8 ms·
The things nobody wants to pay for
- zeroCalories 3y agoI don't know much about the Kernel or testing it, but I submitted one fix years ago that I ended up testing it manually, and that was enough for it to be accepted. I think that's just the culture, which might seem odd to some, but also I imagine it would make coordination almost impossible if they were sticklers for testing. I've also known companies to run full integration tests instead of using stuff like unit tests. Maybe that's more suitable for Kernel testing due to how complex the kernel space environment is. Wondering if anyone has more context. On a different note, I think it's true that the Linux desktop still sucks in 2024. At this point I would be willing to pay a substantial amount for stuff to be clean, consistent, and "just work" on the desktop. Doubt we will ever get there, but maybe companies like Valve will clean it up enough.
- satiric 3y agoOf the ones you listed, consistency is the big downside for me. It seems like there's multiple options for everything in the Linux ecosystem. From the beginner questions (e.g., which distro), to the nerdy questions (e.g., systemd vs sysvinit), to the ones in between (e.g., vim vs emacs). I sometimes wonder if GNU Herd would have been better at this, since everything would be designed by the GNU folks for one unified ecosystem. I don't think Valve will fix it TBH. They only care about Linux UX on their hardware, i.e. Steam Deck. I don't see why they would fund things like KDE, or features in the kernel beyond the ones that they need for their products to work. (Not that I think they're assholes for this; just that it's unfortunate)
- p_l 3y agoThey are very much upstreaming things a lot, in ways that support more than just their hardware, which results in general boost for everyone. They definitely could have done it differently and in cheaper ways (just look at every embedded platform). As for KDE, Steam Deck runs KDE.
- massysett 3y ago> I sometimes wonder if GNU Herd would have been better at this, since everything would be designed by the GNU folks for one unified ecosystem. You just invented *BSD.
- timeon 3y agoWhichBSD?
- p_l 3y agoConsidering Hurd is mentioned, I humbly nominate OSF/1
- satiric 3y agoWhich BSD has its own desktop environment? Which BSD has centralized, discoverable settings? (discoverable meaning I don't have to dig into man pages to figure out what to do). BSD is better but still doesn't go far enough IMO. FWIW, I have never needed to dig into Windows' help system or Google to figure out how to use Windows Settings or the old Control Panel.
- massysett 3y agoNone of them. But GNU does not have this either. For awhile GNOME was part of the GNU project, but isn't now, and even when it was, X was not a GNU project. GNU has this random assemblage of packages: https://www.gnu.org/software/software.html https://www.gnu.org/software/software.html So add the Hurd to that, along with an actual distribution mechanism (not a trivial task), and what you get is something like a BSD.
- satiric 3y agoAh OK, I stand corrected. Looks like my pipe dream of getting a Unix derivative as unified as Windows stays unattainable then (although KDE Neon was pretty good last time I tried it, from a Settings point of view anyway)
- internetter 3y agoValve does fund KDE
- candiddevmike 3y ago> clean, consistent, and "just work" on the desktop In my experience, most Linux desktop environments are leaps and bounds ahead of Windows here. What specifically do you want fixed?
- zeroCalories 3y agoI hate having different install methods for every distro. I don't wanna build from source. Even if you give me a binary, I don't wanna manually make a symbolic link. I hate having multiple conflicting ways to do the same thing. Even within something like Ubuntu I can think of eight ways I've installed software. Steam regularly fails to open, and games compiled for Linux, not running through proton, regularly crash. Hardware features randomly don't work. My laptop won't go to sleep when closed and runs full power while in my backpack. My extra mouse buttons that could be bound in windows without an issue didn't work on Linux. Everything about Linux irritates me these days. I don't want to use other OSes for ideological reasons, but my problems have only increased since moving to Linux on my personal machine.
- gorjusborg 3y agoI'm sorry you are so annoyed, I've been there too. That said, I wonder if some of the pain you are feeling is self-imposed. If you just use a single linux distribution, it is generally consistent in its install methods. Wouldn't you find it weird if someone complained about how the MacOS install process differed from Windows? That's roughly the equivalent of what you are saying. The power management issue is a real problem, and it plagues not just linux, but the PC ecosystem (x86 / intel,amd) in general. MacOS gets around this by tightly controlling their hardware and software to create a great experience. It's harder on the PC side due to the sheer number of configurations of hardware and software that have to cooperate to accomplish good power management. This is the same root cause w/ 'hardware feature' support. A PC is a collection of independently designed hardware and software, smooshed together into some sort of computer. Making that work is difficult due to the sheer number of combinations that are possible. My feeling is that this situation is ripe for solution by a company that treats their software and hardware as a complete system, and to deeply attack these challenges by curating (and eventually designing, if needed) components and software to polish the user's experience.
- n0-n0-wait 3y agoOT - yes, weekendmodus: check!! But an humoristic aproach, "There was a bug-request for v1.0: 'Copying parts of graphics overwrites the text-buffer, and copying text (for whatever use) overwrites the graphics buffer! Still no progress.', for whatever reason." (-;
- Timber-6539 3y ago> At this point I would be willing to pay a substantial amount for stuff to be clean, consistent, and "just work" on the desktop. Which alternative exists today that comes even close to this described utopian product?
- roenxi 3y agoMarkets approximate an algorithm where you line up everyone who can do a job by willingness to do it, then pick the cheapest if someone is willing to pay that much. In the case of open source, that algorithm usually identifies volunteers. Sometimes it identifies businesses. Sometimes people come up with clever ways of funding projects (Red Hat the enterprise was genius from this perspective, they organised a solution to tragedy of the commons in core infrastructure and made a lot of money doing that). I suspect there does need to be a regular social renewal to resolve the tragedy of the commons problem. I expect that the network of OSS foundations and companies will regularly becomes corrupt and ineffective and need to be purged then replaced. That implies there is a fine line of healthy complaining - people need to communicate where the problems are by complaining, but it is useless trying to blame people like kernel maintainers for poor testing. It is good to stop and appreciate how beautiful the dance is; this is one of the purest free markets we have in the world and it is pretty amazing how well it hangs together since it looks like a hearty sneeze could bring the whole thing down.
- morelisp 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jorvi 3y ago> I suspect there does need to be a regular social renewal to resolve the tragedy of the commons problem. Wouldn’t the solution offered on LWN work great? Just excise a tax (well, I guess a licensing cost) for open source use to any corporation that is above x$ amounts of revenue. Make it a tiny percentage (0.1%?). 2022 revenue: - $400 billion, Apple - $200 billion, Microsoft - $120 billion, Meta - $80 billion, AWS $800 billion * 0.01 = €800 million of “sovereign OSS fund” funding. And that’s just the big ones. Bing tells me the 2022 combined revenue of all NASDAQ listed companies is ~$6900 billion. That’s $6.9 billion in OSS funding you’d skim off! What’s more, with how much that would improve open source projects, those companies would see enough productivity improvement that despite the 0.1% in skimmed revenue, they’d see a net benefit.
- artagnon 3y agoThis echoes the problems we see in LLVM. Tooling is de-prioritized in several large corporation-funded open-source projects.
- newgre 3y agocan you elaborate?
- hashtag-til 3y agoMany thousands of companies use LLVM in their products and benefit from the technology. As it is an open source project, in an ideal world, it would e fair to assume they would somehow contribute back, but instead they just take it for granted as there is a group of people who make it available for free. (please read to the end before posting your "wHy pUt iT oPeN-sOuRcE tHeN???" bigoted comments) Don't get me wrong: It is perfectly legal for anyone to do so, as the project is available under a permissive license and you are not mandated to do anything to contribute back. I'm just trying to clarify the point made by OP here, and clarifying that some infrastructure tooling such as compilers and debugger are often taken for granted, and even rich companies opt not to contribute back.
- jeffbee 3y ago> they just take it for granted I just looked at 1 page of the most recent commits to the LLVM project and every single one of them is from a corporate developer. I can't imagine how to arrive at the conclusion that the industry takes LLVM for granted. The major LLVM subprojects that I follow are not just largely written and maintained by large companies, but were also initially invented and contributed by them.
- hashtag-til 3y agoAnd how many companies are those? FAANG, major linux distros, plus a small list? Now compare that with the corporate user base…
- 3y ago
- oneshtein 3y agoAI can help with documentation. Simple tool can annotate all files and function using ChatGPP4 in few hours, then check it for correctness and completeness, then fix bugs, for few hundred dollars.
- Diti 3y agoThat wouldn’t help with the issues described in the article, I think. That is, license violations (LLMs happen to produce almost-verbatim copies of copyrighted works at times) and lack of volunteers (you’d need to hire a technical writer to ensure the generated documentation is actually correct and complete, and nobody is going to want to accept being hired for cheap for fixing AI-generated documentation).
- oneshtein 3y agoI just checked it with Bard: Me: Annotate main scheduler in linux kernel version 6 for interactive workload on multiple cores. Bard: I'm unable to directly annotate kernel code, but I can provide a detailed explanation of the main scheduler's components and mechanisms for interactive workloads on multiple cores in Linux kernel version 6, incorporating images where appropriate: Key Components: Completely Fair Scheduler (CFS): Primary scheduling class for interactive tasks Aims for fairness and responsiveness Employs a red-black tree (image below) to organize processes based on their virtual runtime (vruntime) Processes with lower vruntime are given priority Зображення: redblack tree data structureВідкриється в новому вікні www.eecs.umich.edu redblack tree data structure Per-CPU runqueues: Each CPU core maintains its own runqueue Stores processes ready to run on that core Reduces contention and improves cache locality Load balancing: Mechanisms to distribute processes across cores for optimal performance Triggered when a core becomes idle or imbalanced Migrates processes from overloaded cores to underloaded ones Scheduling Process: Process Creation: New processes are assigned to a suitable scheduling class (CFS for interactive) Added to a runqueue, initially on the core where they were created Process Wakeup: When a process becomes ready to run: Added to the runqueue of the core where it last ran or a suitable core (load balancing) Process Selection: CFS periodically selects a process from the runqueue Chooses the one with the lowest vruntime (most deprived of CPU time) Context Switch: The scheduler saves the state of the running process Restores the state of the selected process to resume execution Key Features for Multi-Core: Per-CPU runqueues: Minimize cache-line bouncing and inter-core communication Improve performance on multi-core systems Load balancing: Ensures efficient use of all available CPU cores Prevents cores from becoming idle while others are overloaded Scalability: CFS design scales well with increasing core counts Maintains fairness and responsiveness in large systems Additional Considerations: Scheduler domains: Hierarchical structures for managing CPU resources across multiple cores or NUMA nodes Allow for fine-grained control over scheduling policies Preemption: CFS supports preemption to prevent processes from monopolizing the CPU Ensures interactive tasks remain responsive Remember: Linux kernel version 6 is under development, so specific details may change. The scheduler is a complex component with various optimizations and tuning parameters. Understanding its behavior requires deeper exploration of the code and experimentation.
- huijzer 3y agoI once compared Linus Torvalds' net worth to Warren Buffett's net worth. I think they are both extremely capable individuals in their fields. Torvalds earns about 10 million per year. With that income, it would take Torvalds 12k years to reach the same net worth as Buffett (about 124 billion). Put differently, Buffett could personally fund 10k open source contributors 200k per year for their lifetime (60 years) if he wanted to. So maybe that's the solution? Convince billionaires that open source software is a philanthropic endeavor?
- giantg2 3y ago"Torvalds earns about 10 million per year" I'm curious how he earns so much? That seems like a lot for someone who is associated with FOSS, even if they are so influential/skilled.
- kornhole 3y agoYou would need to convince them that it is a philanthrocapitalist endeavor. If they see how it can help them avoid taxes and steer policy to benefit their investments, they might join on. Unfortunately open source SW goes pretty much opposite in the direction Gates and Buffet want to go. They want license everything and make us dependent on it as a subscription.
- offices 3y ago
- ableal 3y agoI'd make two notes on this. First, I've taken to looking at the economics as shared infrastructure costs - companies look at the volunteer built pot and make a self-interested decision on participating. Second, this observation - "commoditize your complements" - seems still as apposite as when it was published in 2002: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/06/12/strategy-letter-v/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoOpen source is the biggest voluntary transfer of wealth from the working class to the business/investor class ever. Software in the modern economy is the "means of production" and software developers have given it away free to the business/investor class. The investor class, happily funds software startup gambles that people pour their lives into knowing that most will fail but they will still statistically make bank. Companies making billions of profits lay off people who have made massive contributions of open source ( see for example Ben Collins-Sussman https://social.clawhammer.net/blog/posts/2024-01-10-GoogleExitLetter/ https://social.clawhammer.net/blog/posts/2024-01-10-GoogleEx...) knowing that the software will still maintained by volunteers without them having to pay for it.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoMy career solely exist because of foss. My salary level is only that high because of foss. I don't feel like I've been in a bad position.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y ago> My career solely exist because of foss. You are likely an excellent software engineer. Why would a company not have hired you to work on non-foss software?
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoThey did. But how do you think I got interested in software in the first place? How do you think I practiced my skills ? How do you think I created my toolbox, met my peers, solved problems beyond my reach, and eventually created a company, while feeling good about it?
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoA lot of us did all that before FOSS was a big thing. Yes I did have to get my wallet out to buy a copy of Turbo C but it wasn't much of a barrier (at least compared to the hardware costs).
- andrey_utkin 3y agoYou're welcome to "audiobook" of this by Piper TTS (en_US-lessac-high): https://autkin.net/audiobooks/things-nobody-wants-to-pay-for/nobody-wants-pay-for.txt.opus https://autkin.net/audiobooks/things-nobody-wants-to-pay-for... (8:13)
- AlbertCory 3y agoI have a better idea for funding: All the tech billionaires and their ex-wives throwing money at cool and fashionable causes should redirect a small part of it to the industry that made them rich.
- planede 3y agoAs an individual where do I click and say donate $20 towards the development efforts of the Linux kernel? It looks like one can donate towards the LF as a whole [1], but the LF manages a ton of other projects besides Linux. So if was possible to restrict small donations towards the development of the Linux kernel, that would be great. [1] https://www.linuxfoundation.org/about/donate https://www.linuxfoundation.org/about/donate
- phkahler 3y agoDirected donations don't always work. If there is a fund paying to multiple things and you say "this $20" goes to that project, they can just send that much less from the fund and send it elsewhere. My state promised that money from the lottery would go to education rather than the general fund. It does, but that doesn't mean education got more money when they started the lottery.
- planede 3y agoThe question is how much unrestricted donations would the Linux Foundation get if they offered directed donations as well. They might not get enough unrestricted funds to pull this. It might also not look good on them if they used the unrestricted donations in a very unbalanced way to counter restricted donations the way you describe, so they might get less unrestricted donations in the future.
- red_admiral 3y agoIt's strange not to mention the OpenSSL situation pre-Heartbleed in this article. It would make a very strong case for funding critical "infrastructure" - I think the fallout from that was estimated at half a billion dollars or something?
- jeffbee 3y agoIt's not an interesting situation. OpenSSL is a dysfunctional project, maintained by unreasonable, antisocial people, following exactly none of the practices that professional software developers take for granted. Throwing money into that project solves none of its problems. On the other hand many of these problems are solved by just ignoring them and reimplementing their junk, which is what several companies have done.
- skybrian 3y agoI'm guessing that with some neglected projects, fundraising is neglected as well? Maybe people would contribute with the right fundraising campaign? There are no guarantees that anyone is interested, but it seems hard to tell whether that's true in advance.
- bxparks 3y agoI must not be the first person to think that government sponsorship can play a positive role with funding and promoting critical software projects. Just as basic science research is funded by agencies such as the NSF, NIH, DARPA, DoD, and so on. Even the Arts have the NEA. Where is the National Institute of Critical Software? People working on software projects could apply for grants, which would be reviewed by a panel of peers and experts, then funded, and the impact of the software project can be reviewed. I would think that judging the value of a software project would be easier than many basic science research, because the impact of software is more immediate and easier to measure. Yes, any system that involves money will be susceptible to some amount of fraud, waste, and deception. But most people still support funding science and medical research.
- WalterBright 3y agoOpen source software is doing just fine. The siren song of government intervention will not make it better. > People working on software projects could apply for grants, which would be reviewed by a panel of peers and experts, then funded, and the impact of the software project can be reviewed. That's the dream. The reality is that the money will get allocated according to politics and corruption. The money will come with strings attached, and a lot of extraneous bureaucratic requirements. An industry will spring up that is specialized in getting as much grant money as possible.
- r14c 3y agoIf we recognize that the US government is corrupt, which I believe is a pretty universal sentiment among Americans, why aren't there any substantial anti-corruption movements?
- chrisknyfe 3y agoThe anti-corruption movements on the right get co-opted by fascists. The anti-corruption movements on the left get bombed by the police and sniped by the FBI.
- mike_hearn 3y ago
- ThinkBeat 3y agoI find it hard to understand that the head of Mozilla foundation is paid nearly $7 million for the important job to run the foundation. Linus gets paid $1,5 million (from the Linux foundation). I think given the central position and importance of Linus compared to the head of the Mozilla foundation seems a bit off. A little while ago Linus announced that they had lost power at their home due to a large storm. I was picturing large corporations sending in giant Tesla batteries and diesel generators and hooking it all up in hours. (free of charge of course). but as far as I know it did not happen. It might have if he asked for it I suppose. Linus seems like a most humble guy, given his celebrity status, his life's work and his high importance to the world. (I do see things that he has several other income streams than just the Linux Foundation so that s good)
- rqtwteye 3y ago"I find it hard to understand that the head of Mozilla foundation is paid nearly $7 million for the important job to run the foundation." That's pretty insane. I used to view Mozilla as "good guys" but it seems they are more like a lot of other non profits that are run mainly for the benefit of their executives.
- ametrau 3y agoI believe a good size chunk of that 7 million comes from Google. Which is a pretty strong conflict of interest.
- wmf 3y agoLinus doesn't bring in any revenue or manage the foundation. He's more like the CTO of Linux. Mozilla has over $500M revenue and almost a thousand employees.
- ofcourseyoudo 3y agoAt first glance, I genuinely that this was a troll post about paywalled content with the title and the "subscriber-only" messaging all around it.
- phkahler 3y ago>> Have you ever wondered why KDE was deprecated in RHEL? It wasn't just because KDE Plasma 5 was so big that they couldn't make the jump for RHEL 8, it was also because people were not paying for RHEL for the desktop, so they had no budget for more people. When you make code libraries or other "infrastructure" software it's important to be as stable as possible so your users don't have to constantly maintain compatibility. I suspect if it was easier to upgrade RH would have kept it KDE around. Same can be said for some of the Gnome updates too, and other software as well. "Maintenance" should be minimized particularly when people are working for free.
- ranger207 3y agoThis is why I'm sad to see the widespread use of MIT and BSD licenses, and others that allow the project to be pulled into closed-source services without anything returned. At the least use the GPL so that changes are upstreamed; ideally license it for free under something like the AGPL and then offer it under less restrictive terms in exchange for a fee
- pie_flavor 3y agoI love the irony in this being a subscriber link to a paid LWN article, LWN being one of the things people do not want to pay for.
- yencabulator 3y ago> The kernel community has never put the effort into tooling that it needs; I know a certain git that might disagree.