5 ms·
And that is why I'm against eSIMs. I shouldn't need the carrier's, google's or apple's permission to use different phones.
by nottorp 3y ago
And that is why I'm against eSIMs.
I shouldn't need the carrier's, google's or apple's permission to use different phones.
- IshKebab 3y agoI would maybe say the same except there's one use case where esims are undeniably awesome: travelling. There are tons of apps that let you get very cheap esims in any country, so you basically never have to pay roaming charges ever again. Before esims you would have to go and get a physical SIM from somewhere. I've done it before. It's possible, but it was much more of a pain than esims. The only issue with them I've found is that they're delivered by QR code via email, and the only way to install them on Android (that works) is scanning a QR code with your camera. I had do ask someone to take a photo of my phone so I could scan that photo. facepalm
- nottorp 3y ago> There are tons of apps that let you get very cheap esims in any country, so you basically never have to pay roaming charges ever again. ... you mean, with Google/Apple's permission :)
- addandsubtract 3y agoCan you link some of those apps? I'd love to have a travel eSIM just for data.
- Brajeshwar 3y agohttps://www.airalo.com https://www.airalo.com
- addandsubtract 3y agoHmm... that's 5x as expensive as getting a regular SIM, though :/
- mFixman 3y agoI use https://esimdb.com/uk https://esimdb.com/uk instead of a single app. It lists the cheapest e-SIMs for travelling to each country.
- IshKebab 3y agoYeah this is the best option by far.
- dylmye 3y agoI've used Nomad (https://www.getnomad.app/ https://www.getnomad.app/), they usually have a 10-25% code somewhere. I've had no issues and used them 10s of times.
- bmicraft 3y agoIf this can be done through Google lens, then it would be possible on device. If you share an image with the Google app it opens in lens and can scan codes.
- IshKebab 3y agoIt can't unfortunately. It's special QR scanner activity deep in Android's settings somewhere.
- SoapSeller 3y agoThat's depends on the device and app, I've used Airalo on couple of Android devices and it was always one click inside the app to install the eSIM.
- m-p-3 3y agoThey're also great for corporate devices deployments. If the carrier is compatible, you can have the MDM/UEM auto-provision an eSIM during the account registration. This also has the benefit that the user cannot take it out or lose the SIM while traveling, or do SIM-swap with another device because their manager doesn't follow procedure of contacting IT when reusing spare phones between employees, creating all sorts of mismatches in the inventory between S/N and phone number, etc.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> There are tons of apps that let you get very cheap esims Wait. Why would you need, or want, an app for that? I'd automatically assume that any such app is a scam. These kinds of things are not what apps do, it's out of scope on restricted mobile OS.
- nottorp 3y agoHe means that instead of buying the service on a web site he buys it in the web site packed inside an Electron "app". He does say they're delivered via QR in the email, so the "application" is just a store frontend, it doesn't change his esim itself.
- dannyw 3y agoBoth iOS and Android provide eSIM APIs. How else do you think carrier apps work? Apps like Airalo, etc, are legit.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> How else do you think carrier apps work? IDK, I've always considered carrier apps to be the prototype example of garbage / scams, next to "value-add" software shipped by printer vendors. None of the services I pay my carriers for are, or were, ever enabled or improved by an app.
- IshKebab 3y agoThey are apps because they're almost universally used on phones and apps can provide a much better UX than web sites (fight me PWA delusionists). I think you can probably do it on the web if you want too though.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoI agree that apps can and do provide better UX (or at least used to, now they're just mostly wrapping webviews, which sucks) - but this class of activity is something I'd never consider using an app for in the first place. An app for a big e-commerce platform make sense. An app for one-off, transactional buying relationship? That a red flag to me.
- drdaeman 3y agoThere are always caveats and eSIMs are a double-edged sword. I'm locked down to my current phone because of eSIM. I have two eSIMs from different countries, both necessary for long-term use (e.g. I have bank accounts in both countries, and banks want local numbers). Replacing or upgrading phone would be a tricky endeavor, with temporary outage on one of my lines, as I will be able to move only one eSIM, but not the other until I physically travel to a different country. Sure, it's a rare edge case, but still - super inconvenient.
- judge2020 3y agoAT&T et al have been blocking transfers or requiring physical verification for transfers for a decade now, not exclusive to eSIM.
- nottorp 3y agoHmm I can take my physical sim out and plug it into any other phone over here. The only exception is when the destination phone is carrier locked by a contract, but they have to unlock it for a nominal fee at the end (I think it was a few eur, or maybe last time they didn't charge me anything.). Are you referring to the fact that no one buys contract free phones in the US?
- ratg13 3y agoThey are referring to SIM locks. ATT locks the sim to the phone so it can't be transferred if you got a subsidised phone from them. All depends on if someone set this flag when creating your SIM and if you took their discount when buying their service.