5 ms·
They’ve introduced pricing that their lawyers think is compatible with the regulation (the regulations don’t ban egregious pricing). Frankly, I think Apple shou
by seanmcdirmid 3y ago
They’ve introduced pricing that their lawyers think is compatible with the regulation (the regulations don’t ban egregious pricing). Frankly, I think Apple should have just allowed third party app stores without any guarantee of malware/fraud protection, let consumers decide for themselves if they want to risk it or not.
- tovkal 3y ago> I think Apple should have just allowed third party app stores without any guarantee of malware/fraud protection No way they can do that, because the second something malware or fraud happens, you can imagine the headlines. Apple advertises the iPhone as a secure and private device. By notarizing third-party store apps, they still have the ability to remove malicious apps.
- Wowfunhappy 3y ago> Frankly, I think Apple should have just allowed third party app stores without any guarantee of malware/fraud protection, let consumers decide for themselves if they want to risk it or not. Apple did not do this because consumers do not value malware and fraud protection nearly as much as Apple would like everyone to believe.
- mh8h 3y agoIt's not that they don't value it. It's more like they aren't aware of the risks.
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> It's more like they aren't aware of the risks. I doubt that. Decades of having to run malware (removal) software on Windows has pretty much guaranteed everyone knows what a virus is.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoMaybe that's true, and consumers don't know what's best for them. However, we live in a free society, where consumers are supposed to be able to decide for themselves what they value, and spend their money accordingly. Where we do impose regulations to ensure public safety, they are decided by a democratic process. And as imperfect as that process may be at times, it is better than letting a single for-profit corporation set the terms.
- gms 3y agoConsumers are indeed able to decide for themselves: they can buy any number of Android phones from many manufacturers for a different experience.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoSo, what other features do you wish to prevent and or remove from iOS/iPhones because you don't have a use for them even though they would not affect you one iota?
- gms 3y agoThey do affect me - non-technical members of my family are on iPhones and I’m glad they can’t install malware by accident. More generally, I don’t believe I nor anyone else should mandate anything about a private software company’s product roadmap (least of all spiteful bureaucrats obsessed with targeting American technology companies). The precedent this sets is absurd. The market already provides a solution outside of arbitrary coercion: we all have the freedom to purchase other products.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoDo non-technical members of your family accidentally disable Gatekeeper on their Macs?
- dns_snek 3y agoThankfully the EU regulators have decided otherwise.
- kolinko 3y agoConsumers (myself included) already made their decision by choosing an iOS. I don’t want every other game dev/streaming service pushing me to install their own “store” like they do on the other platforms. That’s why I keep choosing Apple.
- Andrew_nenakhov 3y agoWhen my wife chose iOS she didn't consent to Apple removing apps at the behest of Russian government, which Apple does. Apple altered the deal after the fact. Apple should be absolutely prohibited from controlling what apps users want to run on their devices. If a user wants to install an app, and developer of said app wants it too, they should be able to do it without any restrictions. Or else Apple should start being honest and admit that they are only lending their devices to users, and not selling them, because selling implies full control over property.
- insane_dreamer 3y agoThis. Users don't care about alternative app stores. Developers do.
- frenchy 3y agoIf users didn't care about alternative app stores, then why does Apple ban them?
- insane_dreamer 3y agobecause it provides no benefit to Apple while carrying significant risk: - if users are happy with the alt store and it becomes highly successful, Apple loses revenue it would otherwise get from its own store - if users are unhappy with the alt store because viruses, etc., get onto their phones, or it becomes a spam-ware cesspool, Apple gets the blame (the vast majority of users will not differentiate and then Apple has to spent tons of effort to "don't buy from stores X, Y and Z"--much easier to just disallow them) Remember, most Apple users care about an optimum experience. If they care a lot about openness they would be using Android / Linux and are not Apple's target.
- VWWHFSfQ 3y ago> Apple should have just allowed third party app stores without any guarantee of malware/fraud protection, let consumers decide for themselves if they want to risk it or not In general I agree. But the support burden/cost goes up enormously. Ask Microsoft.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoJust support alternate app stores with a button that allows consumers to restore their iPhone software to factory condition once they get bogged enough by bad software? They don’t have to do much more than that, and they can be up front about it.