anywhere near Howland. An airstrip was built on Howland in the 1930s in anticipation of commercial trans-Pacific flights, but Earhart was going to be the first to actually use it. During the war it was bombed by the Japanese to prevent its use, and that’s the extent of its aviation history. None of the WWII air-sea battles were fought in the vicinity, and it’s much too remote for general aviation planes to ever go near. ---- https://briandunning.substack.com/p/i-remain-very-guarded-about-the-new https://briandunning.substack.com/p/i-remain-very-guarded-ab...
- wolverine876 3y agoWho is Brian Dunning and what do they know about the subject?
- NikkiA 3y agoHe's wrong because that is an area that the USN actively did carrier training in from 1945 to today, and lots of planes ended up in the ocean after missing a landing, a take-off failure, or just because the pilot had to bail for whatever reason. Heck, during the evacuation of Hanoi they were pushing perfectly good jets into the ocean just to clear enough room for helicopters and the odd cessna, but that would have been further west. https://theaviationgeekclub.com/that-time-a-south-vietnamese-o-1-bird-dog-landed-aboard-uss-midway/ https://theaviationgeekclub.com/that-time-a-south-vietnamese...
- maplet 3y ago> Roughly a month into the trip, the team captured a sonar image of the plane-shaped object about 100 miles from Howland Island — but didn't discover the image in the submersible's data until the 90th day of the voyage, making it impractical to turn back to get a closer look. To be a skeptic, this sounds like confirmation bias.
- gleenn 3y agoOr maybe the computer they had analyzing the data takes a while to search and it had nothing to do with people at all.
- Sniffnoy 3y ago> The theory, which Romeo relied on partly to guide his search, suggests that when Earhart crossed over the international dateline during her 20-hour flight, her navigation system became inaccurate and misdirected her by about 60 miles, potentially leading to a tragic end. How would this happen? It's not like her plane would have contained a misprogrammed computer.
- ciscoriordan 3y agoAn electrical issue could cause a gauge to misreport. E.g. vibrations cause a bad ground.
- Sniffnoy 3y agoAn electrical issue wouldn't be caused by crossing the international date line.
- dtgriscom 3y agoMaybe the Bermuda Triangle is on walkabout?
- WalterBright 3y agoCrossing the equator causes the sun to flip around and go the other way in the sky. Source: When I went to Australia, the sun went the wrong way. It was curiously unsettling.
- Jgrubb 3y agoGoogle brings me here - http://www.datelinetheory.com/p/time-and-celestial-navigation.html http://www.datelinetheory.com/p/time-and-celestial-navigatio...
- chernevik 3y agoProbably a polite way of saying she screwed up. She had a reputation as an indifferent navigator and aviator which is consistently downplayed.
- CSMastermind 3y agoTo quote Brian Dunning of Skeptoid: > The biggest secret of the Amelia Earhart mystery is that there is no mystery, and never has been. The USCG Itasca was on station at Howland and in partial radio contact with Earhart when she and Fred Noonan ran out of fuel and ditched after having slightly overshot the island in the dawn lighting conditions. The USN and USCG analyzed their data and identified this area as where the plane went down... > So the best news about Tony Romeo’s find is that he’s looking in the right place, unlike the TV networks and the random crackpots whose claims they promote. Romeo hasn’t divulged the exact location, for obvious reasons; but his location has the endorsement of Dorothy Cochrane, a curator in the aeronautics department of the Smithsonian Institution’s National Air and Space Museum. She knows where the USN and USCG have said where the plane is, so that tells me Romeo is probably right. https://briandunning.substack.com/p/i-remain-very-guarded-about-the-new https://briandunning.substack.com/p/i-remain-very-guarded-ab...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rconti 3y agoI was curious, but the link doesn't elaborate on how much is known about the "ran out of fuel and ditched after having slightly overshot the island" -- whether that's all fact, or partially fact, or all speculation.
- CSMastermind 3y agoHere's the US Navy's full report: https://catalog.archives.gov/id/305240 https://catalog.archives.gov/id/305240 Which references the radio logs from the day of the disappearance: https://catalog.archives.gov/id/6210268 https://catalog.archives.gov/id/6210268 tl;dr we know they overshot the island and were running a search pattern for it while running out of fuel because they told the radio operator on the other end as much. The only question is what specifically happened (did they manage to get life rafts out, etc.
- Apocryphon 3y agoSo like the fate of the Roanoke colony, the cause of the Tunguska explosion, the Dyatlov Pass incident, the explanation is what's right in front of everyone?
- qxfys 3y agoCan we do the same with MH370? I've got a classmate inside that plane. His family has been deprived of any form of closure or peace regarding his fate.
- stirlo 3y agoAround $150 million was spent searching including with high resolution sonar[1]. But obviously nothing was found. The area they're searching is far larger unfortunately. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Search_for_Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_370#Contribution_to_geophysics_and_oceanography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Search_for_Malaysia_Airlines_F...
- ianburrell 3y agoA company, Ocean Infinity, is continuig searching with robots.
- chasd00 3y agoiirc when it was missing there was a lot of wild speculation and then someone (maybe it was on twitter) discretely said it was on the bottom of the ocean at some location i can't remember and nothing else. The conclusion was this person was from some three letter agency and knew exactly where it was because of all the listening devices in the various oceans hunting for submarines. They(agency) will never say where it is because it exposes their capability. I think a similar thing happened when that submarine imploded on the way to the titanic.
- GenerWork 3y agoIs there a screenshot of this Twitter post?
- wolverine876 3y ago> The conclusion Whose conclusion? On what basis?
- codezero 3y agoThey readily shared the implosion detection data with search and rescue teams.
- pfdietz 3y agoThis is likely Earhart's plane, as it has a fuselage and two wings. Also, I am likely the Pope, because like the Pope I have two arms and two legs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 0xDEADFED5 3y agohere you go, you earned it! https://discordia.fandom.com/wiki/Pope_cards https://discordia.fandom.com/wiki/Pope_cards
- dreamcompiler 3y ago> the object, which rests more than 16,500 feet beneath the surface So 4000 feet deeper than the Titanic.
- Izkata 3y agoSo around 400 miles* from where (likely) her bones and shoes were found? https://www.npr.org/1998/12/02/1032135/bones-shoes-may-have-been-amelia-earharts https://www.npr.org/1998/12/02/1032135/bones-shoes-may-have-... https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/08/591950171/new-research-claims-bones-found-80-years-ago-on-pacific-atoll-likely-amelia-earh https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/08/591950171... * Eyeballing it on Google Maps, distance from Howland island to Nikumaroro island
- justinclift 3y agoDoesn't the mention of titanium here seem wrong? If the Electra had been built of other metals, say aluminum and titanium, there wouldn’t be anything left but free atoms floating around. Titanium is supposed to be resistant to corrosion in seawater due to the oxide layer that forms: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.5301/jabfm.5000387 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.5301/jabfm.5000387 Titanium is reported to be highly resistant to general corrosion in seawater. ... These properties make titanium suitable for a variety of applications involving seawater, starting from thin-walled heat exchanger tubing, with consequent good heat transfer properties, up to submarine hulls, ships, platforms, desalination plants, salt production evaporators and water jet propulsion systems.
- BarbaryCoast 3y agoIf he's "searching Earhart's plane", doesn't that imply that he's found it? Or is he searching a plane he _thinks_ was Earhart's, trying to find confirmation from the contents of it? On the other hand, if he's "searching FOR Earhart's plane", this contradiction resolves itself.
- RecycledEle 3y agoLike dozens or hundreds of others before him, this guy thinks he has found her plane. Good luck to him, but I doubt he really found it.
- amai 3y agoSince the journalist doesn’t seem to know about metric units: The plane was found at 16,500 feet = 5.029 km beneath the surface of the sea.
- boilerupnc 3y agoNice background story on Earhart from my alma mater, Purdue University. [0] Boilerup! [0] https://stories.purdue.edu/amelia-earhart-aviator-legend-boilermaker/ https://stories.purdue.edu/amelia-earhart-aviator-legend-boi...