9 ms·
CNC lasers for cutting and engraving
- DannyBee 3y agoThis talks about accuracy, which is about positioning accuracy, but not repeatability, without which accuracy is mostly worthless. They are also often giving unidirectional accuracy numbers, which doesn't account for backlash in positioning (let alone repeatability). Think of it as (this is not perfectly right but good enough for this explanation): unidirectional accuracy - I command a position from 0. Where am I? bidirectional accuracy - I command a position from 0. Where am I? I command a position in the opposite direction. Where am I? repeatability - I command a position from 0. Where am I? I command us back to zero. Where am I? Repeat. Compare results. It is true that, given a single directional commanded position from 0, the accuracy is likely to be 0.1mm or better. But one missing factor in whether that will be true repeatedly is not just how it is driven, but what is being driven. Is it lead screws? ball screws? gears on rack + pinion? Nothing? If it's nothing, you will have repeatability issues, because both stepper motors alone, and stepper motors + belts, accumulate error through backlash. It is possible to get a lot of the backlash out using the right types of belts or gearboxes or what have you. But even at this price point, you probably want some mechanism (helical rack + pinion, ballscrew, etc) that ensures repeatability, to ensure your accuracy will be worthless.
- rkagerer 3y agoWhat do you think of magnetic linear motors like the one in the new Peoploly Magneto X? Does it help achieve substantial improvements in backlash? BTW I would have expected accuracy would be quoted from a fixed reference point, that would coalesce all the repeatability scenarios you laid out into a single 'worst case', error-does-not-exceed value. (Are you implying with low accuracy but high repeatability you could get good results that are, conceptually, simply offset by whatever margin? Or that you'll get jagged edges / artifacts / incomplete or overdone cuts at scales below the stated accuracy threshold eg. if you have a corner approached by cuts from different ends?)
- carterschonwald 3y agoI’ve been told that magnetic linear motors have much better accuracy.
- jacquesm 3y agoIn principle they do, as do servos, you'll find neither on machines like this. An industrial servo + driver (a single one) costs more than this whole rig. I've designed CNC gear for a living and I'm aware of the way things are done in industry. I think this low cost approach opens up an entirely now domain and if you're making boxes, wooden toys and decorative pieces the accuracy requirements are much less critical than they would be if you were to make parts for aerospace or such, but nobody is going to attempt to do that using a rig like this.
- kragen 3y agoi feel like if brother can make an inkjet printer for a hundred bucks that gets positioning repeatability well below 100 microns with an optical servo, laser engraver makers can do the same thing. my capacitive digital calipers cost like ten dollars and are also in that precision range. optical, magnetic, or capacitive servos don't need to cost thousands
- ComputerGuru 3y agoYou have no idea how much this question has been vexing me! I gave up on the development of a public good product because I couldn’t answer that very question (low cost braille reader). I couldn’t get it to work seamlessly without high precision and couldn’t achieve high precision at low cost. Bought a couple of cheap inkjets and stripped them for parts, found proprietary optical strips and encoders, but still couldn’t figure out how they managed to machine/manufacture the plastic/nylon/POM parts to such high precision and still make a profit. In the end, I surmised they don't make a profit off the parts (though selling at a loss is illegal in the EU?) and rely on the cartridges to make money, but the bigger part of the equation is that they probably have those parts manufactured in massive numbers and with highly tuned and optimized designs carefully matched to the manufacturing process and the application. I even put out ads trying to hire someone that’s worked as an (electro)mechanical engineer at an inkjet company to hire on a contract basis but got no responses. It’s possible those are mainly outsourced - or that the know how turned into domain knowledge that can’t be reproduced these days!
- jfoutz 3y agoThese are excellent points. I think, these are sort of problems after you "level up". Lasers and 3d printers both have pretty light toolheads and no resistance. So you can get away with being pretty half assed with your stepper control, and still get results. You're not wrong. But there's a big mountain of stuff to learn when starting with CNC stuff. Getting a cheap machine, figuring it out, tinkering with it, improving repeatability, these things are all part of how you get better. This is sort of a hobbyist diy mindset. Even if it's not a very good machine, you can still get results out of fusion360, or scad or whatever toolchain you work through. Now, you're absolutely right, if you've got some cash burning a hole in your pocket, you can skip a lot of that machine tinkering hassle. pro level gear is absolutely magical. I'm more of a dabbler kinda guy, try it out, learn about it, if it seems cool 10x my investment in the hobby. Anybody who wants to turn a laser cutter into a business is going to know all the stuff you've addressed. A hobbyist, they're going to need to not die from toxic gas from tanned leather. they're going to need to work out if they want to make stuff or if they want to tinker with the machine (both are totally valid). To be super clear, I agree with all of your points. And it would be good to indicate the suffering you'll go through with a cheap machine. But, I'd argue a cheap machine can still be really fun. It all depends on what you're after.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's all about the work piece. If you have that kind of requirement you most likely aren't going to be making it out of wood anyway, after all wood is an organic material and things like moisture content and temperature and moisture related shrinkage and expansion are going to undo pretty much all of your efforts to achieve 100ths of mm worth of precision. It would cost a fortune and you'd end up with workpieces that are no better than what these cheap machines produce. If you were to improve on this I'd invest in a better laser head long before I'd start to worry about the final bits of precision because for that you are using the wrong material to begin with. Woodwork to within 0.1 mm is insanely precise. You won't be making watches with this, but a mechanical clock with wooden gears is well within the realm of the possible and your accuracy will be much better than that of the best woodworker using non-CNC tooling.
- 3y ago
- jacquesm 3y agoNone of these cheap machines have rack + pinion or ballscrews, that's simply not available at this budget and if it is you'll end up with a machine so small that it is probably worthless. But you probably already knew that. You could retrofit it onto an existing machine but by the time you're done it would cost more than the original and the improvement would be too small to notice. While we're at it let's throw in servos and focus compensation as well as a movable Z axis... But now the machine is priced out of hobbyist territory. An aluminum open frame machine like this is not aimed at industry and so should come with lesser expectations. It doesn't even compensate for thermal expansion of the frame. The belts are usually quite good in quality, contrary to your assertion belt drives do not accumulate backlash (though they will have some it is more or less constant as long as you don't lose steps, which normally should not happen), have a Kevlar component in them to remove a lot of the stretch issues that you'd have with cheaper belts and either the gantry is moved with two steppers or there is a cross gantry shaft which operates a passive gear (without a motor) on the other side. Obviously this isn't perfect, the shaft is long enough that it will see some torsion so when moving fast one side will lag a bit and when you come to a sudden stop you'll see some overshoot. But even at very high speeds and long series of repetitions (100's) I've yet to see any backlash or 'slop' that is visible or measurable with the tools that I currently have at my disposal. This is funny because I totally expected to find a measurable positioning error but given a nice micrometer I find the positioning error when the machine comes to a stop after many 100's of meters of travel to be < 0.1 mm and positioning error from the origin to any point on the machine to be well within the acceptable. The thing that you will notice is that because of the open construction of the frames that the machines aren't going to be square 'out of the box', and you'll spend quite a bit of time getting them to be just so. I don't have access to an interferometer but if I can get my hands on one for bit by borrowing one somewhere I'll do some measurements on it but for now my simple tests suffice to show that the machine is quite usable and produces output that is dimensionally accurate to the point that it makes zero sense to farm out jobs to professional laser cutting services. If I were cutting metal (which you won't be doing with a diode laser for obvious reasons) it would be a different matter, but even there in sheet cutting the tolerances on larger work are different than they are with for instance a mill or a lathe. You won't be making any press-fit shafts with a machine like this, nor will you be cutting gears with 1 mm teeth. For that kind of work it just isn't the right tool, and lasercutting isn't the right process. If you want that kind of precision in sheetmetal you would probably either use a mill (but then your workpieces will likely be small) or you'd etch your workpiece after a photographic process to create a mask. When working in wood, cardboard or textile the precision that these cheap machines offer is ample.
- jfim 3y agoA few things with regards to safety that aren't mentioned in the article. Get laser safety goggles that are appropriate for the wavelength of your laser, and get them from a reputable source. Always wear them whenever the machine is powered. Make sure to have a way to easily and quickly de-energize the laser for when stuff catches on fire, be it an e-stop button or using an outlet with a switch. And don't ever cut PVC. It'll generate chlorine gas, which will either injure/kill you or corrode your machine.
- jacquesm 3y agoExcellent stuff! I will update the article to add these items, one I actually thought off during the writing but forgot to include (the first) the rest I didn't think of but certainly should have. Thank you. Edit: update the article.
- kragen 3y agoi think technically it's hydrogen chloride, not chlorine, that makes cutting pvc hazardous
- elihu 3y agoAlternatively, a machine with a proper enclosure and interlock makes the laser goggles unnecessary. Something else I might add is don't try to cut plywood with phenolic resin. I'm not entirely sure how hazardous the fumes and residue are (probably the main risk is formaldehyde), but phenolic resin also just doesn't cut very well at all. At least, not with a CO2 laser. I'm not sure if diode lasers do better. What seems to work well for me is to check the edge of the plywood -- if it looks like there's a thin black line between the plys, that means it's probably phenolic and it'll make a sooty mess if I try to cut it.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's a good thing to know, I had not yet come across this information anywhere.
- ameminator 3y agoAs a supplement to this excellent breakdown of laser cutting, can I recommend the Guerrilla Guide to CNC [0]. To this day, it's the best reference I've ever read on small volume fabrication with a CNC machine and/or 3D printer. If you enjoyed the original post, you may enjoy this as well. [0] https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/gcnc/ https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/gcnc/
- jacquesm 3y agoI will add this link to the resources section. Thank you. edit: link added.
- double0jimb0 3y agoDelrin/acetal has incredible properties and is great material to laser cut. Make sure to ventilate, small amounts of formaldehyde produced.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's a material I had not thought of yet, I did try some others with unusable results, which I will document when I have a bit more time. Ventilation is a must, I really think the manufacturers of this gear are doing their customers a disservice by suggesting that you can just use them in a dwelling. edit: holy guacamole, that stuff is expensive!! I've found some but it is so expensive that I'll look around a bit longer to see if I can find a coupon for a test somewhere. https://perlaplast-kunststofshop.nl/catalogsearch/result/?q=delrin https://perlaplast-kunststofshop.nl/catalogsearch/result/?q=... another local source: https://richkunststoffen.nl/product/pom-plaat-zwart-6mm/ https://richkunststoffen.nl/product/pom-plaat-zwart-6mm/
- AdamTReineke 3y agoI'm pretty sure I recall hearing that if you cut features that are too thin in Delerin, it gets too hot and catches fire easily. I don't think you were allowed to cut it at the maker space I was at. But it's been like 7 years so I could be fuzzy on that.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's one of the reasons I started with this article in the first place: there is so much knowledge about all of this stuff floating around but it is very fragmented. I wanted to have a single notebook for myself to keep track of what I've figured out, what works and what does not and then it seemed a natural to share it with others. Over time I intend to keep fleshing it out.
- Animats 3y agoYes. I used to laser-cut Delrin using a 75W Epilog in my TechShop days. Probably the strongest plastic you can safely laser-cut. Acrylic can be laser-cut, but polycarbonate in air, no.
- 542458 3y ago> On the plus side that makes diode lasers moderately safer for use by people that haven’t been specifically trained: you can see the beam and if you can then you at least have a chance to block it. I disagree with this. Both diode and tube lasers can instantly blind you. But diode lasers can be a pain to block - because they’re in the visible spectrum you need specialized blocking materials that are opaque in that very specific part of the visible spectrum. Worse still, many have leakage into other frequencies, making them even more difficult to block. On the flip side, a co2 tube is much simpler - some common and readily available plastics transparent to visible light are opaque to the IR wavelengths emitted by co2 tubes, dramatically simplifying blocking material selection. You should never operate any sort of cutting laser without an enclosure and safety goggles, and it’s MUCH easier to do this for co2 lasers.
- sen 3y agoThe number of hobbyist diode laser machines that come with zero enclosure or air extraction is mind boggling. It then leads people to assume that stuff is optional. It’s not.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, it is very much negligent on the part of the manufacturers, on the other hand, at that price point you should look at these as things that you can make a laser cutter from, not a complete product. For instance, my machine was after the initial build quite far out of square, it was a parallelogram rather than a square and it took quite a bit of fiddling to get it to cut square pieces. It also didn't want to stay level and that too took some work to correct. These weren't small errors, > 2 mm in either axis across the 61 cm x 61 cm work area of the machine. But now that it has been set up properly it is quite usable. A 'real' machine has a calibration procedure that will allow you to correct for such errors as well as a large variety of others but these cheap machines just output stepper pulses in fire-and-forget mode without any feedback at all besides the ability to re-home in case they get lost (and the homing switches are so crummy that I'm amazed they work at all). But that usually implies a ruined work piece.
- msds 3y ago
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoIf anyone is interested I designed a 60 inch by 78 inch large format laser cutter that can be built for a couple hundred bucks, designed for cutting fabrics for sewing. It is an ultra low cost design, and it can be built in a way that essentially takes up no extra space in your apartment, because the gantry is removable and the bed is a thin sheet of plywood which you can cover with a rug when the system is not in use. The concept works but in my case the gantry gets a bit sticky and I lose steps, so it needs to be refined. However I have basically abandoned the project. I would love for people to use it as inspiration for future versions: https://github.com/tlalexander/large_format_laser_cutter https://github.com/tlalexander/large_format_laser_cutter I never finished making the youtube video for it, but I have a partially completed video that lacks a voiceover or proper edits for the second half. However it shows the operation of the system and offers some additional detail: https://github.com/tlalexander/large_format_laser_cutter/issues/1#issuecomment-1455587102 https://github.com/tlalexander/large_format_laser_cutter/iss... Notably the design includes a built in raspberry-pi based pattern scanner which can be used to scan in clothes to make copies (with some manual work in inkscape) and can be used to scan in paper sewing patterns.
- jacquesm 3y agoOh that's great, shall I link to your project from the article?
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoYes please! Feel free to link to the video too, which is otherwise buried in the issues page. I do really want this project to get more exposure, but I am lead on a pretty important open source farming robot and that has taken up enough of my time that this laser cutter did not get the attention it deserves.
- jacquesm 3y agoYou probably have a bit of a fumes issue with that setup :) Done. How is the farming robot coming along? I have not kept up the last couple of months.
- bruce511 3y agoI'd be really interested in any thoughts you may have in cutting ceramics, like say tiles.
- jacquesm 3y agoAnything reflective is right out, but I have some tiles of various plumage laying around and I'll run a materials test on them. I'll post an update (this will take a few days to set up). My first response is: wrong process, I'd use a water cutter with an abrasive added to the water for this particular application. But my second response is: you can't be sure without trying, but I predict it will either not work at all or it will take an insane number of passes.
- kragen 3y agomaybe cnc sandblasting with emery will work for that, but it will produce a lot of airborne crystalline silicon dust, which causes silicosis if animals breathe it. maybe better to cut your clay to rough shape before firing and then wet grind to final dimensions after firing if necessary. hot isostatic pressing may also be an option depending on the use
- xyzzy123 3y agoWarning about pvc is good - I feel like sterner caution about leather might be warranted - e.g. veg tan leather is fine (if stinky) but most leather you see is gonna be chrome tanned and lasering it will blast heavy metal vapour / toxic dust into the air and contaminate your enclosure. IMHO if you are a beginner you should be very careful about cutting any material that hasn't been explicitly designed to be laser safe.
- jacquesm 3y agoLeather is really bad, I'll up the warning level on that one, thank you for the pointer. Edit: amped up the warning on leather, also added a more general version of that warning to the heading on materials.
- mattlondon 3y agoSo something that I just can't get past with laser cutting things is the smell. You cut e.g. a Christmas bauble and it stinks of pungent burnt wood ~forever. If there is a laser-cut bit of wood there, it's the first thing you smell as you walk in the room Anyone have any good tricks to avoid that?
- jacquesm 3y agoYou're absolutely right, I can tell whether a laser cut part is present though ~forever seems to be 'a couple of months'. Eventually the smell fades. I'm particularly sensitive to fire smell (we all are but I have my reasons for being a bit more paranoid than most) so this was a real problem initially for me. To remedy you can oversize the part a bit and then sand off the burned edge, you can lacquer or paint it to stop the carbonized wood from escaping (though adherence of lacquer and paint is poor on the burned edge) and you can (lightly) sandblast the pieces. Edit: I've added this to the article in the 'wood' section.
- Ographer 3y agoI got a trash can with a lid for all my small parts and a shop vac nearby to clean out the catch tray of the laser after I cut something smelly. I also upgraded my exhaust fan to make sure nothing got into the room. I got a variable speed DC fan so that I can leave it on a low speed after cutting something smelly to help the smell go outside until it dissipates. I had the most issues with smell when I was using cheap wood from home Depot. When I switched to real Baltic birch the smell wasn't as bad so I think the other stuff had chemicals in it. Acrylic still smells bad but it dissipates quickly.
- jdietrich 3y agoUsing laser-grade ply is important, because often the smell is more glue than wood. Air assist makes a big difference, as does using a well-focussed laser source with good beam quality. Failing that, try a sealer coat of shellac or polyurethane.
- tlarkworthy 3y agoI love Lazer cutting because the drawing format is SVG and therefore it's very easy to to write parametric generators in the programming language of your choice! So it's very easy to connect the physical object to some larger app, like 3d visualizing the expected output or assembly instructions and remain parametric throughout. I'me using observable notebooks to design some things https://observablehq.com/d/1117987aeab1be0d https://observablehq.com/d/1117987aeab1be0d
- jacquesm 3y agoParametric generation of SVG is a really nice tool in the box. That's how https://festi.info/boxes.py/ https://festi.info/boxes.py/ works its magic too.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- djmips 3y agoThe LightBurn software they list in the post is a very cool piece of software!
- ireflect 3y agoIndeed, highly recommended! At Vancouver Hack Space we recently upgraded from LaserCAD (terrible software that came with our 80W CO2 laser cutter ~10 years ago) to LightBurn. It's been a joy.
- jacquesm 3y agoBeware some possible subtle radius compensation bugs in LightBurn, I haven't nailed it down exactly yet and when I do I'll contact them but the inside/outside detection doesn't always work with imported SVG files. This bit me quite badly and it took a while to figure out what was going wrong. Choosing 'optimize toolpath' seems to cure it for now as a workaround.
- djmips 3y agoThere's a Vancouver connection here. Jason Dorie, who started LightBurn is from Vancouver! You might already know that.
- reacharavindh 3y agoI wish the CNC machines with a router instead of the laser became more standardised, and available to buy off of AMAZON and made in a “it just works” territory. The choices are either DIY ones off aliexpress or the more expensive ones like Shapeoko.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe laser cutters are usually also sold as a kit rather than assembled. There are quite a few of these: https://www.aliexpress.com/w/wholesale-cnc-router.html https://www.aliexpress.com/w/wholesale-cnc-router.html Quality is all over the place and given the fact that they have a tool that creates backpressure (and that sometimes wants to 'climb' the workpiece depending on the direction of the cut) any kind of imperfection in the mechanism will immediately show up on the work product. I posted a DIY one the other day that I think is pretty neat https://www.instructables.com/LOW-COST-DIY-500-CNC-MILL/ https://www.instructables.com/LOW-COST-DIY-500-CNC-MILL/ . I don't think anything you buy of Ali or Amazon in this price range will ever be in 'it just works' territory, neither laser nor mill. They're barely functional and usually need quite a bit of tweaking to get them to work properly. And tbh I don't think the Shapeoko is that much better. CNC milling is messy, you'll spend quite a bit of money in tooling and the work area is usually quite limited. If you want a larger machine and it still has to be affordable I'd shop around for an older industrial machine. It will be large and heavy but construction wise there isn't going to be anything small and lightweight that can begin to compete. If you're lucky you might even get a bunch of tooling with it.
- reacharavindh 3y agoIndeed. Thanks for the link to the DIY setup. A few years ago, I would have been super excited about building one like this myself even if it takes a month of tinkering to get it to do what I want. Now with two kids and _life_ the way it is, my 5 hours on Saturday is precious. I need to choose between building tooling versus building the thing I want.. As much as I resist, I’m probably the target audience for companies like Shapeoko. I just can’t pull myself over the wall to spend three thousand plus Euros on a thing that will get used on weekends in my hobby workshop :-( If it was about a thousand euros, I’d have found a way to justify it.. I see all the caveats about the lasers and also the nasty fumes they make me deal with - hence the desire to go with a mill - a known devil to me. Also, I work most of the time with Hardwoods and CNC mill is more appropriate for the task than the laser regardless of power. I’ll keep a look out in marktplaats for any used CNC mills. I hadn’t thought of that.
- fmajid 3y agoI am primarily interested in engraving metals, so I got a 18W fiber laser with a galvo head (laser is deflected by mirrors mounted on magnetic mounts like those on old analog multimeters, much faster than moving the laser head on a gantry).
- kragen 3y agothis is exciting, I look forward to hearing what you end up doing
- fmajid 3y agoMostly engraving tools with my name and contact info, some keychains as gifts (got cheap blanks from AliExpress). Some examples: https://majid.info/images/reddit/laser_dog_tag.jpg https://majid.info/images/reddit/laser_dog_tag.jpg https://majid.info/images/reddit/laser_pliers.jpg https://majid.info/images/reddit/laser_pliers.jpg https://majid.info/images/reddit/flash_drives.jpg https://majid.info/images/reddit/flash_drives.jpg https://majid.info/images/reddit/laser_coin.jpg https://majid.info/images/reddit/laser_coin.jpg https://majid.info/images/laserbinos.jpg https://majid.info/images/laserbinos.jpg
- kragen 3y agowow, that looks fantastic! it looks like you're able to engrave deep enough to cut through thin metal; is that true? how many passes do you need? does it work on aluminum foil, or is that too reflective? how about razor blades? how big is the positioning error, like, what dpi of laser printer is the result similar to? how fast is it, and how much does it cost to run?
- fmajid 3y agoOh hi again Kragen, I didn't notice it was you. This is the specific model (EM-SMart Nova 18W): https://www.em-smart.com/EM-Smart-Nova.html https://www.em-smart.com/EM-Smart-Nova.html I don't have a depth gauge but I would guess 0.1 to 0.2mm. It's with 10 passes, which takes about 8 minutes with a complicated pattern like the crest on the coin (stainless steel, about 20mm in diameter). It doesn't work on brass or raw (not anodized) aluminum, not because of reflectivity but because they are thermally very conductive and don't heat up locally like steel or titanium would. The dog tags are mirror-polished and very reflective, but they engrave beautifully. On anodized aluminum, the laser just strips the anodizing, revealing the raw almunum underneath. Repeatability is excellent on the galvo, otherwise it would not yield good results with multiple passes. I can't give a dpi rating because it is intrincally a vector machine, but here is a pic with a calibrated microscope showing a 1mm square grid superimposed: https://majid.info/images/reddit/laser_engraving.jpg https://majid.info/images/reddit/laser_engraving.jpg Their rating is 0.01mm, which is probably optimistic. In any case, you can see the sparks the metal makes as it is ablated by the laser, that process is inherently a bit messy, just like you can't compare a laser printer's dpi with an inkjet's because the ink drops splatter: https://majid.info/images/print_quality.jpeg https://majid.info/images/print_quality.jpeg The working area is fairly small, about 20cm x 20cm x 10cm, pretty common for galvo heads. The limiting factor is the optics since the laser head itself is stationary and the lens needs to focus on the engraving plane. You focus by raising or lowering the head on a vertical rail using a knob. Some fancier models have motorized Z axes and autofocus cameras. I've never tried on razor blades, I would assume it would punch through. It's likely thermal warping would yield unusable results, however. No idea what the cost to run is, I doubt it's more than a couple hundred watts. The main cost is the laser, I paid $2000 for it on Black Friday special plus about $500 for the enclosure. The brand of the engraver doesn't really matter, they are all assembled using the same lasers, galvos and lenses, just like most PCs are made from the same few components no matter whose brand sits on the faceplate, but getting support will be important. I had to fix mine because the red preview laser burned out. It's not too hard if you have any experience with computers and electronics (no soldering needed) but still a bit disconcerting. The EZCAD 1.x software (Windows-only) is abysmal. I would strongly recommend getting the Mac-only Lightburn software instead if your laser is compatible (mine claimed to be but didn't in practice, and I had no interest in debugging this).
- juggertao 3y agoLasers are so cheap these days. For $50 you can buy a DMX controlled 0.5W RGB laser from AliExpress. I've been thinking about using them for Christmas lights.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's very much not safe! I was at a resort in Eastern Europe over Christmas and on the other side of a lake someone had a rig like that. It caused me no end of trouble because it kept sweeping across the place where I was seated and this was easily a 100 meters or more. Make sure you know what/who you are pointing at.
- mrgaro 3y agoPlease don't. It's so easy to blind somebody with a laser. I always get anxious near laser shows, especially when there's a change it's not done properly as it could still blind you several hundred meters away.
- CarRamrod 3y agoHere are some nuances that I didn't catch (admittedly, skimming) in the article based on my research and experience owning a diode laser for the last few months. I'm not usually one to advocate buying things on Amazon, much less using filters, but in this particular case your eyesight is on the line. Unless you know a dealer of the following products that you personally trust, buy on Amazon and sort by "Avg Customer Review". And for the love of God, do your due diligence and take everything you hear about these things with a grain of salt. First of all, the fireproof fibreglass enclosures generally work fine, but don't trust their tinted plastic windows to protect your eyes. The best practice with these things is to cultivate a habit of always, ALWAYS putting on your goggles before you ever enter the laser room. If other adults have access to the room it's in, hang a couple pairs on the door with a warning sign to never enter without goggles. Make sure they know the rules. Children should never, under any circumstance, enter a room containing a diode laser. If your diode laser came with green goggles, those are almost certainly not good enough. Even if it was an expensive kit you bought. They're still the wrong ones. Look for ones with orange lenses that have video showing their lenses smoking/burning when the laser is pointed at them. And even then, make sure you have an enclosure with orange/brown tinted windows. Consider both proper goggles and the tinted window to be the absolute bare minimum in terms of eye safety. If you bought a fibreglass enclosure and it came with a fan, it's probably too weak to do the job it needs to do. Get an inline fan that's marketed for growing weed. The diameter of the inlet and outlet ports should be smaller than that of the area within which the fan spins. The ones shaped like a can of beans almost certainly aren't going to be up to the job. If your enclosure's design / instructions "require" the installation of a computer fan between the enclosure and the ducting adapter, you should ignore them and bolt the adapter right onto the the enclosure. The general idea for exhausting your fumes is Enclosure->Ducting->Fan->Ducting->Exhaust Port. The exhaust port should vent outside of the building. If you own, drill baby drill and attach a permanent pest-proof vent out of which you will vent the exhaust. Otherwise buy one of the window ones. On the subject of fans, because these enclosures are so small, make sure you buy a fan speed controller specifically designed for inline fans unless you spec out the CFM properly. You need a proper one because running large inline fans below a certain speed threshold will damage them, but on the other side of the coin, an overpowered fan is a waste of electricity at best and a safety hazard at worst. And an underpowered fan is effectively useless. My final note for now is that there is, in fact, a method to the madness of the design of the enclosures with no bottom. Any fan worth its salt will be airtight enough to use suction to hold your enclosure down on the tabletop even with its intake window(s) open. This is a good thing - a fully enclosed fibreglass box would not allow sufficient air movement to vent fumes. There is so, so much more to it, but in terms of safety logistics, I think that's most of the important points.
- azazel75 3y agoSome years ago with a friend we built a Lasersaur ( https://lasersaur.com https://lasersaur.com ) from scratch. It is equipped with a 130 w CO2 laser. Amazing open source project. Unfortunately the guy that stays it abandoned the project, but there a ton of resources there
- perecg 3y ago> if the spot size is asymmetrical, so you need to cut slower in the direction where the beam is less focused for consistent results Some CAM software orient the trajectories so that the part is always on the same side of the trajectory (i.e. only G41 or G42 is used in a given NC file). This is what we do at https://nestandcut.com/ https://nestandcut.com/.
- jacquesm 3y agoDoes that take the oval shape of a typical stacked laser head into account or does it assume a circular spot?
- perecg 3y agoCurrently we modelize a circular spot. When the machine has 5 axes the post-processor may tilt the beam axis to compensate a conic beam (especially useful in oxy-fuel cutting and water jet cutting afaik).
- jacquesm 3y agoJust the knowledge that the spot is oval is already useful: you could compensate cutting speed to correct for that and get a more even burn. A simple trick to check the shape of the spot is to set the beam to low power and to purposefully increase the Z as far as it will go and project the beam on a piece of black anodized aluminum. You'll very clearly see the alignment of the individual diodes and as you lower the Z you see them converge on what eventually will become the focal point. This gives you very useful hints about the shape of the cone, on my machine the cone is definitely oval (if not outright linear!) in cross section, far longer in X than in Y. This results in an ~ 30% penalty in cutting speed depending on the direction of travel. To ensure full penetration I have to set the machine 30% slower, whereas if the software compensated I'd be able to run the same speed with much more consistent kerf width as a result and less time wasted.
- perecg 3y agoInteresting, do you do the speed reduction per-axis or globally ?
- drra 3y ago> Seriously: stay away from most plastics and all PVC Could you still test it wit EVA (ethylene-vinyl acetate) foam? I use it for prop-making. While it's easy to cut with knife, CNC laser would make that stage much faster.
- CarRamrod 3y agoSure! In fact I'm just starting a test burn andllll'llll let you kn
- mobilemidget 3y agoIs that the Macbook I put linux on for you? :) RB
- jacquesm 3y agoHey R, yes, it is!! It still goes strong even though the battery doesn't hold much charge any more. Quite amazing, given that it's been around the planet three times or so and it hasn't exactly been treated friendly.
- sylware 3y agoIf we could get off-the-self and cheap CNC cutters to deal with aluminum ~2-3mm plates... But I don't think it is possible. A pain to get that DYI keyboard plate (no, I don't want to use a PCB).
- jdietrich 3y agoDepends on your definition of "cheap", but a Shapeoko handles light cuts in aluminium very well. Cheaper routers are readily available on Aliexpress if you don't mind tinkering. https://shop.carbide3d.com/collections/cnc-routers https://shop.carbide3d.com/collections/cnc-routers
- sylware 3y agoI did watch some youtube video about "cheap" aluminium cutting (carbide mills), it is far from easy. It seems plasma/high energy laser cutters are a must.
- jacquesm 3y agoPlasma cutting aluminum has challenges all its own. Hydrogen production for one (you can imagine where that's going :) ), and you'll need some shield gas to make it work reliably. Cutting speed is going to be pretty impressive, edge quality not so much compared to a laser.
- 3y ago
- Kosirich 3y agoThere is a boom in this field in recent years, specifically for laser texturing using femtosecond lasers. What were 10 years back laboratory lasers are now being put on standard CNC machine gantrys. Unfortunately, what I see lacking in high end laser CNC machine market is software and no separation between CAM programming and execution that exists for milling machines. There is no equivalent to G-code that can be generated on w/e software and then run on different machine. There are cases where this is impossible as due to the way it's done, it would quickly overload even large RAM memory capacities.
- huytersd 3y agoWhat’s the problem with just using existing CAD/CAM software and gcode?
- jacquesm 3y agoI don't think there is a problem per-se, it's just that G-code tends to be rather static so if you're doing things like nesting and engraving of variable text going through and extra G-code conversion step can get a bit tedious. I'm old school enough that I can program G-codes by hand (and by heart), compared to normal programming it is super simple, you can pick it up in an afternoon. But for complex graphical work the automatic conversion to G-code from a drawing tool is a real time saver. CAD/CAM software tends to export in some 2D format for laser cutting, usually either a 2D DXF file or SVG. You then convert on the fly to G-code in the laser driver software.
- micwag 3y agoI'm working in the laser marking/engraving field, we actually discussed G-code internally but in the end decided against it as it was not suitable for our product. (Too many laser parameter and "dynamic" stuff like QR codes)
- smallerfish 3y agoI'm waiting for the price to come down a little. I need to engrave 200+ plant labels for my garden, but I can't justify spending $2-3k on a machine that could handle that.
- jacquesm 3y agoIf you're near me you are very welcome to come by.
- FuriouslyAdrift 3y agoJust be sure the ventilate the area properly https://www.theregister.com/2017/01/30/berkeley_maker_couple_asphyxiated_by_fumes_suspicion_falls_on_home_laser_cutter/ https://www.theregister.com/2017/01/30/berkeley_maker_couple...
- iancmceachern 3y agoAnd have fire suppression and detection
- jacquesm 3y agoWow that's ugly, and yes, that's covered. And without that I consider a laser cutter to be both utterly unsafe and unusable. Edit: I thought that was familiar: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13507734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13507734 Edit2: it turned out to be CO2 poisoning after all.
- hdivider 3y agoInterestingly, if you're doing CNC laser cutting as a business, with the larger CO2 laser cutters, you're gonna spend a lot to keep replacing those CO2 laser tubes. Because the gas degrades with heavy use, even if the tube is intact. Why can't you just refill the gas? Because the precise gas combination that makes for a stable, reliable laser tube was monopolized ages ago. Because of that one trade secret, countless tubes end up in the trash and way more than necessary are manufactured. Classic case where monopolization of scientific knowledge can end in significant unnecessary waste.
- the_optimist 3y agoWell, what is it?
- codazoda 3y agoIf you have trouble engraving tumblers, I've found a trick that works really well. The tool ensures that the laser maintains consistent focus at both edges of the tumbler resulting in a more uniform engraving. I call it The Tumbler Trick™ and I've posted instructions on how to make your own at the URL below. https://www.tumblertrick.com/how-to-make-the-tumbler-trick-diy.html https://www.tumblertrick.com/how-to-make-the-tumbler-trick-d...
- jacquesm 3y agoDo you use a special lens for such long focus work? I don't think my machine has the depth-of-field required for engraving across more than a few mm deviation in the Z direction.
- codazoda 3y agoWe aren't using a special lens. It works but only within a certain range. The ideal laser focus, on our machine, is only about 3mm from the lens body. The handle posts necessitate moving the laser head farther away, to around 11mm. So, we move the laser head as close as possible without hitting those posts. We don't bend the posts for fear of damaging them. This tool helps level the cup edges the best we can. My wife makes between 25 and 100 of these cups a month and this tool really helped her. We were using a digital level and having to create a design of the cup edge and figure out the angle for each brand and size. This gets rid of that complexity. The laser is out of focus for the majority of the burn but it's in a range that allows it to work well on powder coated tumblers. Specifically, we use a Creality Falcon 2 Diode 22W laser for tumblers. It's not, however, the machine I would recommend to others, for a number of reasons.
- jacquesm 3y agoVery interesting comment, ok I will abstract and put this in the engraving section, is there a set of materials and/or colors that you find work better and others that really do not?