3 ms·
It sounds like this may be done in an effort to improve the reliability of eye tracking in VisionOS when dealing with checkbox, not Apple just throwing the desi
by al_borland 3y ago
It sounds like this may be done in an effort to improve the reliability of eye tracking in VisionOS when dealing with checkbox, not Apple just throwing the design book out the window for no reason.
>In general, prefer circular or capsule-shape buttons. People’s eyes tend to be drawn toward the corners in a shape, making it difficult to keep looking at the shape’s center. The more rounded a button’s shape, the easier it is for people to look steadily at it. When you need to display a button by itself, prefer a capsule-shape button.
https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guidelines/buttons https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guideline...
- Mtinie 3y agoI may be missing a fundamental point of your comment or from the linked content, but given the minuscule number of users who’d be concerned with this in practical presentation, I sincerely hope that the UXers involved didn’t optimize for this use case.
- al_borland 3y agoFrom the OP’s article: >Apple is the first major operating system vendor who had abandoned a four-decades-long tradition. Their new visionOS — for the first time in the history of Apple — will have round checkboxes. So the death of the square checkbox they are predicting is only in the context of VisionOS. Apple’s HIG explain why this decision was made (my link), so I don’t think it is part of a larger trend and we shouldn’t expect it to impact anyone not using VisionOS, or other such headsets with eye tracking. It was done for technical reasons relating how the person will interact with the device, not style reasons.
- Dalewyn 3y ago[flagged]
- ludwik 3y agoI don't understand why some people feel the need to attack the only person in this thread who provided context about the change being discussed. You may agree with Apple's decision, or you may not. You might believe that it will have far-reaching negative consequences for the entire industry. Regardless, al_borland sharing the reasoning behind the decision (and linking to the source) is valuable and is the opposite of 'living under a rock'.
- Dalewyn 3y agoI'm not disputing the logical reasoning behind circular checkboxes, I'm saying that if Apple does something then everyone else will follow suit regardless of any reasons. Apple is the fashion leader and trend setter of the IT industry, everyone else will follow them. It's appropriate to ring the death bell for square checkboxes, given that track record.
- ludwik 3y agoOf course, you can have your view and express it in this thread. I just don't get why that needs to come with being rude and confrontational towards the person who simply provided important context.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoHe did more than that. He also assured everyone that this was an isolated phenomenon: >>> Apple’s HIG explain why this decision was made (my link), so I don’t think it is part of a larger trend and we shouldn’t expect it to impact anyone not using VisionOS, or other such headsets with eye tracking. Dalewyn's response makes perfect sense in this context.
- Dalewyn 3y agoExactly. Apple's influence with regards to design and aesthetics is unparalleled, to downplay it is either straight ignorance or naivety. Everything from naming schemes (iPhone -> Core i3/5/7/9, Macbook -> ASUS Zenbook, et al.), to desktop interfaces (MacOS -> Windows 11 Explorer, GNOME), to phone interfaces (iOS -> Android), to connectivity (rather the lack thereof), to form factor (Macbook Air -> Intel ultrabooks and EVO), to entire markets (smartphones, tablets, portable music players) and more have all been defined or redefined and led by Apple. To suggest anything Apple does concerning design would be an isolated incident is ridiculous. If Apple says "jump", the IT industry asks "how high?".
- hulitu 3y ago> Apple’s HIG explain why this decision was made (my link), so I don’t think it is part of a larger trend After seeing everybody adopt the Android flat UI (win 10), i really think that stupidity is contagious.
- tadfisher 3y agoDo you not remember when Apple started this trend with iOS 7? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IOS_7 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IOS_7
- andirk 3y agoI think UI in general is changed so often for no reason other than because it's like art to the UI staff. And then others follow thinking that there is a good reason for those changes made by Apple or whomever. And some FOMO in there too.
- troupo 3y ago> Apple’s HIG explain why this decision was made Honestly, I wouldn't trust any modern Apple HIGs. After the UX butchery of BigSur they retroactively updated the HIGs to justify their decisions.
- n2d4 3y agoIt's not a "minuscule number" because visionOS is controlled by looking at things and pinching your fingers. If people subconsciously stare at the edges of a square button, can you imagine how often they'll misclick? (mispinch?)
- layer8 3y agoControls are highlighted in visionOS when you focus on them, making it clear when the pinching will or won't work.
- mrguyorama 3y agoOther eyetracking software solves this and all related problems by simply showing you a pip of some sort where it senses you "looking". It's stupidly intuitive, low intrusiveness (and can go away when it senses you don't need to "look" at anything like when you are looking at a movie screen with no controls on it) and works just fine. Only Apple decides the solution to their broken UI is to break more of the UI.
- demondemidi 3y agoI'm glad you actually brought a reason to this debate. Not sure I agree but there is at least a reason.
- kibwen 3y agoEven a rounded rectangle would be more distinguishable than a circle. This is a poor excuse that decreases usability masquerading as an increase to usability.
- musha68k 3y ago“The sudden realization that the throne was empty.”
- Y_Y 3y agoIs this a biblical reference?
- FrontierProject 3y agoNo.
- lucasban 3y agoLooks like a misquote of a Slavoj Žižek tweet from 2016 right after the U.S. election? That’s as far as I got with 2 minutes of digging.
- endofreach 3y agoGreat point. Very disappointing to read an critique that tries to appear thoroughly thought through, but not even considers that the company that has been very consistent in UX design choices, might have thought about what they're doing in a system, that probably requires fundamentally different approaches to UX. I mean: > Apple is the first major operating system vendor who had abandoned a four-decades-long tradition. Their new visionOS — for the first time in the history of Apple — will have round checkboxes. And yet the author is too lazy to think about that this might have a reason other than "they're stupid, look at all my screenshots, i know better than them". Btw: not saying i agree with this decision. But why even take the time to write when not trying to actually think about what you're criticising? Laughable.
- toyg 3y agoDad must know better, surely! It's absolutely impossible that almighty Apple is now full of subpar UX wannabes. Apple design has been on a downright trajectory for a long time now, basically since Ive was promoted to the very top (yes he left now, but the damage was done). The Peter Principle doesn't make exceptions.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoIf someone spends over an hour writing a blog post than the normal expectation is that they at least spend a few minutes confirming the point based on information, or lack of, in publicly available resources, such as Apple design documents.
- endofreach 3y agoWell i wasn't defending apple as if they wouldn't make mistakes or couldn't be led by people who don't know what they're doing. My point had nothing to do with the design choices themselves. But if the point isn't obvious, there is no point to be explained. Apple & elon musk make people on HN act so weird. Sad.
- wonrax 3y agoTotally agree. I'm surprised that a post making a big claim with little research and shallow content like this got to the frontpage with over 800 upvotes. Sad you're being downvoted too.
- Asooka 3y agoWell, the checkmark itself is pretty angular and hard to look at. I think we should take a page out of East Asian visual language and adopt the circle as the "yes" mark. That is, radio buttons and check boxes should look like this: ( ) Radio button off (·) Radio button on ( ) Checkbox off (O) Checkbox on
- gcr 3y agoIt isn’t clear which is which if they all are unchecked
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoSo we reduced surface area of elements and made GUIs worse to accommodate disability. Wasn't that Apple's MO all along?