8 ms·
A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura
- verisimi 3y ago[flagged]
- IHEARTANAL 3y ago> In my opinion, the individual is best off ignoring all of it, _and dealing with their actual lives_, rather than taking any of the distracting and manipulative stories seriously. Yes, yes, and yes. And now observe how many clickbait and fear-mongering articles people tend to react to. Don't gey sidetracked by topics pushed by other people.
- 082349872349872 3y agoOne way to get useful signal is to ask oneself "Why might $SOURCE want me to read this particular $CLICKBAIT?" (of course, one then gets into the rabbit hole of source attribution, a topic already known to be difficult even before the internet era) see also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39093409 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39093409
- hilux 3y agoIt's very sad, but you're completely right. The Dan Ariely scam (reveal) changed everything for me. But it's clear, he's not special at all. A good moment to remember Gell-Mann Amnesia.
- verisimi 3y agoThank you for sharing about the Dan Ariely scam. From his wiki: > Ariely is the author of the three New York Times best selling books Predictably Irrational, The Upside of Irrationality and The Honest Truth about Dishonesty.[3] He co-produced the 2015 documentary (Dis)Honesty: The Truth About Lies.[4] You have to say, this guy has chutzpah! He's fine to promote himself as a bastion of truth and rationality, and all the while he's making up his studies! Lying through your teeth gets you "three New York Times best selling books"!
- 082349872349872 3y ago> ignoring all of it That's one approach. A different approach would be to encourage people to double check or at least smoke test.
- verisimi 3y agoI say either personally verify it or do not repeat it as true.
- mike_hearn 3y agoThat would be great but the message from government, media and academia is overwhelmingly that people who double check ("do their own research") are fringe crazies who to be mistrusted and ideally silenced. Before getting to the point where people are actively encouraged to double check, we'd have to get to the point where people aren't actively ostracised for it!
- moomin 3y agoThe problem is that skepticism on its own isn't a route to the truth. An embarrassing number of people "doing their own research" are doing on reddit, not e.g. arxiv.
- 082349872349872 3y agoSorry, I had been assuming that the HN readership would assume that double checking tertiary sources involves consulting (at least) secondary sources, secondary sources primary, etc. Just as well-founded loop variants help avoid nontermination, making strictly closer-to-ground double checks helps avoid echo chambers. (and frankly, "do your own research", to me, is a clear sibboleth translating to "enter our echo chamber")
- usrusr 3y agoTrue. Naive skepticism is what lies on the path to "can't see the earth's curvature from an airplane!"
- mike_hearn 3y ago
- MrBuddyCasino 3y ago> There is 'journalism' which is basically propaganda served by AP and Reuters It has always been like this, we're just starting to notice now. The fascinating thing to observe is that they're still continuing to lie as if nothing changed, even though they get called out for it on Twitter via community notes or quote tweets. Not even a reaction, apology or correction. They just continue lying.
- moomin 3y agoNot quite true: it’s amazing how many mainstream media figures have nasty things to say about social media.
- verisimi 3y agoThis is true. And what it tells you, is that they are unapologetic about the lies. They are acting in bad faith. When an honest man discovers he is mistaken, he will either cease being mistaken, or he will cease being honest.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoIts hard to tell sometimes, there are certainly a lot of midwit true believers, and the capacity of man to hold contradicting beliefs at the same time seems boundless. But yeah, at some point one gets really disillusioned.
- verisimi 3y agoBeing disillusioned sounds bad... but it's also necessary to live in truth. You can't be subject to illusions and live in truth.
- somedude895 3y ago> the individual is best off ignoring all of it, and dealing with their actual lives, rather than taking any of the distracting and manipulative stories seriously. Hard to do when you're in school. And yes, there is some serious indoctrination going on, as you mention.
- Angostura 3y ago> In my opinion, the individual is best off ignoring all of it, and dealing with their actual lives, rather than taking any of the distracting and manipulative stories seriously. That’s one way to remain entirely ignorant and unengaged with anything that happens in the world beyond your immediate vicinity. This feels a rather high price to pay to avoid the occasional egregiously fraudulent piece of journalism
- andy99 3y agoI wouldn't say it's best to outright ignore so much as not take seriously, or at least not use for anything actionable. You can read the news and magazines etc. if you find it interesting, just make sure to do some independent verification in line with the importance of any decisions you are making.
- usrusr 3y ago> In my opinion, the individual is best off ignoring all of it, and dealing with their actual lives, rather than taking any of the distracting and manipulative stories seriously. Sounds like the thing Russian propaganda aims for: "we are lying, q.e.d., and if we can get away with that much lying, would you expect others to be much better? Truth does not exist, just pick whatever lie you feel most comfortable with." Looking back at the most egregious lies of the last decade (the Bush/Blair Iraqi WMD deception), I'd say media was pretty good at calling it out as a lie. Unfortunately not successful to the point of tangible consequences, but it's not like anyone really believed them.
- oevi 3y agoThere was a similar scandal surrounding German news magazine „Der Spiegel“ with at least 14 articles fabricated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claas_Relotius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claas_Relotius
- woolion 3y ago>Der Spiegel published the final investigation report in May 2019, concluding that "no indications were found that anyone at DER SPIEGEL was aware of the fabrication, helped cover them up or otherwise participated in them" No worries, no one has bad intentions. They're just thoroughly incompetent.
- somedude895 3y agoThe Relotius scandal was much worse too, since his fabrications were clearly politically motivated. The one in TFA is at least fairly harmless.
- fmajid 3y agoThere is also former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson who, in his former career as “journalist” was fired for fabricating stories about the European Union that contributed to the climate of Euroskepticism that ultimately led to Brexit, and Johnson’s rise to power. Who says crime doesn’t pay?
- kappuchino 3y ago"clearly politically motivated." - interesting, how so? Most of the people I talked about it see his forgeries as "simple" work for awards/compliments: Everything he wrote/reported seemed believable, because it was in range/sync with events/storys/news that actually happened. Again, I'd love to know how to identify his/the political motivation.
- otteromkram 3y agoThe Wikipedia talks about "anti American" narrative, so there's that.
- woolion 3y agoBesides the glaring absence of Claas Relotius, the article lists a number of high-profile journalistic fraud (one that briefly got a Pulitzer prize). It does not go into detail but it does present a relatively fair assessment of how journalism goes back to being dubious, and that journalists as guardians of truth is actually not the historical pattern. It is very surface level on everything though. It does not go into details about what is below the apex of 'outright fabrication' in the journalistic fraud pyramid. Most journalists have always relied on either some extremely rich investor or Government funding and in both cases it is obvious they won't tolerate real independent journalism for their money.
- jacquesm 3y agoThis is very much one of those things that the ridiculous right parrots in order to reduce trust in 'the media'. But the simple truth is that every profession, including journalism, has its rotten apples. But they're a small fraction of the total and in general journalists are the real thing.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> every profession, including journalism, has its rotten apples Referring to a professional person gone to the bad as a "rotten apple", meaning that most of the apples are fine, is a kind of malapropism. The full saying is: "One bad apple spoils the barrel". The claim is that corruption spreads if it is not opposed quickly and throughly. It's an error to use the phrase to minimise the scale or severity of wrongdoing.
- slfnflctd 3y agoThe usage of 'bad apple' which you are describing as incorrect is so widespread now that railing against it is futile. Language sometimes changes in ways we disagree with personally. I understand how you feel, I have the same feeling about how the word 'literally' is now defined as 'figuratively' in some dictionaries. Makes me want to tear my hair out... but the people have spoken.
- moomin 3y agoAnyone else think this dude should write a book of fake articles and market them with the Atlas Obscura story, only their version contains several falsehoods?
- KineticLensman 3y agoThis is the sort-of premise of the UK radio/TV panel show, "The Unbelievable Truth". Contestants take turns to give a brief lecture about a subject, the majority of which is untrue, with four facts smuggled in. The others get points if they can identify the facts, and lose points if they incorrectly identify a falsehood as true.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago> why would anyone undertake such revealing and labour-intensive deceptions? It’s totally about personal satisfaction. We need to “scratch an itch.” The thrill we get from “getting away with it,” is also a big part of the equation. Many stories are embellished, along the way, by people involved in the oral tradition. Some, become almost unrecognizable, after a few generations. These folks often do it, to “add spice,” for entertainment value. I’ve come to learn that most folks that “front,” are often doing so, in order to personally feel better; not harm others. It’s not healthy, but often, doesn’t result in much harm to anyone else. I’ve learned to relax, when I encounter it, and sometimes, even enjoy it. Very many folks have terrible self-esteem, and develop coping mechanisms, which can sometimes be quite destructive, but, more often, are just energy sinks. I have learned to be cautious, though, and not take things at face value, which can be difficult, if I don’t want to become a bitter cynic.
- jhbadger 3y agoExactly, It's like the people who created false Wikipedia pages (complete with seemingly valid references). Maybe the first time someone did that there was a point -- showing how such an article could get past the mods as a wake up call to improve scrutiny. But certainly the thrill of "getting away with it" is probably the real motivation.
- Tao3300 3y agoIt was a sad day when I learned Scots Wikipedia was pretty much entirely fake.
- executesorder66 3y agoThe harm to others is the broken trust. Every time someone willing spreads misinformation it makes people think less of other people and life in general. The fact that we are reading about this now, shows that people were negatively affected by it. It wasn't a harmless activity. People should be called out for intentionally spreading misinformation, and they should feel bad about it, and people shouldn't trust anything they say again for a very long time. Don't feel sorry for these assholes, and don't let them get away with it, because that encourages them to continue this sort of behavior.
- CM30 3y agoHonestly, I'm surprised this hasn't happened more often. The challenge with stories about unusual situations, events and topics is that they're often difficult to verify, and you're relying on the author's word that they've actually done the research. Sites like Atlas Obscura feel like perfect publications for hoaxers because of that. Make up an extremely obscure topic or event, then bet the editors won't bother to do any real fact checking because of said obscurity. It's also the reason that stories about cancelled movies/TV shows, lost scripts, unused content in video games, media that's gone missing in general, etc are so likely to be inaccurate or outright hoaxes; trying to actually verify these stories and get reliable sources is quite the challenge.
- pvaldes 3y agoI knew it! That explains a lot of strange feelings when reading it. I'll admit that I swallowed the stories completely so; a good creative writer, I suppose.
- rexreed 3y agoHow would you know that this article is itself not fake? In this case, disclaimers have been placed on the original article, but that doesn't usually happen. This is the problem with confirmation bias. What if another article came out to reveal that this article was fake? And then recursively on and on. How would you know how to distinguish the reality? I sense most people will believe what they want to believe, and if that be the original article (possibly fake), or the rebuttal article (possibly fake). We have to go entirely on our ability to trust the source.
- mkl 3y agoReminds me of this non-fabricated Atlas Obscura article about a fabricated "largest island in the largest lake on the largest island in the largest lake on the largest island in the largest lake in the world": https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/moose-boulder-debunked https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/moose-boulder-debunked, discussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22674342 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22674342 It debunks an unintentionally untruthful (not fabricated) page that Atlas Obscura used to have.
- B1FF_PSUVM 3y agoSpeaking of fabrications, I have my doubts about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Howel_Evans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Howel_Evans and his Poirot forerunner Jules Poiret ( https://www.goodreads.com/series/149474-jules-poiret https://www.goodreads.com/series/149474-jules-poiret ) Seems a little too pat, popped up a few years ago, never heard of before. The text of the ebooks is respectable, but may give off a whiff of anachronism in places. If anyone in the UK feels like checking a library ...
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- qingcharles 3y agoSurely you can just check eBay, Abebooks and the like?
- B1FF_PSUVM 3y agoLooks pretty sketchy in https://www.librarything.com/search.php?search=Frank+Howel+Evans&searchtype=newwork_titles&sortchoice=0 https://www.librarything.com/search.php?search=Frank+Howel+E... - no library records, etc. Ebay tosses up unrelated baseball cards and comics. Abebooks yields four sketchy hits, e.g. one is "print-on-demand" with a fake pic of a leather binding.
- qingcharles 3y agoI have to agree. This is weird as fuck, honestly. So what you are proposing, and I am perhaps agreeing with, is that someone has created a bunch of random ebooks and then invented a backstory for the fake author?
- plibblr 3y agoInteresting, you might be onto something, the series of books looks plausible and somehow not-quite-right. My local UK library doesn't have any books by that author - https://libraries.hounslow.gov.uk/client/en_GB/hounslow/search/results?qu=frank+howel+evans&te=&lm=HOUNSLOW https://libraries.hounslow.gov.uk/client/en_GB/hounslow/sear... . This one in particular seems too implausible - inspiration for Poirot and Downton Abbey? https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/23309690-down-to-the-abbey https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/23309690-down-to-the-abb... I haven't actually read any of the ebooks mind.
- rsynnott 3y agoThis feels stylistically quite like an Atlas Obscura story, making it rather meta.
- thih9 3y agoYes and I find the style annoying in this case - for a topic like this I’d prefer a wikipedia/readme style structured list of relevant articles, perhaps with dates and a little context.
- Oarch 3y ago...unless this article is entirely false and fabricated! Gotcha.
- mcphage 3y agoI did wonder about that... it would have been pretty clever.
- Oarch 3y agoI knew a chap in the band Teeth. They faked a media storm about how they "hacked the Pope's Twitter account" by guessing the password. But they never did. Then the real media picked up the story. Next day came the real story: no one ever hacked anything. Clever, they got two media storms for the price of one.
- mcphage 3y agoThat is pretty brilliant :-)
- kalleboo 3y agoWith the articles left up but with a disclaimer, it will be interesting to see if the “facts” and “quotes” work their way into LLMs, losing the disclaimer
- hammyhavoc 3y agoEven with a disclaimer, they've already worked their way into factoids touted by human beings and will continue to be. It's an inevitability for LLMs too if it hasn't already happened.
- emayljames 3y agoOh dear, from copilot: The term “Dark Weeks” in the context of the Scottish town of Moffat refers to a volunteer-led initiative where many residents and businesses in Moffat turn off their lighting for two weeks each winter, particularly in the village center1. This is done to reduce light pollution and preserve the wonders of the night sky2. However, public lighting around essential locations like the hospital and firehouse remains on1. It’s worth noting that Moffat is recognized as Europe’s first Dark Sky Town2, and it’s home to the Moffat Community Observatory3, which offers beautiful views of various night sky objects3. This observatory complements the town’s Dark Sky Town status as recognized by the International Dark-Sky Association3. However, an article from Atlas Obscura had to be retracted because it was found that the author fabricated the idea of “dark weeks” in Moffat, and also fabricated interviews with multiple sources1. Therefore, while Moffat is a Dark Sky Town, the specific concept of “Dark Weeks” might not be an officially recognized or widely practiced event. It’s always a good idea to check with local sources or official town information for the most accurate details. Learn more 1 atlasobscura.com 2 visitscotland.com
- kalleboo 3y agoAt least it included the disclaimer! Too bad it was at the end past where anyone will read, it wasn't smart enough to retroactively remove the false info.
- gadders 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dependsontheq 3y agoIn the case of Atlas Obscura I never took the articles very serious, the are all on the border between art, myth and story. I thought that was the appeal. I think something like Atlas Obscura will be the internet of the future, wonderful collections of weirdness, with no way to discern truth.
- csours 3y ago> wonderful collections of weirdness, with no way to discern truth So just like real life, then. To be clear, I believe that objective truth exists. I also believe that people have a lot of stories. I'm from a small town, the size where you could learn a story about pretty much every family, and a lot of the stories would intertwine, or be very similar to each other, forming a shared reality among neighbors. I'm sure we could talk a good long time about the social implications of that sense of shared reality. I think there's something deeply uncomfortable about having too many people available in your life to form a shared reality. I feel like that discomfort is a big driver of modern angst.
- smallerfish 3y agoFunnily enough, I complained to Atlas Obscura a couple years back about a story they ran that included a bunch of statistics which were mathematically inconsistent with each other. I get that english majors don't like math :) but these numbers were so central to the story that you'd think any fact checker who had the story to review would have pulled out a calculator and checked them (if not actually review the sources of the numbers). I got an email reply from Patel (who is mentioned in the Walrus story) about 3-4 weeks after my initial complaint, acknowledging the issue and saying that they'd issued a correction. In the editorial comment that they'd added to the story along with the corrections, they understated the issue that I reported, but they had fixed all of the numbers. Of course, fixing stories 3-4 weeks after publishing means that only the fictional long tail will benefit.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- maaaaattttt 3y agoThe other day I was thinking that in "the times we live in"™ it would be nice to have a sort of notary for anonymous sources. The source is known between the journalist and the notary. The notary has to be assigned to the journalist from another third party randomly (probably a state institution through a process like `get_notary(unique_article_id, unique_journalist_id) -> unique_notary_id`). The journalist communicates quotes and contact information for the quotes to the notary they've been assigned to. Then, in case of doubt, it's possible for anybody to request the notary validates the sources of the story. Freelance journalist could also go through the process to be able to guaranty to the Editor they're submitting to that their story is not bullshit, without having to reveal their sources or the editor to have to do the checks themselves.
- alex_duf 3y agoNow you have N more points of failures, possibly concentrating far more power than attacking journalists directly. There's a reason journalists tend to be all hush hush around giving who their sources are, sources are often risking their lives, and are often putting regimes in place / powerful people under scrutiny. The very same people that can decide whether you should live or not. So in principle: yes, in practice: please no!
- lolinder 3y agoThere are lots of ways around this. The most obvious is to forgo the process if the story is one of the few that would draw the ire of a national government or otherwise place lives at risk. There are lots of cases where anonymous sources are used in less extreme circumstances, and to protect those you could build a rigorous system of vetting notaries, equivalent to a security clearance. Under OP's proposed model we wouldn't need a lot of these notaries, since as I understand it they'd only be actually validating sources if doubts are raised, so the requirements could be quite strict.
- maaaaattttt 3y agoI agree, I was thinking about it while writing it. My thinking was that it should somebody sworn in to try not break the chain of trust. But adding somebody new in a chain will always weaken it (in this context). As the sibling comment mentions, it wouldn't have to be mandatory as well. It's just that in general I find the "anonymous sources" a bit too easy to use. It's very easy to have your article say whatever you want by using "anonymous sources".
- nescioquid 3y agoThe name "Atlas Obscura" puzzles me since it looks like they intended "atlas of obscure things", but the only way I can see to read these two words together in a grammatically valid way yields the command "hide, atlas!". I'm tempted to wonder what attitude this reveals on the part of the publisher towards its readers. Do they think "This is obscure, our readers won't notice if we make stuff up"?
- mayormcmatt 3y agoA real Life of Brian moment. https://youtu.be/0lczHvB3Y9s?si=tbyIauh3fBCdLWi4 https://youtu.be/0lczHvB3Y9s?si=tbyIauh3fBCdLWi4
- karaterobot 3y ago> Mastbaum’s stories didn’t raise any red flags, he said; details were spot-checked by editors, and notes were provided whenever they had questions. They didn’t suspect anything was amiss until a reader reached out to them. Once they realized there were problems with the story, he explained, they did a complete review of all of Mastbaum’s work, reaching out to every single source and documenting the inconsistencies in an editor’s note. In addition to the fraudulent author, editors are (or were, or should be) accountable for lies getting into print. Especially when a writer under their purview lies over and over. Especially if you don't immediately pull all of that author's stories after even one of them is deemed fundamentally fraudulent. And I'm not sure how 'spot-checking' is meant to be used here, given that you could apparently catch quite a few of the lies in the articles with a Google search. What were they doing as editors? When we talk about the dwindling quality of journalism, or the dearth of trust in journalism, to me it always goes back to editors and fact-checkers. More precisely, the lack of them. It doesn't matter why they aren't doing their job, whether it's lack of money, time, or lack of skilled practicioners. Editors are really important, as it turns out.
- Suppafly 3y agoI always assumed that most of their content was fabricated. I doubt it's just this one writer that's the problem.
- deltasepsilon 3y agoAn introduction to my favourite thinker on such things [1]. [1] Umberto Eco takes on big lies and the human compulsion to hate, The Philadelphia Enquirer, Nov. 10, 2011. https://archive.is/sTIuk https://archive.is/sTIuk
- divbzero 3y agoThe Atlas Obscura website is down right now, but I’ll be curious to see if the editors publish their own apology and retractions.