6 ms·
Or a worse experience? I mean android phones and tablets are already something you can buy, people still buy Apple products despite that. > It's not my intenti
by seanmcdirmid 3y ago
Or a worse experience? I mean android phones and tablets are already something you can buy, people still buy Apple products despite that.
> It's not my intention to poison the well, but Apple feels like treating its customers like cattle
A lot of remember how the computing world was before, the Wild West that the EU is trying to make the only option. We aren’t eager to return to that, and would make different platform purchasing decisions if we did. The EU is simply taking away choice, not adding to it.
I get it, Apple has an unfair advantage because they lock down their platform, and the EU making it suck as much as the other platforms, Apple will compete with the other platforms more fairly.
- jchw 3y agoThe reason iPad is good is not because you're not allowed to choose what browser engine to use. It's, largely, because the hardware is simply better than anything else on the market. I think it is amusing that there is a contingent of Apple fans that actually believe the platform will get significantly worse because people are allowed to sideload and install browsers that have their own browser engines. I think this is a truly ridiculous line of argument. I don't like the other line of argument, which goes somewhere along the lines of "We should tolerate Microsoft-esque anti-competitive behavior because otherwise Google Chrome's anti-competitive behavior might win", but that is literally a better argument, to be fair.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoWe know it will because we remember what life was like before. Sucky platforms that were never good enough, always some weird piece of software that you thought was benign gunking up your system. It really did suck. And then…most of the problems were gone and things just worked. I’m ok if this is actually all optional, but I don’t think the anti-Apple crowd is going to be content until iOS is just another Windows. That somehow it won’t just be an unlock that we have buy into and know what we’re are getting into.
- ChrisLTD 3y agoWhy can’t iOS be more like MacOS instead of going all the way to being like Windows?
- CamperBob2 3y agoMan, that Plato guy knew what he was talking about. Try to rescue the prisoners from the cave and they'll fight like wildcats to get back in.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoBecause what we really need are less choices to save us right? “Look at all those poor sheeple buying Apple rather than a more open platform, they shouldn’t be making that choice so let’s take it away from them.”
- ephemeral-life 3y agoIf their bad choices have negative effects on others, for example developers being exploited, then yes the choice should be made for them. It's the same as smoking or drinking. When you smoke, there are harmful effects to third parties so the government limits the use of those products. When millions of people make choices that lead to millions of other people being exploited, governments should get involved. That is the entire point of modern legal systems. Free markets until negative externalities become out of control and then the government steps in.
- spiderice 3y agoThe idea that iOS has been a negative for developers is a hilarious one. Funny that all those poor developers choose to develop on iOS before android because that’s where the money is.
- ephemeral-life 3y agoIs it though? Before the iphone desktops were king. On desktops - developers could use any programming language and there was a standard language that was well supported on pretty much all systems (C), so no need to learn 4 different language ecosystems to target different platforms if you arent a language nerd. - you could release your software to users under any licence you see fit. - Software SDK's billed with flat fee's instead of revenue sharing. - Developers could develop in any environment and didn't have to depend on heavy, buggy IDE's. - Cross compilation for other systems was common. You didn't need a system from the target vendor to build and distribute software (although for testing purposes it was still common). - There weren't arbitrary rules on how you are allowed to monetize your software. The developer experience since the release of mobile systems has dramatically decreased. To say that is not true is just naive. These electronic markets will form no matter what. If apple and google was wiped of the face of the earth today, new markets will form within months. Apple and Google act like the markets are their God given property but in reality they are piggy backing off their first mover's advantage. Honestly, i feel sad to see your type of attitude on HackerNews.
- pharmakom 3y agoThe hardware is better because of RnD, funded by high margins due to software lock-in. Not sure why people struggle to see the connection here.
- jchw 3y agoNobody "struggles" to see something that you literally made up. The original iPhone and iPad were literally global news and that happened before they ever did anything like this. I am sure it made them a rich company, but they were going to be rich anyways. They also hoard money like fucking crazy, so it's not like it's all getting spent on R&D.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Or a worse experience? I mean android phones and tablets are already something you can buy, people still buy Apple products despite that It’s a good natural experiment. In the states, it feels like a good issue to drop for a couple of years from a lawmaking perspective. (Investigation and enforcement should continue.)
- rezonant 3y agoMacOS works exactly like what you are purporting to be undesirable, but I bet you have a Mac, and I bet your experience is none the worse for Apple's wild west policies on it.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoI bought an iPad and an Apple Pencil for drawing. If I could have bought the same hardware with the same functionality, but not Apple, I absolutely would have. It's not because I hate Apple products (I happily use Macintoshes), but because the system is too closed. I overwhelmingly prefer Android, Microsoft, and macOS to iPadOS -- primarily because I can get a browser I like on them, but not on my iPad. If I didn't use it for drawing, I would sell it.
- spiderice 3y agoYou forgot the final line of your argument: “…so we should use the government to force people to build that product I just dreamt up, rather than the one they want to build.”
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoI don't live in the EU or have any connection to the EU, and I am not positioned to have any strong opinion of the laws or court cases there. My argument was against the person above claiming that an open platform makes for a worse product, and that European iPad users would get an inferior experience. I disagree. Let's not forget that Apple invented the smart phone, but then they lost their dominance over the smart phone market. It seems to me that consumers like open platforms. I don't think there should be laws forcing closed platforms to be open, given a competitive marketplace where people have a choice. I think most people will choose open platforms in a free market, but it is good that closed platforms exist for people who prefer them. That is one of the benefits of competition. I do think anti-monopoly laws are necessary for maintaining this competition. However, I don't know enough details of this case to know whether I agree with this specific ruling. I do think the EU can be very heavy handed without sufficiently considering the implications. But that's their business, I guess.
- sujal 3y agoApple didn’t invent the smartphone, never had a the dominant share of phones sold globally. They didn’t even invent the first touchscreen phone. Their innovation has always been marrying software and hardware. It is a high risk approach that they execute well.