6 ms·
NSA Buys Americans' Internet Data Without Warrants, Unclassified Letter Says
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated from last week: Feds crack down hard on selling of personal data without consent https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39062247 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39062247
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NFVLCP 3y agoTherefore, so did China and Russia and anyone else.
- kromem 3y ago[flagged]
- caseysoftware 3y agoThis BS is allowed by "Third Party Doctrine" which means that once you give information to a third party, you no longer have a legitimate "expectation of privacy" so therefore you don't have one. For example, if I want to pay you $100: - I can give you $100 directly in cash. We can limit that knowledge to two people, therefore it could remain private. - If I pay you via check, credit card or Paypal, now I've involved a third party and the government can collect any information they want. It's up to that third party to choose not to share it. Check out the book "Habeas Data" if you want to understand the US rules - and how we got there - https://amzn.to/311a0yl https://amzn.to/311a0yl
- thfuran 3y agoThe third party doctrine is eminently unfit for the modern era.
- xnx 3y agoFor the level of surveillance taking place, I want a lot less crime.
- ironmagma 3y agoI don't. That would require them to use it.
- throwawayqqq11 3y agoBe careful what you wish for, because you wont just get less crime but less deviant behavior. We are borg.
- bawolff 3y agoIt seems like the problem is that the information is for sale at all. I generally think warrants should be needed when police (or i guess spies) do something that an ordinary citizen wouldn't be allowed to do. If the info is available for purchase by anyone, then i don't think warrants should be needed.
- geraldhh 3y agoone step further: the problem is the existence of the data as in, pii should be a massive liability and everyone should be incentivized to avoid collecting it
- aetch 3y agoI’ve got news, lots of fellow HN readers support this data collection through jobs called the ad / marketing industry.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- geraldhh 3y agobarely news, thou most industries profit from consumer insight in some way
- bawolff 3y agoMaking it illegal to sell would go a long way in that direction.
- geraldhh 3y agonot as much as it would strengthen black markets
- janalsncm 3y agoThis makes it seem as if the NSA would stop spying on Americans if the data wasn’t available on the open market. If we just change our data privacy laws! Historically, the NSA doesn’t care whether they get the info off the open market or from in-house infrastructure. They’re probably doing both now. The problem isn’t this particular method they happen to be using today. The problem is that the NSA and the 4th Amendment are often in conflict, and the NSA wins because there’s no consequences for violating it.
- pockmockchock 3y agoI think this Orwell guy talked about this, I think there is even a book? Probably nothing. lol
- hulitu 3y ago> NSA Buys Americans' Internet Data Without Warrants, Unclassified Letter Says I really hate to take NSA part on this, but, if the data is available on the open market, why would they need a warrant. The problem is not that NSA buy it (they have access to it anyway, through other means) the problem is that everyone can buy it.
- blitzar 3y agoVC backed startup sells user data on open market.
- oneplane 3y agoThink of it this way: knives are available on the open market, that doesn't mean NSA can just go around stabbing people. The concept of a warrant is to have an authorization to do something that an entity would normally not be allowed to do. So if the NSA would normally not be allowed to have some bit of information, then it doesn't matter where that information is, how it is acquired or how 'available' it is. Of course, that's all up to interpretation because the various documents/amendments etc. are all made up in legalese that relies on precedent and opinion to make some sort of sense of what's actually allowed. So in the case of the NSA they would make the same argument you are making: the NSA didn't "get" the information so therefore they don't need to be authorised to "have" it. But the issue is that "getting" something and "having" something isn't the same thing. Realistically, the problem is exactly as you describe it, you can't really protect people if you're allowing random parties to just collect data on everyone with no consent or legal base for processing. Because even if the NSA needs a warrant, you can just proxy that too where you don't even buy the data, you just buy 'search results' and offload the entire data mining process. Now the NSA doesn't acquire the data nor hold it, it just gets results. And then we'd all get a discussion about that, and they could just proxy that too (have some other entity to collection and investigation etc. and just relay results as anonymous tips to the NSA). It never seems to end.
- geraldhh 3y ago> Think of it this way: knives are available on the open market, that doesn't mean NSA can just go around stabbing people. but the nsa can go around and buy knifes
- herbst 3y agoCan anyone explain why people choose to use internet providers that sell their data? Do they get internet for free?
- internet101010 3y agoBecause a ton of people only have one reasonable option.
- geraldhh 3y agomost commercial isp's do this
- verisimi 3y agoIts a perfect, self serving loop, if you think about it from a governance perspective. Government takes taxes. It uses those taxes to spy on its citizens. This makes the citizens more compliant. Compliant citizens acquiesce more easily. Government therefore increases its power and does more of the same. Greater invasive control results in more extraction from the citizens and more power to government. From a governance perspective, this is a positive feedback loop. From a citizens perspective, it is a negative feedback loop.
- lucasRW 3y agoMany threat intelligence companies buy that data and then resell it as a service. I'm not very clear as to how accessing that data in the first place is legal...
- tackypenguin 3y ago[dead]
- wrigglingworm 3y ago>N.S.A. Buys Americans’ Internet Data Without Warrants, Letter Says I haven't seen a cent, where do I collect my check?
- xnx 3y agoThese headlines should all be "Your personal browsing history for sale to anyone"
- berniedurfee 3y agoI’d love to have a chat with their LLM. Must be absolutely astonishing what it knows.
- pseudolus 3y agohttps://archive.is/tDuhR https://archive.is/tDuhR
- EA-3167 3y agoMaybe this is a naive question, but if the information is for sale, why would the government need a warrant?
- leoh 3y agoThe fact that this data is available at all is such a fail.
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoRight, but raising a panic by saying the government has this data or China gets this data is a distraction from the real issue, that such a vast marketplace exists openly for anyone to shop.
- leoh 3y agoCan't say I disagree.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoIf the government is doing it as an end run around the fourth amendment then that should be illegal.
- halJordan 3y agoBut they are though? I agree that intrinsic privacy rights should prevent this. But the fact is this data is freely available, it's public information, the individual has released it appropriately. The problem isn't the govt using public data, the problem is that the data is public. You simply cannot have a privacy concern when you've agreed for it to not be private in the first place.
- h-c-c 3y agoIt's not freely available, it's for sale. And just because private data is for sale does make it public.
- legitster 3y agoI'm trying to think through this from a legal perspective. If I'm going from store-to-store around town, my understanding is that police are allowed to watch me and even go into the businesses and ask questions or pull security footage without a warrant. The information they gather is circumstantial and probably would not hold up in court, but they can use it as grounds to get a warrant. Let's imagine a different case. Instead of police having to go in and ask nicely for customer logs and security footage, the owner happens to have meticulous notes that he keeps and sells to randos around town. Creepy... but it's largely the same data that they could have gotten by asking nicely enough anyway. If there is no law against the proprietor bundling up his customer data and selling it, it doesn't seem like there is a strong legal case against police using it. Obviously, this is a MUCH bigger problem on the internet than in real life - just in the huge difference in scale in the amount of data and the ability to parse it.
- luckettpat 3y agoI think it comes down to quantitative differences resulting in qualitative differences. It's not unreasonable for anyone (public or police) to notice when I am out in public, and what I do in public. But at some point an accumulation of these OK interaction becomes not OK, in the same way we already recognize that an individual simply seeing somebody in public is a protected right but stalking is not. When the technology exists to track everything I do in the public sphere, catalog, summarize it, and sell it for profit, we are dealing with a qualitatively different animal that has entirely different implications morally and with respect to our rights as individuals.
- verisimi 3y agoSmart = spy. Smart devices are spy devices, part of the governance control infrastructure.
- mu53 3y agoI think this gets down to a fundamental problem with tech that society is ignoring like a pink elephant in the room. Society fundamentally changed with the introduction of computers. Things have become possible that were never possible before. This is obvious if you consider the tech of 1900, 1950, and today. The elephant in the room is that the more complete the dataset the more dangerous it is. Its like gunpowder. Firecrackers are sold without license, small amount of gunpowder. Dynamite and other explosives with larger amounts of gunpowder are heavily restricted because of the damage that can be done. Today, there are laws against re-packaging explosives to protect people. I believe the damage that these datasets are doing to society are covert and second-order effects that are hard to track. Most datasets like what the NSA are doing are kept secret precisely because they don't want transparency. If there was transparency, the damage would become obvious that regulations would swiftly come.
- systems_glitch 3y agoIronically this is referred to as "open source" data.
- thelastparadise 3y ago[flagged]