3 ms·
In a similar vein, try explaining to a senior with fading skills that under material design literally nothing is a clue that a region on your screen is a button
by ggm 3y ago
In a similar vein, try explaining to a senior with fading skills that under material design literally nothing is a clue that a region on your screen is a button you can press.
Only prior use can inform what is active, and what is not.
- Smoosh 3y agoAnd making it worse, past experience with other apps cannot be relied upon.
- arcanemachiner 3y agoAnd the UI completely changes every year or three, because progress or something.
- Dalewyn 3y agoI am a mid-30s senior by this definition. Well, maybe I am a senior. I know I spend far more time screaming at clouds nowadays and grow increasingly distant from what kids today are into.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sph 3y agoI don't blame the kids: the brutalist yet colorful zoomer UI design is much easier to parse for 30 year old seniors than the flat UI/material crap our generation created. I have no way to defend this argument but my eyes, but I can say that Google's Material design is the most bland, insipid of them all, and I would rather see Bootstrap again than another Material-inspired with its white cards on white background and tap animations. Just kidding, Bootstrap was as bland. I miss Windows 2000 every day.
- zilti 3y agoWhat is that zoomer UI you are referring to?
- sph 3y agoI have heard it referred that way, I didn't use zoomer as a slur. I can't think of any example off my head, but I remember mention of a striking online clothing store with bold colours, thick black borders and large fonts that's very popular in that age range. From a quick search on google: https://thedigitalmaze.com/blog/three-awesome-ui-design-trends-for-2024-and-how-to-use-them/ https://thedigitalmaze.com/blog/three-awesome-ui-design-tren... See also the design for Gumroad: https://gumroad.com/ https://gumroad.com/
- zilti 3y agoAh, that is what that design is called? Heh. I've seen it, among other names, also been referred to as "chalkboard design". It also reminds me quite a bit of the style you use when drawing on flipcharts, and actually of 90s web design; the good parts of it, that is. I like the ideas behind it and the clarity, but I think everything tends to be hideously oversized on it.
- hydrolox 3y agoCommonly called neo-brutalist ui, iirc. The only issue I have (well not only, but main), is that many have really really large text and it's hard to read. For example: gumroad
- KTibow 3y agoAt least M3's cards are slightly tinted
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wolpoli 3y agoDon't forget to explain that some buttons are inside faint pill shaped shading (or it could be a search field in which they could tap without consequence) and that chips (to show options for a specific context, so they could tap without consequence) are rounded rectangles. Except if the site is still on Material Design 2, then it is the reverse in which some buttons are inside rounded rectangles and that chips are inside pill shaped shading. Are we confused yet?
- Tempest1981 3y agoCan you share a picture of this?
- demondemidi 3y ago> a senior with fading skills Recently had to help an aging parent use their phone to obtain medical care: an app was required to access their MyChart to get a message from their case manager. Having to explain what is "clickable" is infuriating. The race for UX/UI novelty is leaving seniors behind, which is tragic since hospitals are pushing them online.
- Tempest1981 3y agoWhat does the 2035+ version of this look like? Seniors pushed to VR UIs?
- demondemidi 3y agoI hope not for my sake! Whatever it is I hope it is more reliable and HELPful. I expect it will be more seamless authentication with more general accessibility. Meaning I hope I feel safer proving who I am to the nurse at the desk without having to open a gadget I can barely focus my eyes on, and that the nurse will have the most up to date info. That’s really all that is missing, sounds easy but it’s a cluster fuck of record management. Note that digitally it is better today than it was 30 years ago. I think apps will die but not by 2035, probably 2055. Apps are fucking stupid and antithetical to the web IMHO. Oh and I hope phone trees die a horrible death especially ones that don’t immediately put you through to a human. The biggest pain due to cost savings is not being able to get help via a goddamn phone call that doesn’t go to a call center, or worse: a disconnect at the end of a long tree of number presses.
- pennomi 3y agoMy grandchildren will be begging me to join the hivemind, but my crotchety old brain will complain back at them about how a keyboard and mouse are just fine.
- resolutebat 3y agoThe annoyance this causes is not limited to seniors.
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoI have to argue that it’s not the senior’s skills that are fading.
- divbzero 3y agoIt’s definitely not just seniors. If you watch young kids use apps, they tap all over the screen to figure out which elements are actually interactive.
- PennRobotics 3y agoAndroid's own Gmail app is a prime example of shitty use of checkboxes in Material Design (or Material You or Material 3 or whatever the hell it's called now): There's a list of emails with a checkbox for each email on the left. If you want to quickly select a bunch of emails---for instance, to label or sort them---you quickly press all the checkboxes. If you just barely miss a checkbox, you will open the email because you press the larger selectable region (which is, btw, invisible until selected---a nod toward your "prior use" statement) for one email where a checkbox happens to be fully enclosed. Now, if you are trying to label or sort some messages that have been opened and also some that are unread, you now have one extra task of going back after labeling/sorting and marking the one that you accidentally opened as unread---if you actually noticed in the first place whether it was already opened before you opened it! On my phone, Gmail checkboxes are about 3 by 3 millimeters. If I dip my finger in coffee and lightly tap the paper on my desk, it creates a circle about 5 to 6 mm in diameter. I've opened countless emails just trying to do routine sorting and labeling via checkbox. I know there are larger fingertips, smaller screens, and people with less stable coordination than mine. Google's nested, tiny checkboxes are a waste of time and a needless security flaw, as emails often contain info you'd like protected, and cameras are commonplace and usually legal, so it doesn't matter if you are quick to close the message you suddenly opened outside of your home. The alternative? Hold each message until the checkbox populates, which is noticeably slower but lowers the likelihood you accidentally open a message. I don't understand why the Gmail "open this message" region isn't a full 5+ mm right of the checkboxes (except maybe at smartwatch resolutions). They shouldn't be enclosed or nested AT ALL! Nobody reasonable is opening messages by clicking the little blank space to the left or top of the checkboxes. (...at least they weren't until they saw my statement and decided to do it from now on out of spite or curiosity.) I also don't know why Android Studio shouldn't/doesn't harass developers with "Attention! You are committing BAD DESIGN!" alert messages when they try to put small selectable elements on top of other selectable elements that perform an unrelated task.
- urbandw311er 3y agoUpvote just for sheer passion (using word count as a proxy for this)
- neop1x 3y agoExactly this. I hate it. Impossible to distinguish a button from a label. I don't understand how someone could come up with such ideas and get them approved for such wide-spread UI.