9 ms·
Skype replaces P2P supernodes with Linux boxes hosted by Microsoft
- nthitz 15y agoIs this in response to the Skype IP Lookup tool that was released this past week? Or something completely unrelated?
- TazeTSchnitzel 15y agoUnrelated, although this might make such things harder.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- beagle3 15y agothe article says the switch happened a few months ago.
- Tyrant505 15y agoI think it is quite coincidental that now the skype ip lookup site JUST got killed and this press releases timing. They may have implemented this new infrastructure in tangent, and now took them all offline?
- skypeopensource 15y agoRelated, tool also show many supernodes ip's. Which was all located in microsoft data centers.
- wmf 15y agoSomething not mentioned by Ars is that the difference in cost between datacenter bandwidth and broadband has changed significantly in the last 10 years. Datacenter resources are now so cheap that P2P has little advantage. (I think the rise of cyberlockers are another manifestation of this trend.)
- edge17 15y agothat's pretty interesting. do you have a link or something with some of the cost analysis?
- wmf 15y agoHere's bandwidth pricing: http://drpeering.net/white-papers/Internet-Transit-Pricing-Historical-And-Projected.php http://drpeering.net/white-papers/Internet-Transit-Pricing-H... Let's say 100x drop in 10 years. (But broadband upstream certainly hasn't gotten 100x faster!) Determining the cost break-even point between P2P and client-server is more complex and I haven't seen any public analyses of it.
- sedachv 15y agoProblems with DSL upstream bandwidth is the main reason that Kragen thinks P2P networking won't work very well: http://lists.canonical.org/pipermail/kragen-tol/2011-August/000935.html http://lists.canonical.org/pipermail/kragen-tol/2011-August/...
- ra 15y agoI hope Spotify hear you and follow suit
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- huhtenberg 15y agoP2P has an advantage of being harder to block or to throttle at the last mile ISPs. Also, P2P generally delivers smallest connection latency as compared to all other setups. Also, P2P makes it harder for the service provider to snoop on the traffic, and this might be just the reason why Microsoft is shifting towards supernodes. Skype is just too big of a communication infrastructure piece to let it go "unsupervised." So while the bandwidth might be getting cheaper, there's still plenty of reasons to do things in P2P way.
- revelation 15y agoLet me just make this very clear: you don't go from zero operating cost to multiple millions of hardware and colo space to do the very same thing, in a move so transparent that it needs security researchers to dig into your program to find out it has happened at all. I guess Skype (by extension, Microsoft) is growing interested in what people are speaking about. To get hold of that data you need to route it through your own network, at significant processing and bandwidth cost.
- pbz 15y agoI would assume being able to guarantee a certain level or "service quality" played a bigger role than finding out what people are talking about. They're probably going to integrate Skype at a much deeper level into WP8 and they need to make sure there are fewer breaking points, both technical and legal.
- beagle3 15y agoThat's one option. Other options: a) datacenter bandwidth is now much cheaper than it was 10 years ago, to the point that the cost saving from using p2p is not that significant anymore. (Skype did not have zero operating cost, and contrary to the article, they did operate their own supernodes - few tens to a few hundreds at least). b) Microsoft is going to change the business model, e.g. no more free calls (or, no more free conference calls, or something like that), and if they are going to charge money, they need to guarantee a level of service - which they cannot with a P2P infrastructure. c) The marginal cost for Microsoft (who already have data centers etc) is actually LOWER than running a p2p, with everything (including end user liability) is taken into account. Running 10,000 servers in existing data servers would cost ~$1M/month. May seem a lot to you, but it's a rounding error for microsoft (and certainly, at a $8.5B total cost, 4 years would make this ~$8.55B from Microsoft's side. Rounding error) d) Microsoft is planning some kind of integration with their other properties (hotmail? live? office live?) for which hosting everything is essential. I would guess (c) or (d), although the parent's guess is not without merit.
- excuse-me 15y agoUnless a significant number of paying users decide that they don't want their calls going through a US company with a history of security and monopoly issues. So you should now assume that ALL your skype calls are being recorded and monitored and anything of interest to the US authorities is now available to them ? Are you doing anything in the US that might be considered naughty - like online gambling, tax 'optimization', overly-fair use of some recorded entertainment? Do you work in a foreign company that competes with a major US oil/aerospace/defense/financial concern? Do you supply to any of the above? If you wouldn't forward an email about it to the DHS should you now still talk about it on Skype?
- pritam2020 15y agoSo, Microsoft would use Linux boxes..
- beagle3 15y agoWhen they bought hotmail, it took them years to migrate off the freebsd boxes that was running it -- they had several failures, and when they finally succeeded, they needed several times as many NT boxes as the original BSD boxes. I would guess that the supernode software was written by skype long before the acquisition (they were running their own supernodes, despite what the article claims -- although not as many, and most supernodes were users), and microsoft hasn't had the chance or the reason to port them to Windows yet.
- zethraeus 15y agoIt's not at all unheard of for companies to do this kind of thing as a stopgap. http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/09/02/icloud_runs_on_microsoft_azure_and_amazon/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/09/02/icloud_runs_on_micro...
- wetsocket 15y agoMS using Linux to run their business. That says it all. A company with more money than it knows what to do with, acting desperately to save itself from obsolescence. Skype was flawed from the outset, being non-transparent (about how the network is set up, turning machines into supernodes withtout permission, and the encryption they use). It's all closed. Why? You can't verify it's well-designed. Now it's worse. Do I want MS routing my calls? Scanning every file transfer? Being able to peek at any video? No thanks. That's not their role. There are other true decentralised P2P Video/oiceOIP solutions. People now know that free calls, even video calls, through the internet are feasible, even without having technical knowledge. Right now, use Skype. But it will not hold the market when more robust, flexible, decentralised, transparent services are ready for non-technical users. Because they will be free. And Skype will not be free: the price you will pay, to a software company[1], is your privacy, at the least, and probably more. 1. No software company has a need to know such things. They are not the government, they are not law enforcement, and they are not defenders of national security. They are a software company. Who are they accountable to? It's just not a smart idea to let MS take this role. The potential for abuse is too great.
- wmf 15y agoI remember when open source P2P VoIP was "being polished" in 2002. I guess if we're lucky we'll get WebRTC, but being from Google it may not satisfy the wannabe cypherpunks.
- angersock 15y agoIf we had 1 good application programmer for every 100 cryptoweenies, the world would be a better place. Write code or shut the fuck up.
- wetsocket 15y agoCode is written. Command line only. So not ready for you yet. There are good application programmers (who are also competent cryptographers). But it seems, based on mailing list and forum comments, all the incompetent ones hold them in spite. One can only guess why.
- CTop 15y agoJust so I understand this: they're switching from direct P2P messages between users (like MSN), to routing the messages through their own data centers first (like Facebook)? So in theory this will prevent any messages ever getting lost en route to the recipient? I can't tell you how many messages have gone undelivered between my friends and I when we used to use MSN messenger exclusively (even happens once or twice on Skype), causing serious breakdowns in communication. ("Did you get that message? Did you get that message?) I always wished they'd switch to this architecture.
- Wilya 15y agoIs MSN P2P ? It's been a long time (like.. oh. 7 years maybe ?) since I've used it, but iirc it was centrally routed. Only some things like file transfers were P2P.
- riffraff 15y agofrom what we get from the article: no, they are replacing the bit about connecting over NAT, which went through some random people, making it go through some servers they own directly. If you and your peer are on mutually accessible networks the data will still be p2p in the same way (or not, as before).
- wetsocket 15y agoMSN relies on central servers to broker connections, just like this does. It is not going to solve the problem you describe. True P2P, via an overlay, where you and the other person(s) have a direct connection, is fast and reliable "enough" (otherwise Skype would not have been successful), but not perfect. Nor is store-and-forward (e.g. text mesaging) perfect either. But it is "good enough" for people to use it. If I were really concerned about "lost messages", I'd prefer a direct connection as opposed to one that goes through a third party. It just makes more sense.
- grandpoobah 15y agoI have a fair amount of experience with MSNP, and it is the exact opposite of P2P. Some things like file transfers will sometimes use P2P if it's available.
- muppetman 15y agoGood to see the grsecurity patch getting a bit of publicity. I think for critical devices it's an essential patch, mostly because of it's integration with the PaX patch which is aimed at preventing many different types of memory overflow exploits.
- tar 15y agoI just wish they would update their Linux client.
- diminish 15y agosame here. I hope linux boxes save Microsoft some money and stability.
- nextparadigms 15y agoEverything Skype does will soon be replaced by WebRTC anyway.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoHow soon? I presume you mean this - http://www.webrtc.org/ http://www.webrtc.org/. Is it just a more simple way of setting up chatroulette style sites only using browser native programming rather than relying on Flash?
- drivebyacct2 15y agoIt allows you to do the same thing Skype does. It uses a server (supernode) to make P2P connections (via SDP signaling) between web browsers. I can assure you, it can be used much like Skype is used.
- qeorge 15y agoMy biggest complaint with Skype is its inability to persist chat messages when one client is disconnected. If this addresses that it would be great. That said, we're using HipChat now and love it. If you use Skype for group chat and don't use the phone a lot, I recommend the switch wholeheartedly.
- Karunamon 15y agoSay what now? It always seemed to do that quite fine for me. If a client drops off, I can still send messages, and they'll sit in the window with the little "working" circle next to t hem. The partner picks them up when they reconnect. I've logged in more than once to have a metric ton of IM's waiting for me.
- qeorge 15y agoBut if you send a message they won't see your message until you're both online again. So if you sign off before you sign on, it won't send until both clients are online again (could be days). If you use multiple computers it gets worse - if you send the message from your laptop it won't go through until the laptop and your friend are online again. Its not a huge problem with a 1 on 1 chat, but with groups its frustrating. We benefit greatly from having the chat room as sort of a canonical log of what's happening. Its nice to be able to leave a message for coworkers before you sign off for the night, and know that everyone will see it. With Skype we didn't have that guarantee.
- Karunamon 15y agoAhhhh, gotcha. I see what you're getting at now. It's kind of odd that they don't - messages are stored server side (have a bunch of conversations and then sign into an empty skype elsewhere - open chats are synched). You'd think this would be trivial to add.
- freshhawk 15y agoCertainly helps solve the intercept problem for the American national security agencies. (Was that still a problem? My info is probably out of date, but skype being p2p was a pain in the ass for spying on customers a short while ago)
- revelation 15y agoSkype offers lawful interception access to anyone interested. The encryption is literally just obfuscation to deny intermediate peers access.
- freshhawk 15y agoBut not large scale trawling of all call data or the ability to mirror all traffic to another location as far as I know.
- revelation 15y agoOf course not; thats not "lawful interception" in the countries that Skype would market such services to. They don't have access to that large-scale data anyway, hence my comment on getting access to it by routing it through your own infrastructure.
- freshhawk 15y agoRight, which is the "intercept problem" I was talking about. Your concept of "lawful interception" is pretty dated when we're talking about national security agencies rather than police. The NSA is splitting signals and trawling everything for what they want, it's how it's done now. The recent wired article about the new datacentre was pretty interesting. Which was, as far as i know, not possible with the p2p architecture that skype had previously.
- joelhaasnoot 15y agoThis was the first thing I thought of when reading the article: it's a heck of a lot easier to tap off an (encrypted) stream running through a datacenter than it being remote on a supernode.
- dgregd 15y agoWith IP6 supernodes won't be needed for A/V traffic. Supernodes are only needed for NAT hacks. Skype succeeded because it worked in many different network environments. As contrasted with h323 and sip. Just to remind.
- wmf 15y agoThink again; firewalling and NAT are coming to IPv6 whether they're needed or not.
- trotsky 15y agoWho has ever said IP6 didn't need firewalling? That sounds insane... And where is this IP6 NAT you speak of??
- ghshephard 15y agoAll the enterprises that have deployed in RFC4193 space are using IPv6 NAT. It's been available in OpenBSD (a popular IPv6 Firewall/NAT device) for several years. If cisco hasn't deployed it yet in their ASAs, they will soon. Enterprise cannot leak their internal addresses, and, if they do, they want it to be something that nobody can make use of/route to.
- dgregd 15y agoFrankly speaking I'm not familiar with IPv6 NAT. So to hide IPv6 corporate network structure it is necessary to send outside all IPv6 packets with one global address. Is this an only option? It should be possible to hide internal network structure with some address shuffling techniques.
- ghshephard 15y agoIPv6 NAT (or, more precisely, PAT/NAPT) is pretty much identical to it's IPv4 ancestor. One external (globally routable) IP Address which represents the entirety of the internal IP address space. If you are on a corporate LAN, and your IPv6 address is from the RFC4193 range (it starts with "FD" e.g. FDC2:D343:1234:5678:..." ), and, you are accessing IPv6 resources outside your company, then some kind of PAT/NAT/Proxying is taking place.) I'm sure it will be very popular.
- RobertKohr 15y agoWhat alternatives to skype exist? Something that does voice, and not likely to invade my privacy.
- mey 15y agoI would recommend looking at something like Mumble http://mumble.sourceforge.net/ http://mumble.sourceforge.net/ Assuming you are concerned about the code you run, the location you run it in, etc. Does not provide encryption to my knowledge, but VPN can solve that. If you are looking for something more robust that can interconnect with telecom stuff, I'd suggest http://www.freeswitch.org/ http://www.freeswitch.org/ or http://www.asterisk.org/ http://www.asterisk.org/
- SpiderX 15y agoMumble requires a server.
- mey 15y agoI don't know of any truly distributed encrypted voice systems you can trust out there. Hosting your own server for a service seemed like the next rational way to solve the persons question.
- snarkinatree 15y agoTry not to think in terms of server and client being separate machines. Or thinking that a server needs to be complex or able to handle an unlimited number of nodes. It's possible to be both a client and a server. And that is in fact what Skype was doing. Some clients were also functioning as supernodes.
- wetsocket 15y agoTeamspeak is another option, along the lines Mumble. There are others. It's a diferent concept from Skype. ONe person has to run a server. They choose who they want to be on the P2P network. Teamspeak is closed source. Free SIP services are another option, but not easy enough for the novice who is in a hurry and just want things to work. Most people seem to use SIP servers operated by companies, not running the servers themselves. Some ISP's are selling pre-packed VOIP service (and some are deep inspecting every packet, lol). Skype has the market now. It is ubiquitous. It's easy to use and works reasonably well. But to think Skype will become the world's new default global communications channel, with MS in control, is just silly. Skype is just a hint of what's possible, given today's bandwidth and a network that no one player controls.
- furyg3 15y agoI wonder if this has to do with mobile. A laptop on a broadband line can keep track of all the P2P nodes necessary to keep my contact list & chats up to date, have a 3-way video call, and top it off by routing for a few less-well connected peers nearby. Asking that of my phone is a bit much. Skype on an iPhone + wifi is rough sailing as it is, let alone on 3G or with a less-powerful device. The behavior I see (really random incoming chats, call false-starts) seems to be more related to the P2P layer than the app itself. I almost never see that behavior on Skype desktop. I think leaning a bit more towards client-server would be a lot more friendly for mobile devices. Hopefully they hit the right mix.
- zerostar07 15y agoI had my account hacked, and it also happened to a friend a few weeks ago (and i m unable to reclaim it because they ask for the day i registered). Is it possibly related to the transition?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tbundy 15y agoLet's hope this at least makes user presence more accurate. I'm doubtful.
- speleding 15y agoWhen I had a fixed IP address and no NAT between the internet and my PC, I regularly caught Skype promoting me to supernode and using a serious part of my bandwidth. It made me get into the habit of quitting Skype unless I wanted to make a call. Perhaps I can keep it running now.