10 ms·
Which shows got their finale right, and which didn't?
- euroderf 3y agoThe Prisoner had a scary good finale, if you downplay the feeling of surreal circus. The hero came full circle. (btw ignore the movie of the same name, it was unrelated generic sci-fi)
- pallas_athena 3y agoIf anyone wants to discuss the LOST finale, I'm here for it. Let's start with the obvious: They were not dead since the plane crash. Basically every mystery was explained. JJ Abrams only had input for the Pilot and very little afterwards. So no magic box bullshit. Of course the writer were "making it up as they go", they didn't have a 6-years plan. But the themes and motives were there since the beginning. (in fact you can read the early outlines here: https://www.reddit.com/r/815/comments/13kr6ua/the_black_box/ https://www.reddit.com/r/815/comments/13kr6ua/the_black_box/). LOST was all about the characters _and_ it had a compelling mystery. It was perfect. Also it's one of the few media to get Time Travel 100% right (as in: internal logic).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cwillu 3y ago* M * A * S * H * That is all. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodbye,_Farewell_and_Amen https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodbye,_Farewell_and_Amen “From 1983 until 2010, "Goodbye, Farewell and Amen" remained the most watched television broadcast in American history”
- boomboomsubban 3y agoFor thirty years I thought I saw the finale of MASH, it's just now that I realized I saw the ten year anniversary showing.
- vavooom 3y agoI really like this classification. - Transcendent Finales: the best of the best. - Satisfying Finales: endings that more or less meet viewer expectations. - Disappointing Finales: a conclusion that falls short of previously established show quality but is not so bad as to retroactively render prior viewership a waste of time. - Disaster Finales: an ending that is so terrible it begs the question, "What were the writers thinking?" Note to the author: run this through spell check again, saw a few spelling errors (e.g. Saitsyfing)
- yesbut 3y agoStar Trek: Enterprise. May UPN forever rot in hell.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoIs that the one that ended with President of Earth Stacey Abrams? oof.
- pseudo0 3y agoEnterprise was the early 2000s prequel, set before the Kirk original series. It wasn't bad but it got badly overshadowed by Battlestar Galactica.
- shiroiuma 3y agoYeah, Enterprise had its issues (especially the awful theme music at the beginning), but overall was pretty enjoyable to watch and had likeable characters, unlike Discovery.
- GolfPopper 3y ago"Energize the hull plating!" Because the ship didn't have shields, but they couldn't manage to write episodes without "Shields up!"
- Kluggy 3y agoThat was Discovery
- shampto3 3y agoI really enjoyed this, well done. I love that there were surprises like the LOST finale not being as bad as you thought (statistically). Some obligatory personal hot takes: - the Scrubs finale should be considered the last episode of season 8 (which was great). Season 9 should be considered a spinoff series. - The Blacklist recently aired the series finale and I would consider it a disaster finale. It has ruined the series for me, and I no longer recommend it to friends. - I think most comedies aren’t ruined by a series finale. That’s probably due to the character over plot idea, as there usually isn’t a storyline I’m dying to finish.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> the Scrubs finale should be considered the last episode of season 8 (which was great). Season 9 should be considered a spinoff series. If you're going to divide the show like that, wouldn't the spinoff start with season 5?
- khazhoux 3y ago?? Season 9 had Denise as main character, with Turk in a supporting role. Ergo, it’s the spinoff season.
- shampto3 3y agoFrom the Wikipedia for the ninth season: > Lawrence considered the eighth season to be the end of the show Scrubs, going so far as to ask ABC if he could change the name to Scrubs Med School. ABC declined, but Lawrence still advised fans to treat it as a new show, even putting a caption under the "Created By" on the X-ray in the opening sequence saying [Med School] So the showrunner treated it like a spinoff but the network wanted to keep the name.
- ethbr1 3y agoI'm in the minority of people who enjoyed the LOST finale. In the end, for me, it was about the characters. Not the mystery. And the finale was about seeing the characters off. ... I know, I'm terrible at being a nerd. :( PS: But then, I also loved the Seinfeld finale. For me, it peeled the curtain back a little more and showed they were in fact, awful, neurotic people who were the source of the very craziness in their lives that they spent so much time bemoaning.
- shimonabi 3y agoIt's pretty well established now that The Sopranos finale HAD closure. It's just that only the real fans figured it out.
- Bud 3y ago[dead]
- Spivak 3y ago> I can't think of a television reboot that has reproduced or outshined a series' foremost iteration. Futurama I think is the exception that proves the rule here for maintaining quality. Keeping the core writers and deliberately not flanderizing the characters seems to be the key here. Sabrina is the gold standard of a reboot that surpasses the original.
- frfl 3y ago> Futurama I think is the exception that proves the rule here for maintaining quality. Sadly the reboot has terrible ratings, at least according to IMDB. I haven't seen the second half of the _true_ last season (from 2013) of Futurama, nor have I seen the reboot. I feel if I never watch the _true_ final season it never really ends.
- schmookeeg 3y agoAny high marks Futurama may earn for its finale need to be halved by the episode providing the saddest kick in the bonch ever -- "Jurassic Bark" :)
- agarren 3y agoI’m surprised that Sopranos made the transcendent finale list, and equally surprised that Six Feet Under didn’t make it (and isn’t even in the review.) Six Feet Under wrapped everything up so perfectly. The Sopranos, as much as I enjoyed it, did not have a finale that lived up to the show.
- MrMember 3y agoSix Feet Under had arguably the greatest finale of all time. It's been like fifteen years since I watched it and I still think about it.
- jameskilton 3y agoIt would have been an invalid article had it not included The Sopranos! The Sopranos did have the perfect ending. It's been debated and will continue to be debated till the end of time, and I loved it. My take: life continues and Tony keeps doing what he's been doing, which fits the entire theme of the show: The more things change, the more things stay exactly the same.
- hotpotamus 3y agoFunny - I heard about the finale before I saw it, so I figured there would be a lot of ambiguity, but it was quite obvious to me that it was “lights out” for Tony so to speak. I suppose that speaks well for it that we are able to take our own meaning.
- Physkal 3y agoThe expanse... Are they still working on a sequel? I wish they hadn't had to get rid of Alex. Also season 6 of the walking dead still feels like the shows awkward finale.
- Kluggy 3y agoAFAIK there hasn't been any talk of them not exploring options for the last three books.
- frfl 3y agoThe double negative (hasn't, not) makes your comment a bit confusing. You're saying there is talk of something to cover the final 3 books? Do you have any sources on this? I haven't seen anything about this online besides one thing I saw, but can no longer find, something along the lines of "we're not done with the Expanse universe yet", but I may be misremembering.
- Kluggy 3y agoNaren Shankar and the cast have said pretty much that same thing and Wes Chatham said something around the lines of "there's more in the works", but that is it. My comment was around the fact that there hasn't been anyone saying anything negative around it's future, so we can presume they're still trying.
- frfl 3y agoExpanse was apparently axed at end of s6 because of budget reasons from one Reddit comment thread I came across a few years ago, someone quoted something along the lines of "Internally it was called 'The Expense" because of how much the show cost to make". Makes you wonder if someone else would be willing to put up the money for new stuff. But then again you have shows that cost multiple millions per episode these days. A small hope of something is better than nothing.
- BLKNSLVR 3y ago
- ethbr1 3y agoIt's so cool to see Person of Interest on the transcendent finale list! I'm in the middle of a second watch through, 10 years on. For a show originally penned around worries about the post-9/11 surveillance panopticon, it's still disturbingly timely, albeit in a much weirder modern world than could have been imagined then. If you've never seen it, but read HN, would recommend. Definitely don't research the plot on the internet before watching! And give it until the end of season 2 before you throw in the towel... it ends up being about very different things than it starts about.
- class3shock 3y agoI'll second this. It is a show that I think slightly suffers from having to make 20+ episodes a season (besides the last) so at times certain episodes will feel like they are filler. Unlike many other shows though it ended just about when it should which I think is why it made this list.
- Semaphor 3y agoAgreed, it was an amazing show that was far more intelligent and often prescient that one would expect from a 24 episodes/season show.
- GeekyBear 3y agoIt's one of those shows that looks like yet another "monster of the week" program at first, but develops a compelling story arc as time goes by. Other examples would be Fringe, or Supernatural.
- Physkal 3y agoCurious to know how the house of dragon is doing now, I haven't heard much from anyone watching it.
- lax0 3y agoI went into it with my defense up pretty high, but it won me over within a couple episodes. If you like GoT youll like HoD, I think.
- Fezzik 3y agoIt was a fantastic first season. But it aired a year and a half ago and there is still no release date for season two, so any hype has subsided quite a bit. Season two was reportedly filmed in April/May of last year.
- mikub 3y agoI didn't watch every single episode of it, but from what I saw I think Babylon 5 had a really good Finale.
- ethbr1 3y agoWhich one? Season 4 or Season 5? Or the movies?
- mikub 3y agoI just did watch the episodes on TV when I had the time, so I'm not really deep into it. From looking it up the ending I mean is called "Sleeping in light" so Season 5 i guess?. I think I need to do a rewatch and watch it properly this time.
- ethbr1 3y agoAs context afaicr, they were expecting to be cancelled after season 4, so wrapped up the big arc. Then unexpectedly got a season 5, but weren't sure if there would be a season 6, so ended up hedging their bets with an odd season (compared to the others). And then the post-show movies provided a few more opportunities, but never evolved into follow-on series.
- lrasinen 3y agoNot quite; the plan was always to go for five seasons, but the PTEN network closing up shop put season 5 at risk. Sleeping In Light was always intended to be the finale; once season 5 got secured they shot another episode (which was also great) to act as season 4 finale. The uncertainty with season 5 did play havoc with the pacing of the arcs. Season 4 did have to cover a lot of ground to get the most important arcs to close, so parts of it feel rushed, and vice versa the beginning of season 5 takes a while to get back to speed. Sigh.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- autarch 3y agoScrubs is a funny one. It's both disaster and transcendent. Everything about Season 9 is garbage, but up to that point it was a fantastic show. And Season 8 has an incredibly well-done, moving, funny finale. I highly recommend anyone watching this show for the first time simply stop at the end of Season 8.
- colordrops 3y agoI was hoping to see Mr. Robot and Dark on there and was happily not surprised.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- js2 3y agoMissing a couple great finales: The Americans and Justified. I want a finale to provide closure, to tie up most loose ends, and to send the characters off to a fitting future or end. Also, my disdain for Lost has no bounds. I watched it in real time and want every minute back. I've never felt so ripped off by a show, ever. It turned me off watching most shows in real time ever again. I usually wait for series to conclude with rare exceptions. But I'm also the kind of crazy person who reads the last chapter of a book first before deciding whether to read the whole thing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dclowd9901 3y agoI see we’re kindred spirits. Everyone talks about Vince Gilligan or David Simon. But no hats raised for Graham Yost. As far as LOST goes, I enjoyed the ride up until that very last episode, much like Battlestar Galactica. It’s a pity but I bet I could watch it all again and just skip the last ep and fill it with my head canon.
- js2 3y agoI think Better Call Saul is the better show. I really enjoyed it. And Rhea Seehorn was totally robbed of an Emmy. My problem with Lost is that we were promised something better but it turns out the show runners were just yanking our chains. They have no more idea what really happened than the rest of us. I'd almost rather them say: yes, everyone really is dead, it was all purgatory just like everyone thought from the beginning. Ugh even thinking about it is raising my blood pressure.
- cwillu 3y agoThe Cylons did not, in fact, have a plan.
- paulmd 3y agoEvery great anime got to have the beach episode
- 8organicbits 3y ago> I can't think of a television reboot that has reproduced or outshined a series' foremost iteration. Are Star Trek NG and The Office (US) not considered reboots? They are at the top of the list. If we include British shows, Dr Who stands out as well.
- arunix 3y agoI consider Star Trek TNG a continuation, not a reboot (it is set in the same universe as TOS but several decades later).
- dclowd9901 3y agoLost me immediately with the Breaking Bad finale. Absolutely terrible finale. It should have ended with white dying alone in a cabin. Conversely, a show that didn’t appear here that had, IMO a perfect finale was The Leftovers. Edit: really, The Leftovers is a perfect show. One of the few. Go watch it.
- Kluggy 3y agoI honestly believe the entire finale was designed around the machine gun in the trunk scene.
- sirspacey 3y agoyou’ll love the Dexter finale then The ending of Breaking Bad made me grateful for life itself. Jesse became an icon for all time as he drove away.
- class3shock 3y agoThe Leftovers didn't just have a perfect finale, it had a perfect run imho. Such a unique and beautifully crafted show.
- frfl 3y agoJust finished s1. I never really rewatch immediately, but I feel like I kind of need to for this show. There was so many small details I likely missed, but there were a ton I did notice that puts a spotlight on the attention to detail and storytelling they have. And that's just s1, I've heard 2 and 3 are the really good ones.
- dclowd9901 3y agoAbsolutely right. Most of us who were watching the show as it was released felt the first season was good and hewed closely to the book which was also good. But then seasons 2 and 3 are gobsmackingly good. Every episode is important and pertinent, and ideas and themes flow like water. I envy you getting to enjoy it for the first time!
- 3y ago
- colmvp 3y ago> Do Finales Define a Show? It's mind-boggling how much Benioff and Weiss dropped the ball on the final two seasons of GOT. It's hard for me to even re-watch clips of the early seasons on YouTube because of how much I know its going to take a turn for the worst. The sad part is the production value and actors were still on their A game. In contrast, I can rewatch practically anything from BB or BCS.
- Sebb767 3y agoI feel the same way about Game of Thrones. I really loved the first few seasons, but I can't bring myself to start rewatching them as I know where it inevitably goes. It's even worse than How I Met Your Mother in my opinion, for two reasons - first , GoT is much more focused on a long running story, making the conclusion more important. But more importantly, HIMYM is a sharp decline; you can simply skip the last two episodes and have a perfectly fine ending. GOT just declines ever more, making it hard to set a point at which to end the show.
- Log_out_ 3y agoA rewriting AI made better ending for that series is my personal generative AI milestone.
- rags2riches 3y agoPlease save the acronyms for repeated uses of a long name. It helps the rest if us to understand what the hell you're talking about.
- gordon_freeman 3y agoBB = Breaking Bad, BCS = Better Call Saul
- mvdtnz 3y agoHacker Newsers do this on purpose. Many believe that the fewer people that understand what they're saying, the smarter they will look.
- LeonB 3y agoThe heading made me immediately want to read this article in hope of sharing my ongoing grief at the terribly, criminally disappointing finale of Game of Thrones. And yes it was included as the golden standard of beyond terrible in section 4, “Disaster Finales: So Terrible It Hurts” A problem shared is a problem halved (or doubled or something). I feel some comfort here. Imagine, though, how bad George R R Martin must feel?
- bestouff 3y agoI hope he feels bad about this. What he did was terrible.
- gordon_freeman 3y agoSurprised that one of the greatest comedy shows of last 20 years "Parks and Recreation" did not make the cut. The finale was superb!
- edanm 3y agoyes! Especially since The Office and Brooklyn Nine-Nine both made the cut, and are very related shows. (The Office finale is one of my favorite finales ever. While both are great, I'd probably say P&R beats Brooklyn Nine-Nine, though neither is on the level of The Office.)
- moontear 3y agoI don’t quite understand how shows were chosen. There seem to be a shows missing, fitting the criteria’s. Six feet under: average rating 8,7, finale 9,9 (!)
- dasil003 3y agoI wanted to see where The Wire landed. Season 5 was the weakest but also rounded out the series by showing several cycles completing. Perhaps not the best, but in some ways the most important?
- fastball 3y agoFun analysis! Some thoughts and subjective opinions. - Westworld's very poor showing helped me realize what I think the major flaw is in this analysis, which is that it doesn't properly capture shows that have been on the decline for a while. In Westworld's case, the season scores are as follows: S1 8.86, S2 8.38, S3 80.25, S4 79.38. As you can see, there is a consistent decline from beginning to end, not just a disappointing ending. The series average is propped up by a very strong first season and goes downhill from there. Not sure how to best adjust the calculation to try to take this into account. - I found The Expanse ending disappointing because it ended mid-plot (which is less excusable than GoT since the authors actually finished the book series), but I also understand that they had to end it somehow and did pretty well with what they had. As a note to anyone that is enjoying The Expanse show but maybe hasn't finished it, I would definitely recommend stopping now and reading the books first, then watching the show. The books actually have a complete arc, but also the first six books pretty closely match the series, so if you watch the show first those books will be a bit of a slog to get through. Doing it the other way I think will work much better, because although you'll know the plot of most of the show in advance, the space battles and other visuals are so cool that it is still a fun watch. Then you can just kinda imagine what the rest of the books would look like if the'd actually made them into the show. - Ozark being in the Disaster Finale surprised me – I thought the ending was good (if not great). I guess viewers were hoping for a Breaking Bad-tier ending (given the subject matter and strong rest of the show) and so were let down. - Agree with the author that Lost is a surprise "satisfying finale". It is definitely in my top 5 most disappointing series endings (alongside the unsurprising disaster finales of GoT and Dexter). - Big Bang Theory had a finale that seemed right in line with the rest of the show, surprised by the delta that puts it into Transcendent territory. I have a sneaking suspicious that non-fans may've been watching other random episodes and rating them (negatively), thus dragging down the season average by a good bit. But non-fans would probably not be tuning in for the finale, thus leaving that score to be entirely dictated by fans.
- Apocryphon 3y agoShould've restricted it to (prestige) dramas, as there is a world of difference between Game of Thrones or Mad Men and, say, Big Bang Theory. For instance, where's the greatness of The Shield? Or the controversy of Battlestar Galactica?
- mvdtnz 3y agoAh now The Shield, there's a show with a great ending.
- deepsun 3y ago> "What were the writers thinking?" As for the Game of Thrones -- that's exactly what JRRM envisioned. At some point he sat together with GoT storywriters and producers and laid off all the plans, how who dies, and of course the finale. I think the finale was awesome -- what a nice populist autocratic ruler may become. That sometimes life is not what you want it to be, and you cannot change it. That your favorite characters don't always win. PS: I only regret they pictured protagonist Tyrion (the dwarf) somewhat nice. The whole GMMR's idea was that his character was repulsive, incredibly ugly, but did good things all the way. That would stand off from pretty much all the movies, when I can tell who's who from the first minute (good are cute, bad are ugly).
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoThe "end result" is not quite the same as what they mean by finale. The shortcuts taken in the final season of GoT, my word, are unforgivable when placed alongside the care and detail taken up to that point. By the pace of the series up until the start of the final season, there should have been two more seasons to do it "properly". The decline of Daenerys deserved detailed, focused nuance as power and inherent genetic disposition combined to corrupt and disconnect her completely from reality. And Jon Snow's slow drawn-out torture as her decline played out, should have been comparable to Theon's at the hands of Ramsay. It could have been beautiful. Edited to add: It may have been the final two seasons that were greatly accelerated, not just the last. I can't remember, I don't want to re-visit the series because of it.
- paulmd 3y agoand they needed to be full seasons and not the shorter and shorter seasons they were running towards the end. 8 episodes was too short (and the production schedule far too long) let alone 6 episodes. Perfectly eulogized by the pitch meeting guy: “sorry, just not enough time!!!” https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jAhKOV3nImQ https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jAhKOV3nImQ top comment: > You wanna know how bad season 8 was? We are in The middle of a long quarantine, and not a single person I know is rewatching this show. Hard to overstate how bad hbo fucked up there, I wish they’d have thrown it away and just reshot it with a team who wanted to be there. (the directors needed it to be over so they could go do Star Wars… and Disney was so dismayed with how unprofessionally they’d handled it that they took Star Wars away from them lol.)
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoStranger Things feels like it could be heading towards a transcendent finale.
- mvdtnz 3y agoI simply refuse to accept The Sopranos as a quality finale. I don't care how pretentious people believe it has aged, it's just a crap way to end one of the all time greats. Total cop out.
- WarkFlark 3y agoI watched the show about ten years after the finale aired and I was shocked to see the finale get such a negative reaction—it's probably my favorite show ending I've ever seen. The combination of "Don't Stop Believing" and the cut to black is unmatched. I don't know what you mean by "cop out"—what ending would you have preferred?
- cookiengineer 3y agoThe most unsatisfying finale of any show or season ever was Stargate: Atlantis. This show ended in a dead-on cliff hanger, leaving the whole story in an open end, just because they wanted to get people into watching the remake cinema movie.
- Lamad1234 3y ago[dead]
- hightrix 3y agoThe Letterkenny finale was damn near perfect. It was the perfect blend of what you expect from the show and nostalgia.
- frfl 3y agoIn my books Top Boy ending was quite well done. Gritty and tragic.
- Prcmaker 3y agoGoodbye, farewell and amen, the final episode of MASH. I've not seen a better end to TV show.
- polotics 3y agoModest proposal for y'all: each season finale of GoT is an opportunity for great branching discussion about how the story should best develop from that point on! For example: once John Snow's been stabbed, he's really dead, and replaced by the faceless man, working on orders for the Bank of Braavos, all are fooled by the statagem, except for one spunky skilled sister of his... What happens next? Here's your rewatchability!
- magnio 3y agoBetter Call Saul half-ruined the drama genre for me. Watching anything else and I ask myself why they can't make it slower and more well-paced like BCS, make it subtler and more contemplative like BCS, make it faster and more suspenseful like BCS. And all of that is with BCS having to work as a prequel, it is just poignant how long we will have to wait for another Jonathan Banks monologue or a Tony Dalton looming terror over the whole season. I half-wished the show never exist in the first place.
- anotherevan 3y agoAny data on the number of votes for the finale vs. average episode votes? I wonder if there might be any correlation showing that voting on the finale was made only by the most persistent of fans that may impact the findings.
- anotherevan 3y agoWhen I read your article title, "Dexter" popped immediately into mind. When I had finished watching the finale of Battlestar Galactica with my kid, they turned to me and said, "At least it had a better ending than Dexter!"
- lamontcg 3y agoAm I the only one in the world that watched GoT purely for the sex, violence and escapism and just thought it was popcorn and didn't care if the finale sucked?