7 ms·
The civilian death toll in Gaza has been tragically high but there hasn't been any independent verification. Regardless of what's on Wikipedia, we can't trust s
by nradov 3y ago
The civilian death toll in Gaza has been tragically high but there hasn't been any independent verification. Regardless of what's on Wikipedia, we can't trust specific numbers.
- throwaway421967 3y ago- Israel's own numbers say "2 civilians killed for every one militant"[1], that's 66% - 766 / 1200 = 63.8% Of course, the numbers claimed by other NGOs / UN make it worse. But Israel's numbers are sufficient to make that claim. [1] - https://edition.cnn.com/2023/12/05/middleeast/israel-hamas-military-civilian-ratio-killed-intl-hnk/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2023/12/05/middleeast/israel-hamas-m...
- slibhb 3y agoHamas can't go toe-to-toe with the IDF. They are hiding in tunnels and among civilians, so these ratios aren't surprising. To some extent, you can't blame Hamas for these tactics. They would quickly lose a conventional war. At the same time, if you have zero chance of winning a military victory, perhaps you shouldn't use violence to pursue your political goals...
- SomeoneFromCA 3y agoYes right, if israel is unable to fight conventional war, without massive disproportional amount of civil casualties, they should not probably engage in one.
- llamaLord 3y agoLooking at the historical data, that tends to be a pattern of urban warfare, not the IDF. Civilian/combatant fatality ratios of 3/1 are not uncommon in urban warfare.
- SomeoneFromCA 3y agoAs if we know how many Hamas fighters have been killed at the first place. According to the official stats there is like 259 IDF casualties during the land operation. Which means that death ratio is 30:1 wrt to supposed 8000 Hamas death.Laughable. Even then, military necessity of killing combatants, not actively particpating in the war is not justified. Yes, you can kill those, who is shooting the rockets at Tel-Aviv, but bombing willy-nilly all of Gaza just because there might be tunnels, where potential combatants might be hiding,. is not acceptable, although not am not an international law lawer.
- runarberg 3y agoWell, it is not acceptable, and it seems like the ICJ has, indeed, not accepted it.
- nvm0n2 3y agoThat wasn't their choice ...
- SomeoneFromCA 3y ago"No choice" is how all genocidaires justified their actions.
- dlubarov 3y agoWhat’s the alternative? Just no response and wait for Hamas' next attack?
- nashashmi 3y ago[flagged]
- runarberg 3y agoThen they shouldn’t. That’s the simple answer of it. If they want to get rid of Hamas they will need to find another way. This level of civilian casualty is unacceptable. And as proven by the ICJ decision, it is not accepted.
- krainboltgreene 3y agoThe state of israel agrees with and trust sthe numbers coming from Gaza: https://www.newarab.com/news/israeli-intel-confirms-gaza-health-ministry-stats-reliable https://www.newarab.com/news/israeli-intel-confirms-gaza-hea...
- jdietrich 3y agoWhile their statistics are regarded as an accurate account of the total death toll, they make no distinction between civilian and combatant deaths. This is obviously a crucial shortcoming if we are trying to ascertain whether the number of civilian deaths are disproportionate to the military objectives.
- runarberg 3y agoIf we go all 19th century and assert that all men over the age of 18 are combatants. Then we get 70% of the deaths are civilian, and 30% are combatants. However we know a large number of adult men killed in Gaza or not combatants, e.g. they are journalists, UN workers, poets, university professors, etc. So 66% civilians seems very likely to be a huge underestimate.
- loeg 3y ago[flagged]
- krainboltgreene 3y ago[flagged]
- dlubarov 3y agoOn the other hand “journalists” and UN workers aren’t disjoint from militants or terrorists. We just learned that UNRWA employees took part in Oct 7.
- runarberg 3y ago
- Sporktacular 3y agoDo you believe 695 Israeli civilians, 373 security forces and 71 foreigners, giving a total of 1,139? They're all numbers from the Israeli government. Weird how only disputing the Hamas numbers as biased is a talking point.
- sebzim4500 3y agoIt is way easier to verify those numbers though, there is an actual list of names and journalists can (and have) talk to the families etc.
- Sporktacular 3y agoTrue, verifying 695 deaths is easier than 30 times that number. Also convenient then that journalists are allowed to safely operate there.
- tety 3y agokinda different comparing a state with an organization that was caught lying about death statistics numerous times in the past [1] and including in this war (such as the ali ahli hospital incident). it should raise some questions how the casualty count went to 500 in a few hours, where everywhere else in the world it takes days to get a body count after any disaster It is beyond me how someone can believe that an organization capable of kidnapping babies to advance its political goals is beyond lying to do the same [1] https://www.haaretz.com/2010-11-09/ty-article/hamas-admits-600-700-of-its-men-were-killed-in-cast-lead/0000017f-ee02-ddba-a37f-ee6edc3f0000 https://www.haaretz.com/2010-11-09/ty-article/hamas-admits-6...
- Sporktacular 3y agoThere are lies and errors. From both sides. But the 26000 figure is generally accepted by the UN and aid agencies. Figures from Hamas in previous conflicts have been confirmed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Israel–Hamas_war#Death_toll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Israel–Hamas... https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/gaza-death-toll-records-1.7010255 https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/gaza-death-toll-records-1.7010... Simply dismissing a figure as skewed because of its source without a better one is a weak argument.