7 ms·
Artist trained rats to take selfies to make a point about social media
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoWhen I was.a kid, I "learned" from some authority (TV? book?) that cats and dogs could not recognize process two dimensional images, and that a TV was therefore just visual noise to them.
- hnbad 3y agoSame here and while that's demonstrably not true (the explanation I heard was something about the colors and refresh rate so maybe this was true at some point in the past) the article does state the rats don't recognize themselves - that's different from recognizing the picture or being able to see it. That said, it's really more of an art project than anything to do with science as the article makes it clear the rats were trained to push buttons to get sugar, the selfies were just artistic flourish to make a (fairly overt) point.
- frangolino 3y ago> That said, it's really more of an art project than anything to do with science as the article makes it clear the rats were trained to push buttons to get sugar, the selfies were just artistic flourish to make a (fairly overt) point. according to the article, this was just to get them hooked at first, but they kept doing it later: > After the rats were trained to push the level for sugar, Lignier changed the experiment's parameters. Sometimes taking a picture would yield a piece of sugar, and sometimes would not. > Nevertheless, the rats kept on jamming the button, taking dozens of selfies. After awhile, he says they largely stopped bothering to eat the sugar, even when it came out.
- throw__away7391 3y agoSame here. Obviously this is not true. A ton of "science" taught to kids through seemingly legitimate channels is in fact just the off the cuff intuitions of some thoroughly average adult, and adults on average tend to be staggeringly uninformed on most topics. EDIT: And even more so for history.
- sixothree 3y agoIt may have been true during the days of CRTs. I have had a lot of pets and don't remember any of them showing interest in the televisions whatsoever, other than a source of warmth. And that is definitely no longer true.
- broscillator 3y agoThe observable non-reaction was true, what was not true was the cause, which is the low frame rate. This is the problem with this kind of thing so often, people observe something and an explanation that sounds completely logical gets spread around.
- 1000100_1000101 3y agoI remember a friend's cat following the mouse pointer on an Amiga with a CRT monitor. When moved off the bottom of the screen, the cat would go right up to the screen and try to peer down to see where it had gone. Not sure about dogs, but cats definitely could see a plain 60Hz CRT display... atleast some of them anyway.
- broscillator 3y agoSure but a cat would probably have the same reaction if an arrow behaved like that irl, it's not the same as recognizing something as a living being due to how it moves.
- devbent 3y agoI had a dog growing up that insisted on watching The Price Is Right every weekday morning and she'd bark at you until you changed the channel. Then she'd push a stool in front of the TV, sit on it, and watch Bob Barker for an hour and when the show was over she'd get up and leave.
- ryandrake 3y agoSomething about a dog liking to watch someone whose last name is Barker makes this a great story!
- TechRemarker 3y agoAssuming you looked up the current info on that, according to a quick Google current research all seems to show they can recognize familiar faces in photos.
- TacticalCoder 3y agoWhen I was a kid I was taught by every adult that "humans cannot discern more than 24 fps". Except that we could all immediately tell if a Commodore Amiga demo was running at 25fps or 50fps and groups that'd have the frame rate drop from 50 to 25fps on some frames were "lame". So I knew it was obviously false that humans couldn't discern when something was running at more than 24 fps. Same when little Windows 95 utilities allowed to bump the framerate from 60 to 72 or 75 Hz. I remember those: they'd enhance the experience. Yet everybody was still telling me: "Why do you even bother, 60 Hz is enough, humans cannot discern more than 24 images per second". Same for cats and dogs and the TV of course. Which I knew was wrong because on my Commodore Amiga I'd take a big circle, filled with a solid color, and make it bounce across the screen and watch my cats' reactions. People can be really extremely dumb, even in the face of evidence.
- stephen_g 3y agoThe claim that nobody could discern more than 24 fps is an odd one (and not one I've ever heard), since it's been generally known that's not true even back before 24 fps was chosen as a standard. Originally some (including Edison) wanted to standardise on higher frame rates for better motion. 24fps was basically compromise to balance against the amount of film used, being fairly close to the minimum speed that was considered satisfactory for motion. Even then, a two bladed shutter was used to flash the image on the screen twice for each frame, and more modern projectors used a three-bladed shutter to reduce flicker.
- Izkata 3y ago> being fairly close to the minimum speed that was considered satisfactory for motion. Basically that: It's a repeated and extremely common misunderstanding of the actual claim, that 24fps is right about the threshold between interpreting a series of images as motion instead of a series of images. A lot of people assume that once you see it as motion, there's nothing more that can be gained.
- marcosdumay 3y agoFake knowledge was the most common thing circulating among people back then. People mostly couldn't verify anything.
- kryptiskt 3y agoCats and dogs need higher refresh rates to see TV as a movie rather than a slideshow of images: https://biology.stackexchange.com/questions/8921/why-can-cats-interpret-things-on-a-monitor-tv-but-dogs-cannot https://biology.stackexchange.com/questions/8921/why-can-cat...
- wegfawefgawefg 3y agoVery interesting. Its like smaller brains have a higher clock speed. global oscillations?
- skydhash 3y agoLess processing to be done? Something like a fly has a much lower reaction time than a chicken.
- jacquesm 3y agoSmaller systems tend to tick over faster. Compare a fly heart with the heart of a mammal and the heart of the child with the heart of an adult. Or an elephant... Neural pathways will be longer and so slower, they may have more synapses in them. Overall it would be highly surprising for a larger system to have a higher clockrate than a smaller one.
- sebtron 3y agoIt is very easy (and amusing) to prove this wrong by playing a video of birds / fish / other wild animals and let your cat watch :)
- Lewton 3y agoSure, now it is very easy. But back then animals rarely reacted to CRT tvs
- dudefeliciano 3y agodepending on your age that may have been true, I think old crt tvs refresh rate made it so that dogs would not be able to perceive the actual image.
- wvh 3y agoCats and dogs rely on other senses such as smell and hearing a lot more than humans, who are very visually focussed. They just "see" the world differently and might not be that excited about something that mainly revolves around visual stimuli. I suppose a theoretical cat or dog TV would included a lot of smells, which might not be something you'd actually want in your living room...
- stronglikedan 3y agoMy sisters dog will bark incessantly at the TV if there are specific animals on the screen, such as horses and elephants. Surprisingly, cats and dogs are allowed.
- telman17 3y agoMy aunt’s dog does the same! Horses are not allowed nor are people swimming in any way on TV. The dog also seems to prefer when the actors have British accents.
- mistrial9 3y agothis brings up complicated questions about perception, and the way that thinking links to senses. In other words, it is quite possible that dogs see (poorly, without red) very much what we see, but the cognitive ability and then the "thinking" that happens after that, is very different.
- smokel 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- forsyth2024 3y ago[flagged]
- HenryBemis 3y ago[flagged]
- moolcool 3y ago> I think that in the event of an apocalypse these people will be my competitors for resources and then I feel joy in my soul I read this in Dwight Shrute's voice
- HenryBemis 3y agoHahahaha perhaps it's from exactly that.. I did finish watching 5 episodes of the US The office a few mins before I wrote this!! GREAT catch!!
- yareal 3y ago[dead]
- tokai 3y agoThe connection to selfies is really weak. Its just classical conditioning. The stimulus is the food not the selfie taking, and the continued pressing of the selfie button without food is conditioned response.
- ravenstine 3y agoEven that is attributing too much. When you give animals food, they tend to do things to get that food, humans being no exception. If you plant a soft-serve machine in the middle of a city square, you can bet people will press the lever to receive free ice cream. Hell, just give out coupons for free anything and people will show up. In either case, if you take away the free thing, people will keep returning in hopes the thing will come back, not just because they've been conditioned but because they want more of the free thing. Neat little art project, but it's not that insightful when you think outside the 34th percentile.
- moolcool 3y ago> not just because they've been conditioned but because they want more of the free thing That is what literally what "conditioned" means. You're belabouring a point that OP is already making, and then following that up by sneering at the "34th percentile". Maybe the real art is always in the comments section.
- ravenstine 3y ago> You're belabouring a point that OP is already making I don't believe I am. I'll try to clarify. > That is what literally what "conditioned" means. Yes and no. I'm suggesting that attributing the effect merely to "conditioning" is reductionist. There's some level of conditioning to all biological behavior, and repeating a behavior in response to a reward is not entirely irrational. In principle, it's very rational for rats to keep returning to perform an action they know through experience provided food at some point. The rats in this art project aren't necessarily as thoughtless as conveniently suggested by the conditioning explanation. There's plenty of evidence that rats have the ability to remember details about the past and plan for the future. > and then following that up by sneering at the "34th percentile". I didn't mean it that way, and in retrospect I admit shouldn't have said that. It was rude but that's truly not the attitude I had in mind. Apologies to whom I was replying to.
- Klaster_1 3y agoWhat's the copyright situation of rat selfies?
- simiones 3y agoI think it's established that photos taken by animals are not copyrightable works, so you can do anything you want with them, at least in the USA.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoThat currently applies to photos with animals deliberately triggering the shutter. I would hesistate to say "it's established" without more than one precedent in US case law. However, candid nature photographs taken with camera traps are copyrighted, and Wikimedia Commons has tolerated this status since 2011. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camera_trap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camera_trap https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Photos_taken_with_camera_traps https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Photos_taken_wit...
- chmod775 3y agoSurprisingly (or unsurprisingly?) it's not the first time that question has come up. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_dispute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_selfie_copyright_disput... Note that this also may have implications for AI-generated work. Here's how, ignoring the many legal theories, it's handled in practice in the US right now: > On 21 August 2014 the United States Copyright Office published an opinion [..] to clarify that "only works created by a human can be copyrighted under United States law, which excludes photographs and artwork created by animals or by machines without human intervention". However note that whether it's "copyright free" will depend on the jurisdiction and also that the article is talking about a french artist. While copyright law is very same-ish across the globe (and countries recognize each other's copyright), it often varies in the fine details.
- wongarsu 3y ago> Here's how, [...] it's handled in practice in the US right now: Forgive my ignorance of the nuances of US copyright enforcement, but in what form is the opinion of the US Copyright Office important? The US joined the Berne Convention in 1989, which includes automatic copyright protection without the need to register anything. And if you believe somebody violated your copyright you take them to court, which also doesn't involve the US Copyright Office. Unless they release actual regulation I don't believe their opinion on how to interpret existing regulation really matters, or am I missing something?
- Alifatisk 3y ago[flagged]
- truculent 3y ago[flagged]
- beej71 3y agoIt was a serious oversight to not have the rats take selfies against a green background.
- throwaway58670 3y agoAgreed! Nothing that can't be easily remedied though! https://www.remove.bg/ https://www.remove.bg/
- neom 3y agoTangential, but come on.. how can you not love the lady who "taught her rats to paint"? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7M9us5DQyrY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7M9us5DQyrY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5NFTMuNxQhY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5NFTMuNxQhY
- omoikane 3y agoIs it still called a "selfie" if the rats don't get to see the resulting pictures? The dictionaries I consulted define "selfie" as the photographic output, and not the act of taking pictures.[1][2] I don't see any display device in that setup, so it seems the rats are just pressing buttons for sugar, independent of any camera activity. [1] https://www.oed.com/dictionary/selfie_n https://www.oed.com/dictionary/selfie_n [2] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/selfie https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/selfie Edit: Looks like I just didn't see the screen but it's there.
- hn_acker 3y ago> In Lignier's box, when Arthur and Augustin pushed the lever, a camera would snap their picture and display it on a screen in front of them. The rats do see the pictures.
- fallinghawks 3y agoThe idea that the rats are taking photos of themselves for the (self-aware) pleasure is pretty silly. The rats could have been trained to do anything with this method. Moving from rewarding every time for the desired behavior to occasionally rewarding causes the animal to keep doing the behavior for the reward. And if you stop rewarding entirely, the behavior will continue for a while, and it'll eventually stop. But by then the artist has made their point and doesn't care.
- woliveirajr 3y ago> (self-aware) pleasure Made me think: when humans take photos on {plataform} to receive likes, doesn't it means that humans know to apreciate what comes after those likes? Money, sex, lots of "friends", relationships, oportunities... The pleasure doesn't come from the post itself, and every like isn't a simple like, it is a whole bunch of things that comes with "I like that from you"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]