3 ms·
The problem with that outlook is that crypto isn't really all that great for people who live under capital controls. It's possibly better than the local curren
by kelnos 3y ago
The problem with that outlook is that crypto isn't really all that great for people who live under capital controls. It's possibly better than the local currency, depending on what they want to do, but it still has serious drawbacks.
Looking at the USD-BTC price chart over the years, pretty much any time after mid-2017, BTC is just a very risky store of value. It's super volatile. You need to know that what you have will still buy you what you expect in a month, 3 months, a year, etc.
Now, again, this still may be a better deal than the local currency for some people. And if you're primarily using it as a money transmission method (convert local currency to BTC, send to recipient, they convert to their local currency), you lose a lot of the price risk. But that still doesn't make it a good deal.
And that's just one issue that directly affects anyone using it. On top of that there's the proliferation of scams, enabling of criminal activity, ridiculous electricity use, etc.
I think my position has softened, over time, though. I used to be very anti-crypto, and wished for its demise. Now I just kinda don't care too much about it; if people want to spend their time working on the technology to see where it goes, who am I to tell them to do something else with their time? And it does seem to be helping a lot of people who don't have good financial options. And who knows, maybe it'll eventually grow or morph into something I might find useful or interesting.
- tock 3y agoIts getting more useful over time. There are good fiat backed stablecoins + ethereum and its peers are all proof-of-stake so no ridiculous electricity usage. But the risk premium of using it(falling prey to scams, hacks, etc) makes no sense in countries with stable financial regimes.
- latchkey 3y agoThe funny thing about this though is that this is so easy to whatabout. Fraud is all over tradfi. I have a true story. The head of finance got phished. Ended up transferring money to some new bank account number they received on a friday. He called, when they opened, on Monday. The money was gone and the bank wouldn't do anything to return it. Call the police/feds they said. I think the next step is to build trustless escrow services. I know that sounds weird, but we need some sort of insurance system that if fraud happens, we can get our money back. Programmable money makes that possible and that would be an improvement on what we have today. Don't forget... how can credit cards afford to absorb the losses? Fees and penalties. Someone always has to pay.
- keiferski 3y agoWhat is “good” is determined by the options available, not by all theoretically possible options. The average person in say, Argentina, isn’t going to have access to complex financial instruments and so is functionally choosing between a hyperinflating local currency and a volatile-but-still-going-up bitcoin. This is a real world use case and it’s echoed in countless places around the world - most of which, I imagine, the most strident crypto critics haven’t ever been to.
- kelnos 3y agoSure, I get that. And I'm not in a position where I need to use crypto, so I know I'm not going to feel it like someone in that position would. And I agree that they should use the best option available to them, and that crypto might be it. But otherwise, I disagree: "good" is not solely determined by the options available. When comparing options, you can only say that some are "better" or "worse". Crypto may be better for some people than their other options, but that doesn't make it good. (Consider sayings like "the best of bad options" or "the lesser of evils". It's an acknowledgement that none of the options are good, but some are nonetheless better than others.) Ideally people in these situations do -- sooner rather than later -- get some actually good options. Maybe crypto will morph into that, or maybe people would get better (and quicker) bang for their buck tackling the problem from a different angle. I don't know what that other angle might be, but I worry that crypto ends up being a sort of local maximum that hits a ceiling, one that is better than the alternatives for some people, but is still not particularly good.
- keiferski 3y agoWhat’s the alternative you’re proposing? For the average person in these countries to push for radical political and economic changes against their governments? Governments which are typically more controlling in the first place? All of this so that they can just not have their meager savings eaten away by inflation? Again, this kind of criticism has little contact with reality and mostly comes from people without actual experience in using the tech. In the real world, in places with hyperinflation or other financial issues, bitcoin isn’t “the lesser of two evils.”
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoI think another commenter said it better, but you second sentence buries the lede. If crypto is better than the alternatives, people will rationally choose to use it, and that seems like a good thing for them. Even if I agree with literally everything else you said.