5 ms·
> why would anyone undertake such revealing and labour-intensive deceptions? It’s totally about personal satisfaction. We need to “scratch an itch.” The thrill
by ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago
> why would anyone undertake such revealing and labour-intensive deceptions?
It’s totally about personal satisfaction. We need to “scratch an itch.” The thrill we get from “getting away with it,” is also a big part of the equation.
Many stories are embellished, along the way, by people involved in the oral tradition. Some, become almost unrecognizable, after a few generations. These folks often do it, to “add spice,” for entertainment value.
I’ve come to learn that most folks that “front,” are often doing so, in order to personally feel better; not harm others. It’s not healthy, but often, doesn’t result in much harm to anyone else. I’ve learned to relax, when I encounter it, and sometimes, even enjoy it.
Very many folks have terrible self-esteem, and develop coping mechanisms, which can sometimes be quite destructive, but, more often, are just energy sinks.
I have learned to be cautious, though, and not take things at face value, which can be difficult, if I don’t want to become a bitter cynic.
- jhbadger 3y agoExactly, It's like the people who created false Wikipedia pages (complete with seemingly valid references). Maybe the first time someone did that there was a point -- showing how such an article could get past the mods as a wake up call to improve scrutiny. But certainly the thrill of "getting away with it" is probably the real motivation.
- Tao3300 3y agoIt was a sad day when I learned Scots Wikipedia was pretty much entirely fake.
- executesorder66 3y agoThe harm to others is the broken trust. Every time someone willing spreads misinformation it makes people think less of other people and life in general. The fact that we are reading about this now, shows that people were negatively affected by it. It wasn't a harmless activity. People should be called out for intentionally spreading misinformation, and they should feel bad about it, and people shouldn't trust anything they say again for a very long time. Don't feel sorry for these assholes, and don't let them get away with it, because that encourages them to continue this sort of behavior.
- virgildotcodes 3y agoFor the sake of argument, teaching people to be skeptical in this low stakes context might not be the worst thing.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago> broken trust That's the thing. If we don't trust, or accept that trust may not be merited, then there's nothing to break. I know some outrageous characters. Many, are decent folks, in their way, but I wouldn't trust them to handle any kind of meaningful responsibility. But I enjoy having them in my life, and have no intentions of driving them away, or avoiding them. I have a cat. He's a great little guy. But if I pick him up, and I don't make him feel secure, he will scratch me. He doesn't want to hurt me, but he needs to dig into something to feel secure; even if that "something" is my chest. It's possible to have relationships with folks that have no boundaries, and we need to maintain our own boundaries, ourselves, as opposed to rely on others, to respect them. That said, we also don't need to defend our boundaries with nukes. Often, a simple "No, I don't want to do that." is sufficient, as opposed to "This is bear spray! Stay away!".
- executesorder66 3y ago> That's the thing. If we don't trust, or accept that trust may not be merited, then there's nothing to break. Yeah but to get to that point you have to break the trust you had in them or people in general, so my point remains. Or did you from the day of your birth assume everyone is lying to you about everything?
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI guess we'll not come to agreement, here. Let's just say that I have spent my entire adult life, in close relationships with some of the most untrustworthy S.O.B.s on earth, and have learned to deal with it. Many folks think, because I am friendly, open, and kind, that I'm weak, naive, and gullible. They tend to get quite upset, when they find out, that's not the case.
- akudha 3y agoI wonder how much of History can we trust? After all, history is written by victors. Something that was written a thousand years ago (or longer) - how can we verify? In today’s world, how much of Netflix “documentaries” are rigorously researched and how much just made up, to save time and money? It is not like Netflix is going to get in trouble, legally or in public opinion…
- emayljames 3y agoDare I say the bible comes to mind
- beezlewax 3y agoThis is my number one reason not to trust anything hawkers of religion state. And paradoxically I trust new religious manuscripts even less. In the context of the modern world they just seem like obvious hoaxes.
- wharvle 3y agoGetting to watch things like Mormonism (and, to some extent, Scientology, though that's a bit of a different beast) develop under conditions that provide pretty good records and a variety of disinterested accounts, has definitely been instructive for interpreting plausible courses of development of older religions. "Why would all these people lie?" "Why would so many people attest to having seen something that was actually bullshit? It must have happened!" Well... I mean, you'd think so, but not so much, it turns out.
- otteromkram 3y agoWe could probably add in any religious documents. Islam, Buddhism, Judaism, etc. But, that wouldn't fit the, "Christianity bad" narrative.
- pfdietz 3y agoSure it would. It's just that the others are also bad.
- jt2190 3y ago> It’s not healthy, but often, doesn’t result in much harm to anyone else. Let’s not forget that the readers are also willing participants in this, and their willingness to believe “half-truths” is what keeps the whole thing going. Edit: You advice to be skeptical is, in my mind, healthier if the reader also is very aware of whether they’re entertaining themselves or trying to educate themselves, and if they’re trying to educate themselves, work hard to seek out the highest quality sources of information, i.e. not Atlas Obscura.
- dwighttk 3y agoThere’s an interesting film: Shattered Glass (2004) That explores this… looking at a fabulist working for a website in the late 90s early 2000s somewhere in there.